We study the problem of a simultaneous measurement of incompatible observables in the framework of Prugoveckiis empirical theory of measurement (i.e., the theory where the irreducible errors in individual measurements ought to be taken into account). We propose a solution for the main problem of this theory: negative probability distributions that arise for some states in the probabilistic description of a simultaneous measurement. These probabilities have a meaningful frequency interpretation. However, limits of relative frequencies exist only in a generalized sense and this is only a chaotic oscillation from the ordinary point of view. We present a measurement (i.e., a preparation and determinative measurements) where negative and usual Kolmogorov probabilities might arise. We show that there are two roots of negative probabilities: disturbance effects and the finite exactness of a measurement. Resume : Nous Otudions le problme reliO aux mesures simultanOes diobservables
We study the problem of a simultaneous measurement of incompatible observables in the framework of Prugoveckiis empirical theory of measurement (i.e., the theory where the irreducible errors in individual measurements ought to be taken into account). We propose a solution for the main problem of this theory: negative probability distributions that arise for some states in the probabilistic description of a simultaneous measurement. These probabilities have a meaningful frequency interpretation. However, limits of relative frequencies exist only in a generalized sense and this is only a chaotic oscillation from the ordinary point of view. We present a measurement (i.e., a preparation and determinative measurements) where negative and usual Kolmogorov probabilities might arise. We show that there are two roots of negative probabilities: disturbance effects and the finite exactness of a measurement. Resume : Nous Otudions le problme reliO aux mesures simultanOes diobservables
According to the Kolmogorovian Censorship Hypothesis, everything that quantum theory says about the world in the language of the quantum mechanical Hilbert space formalism is actually about relationships between ordinary relative frequencies expressible in operational terms using classical Kolmogorovian probability theory. In other words, a quantum theoretical description of a system should in principle be translatable into a purely operational-probabilistic description. However, our goal in this paper is different; we do not want to deal with the problem how to translate the known theory of quantum mechanics into operational terms, or to reconstruct the theory from postulates which can be interpreted in operational terms. Our aim is somewhat broader and points in the opposite direction. We start with a general scheme for the operational description of an arbitrary physical system. The description is based solely on the notion of observable events (measurement operations and measurement results) and on general, empirically established simple laws concerning their relative frequency. These laws are so simple and fundamental that they apply equally to any physical system. In the first part of the paper, we outline the basic elements of such an operational-probabilistic theory. In the second part, we discuss how this operational-probabilistic description compares to the quantum mechanical description and to what extent the standard Hilbert space quantum mechanics can be regarded as a reformulation of the general operational-probabilistic theory.
The empirical meaning of the simultaneity of measurement of several observables is carefully analyzed. General criteria sufficient to guarantee the internal consistency of a framework including simultaneous measurements of incompatible observables are put forward. The case is illustrated with the example of simultaneous measurements of position and momenta of particles in quantum mechanics. It is pointed out that, in general, the outcome of measurements of incompatible observables cannot be described statistically by means of the probability measures of mathematical statistics, which have primarily been introduced only with compatible observables in mind. The concept of complex probability measure is put forward. A generalization of the current interpretation of quantum mechanics is proposed that would also include the case of incompatible observables, by taking advantage of the concept of complex probability measure.
In this paper, we do not try to solve the measurement problem, but rather to properly formulate it. One of the reasons why it still lacks a precise, agreed definition is that the problem may take very different aspects depending on the interpretation of quantum mechanics embraced. Inspired by the methodology of theory-independent results like Bell's theorem, we propose to identify the common root of the puzzle in an interpretation-independent way i.e. as a property of the empirical statistics only, before deriving its philosophical consequences. The key observation is that quantum matter can not be described by a Kolmogorovian probabilistic theory. Arguing that the Kolmogorov axioms of probability theory are the postulates of epistemic uncertainty leads us to reformulate the measurement problem as the impossibility to build an ontology independent of epistemology for quantum matter. Said differently, there exists no God's-eye view on quantum systems. Although it is meaningless to solve the measurement problem as defined in this way, insofar as it is a feature of the universe's statistics, such a formulation may on the other hand bring side benefits. In particular, we argue that it allows to: (i) shed a new light on the variety of interpretations; (ii) propose a fundamental reason why quantum mechanics and general relativity are so incompatible, not relying on purely mathematical or technical arguments; (iii) guide the quest for quantum gravity.
Quantum theory challenges the view that individual measurement outcomes are predefined and independent of the measurement context. Yet the quantum state itself -- the catalogue of probabilities for all possible measurements -- is usually assumed to be well defined. We argue that this assumption tacitly relies on measurements being performed relative to ideal, infinitely-resourceful reference frames. We show that, when measurements are made relative to non-ideal quantum reference frames, the probabilities themselves become indefinite: even in the limit of arbitrarily large number of runs, the relative frequencies may remain uncertain. The uncertainty is irreducible in a quantum-mechanical sense, as we show by proving a Bell-type theorem for relative frequencies. We further propose a quantum-optical implementation of these relational measurements based on pulsed homodyne detection. Our findings motivate an extension of the notion of the quantum state to regimes constrained by finite resources. We expect them to be especially relevant at the interface between quantum theory and general relativity, where the resources and information available in a bounded region of spacetime are fundamentally limited.
This paper is devoted to foundations of probability theory. We discuss interpretations of probability, corresponding mathematical formalisms, and applications to quantum physics. One of the aims of this paper is to show that the probability model based on Kolmogorov's axiomatics cannot describe all stochastic phenomena, i.e., that quantum physics induces natural restrictions of the use of Kolmogorov's theory and that we need to develop non-Kolmogorov models for describing some quantum phenomena. The physical motivations are presented in a clear and brief manner. Thus the reader does not need to have preliminary knowledgeof quantum physics. Our main idea is that we cannot develop non-Kolmogorov models by the formal change of Kolmogorov's axiomatics. We begin with interpretations (classical, frequency, and proportional). Then we present a class of non-Kolmogorov models described by so-called p-adic numbers. Here, in particular, we obtain a quite natural realization of negative probabilities. These negative probability distributions might provide a solution of some quantum paradoxes.
This thesis concerns how attempting to measure certain fundamental properties \nof a physical theory can lead us to new insights. The idea of general probabilistic \nmodels is introduced and developed, in order to provide a way to be able to \nconsider and compare different theories. A measure of incompatibility of two \nobservables is defined, through the amount of smearing needed to make them \njointly measureable. This measure is then used to characterise the degree of \nincompatibility that exists in a given theory. Quantum theory is then shown \nto be as incompatible as any other theory, but only in a very course grained \nsense. A related way of measuring the strength of incompatibility of a pair \nof observables is then shown to put a bound on a measure of the strength of \nnon-local correlations. The notion of steering, or remote ensemble preparation, \nis then shown to be a sufficient condition for the saturation of that bound. \nExamples are considered that demonstrate that the given sufficient notion of \nsteering is not necessary, and it is proposed how the measures can be modified \nin cases where the link does not hold. The idea of formulating measures of \nerror and disturbance associated with a measurement device is discussed. The \nnotion of a direct test of error or disturbance is used to analyse current proposed \nmeasures, and show their shortcomings.