Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

AIP conference proceedings

The Origin of Complex Quantum Amplitudes

Philip Goyal, Kevin H. Knuth, John Skilling, Paul M. Goggans, Chun-Yong Chan

Published Jan 1, 2009• 5 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract. Physics is real. Measurement produces real numbers. Yet quantum mechanics uses com-plex arithmetic, in which √−1 is necessary but mysteriously relates to nothing else. By applying the same sort of symmetry arguments that Cox [1, 2] used to justify probability calculus, we are now able to explain this puzzle. The dual device/object nature of observation requires us to describe the world in terms of pairs of real numbers about which we never have full knowledge. These pairs combine according to complex arithmetic, using Feynman’s rules.

DOI
10.1063/1.3275650

Related papers

Quantum Mechanics as the Arithmetic of A Single Polynomial

Stephanie Alexander

Dirac called the imaginary unit in the Schrödinger equation the deepest thing in quantum mechanics, and admitted he did not understand it. This note offers a candidate: i is the complex place of a single number — Q, the real root of x⁴ − x − 1 — and the strangeness of quantum mechanics is the strangeness of that one number's arithmetic, seen from the inside. For a century quantum theory has been taught as a list of postulates — complex amplitudes, a Born rule, unitary evolution, a dagger — accepted because they work and never because they are understood. Grant a single identification, that the state space of a quantum system is the complex place of Q's field, and those postulates stop being assumptions. They become theorems. The imaginary unit is the field's complex structure; the dagger is Galois conjugation; observables are real because they are Galois-fixed; unitary evolution is the field's unit circle; and the Born rule — the squared modulus, long the least-explained law in physics — is the field's own norm, made unique by Gleason's theorem. Time reversal and charge conjugation appear as named elements of the Galois group S₄, the Weyl group of su(4). And a proved theorem locates the classical/quantum boundary precisely: in the family xⁿ − x − 1 the root is Pisot — its powers settle, its world definite — only through three dimensions, and at the fourth that settling fails. That, on the reading proposed here, is where the classical world ends and the quantum world begins. The dozen postulates of the physics textbooks are thus compressed to one here, named plainly as a posit, with every claim labeled at its evidential tier and the composition of many systems left as the open edge. It is not a metaphor and not a fit. Quantum Mechanics is the arithmetic of a single number — and, at last, a single thing to be right or wrong about.

•Jun 25, 2026•0 citations

The Symmetrical Foundation of Measure, Probability, and Quantum Theories

John Skilling, Kevin H. Knuth

Abstract Quantification starts with sum and product rules that express combination and partition. These rules rest on elementary symmetries that have wide applicability, which explains why arithmetical adding up and splitting into proportions are ubiquitous. Specifically, measure theory formalizes addition, and probability theory formalizes inference in terms of proportions. Quantum theory rests on the same simple symmetries, but is formalized in two dimensions, not just one, in order to track an object through its binary interactions with other objects. The symmetries still require sum and product rules (here known as the Feynman rules), but they apply to complex numbers instead of real scalars, with observable probabilities being modulus squared (known as the Born rule). The standard quantum formalism follows. There is no mystery or weirdness, just ordinary probabilistic inference.

arXiv:1712.09725•Annalen der Physik•Jun 13, 2018•15 citations

The ABC of Physics

John Skilling, Kevin H. Knuth

Why quantum? Why spacetime? We find that the key idea underlying both is uncertainty. In a world lacking probes of unlimited delicacy, our knowledge of quantities is necessarily accompanied by uncertainty. Consequently, physics requires a calculus of number pairs and not only scalars for quantity alone. Basic symmetries of shuffling and sequencing dictate that pairs obey ordinary component-wise addition, but they can have three different multiplication rules. We call those rules A, B and C. “A” shows that pairs behave as complex numbers, which is why quantum theory is complex. However, consistency with the ordinary scalar rules of probability shows that the fundamental object is not a particle on its Hilbert sphere but a stream represented by a Gaussian distribution. “B” is then applied to pairs of complex numbers (qubits) and produces the Pauli matrices for which its operation defines the space of four vectors. “C” then allows integration of what can then be recognised as energy-momentum into time and space. The picture is entirely consistent. Spacetime is a construct of quantum and not a container for it.

International Workshop on Bayesian Inference and Maximum Entropy Methods in Science and Engineering (MaxEnt)•Dec 10, 2021•1 citation

Where Did the Mysteries of Quantum Mechanics Arise? -Complex Numbers, Hilbert Space, Schrödinger’s Cat, Quantum Entanglement, and the Question of Physical Mechanism from the Perspective of NNRT-

Eizo Nakaza

Quantum mechanics came to employ complex probability amplitudes and the abstract state space known as Hilbert space because the behavior of electrons and light could not be described by the intuition of classical three-dimensional space alone. Complex numbers retain the magnitude and phase of an amplitude within a single quantity, while Hilbert space unifies linear superposition, inner products, observables, and time evolution in one mathematical framework. This made it possible to describe point-like particle detections and wave-like interference within the same theory. Yet this mathematical success also raised an ontological question: should the state structure in Hilbert space be read as physical reality itself? That question developed into long-standing debates over Schrödinger’s cat, the measurement problem, quantum entanglement, and nonlocality. This paper traces that history for a general readership and applies to quantum theory the distinction, emphasized by NNRT in relativity, between “successful mathematics” and “the physical reality of the mathematical object.” It then argues that physics remains incomplete at that stage: the next central task is to identify the physical mechanism—what acts on what, and how—that gives rise to the observed phenomena. Central thesis: Three questions must be distinguished: whether mathematics correctly describes a phenomenon, whether the mathematical structure itself is physical reality, and whether the physical mechanism producing the phenomenon is actually understood.

•Sep 28, 2026•0 citations

Quantum theory based on real numbers can be experimentally falsified

Marc-Olivier Renou, David Trillo, Mirjam Weilenmann +5 more

Abstract Although complex numbers are essential in mathematics, they are not needed to describe physical experiments, as those are expressed in terms of probabilities, hence real numbers. Physics, however, aims to explain, rather than describe, experiments through theories. Although most theories of physics are based on real numbers, quantum theory was the first to be formulated in terms of operators acting on complex Hilbert spaces 1,2 . This has puzzled countless physicists, including the fathers of the theory, for whom a real version of quantum theory, in terms of real operators, seemed much more natural 3 . In fact, previous studies have shown that such a ‘real quantum theory’ can reproduce the outcomes of any multipartite experiment, as long as the parts share arbitrary real quantum states 4 . Here we investigate whether complex numbers are actually needed in the quantum formalism. We show this to be case by proving that real and complex Hilbert-space formulations of quantum theory make different predictions in network scenarios comprising independent states and measurements. This allows us to devise a Bell-like experiment, the successful realization of which would disprove real quantum theory, in the same way as standard Bell experiments disproved local physics.

arXiv:2101.10873•Nature•Dec 15, 2021•275 citations

The World According to Quantum Mechanics: Why the Laws of Physics Make Perfect Sense After All

Ulrich Mohrhoff

Overview: Two Simple Rules and Two Easy Applications The Historical Route The Feynman Route Nitty-Gritty: Why Probabilities? Why Vector Spaces? Why Complex Numbers? Whence the Trace Rule? How Probabilities Depend on Measurement Outcomes How Probabilities Depend on the Times of Measurements Whence Those Simple Rules? Why Spin? Composite Systems Why Fermions? Special Relativity in a Nutshell Why Relativity? Whence the Classical Forces? Meaning of EnergyA and MomentumA Why Relativistic Quantum Mechanics? Making Sense: Why Measurements? The Importance of Unperformed Measurements The Stability of Matter A Sleight of Hand That Almost Worked A Sleight of Hand That Cannot Work Pseudo-Problems and Gratuitous Solutions A Space for the Quantum World A Particle by Itself The Emergence of Form CreationA in a Nutshell Defining MacroworldA Assigning Reality The Supervenience of MicroA on MacroA ManifestationA - A Better Paradigm? Not the Theory but the World is Incomplete Explanation or Magic Wand?

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Mar 1, 2011•11 citations
Abstract. Physics is real. Measurement produces real numbers. Yet quantum mechanics uses com-plex arithmetic, in which √−1 is necessary but mysteriously relates to nothing else. By applying the same sort of symmetry arguments that Cox [1, 2] used to justify probability calculus, we are now able to explain this puzzle. The dual device/object nature of observation requires us to describe the world in terms of pairs of real numbers about which we never have full knowledge. These pairs combine according to complex arithmetic, using Feynman’s rules.
Dirac called the imaginary unit in the Schrödinger equation the deepest thing in quantum mechanics, and admitted he did not understand it. This note offers a candidate: i is the complex place of a single number — Q, the real root of x⁴ − x − 1 — and the strangeness of quantum mechanics is the strangeness of that one number's arithmetic, seen from the inside. For a century quantum theory has been taught as a list of postulates — complex amplitudes, a Born rule, unitary evolution, a dagger — accepted because they work and never because they are understood. Grant a single identification, that the state space of a quantum system is the complex place of Q's field, and those postulates stop being assumptions. They become theorems. The imaginary unit is the field's complex structure; the dagger is Galois conjugation; observables are real because they are Galois-fixed; unitary evolution is the field's unit circle; and the Born rule — the squared modulus, long the least-explained law in physics — is the field's own norm, made unique by Gleason's theorem. Time reversal and charge conjugation appear as named elements of the Galois group S₄, the Weyl group of su(4). And a proved theorem locates the classical/quantum boundary precisely: in the family xⁿ − x − 1 the root is Pisot — its powers settle, its world definite — only through three dimensions, and at the fourth that settling fails. That, on the reading proposed here, is where the classical world ends and the quantum world begins. The dozen postulates of the physics textbooks are thus compressed to one here, named plainly as a posit, with every claim labeled at its evidential tier and the composition of many systems left as the open edge. It is not a metaphor and not a fit. Quantum Mechanics is the arithmetic of a single number — and, at last, a single thing to be right or wrong about.
Abstract Quantification starts with sum and product rules that express combination and partition. These rules rest on elementary symmetries that have wide applicability, which explains why arithmetical adding up and splitting into proportions are ubiquitous. Specifically, measure theory formalizes addition, and probability theory formalizes inference in terms of proportions. Quantum theory rests on the same simple symmetries, but is formalized in two dimensions, not just one, in order to track an object through its binary interactions with other objects. The symmetries still require sum and product rules (here known as the Feynman rules), but they apply to complex numbers instead of real scalars, with observable probabilities being modulus squared (known as the Born rule). The standard quantum formalism follows. There is no mystery or weirdness, just ordinary probabilistic inference.
Why quantum? Why spacetime? We find that the key idea underlying both is uncertainty. In a world lacking probes of unlimited delicacy, our knowledge of quantities is necessarily accompanied by uncertainty. Consequently, physics requires a calculus of number pairs and not only scalars for quantity alone. Basic symmetries of shuffling and sequencing dictate that pairs obey ordinary component-wise addition, but they can have three different multiplication rules. We call those rules A, B and C. “A” shows that pairs behave as complex numbers, which is why quantum theory is complex. However, consistency with the ordinary scalar rules of probability shows that the fundamental object is not a particle on its Hilbert sphere but a stream represented by a Gaussian distribution. “B” is then applied to pairs of complex numbers (qubits) and produces the Pauli matrices for which its operation defines the space of four vectors. “C” then allows integration of what can then be recognised as energy-momentum into time and space. The picture is entirely consistent. Spacetime is a construct of quantum and not a container for it.
Quantum mechanics came to employ complex probability amplitudes and the abstract state space known as Hilbert space because the behavior of electrons and light could not be described by the intuition of classical three-dimensional space alone. Complex numbers retain the magnitude and phase of an amplitude within a single quantity, while Hilbert space unifies linear superposition, inner products, observables, and time evolution in one mathematical framework. This made it possible to describe point-like particle detections and wave-like interference within the same theory. Yet this mathematical success also raised an ontological question: should the state structure in Hilbert space be read as physical reality itself? That question developed into long-standing debates over Schrödinger’s cat, the measurement problem, quantum entanglement, and nonlocality. This paper traces that history for a general readership and applies to quantum theory the distinction, emphasized by NNRT in relativity, between “successful mathematics” and “the physical reality of the mathematical object.” It then argues that physics remains incomplete at that stage: the next central task is to identify the physical mechanism—what acts on what, and how—that gives rise to the observed phenomena. Central thesis: Three questions must be distinguished: whether mathematics correctly describes a phenomenon, whether the mathematical structure itself is physical reality, and whether the physical mechanism producing the phenomenon is actually understood.
Abstract Although complex numbers are essential in mathematics, they are not needed to describe physical experiments, as those are expressed in terms of probabilities, hence real numbers. Physics, however, aims to explain, rather than describe, experiments through theories. Although most theories of physics are based on real numbers, quantum theory was the first to be formulated in terms of operators acting on complex Hilbert spaces 1,2 . This has puzzled countless physicists, including the fathers of the theory, for whom a real version of quantum theory, in terms of real operators, seemed much more natural 3 . In fact, previous studies have shown that such a ‘real quantum theory’ can reproduce the outcomes of any multipartite experiment, as long as the parts share arbitrary real quantum states 4 . Here we investigate whether complex numbers are actually needed in the quantum formalism. We show this to be case by proving that real and complex Hilbert-space formulations of quantum theory make different predictions in network scenarios comprising independent states and measurements. This allows us to devise a Bell-like experiment, the successful realization of which would disprove real quantum theory, in the same way as standard Bell experiments disproved local physics.
Overview: Two Simple Rules and Two Easy Applications The Historical Route The Feynman Route Nitty-Gritty: Why Probabilities? Why Vector Spaces? Why Complex Numbers? Whence the Trace Rule? How Probabilities Depend on Measurement Outcomes How Probabilities Depend on the Times of Measurements Whence Those Simple Rules? Why Spin? Composite Systems Why Fermions? Special Relativity in a Nutshell Why Relativity? Whence the Classical Forces? Meaning of EnergyA and MomentumA Why Relativistic Quantum Mechanics? Making Sense: Why Measurements? The Importance of Unperformed Measurements The Stability of Matter A Sleight of Hand That Almost Worked A Sleight of Hand That Cannot Work Pseudo-Problems and Gratuitous Solutions A Space for the Quantum World A Particle by Itself The Emergence of Form CreationA in a Nutshell Defining MacroworldA Assigning Reality The Supervenience of MicroA on MacroA ManifestationA - A Better Paradigm? Not the Theory but the World is Incomplete Explanation or Magic Wand?