Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General

From phenomenological thermodynamics to the canonical ensemble. II

H. A. Buchdahl

Published Jan 11, 1983• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

For pt.I see Found. Phys., vol.9, no.11-12, p819-29 (1979). A general assumption made in a previous paper is modified by the elimination of the metrical entropy in favour of empirical entropy. Without reference to absolute temperature or metrical entropy, one then arrives at a generic form of the canonical probability in phase in which temperature does not occur. It is argued that this is as it should be if one looks upon the canonical ensemble as merely being the representative of a system in thermal equilibrium with its surroundings. One motivation for this work is to take a view of 'statistical mechanics' which does away with probabilistic notions altogether.

DOI
10.1088/0305-4470/16/1/019

Related papers

Fluctuations, Thermodynamic Equilibrium and Entropy

Edwin C. Kemble

To eliminate exceptions to the second law due to fluctuation phenomena, etc., the following changes are necessary. First we must state the laws of thermodynamics in terms of Gibbsian ensembles rather than of individual systems. Second we must sharpen our conception of the experimental procedure required for producing states of thermodynamic equilibrium. It will not suffice to isolate the system and wait. We must have the positive stirring action of thermal contact with a thermostat. Using the new definition of thermal equilibrium we can place statistical mechanics on a more satisfactory footing by showing that the thermostat experimental procedure leads to the canonical ensemble and maximizes v. Neumann's microscopic entropy. (Details of this proof appear in succeeding paper). Difficulties with his macroscopic definition of entropy are avoided by showing that his original microscopic definition is satisfactory when used in conjunction with a proper operational definition of thermodynamic equilibrium. In conclusion the second law of thermodynamics is derived from quantum statistics on the basis of the microscopic definition of entropy.

Physical Review•Nov 15, 1939•18 citations

From classical to quantum statistical mechanics

Giampiero V. M. Esposito, Giuseppe Marmo, George Sudarshan

Classical statistical mechanics tries to derive the macroscopic properties of matter starting from the mechanical laws that rule the behaviour of single particles. To describe equilibrium states, only observables accounting for correlations among states are considered, and only systems consisting of a large number of particles are taken into account. The observables are described by continuous functions on phase space, and the states are represented by linear assignments of a number to each observable. Within the framework of the canonical ensemble, one deals with mechanical systems in thermal equilibrium with a thermal reservoir, and the equilibrium state is reached as a result of the interaction with the external world. The external world may be really external, or equally well, the unrecognized internal degrees of freedom, like in the calculation of viscosity or thermal conductivity. If really only the external world is the cause we may expect some surface dependence while an internal unrecognized degree of freedom would have a volume effect, unless the interactions are long range. The microcanonical ensemble is instead introduced to study isolated mechanical systems, and the equilibrium is viewed as a temporal average, rather than as a limit. Attention is then focused on partition functions, the theorem of equipartition of energy and an elementary theory of specific heats.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Mar 11, 2004•0 citations

An outline of a purely phenomenological theory of statistical thermodynamics--I: Canonical ensembles

Benoît B. Mandelbrot

"Boltzmann's problem" of statistical thermodynamics, is that of eliminating the paradoxical incompatibility of structure, existing between the irreversibility of the classical phenomenological thermodynamics, and the reversibility of any purely kinetic model, one could ever think of for these phenomena. One finds that, in order to construct kinetic "analogs" to the laws of phenomenological thermodynamics, the dynamics of large assemblies of molecules (Liouville theorem, etc,\cdots) must be completed by some hypotheses of randomness. Once established, this randomness can be followed up in its development, with no new conceptual paradox (although with great technical difficulty: there is a great amount of current work on this topic). But the introduction of randomness still raises entirely uncleared problems. Since, therefore, the kinetic foundations of thermodynamics are not sufficient in the absence of further hypotheses of randomness, are they still quite necessary in the presence of such hypotheses? Or else, could not one "short-circuit" the atoms, by centering upon any elements of randomness, for example those introduced by the process of observation? Our aim is to show (partly after Szilard) that a substantial part of the results, usually obtained through kinetic arguments, could be obtained by postulating from the outset a statistical distribution for the properties of a system, and following up with a purely phenomenological argument. The spirit of the theory is extremely close to that of the conventional (Copenhagen) approach to quantum theory, and the results are quite parallel, although the mathematics is quite different. Randomness is introduced by following the modern statistical theory of the estimation of non directly observable intensive variables of state, such as the temperature. The discussion of the methodological foundations of modern statistics can thus be translated into a full-fledged, and possibly significant , counterpart of the discussion of the kinetic foundations of thermodynamics. Statistics is thus provided with a particularly concrete example for some of its more involved methods; thermodynamics appears clarified in its classical aspects, and is further completed with an apparently new uncertainty relationship. It may also be of interest to the communication engineer to have a unified treatment of the foundations of fluctuation phenomena, and of methods of fighting noise : a discussion of entropy and information performed in this spirit, will be given in Part II of the paper.

IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•Sep 1, 1956•47 citations

Gibbs and Boltzmann Entropy in Classical and Quantum Mechanics

Sheldon Goldstein, Joel L. Lebowitz, Roderich Tumulka +1 more

The Gibbs entropy of a macroscopic classical system is a function of a probability distribution over phase space, i.e., of an ensemble. In contrast, the Boltzmann entropy is a function on phase space, and is thus defined for an individual system. Our aim is to discuss and compare these two notions of entropy, along with the associated ensemblist and individualist views of thermal equilibrium. Using the Gibbsian ensembles for the computation of the Gibbs entropy, the two notions yield the same (leading order) values for the entropy of a macroscopic system in thermal equilibrium. The two approaches do not, however, necessarily agree for non-equilibrium systems. For those, we argue that the Boltzmann entropy is the one that corresponds to thermodynamic entropy, in particular, in connection with the second law of thermodynamics. Moreover, we describe the quantum analog of the Boltzmann entropy, and we argue that the individualist (Boltzmannian) concept of equilibrium is supported by the recent works on thermalization of closed quantum systems.

arXiv:1903.11870•WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Apr 21, 2020•72 citations

Information, Entropy, and the Classical Ideal Gas

David Sands, Jeremy Dunning-Davies

The physical basis of the canonical and grand canonical distributions is questioned. In particular, we question the usual methods by which these distributions are derived, namely that fluctuations in entropy around energy and particle number are assumed to occur when the entropy depends only on variables which cannot themselves fluctuate. We show, starting from the Maxwellian velocity distribution, that the probability that a classical ideal gas at a fixed temperature occupies a given energy state corresponds not to the canonical ensemble of classical statistical mechanics but to the Gamma distribution. Computer simulations of a hard-sphere fluid demonstrate the principles. The analysis is extended to open systems in which the number of particles fluctuates and we show that for a system connected to a particle reservoir the Poisson distribution governs the probability of finding a given number of particles. The resulting probability distributions are used to calculate the Shannon information entropy which is then compared with the thermodynamic entropy. We argue that information theoretic entropy and thermodynamic entropy, whilst related, are not necessarily identical and that the information entropy contains non-thermodynamic components.

International Symposium Honoring Mathematical Physicist Jean-Pierre Vigier•Oct 16, 2013•0 citations

Probabilistic Foundations of Statistical Mechanics: A Bayesian Approach

Brian H Buck, A. C. Merchant

We examine the fundamental aspects of statistical mechanics, dividing the problem into a discussion purely about probability, which we analyse from a Bayesian standpoint. We argue that the existence of a unique maximising probability distribution $\{p(j\vert K)\}$ for states labelled by $j$ given data $K$ implies that the corresponding maximal value of the information entropy $σ(\{(p_j\vert K)\}) = -\sum_j (p_j \vert K)\ln{(p_j\vert K)}$ depends explicitly on the data at equilibrium and on the Hamiltonian of the system. As such, it is a direct measure of our uncertainty about the exact state of the body and can be identified with the traditional thermodynamic entropy. We consider the well known microcanonical, canonical and grand canonical methods and ensure that the fluctuations about mean values are generally minuscule for macroscopic systems before identifying these mean values with experimental observables and thereby connecting to many standard results from thermodynamics. Unexpectedly, we find that it is not generally possible for a quantum process to be both isentropic and reversibly adiabatic. This is in sharp contrast to traditional thermodynamics where it is assumed that isentropic, reversible adiabatic processes can be summoned up on demand and easily realised. By contrast, we find that linear relations between pressures $P_j$ and energies $E_j$ are necessary and sufficient conditions for a quasi-static and adiabatic change to be isentropic, but, of course, this relationship only holds for a few especially simple systems, such as the perfect gas, and is not generally true for more complicated systems. By considering the associated entropy increases up to second order in small volume changes we argue that the consequences are in practice negligible.

arXiv:1512.01368•Dec 4, 2015•2 citations
For pt.I see Found. Phys., vol.9, no.11-12, p819-29 (1979). A general assumption made in a previous paper is modified by the elimination of the metrical entropy in favour of empirical entropy. Without reference to absolute temperature or metrical entropy, one then arrives at a generic form of the canonical probability in phase in which temperature does not occur. It is argued that this is as it should be if one looks upon the canonical ensemble as merely being the representative of a system in thermal equilibrium with its surroundings. One motivation for this work is to take a view of 'statistical mechanics' which does away with probabilistic notions altogether.
To eliminate exceptions to the second law due to fluctuation phenomena, etc., the following changes are necessary. First we must state the laws of thermodynamics in terms of Gibbsian ensembles rather than of individual systems. Second we must sharpen our conception of the experimental procedure required for producing states of thermodynamic equilibrium. It will not suffice to isolate the system and wait. We must have the positive stirring action of thermal contact with a thermostat. Using the new definition of thermal equilibrium we can place statistical mechanics on a more satisfactory footing by showing that the thermostat experimental procedure leads to the canonical ensemble and maximizes v. Neumann's microscopic entropy. (Details of this proof appear in succeeding paper). Difficulties with his macroscopic definition of entropy are avoided by showing that his original microscopic definition is satisfactory when used in conjunction with a proper operational definition of thermodynamic equilibrium. In conclusion the second law of thermodynamics is derived from quantum statistics on the basis of the microscopic definition of entropy.
Classical statistical mechanics tries to derive the macroscopic properties of matter starting from the mechanical laws that rule the behaviour of single particles. To describe equilibrium states, only observables accounting for correlations among states are considered, and only systems consisting of a large number of particles are taken into account. The observables are described by continuous functions on phase space, and the states are represented by linear assignments of a number to each observable. Within the framework of the canonical ensemble, one deals with mechanical systems in thermal equilibrium with a thermal reservoir, and the equilibrium state is reached as a result of the interaction with the external world. The external world may be really external, or equally well, the unrecognized internal degrees of freedom, like in the calculation of viscosity or thermal conductivity. If really only the external world is the cause we may expect some surface dependence while an internal unrecognized degree of freedom would have a volume effect, unless the interactions are long range. The microcanonical ensemble is instead introduced to study isolated mechanical systems, and the equilibrium is viewed as a temporal average, rather than as a limit. Attention is then focused on partition functions, the theorem of equipartition of energy and an elementary theory of specific heats.
"Boltzmann's problem" of statistical thermodynamics, is that of eliminating the paradoxical incompatibility of structure, existing between the irreversibility of the classical phenomenological thermodynamics, and the reversibility of any purely kinetic model, one could ever think of for these phenomena. One finds that, in order to construct kinetic "analogs" to the laws of phenomenological thermodynamics, the dynamics of large assemblies of molecules (Liouville theorem, etc,\cdots) must be completed by some hypotheses of randomness. Once established, this randomness can be followed up in its development, with no new conceptual paradox (although with great technical difficulty: there is a great amount of current work on this topic). But the introduction of randomness still raises entirely uncleared problems. Since, therefore, the kinetic foundations of thermodynamics are not sufficient in the absence of further hypotheses of randomness, are they still quite necessary in the presence of such hypotheses? Or else, could not one "short-circuit" the atoms, by centering upon any elements of randomness, for example those introduced by the process of observation? Our aim is to show (partly after Szilard) that a substantial part of the results, usually obtained through kinetic arguments, could be obtained by postulating from the outset a statistical distribution for the properties of a system, and following up with a purely phenomenological argument. The spirit of the theory is extremely close to that of the conventional (Copenhagen) approach to quantum theory, and the results are quite parallel, although the mathematics is quite different. Randomness is introduced by following the modern statistical theory of the estimation of non directly observable intensive variables of state, such as the temperature. The discussion of the methodological foundations of modern statistics can thus be translated into a full-fledged, and possibly significant , counterpart of the discussion of the kinetic foundations of thermodynamics. Statistics is thus provided with a particularly concrete example for some of its more involved methods; thermodynamics appears clarified in its classical aspects, and is further completed with an apparently new uncertainty relationship. It may also be of interest to the communication engineer to have a unified treatment of the foundations of fluctuation phenomena, and of methods of fighting noise : a discussion of entropy and information performed in this spirit, will be given in Part II of the paper.
The Gibbs entropy of a macroscopic classical system is a function of a probability distribution over phase space, i.e., of an ensemble. In contrast, the Boltzmann entropy is a function on phase space, and is thus defined for an individual system. Our aim is to discuss and compare these two notions of entropy, along with the associated ensemblist and individualist views of thermal equilibrium. Using the Gibbsian ensembles for the computation of the Gibbs entropy, the two notions yield the same (leading order) values for the entropy of a macroscopic system in thermal equilibrium. The two approaches do not, however, necessarily agree for non-equilibrium systems. For those, we argue that the Boltzmann entropy is the one that corresponds to thermodynamic entropy, in particular, in connection with the second law of thermodynamics. Moreover, we describe the quantum analog of the Boltzmann entropy, and we argue that the individualist (Boltzmannian) concept of equilibrium is supported by the recent works on thermalization of closed quantum systems.
The physical basis of the canonical and grand canonical distributions is questioned. In particular, we question the usual methods by which these distributions are derived, namely that fluctuations in entropy around energy and particle number are assumed to occur when the entropy depends only on variables which cannot themselves fluctuate. We show, starting from the Maxwellian velocity distribution, that the probability that a classical ideal gas at a fixed temperature occupies a given energy state corresponds not to the canonical ensemble of classical statistical mechanics but to the Gamma distribution. Computer simulations of a hard-sphere fluid demonstrate the principles. The analysis is extended to open systems in which the number of particles fluctuates and we show that for a system connected to a particle reservoir the Poisson distribution governs the probability of finding a given number of particles. The resulting probability distributions are used to calculate the Shannon information entropy which is then compared with the thermodynamic entropy. We argue that information theoretic entropy and thermodynamic entropy, whilst related, are not necessarily identical and that the information entropy contains non-thermodynamic components.
We examine the fundamental aspects of statistical mechanics, dividing the problem into a discussion purely about probability, which we analyse from a Bayesian standpoint. We argue that the existence of a unique maximising probability distribution {p(j∣K)}\{p(j\vert K)\}{p(j∣K)} for states labelled by jjj given data KKK implies that the corresponding maximal value of the information entropy σ({(pj∣K)})=−∑j(pj∣K)ln⁡(pj∣K)σ(\{(p_j\vert K)\}) = -\sum_j (p_j \vert K)\ln{(p_j\vert K)}σ({(pj​∣K)})=−∑j​(pj​∣K)ln(pj​∣K) depends explicitly on the data at equilibrium and on the Hamiltonian of the system. As such, it is a direct measure of our uncertainty about the exact state of the body and can be identified with the traditional thermodynamic entropy. We consider the well known microcanonical, canonical and grand canonical methods and ensure that the fluctuations about mean values are generally minuscule for macroscopic systems before identifying these mean values with experimental observables and thereby connecting to many standard results from thermodynamics. Unexpectedly, we find that it is not generally possible for a quantum process to be both isentropic and reversibly adiabatic. This is in sharp contrast to traditional thermodynamics where it is assumed that isentropic, reversible adiabatic processes can be summoned up on demand and easily realised. By contrast, we find that linear relations between pressures PjP_jPj​ and energies EjE_jEj​ are necessary and sufficient conditions for a quasi-static and adiabatic change to be isentropic, but, of course, this relationship only holds for a few especially simple systems, such as the perfect gas, and is not generally true for more complicated systems. By considering the associated entropy increases up to second order in small volume changes we argue that the consequences are in practice negligible.