Classical mechanics is empirically successful because the probabilistic mean values of quantum mechanical observables follow the classical equations of motion to a good approximation (Messiah 1970, 215). We examine this claim for the one-dimensional motion of a particle in a box, and extend the idea by deriving a special case of the ideal gas law in terms of the mean value of a generalized force used to define “pressure.” The examples illustrate the importance of probabilistic averaging as a method of abstracting away from the messy details of microphenomena, not only in physics, but in other sciences as well.
Classical mechanics is empirically successful because the probabilistic mean values of quantum mechanical observables follow the classical equations of motion to a good approximation (Messiah 1970, 215). We examine this claim for the one-dimensional motion of a particle in a box, and extend the idea by deriving a special case of the ideal gas law in terms of the mean value of a generalized force used to define “pressure.” The examples illustrate the importance of probabilistic averaging as a method of abstracting away from the messy details of microphenomena, not only in physics, but in other sciences as well.
Textbooks in quantum mechanics frequently claim that quantum mechanics explains the success of classical mechanics because the mean values [of quantum mechanical observables] follow the classical equations of motion to a good approximation, while the dimensions of the wave packet be small with respect to the characteristic dimensions of the problem. The equations in question are Ehrenfest's famous equations. We examine this case for the one-dimensional motion of a particle in a box, and extend the idea deriving a special case of the ideal gas law in terms of the mean value of a generalized force, which has been used in statistical mechanics to define pressure. The example may be an important test case for recent philosophical theories about the relationship between micro-theories and macro-theories in science.
Newtonian mechanics focuses on dx and dt units which tend to zero and so presents, it seems, a smoothed over or averaged type of motion. This motion in principle extends to dx and dt values which are almost zero. There is, however, a priori no reason not to expect that such a smooth averaging is at some length scale based on another kind of motion. The question is: What should that “other” kind of motion be? If it is deterministic in x and t, one may reapply the idea of this motion breaking down at yet some smaller scale. Thus it seems one should consider decoupling of x and t because one cannot follow a particle from one x point to another in time within some small length scale as this would be deterministic. The opposite approach seems to be a probabilistic one with t and x decoupled. The external ruler and clock which exist in the Newtonian picture, however, do not disappear simply because a length scale is small. Thus having x positions based on probabilities at some length scale still uses the notion of the probability itself being smoothed over because it contains x which may take on any value. This is not necessarily a problem because the probabilistic behaviour must still appear to be Newtonian on average and so x and t based on the external clock/ruler with infinite resolution need to “appear” again. (For example, an electron has a wavelength and exhibits interference from two slits, but while moving towards the slits, distance = velocity* time with distance and time measured by an external clock. It is a mathematical generalization, however, to expect that d=vt actually fully describes motion (i.e. other than on average) within a wavelength length. If it did there would be no interference pattern. The idea of a smoothed over (or averaged motion) based on probabilistic motion also appears in the classical world, but for many particles. For example, a Maxwell-Boltzmann gas with no potential has uniform density. If one considers a hypothetical box containing many molecules, it is like a Newtonian stationary object with a balance of pressure. In the case of a potential (1-D) one may consider a dx unit (with many molecules) and balance Force(x) density(x) with the difference of pressure to find the density distribution proportional to exp(- V(x)/T). These ideas are completely Newtonian, but they are smoothed over average notions. At a microscopic level molecules undergo probabilistic collisions linked to T (temperature). Thus the microscopic picture is not static - it is only the equilibrium average or big picture which is static. Even in the case of no potential, focusing on a tiny region of space smaller than the interparticle average separation and arguing that density is constant seems to be an average argument which bypasses much of the reality. If x and t may then become probabilistic and -Et+px is a Lorentz invariant, then why should there not be stochasticity linked with E and p? In fact we argue they are == as shown by Maxwell’s solution of a photon from his electromagnetic equations. E and p (energy and momentum) are average values. Their density is given by: .5C1( Electric field dot Electric field + C2 Magnetic field dot Magnetic field) and the Poynting vector for momentum. Both the Electric field and Magnetic field fluctuate as cos(-Et+px) with E and p being average values. At first this was ascribed to wave motion in a medium, but in 1905 Einstein’s photoelectric arguments against energy being spread out seem to suggest a breakdown of deterministic physics describing a wave in a medium. Instead a photon is probabilistic and has a wavefunction of Electric + i Magnetic field. (2)
Classical mechanics is usually valid at the macro scale. The changes in the position and the momentum of the object over time are described by the Hamiltonian equation of motion. The wave function in quantum mechanics, if unobserved, evolves in a smooth and continuous way according to the Schrodinger equation, which is related to the Hamiltonian equation of motion. This equation describes a linear superposition of different states at time. A quantum mechanical description of a physical system is related to a probabilistic representation; it is described by a vector in Hilbert space. This description extends the two- or three-dimensional Euclidean space into spaces that have any finite or infinite number of dimensions. The state of a compound system is projected to the subspace that corresponds to the observed state and the vector representing the state is renormalized to the unit length. An observable describes a subspace for some dimensions with a special case of one dimension.
While ultimately they are described by quantum mechanics, macroscopic mechanical systems are nevertheless observed to follow the trajectories predicted by classical mechanics. Hence, in the regime defining macroscopic physics, the trajectories of the correct classical motion must emerge from quantum mechanics, a process referred to as the quantum to classical transition. Extending previous work [Bhattacharya, Habib, and Jacobs, Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 4852 (2000)], here we elucidate this transition in some detail, showing that once the measurement processes that affect all macroscopic systems are taken into account, quantum mechanics indeed predicts the emergence of classical motion. We derive inequalities that describe the parameter regime in which classical motion is obtained, and provide numerical examples. We also demonstrate two further important properties of the classical limit: first, that multiple observers all agree on the motion of an object, and second, that classical statistical inference may be used to correctly track the classical motion.
The motion of macroscopic objects such as soccer balls, vehicles and planets can be well described using classical mechanics. However, classical mechanics is inadequate to describe the movements or the structure of microscopic objects such as atoms, molecules or nuclei. To properly describe the properties of microscopic objects, the theory of quantum mechanics was developed. While quantum mechanics can be applied to macroscopic objects, it turns out that for objects of large dimensions the quantum mechanical laws evolve naturally into classical mechanics. In general, solving a problem in quantum mechanics is far more difficult than solving it in classical mechanics. Therefore, the laws of classical mechanics are employed when they can be applied safely.
There seems to be much interest in the literature (1) in associating quantum mechanics (in particular the Schrodinger equation) with a classical joint phase space probability F(x,p,t) such as appears in classical Liouville theory etc. Here, we consider that P(x)dx = dx/L for a particle at rest and analyze the extra physics which appears when one considers a single particle bouncing back and forth in a box, which is what a person in a frame moving with -v would see (albeit with a Lorentz contracted L.) We suggest that the constraint L is important as it is linked with physical forces which appear when the particle moves. In other words, a particle at rest is linked with a static probability, while for motion, one must have a probability which is linked to more than x and t, but to force considerations in x and t, a dynamical probability. (Experiment bears this out as we discuss.) In particular, we argue that in the case of a moving particle, two physical concepts related to force appear, namely pressure which is an average over time and impulse hit which is only linked with space. Thus, two different particles may have the same p, but different v and pressure values. We thus suggest a physical grouping of (p,x) and (pressure, t). We then note that one needs to somehow preserve the notion of P(x)=1/L, i.e motion does not introduce a bias to x, nor to time. In a rest frame, there is no motion and so there is neither p nor pressure, but P(x)=1/L pertains. If one tries to define a probability with two groupings, one for pressure, t and the other for p,x, then if one multiples a p1 case by a p2 case, the p,x grouping should yield p1+p2, x. Furthermore, a p,x grouping should imply mixed terms, e.g. px etc, otherwise one does not really have an association between the two variables. This suggests a pf(x) form linked to the p-x grouping. Given the notion of special relativity, it seems that one may replace pressure with the notion of energy and create a Lorentz invariant probability. This would then lead to the free particle quantum wavefunction (probability) exp(-iEt+ipx), but we argue that the roots are in classical physics and a desire to physically describe the physical information present for a particle bouncing back and forth in a box.