Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Modern Optics

On the Hermitian Optical Phase Operator

Stephen Mark Barnett, David Thomas Pegg

Published Jan 1, 1989• 545 citations
Publisher

Abstract

It has long been believed that no Hermitian optical phase operator exists. However, such an operator can be constructed from the phase states. We demonstrate that its properties are precisely in accord with the results of semiclassical and phenomenological approaches when such approximate methods are valid. We find that the number-phase commutator differs from that originally postulated by Dirac. This difference allows the consistent use of the commutator for inherently quantum states. It also leads to the correct periodic phase behaviour of the Poisson bracket in the classical regime.

DOI
10.1080/09500348914550021

Related papers

Phase properties of the quantized single-mode electromagnetic field

David Thomas Pegg, Stephen Mark Barnett

The usual mathematical model of the single-mode electromagnetic field is the harmonic oscillator with an infinite-dimensional state space, which unfortunately cannot accommodate the existence of a Hermitian phase operator. Recently we indicated that this difficulty may be circumvented by using an alternative, and physically indistinguishable, mathematical model of the single-mode field involving a finite but arbitrarily large state space, the dimension of which is allowed to tend to infinity after physically measurable results, such as expectation values, are calculated. In this paper we investigate the properties of a Hermitian phase operator which follows directly and uniquely from the form of the phase states in this space and find them to be well behaved. The phase-number commutator is not subject to the difficulties inherent in Dirac's original commutator, but still preserves the commutator--Poisson-bracket correspondence for physical field states. In the quantum regime of small field strengths, the phase operator predicts phase properties substantially different from those obtained using the conventional Susskind-Glogower operators. In particular, our results are consistent with the vacuum being a state of random phase and the phases of two vacuum fields being uncorrelated. For higher-intensity fields, the quantum phase properties agree with those previously obtained by phenomenological and semiclassical approaches, where such approximations are valid. We illustrate the properties of the phase with a discussion of partial phase states. The Hermitian phase operator also allows us to construct a unitary number-shift operator and phase-moment generating functions. We conclude that the alternative mathematical description of the single-mode field presented here provides a valid, and potentially useful, quantum-mechanical approach for calculating the phase properties of the electromagnetic field.

Physical Review A•Feb 1, 1989•865 citations

A Proof for Poisson Bracket in Non-commutative Algebra of Quantum Mechanics

Sina Ataollah Khorasani

The widely accepted approach to the foundation of quantum mechanics is that the Poisson bracket, governing the non-commutative algebra of operators, is taken as a postulate with no underlying physics. In this manuscript, it is shown that this postulation is in fact unnecessary and may be replaced by a few deeper concepts, which ultimately lead to the derivation of Poisson bracket. One would only need to use Fourier transform pairs and Kramers-Kronig identities in the complex domain. We present a definition of Hermitian time-operator and discuss some of its basic properties.

arXiv:1411.1338•Electronic journal of theoretical physics•Nov 5, 2014•2 citations

Quantum optical phase, rigged Hilbert spaces and complementarity

Khai Bordon, Joan A. Vaccaro

in its historical context, and outline research that it inspired. We show how it led Pegg and Barnett to their quantum phase formalism, explaining the challenges that they overcame to define phase operators and phase eigenstates rigorously. We show how the formalism essentially constructs an extended rigged Hilbert space that supports strong limits of the phase operators and includes their eigenstates. We identify the complementarity structure (consisting of mutually unbiased bases and generators of cyclical permutations) underpinning Pegg and Barnett's general approach that gives a quantum-classical correspondence free of the ambiguity of Dirac's commutator-Poisson bracket correspondence.This article is part of the theme issue 'The quantum theory of light'.

Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Dec 24, 2024•1 citation

Quantum optical phase

David Thomas Pegg, Stephen Mark Barnett

The phase associated with a single mode of the electromagnetic field is complementary to the photon number. This simple idea leads us to construct a probability density for the phase. The phase operator cannot be represented exactly in the usual-infinite Hilbert space but can be constructed in a subspace of it and provides a valid representation of phase if used together with a suitable limiting procedure. We introduce the Hermitian optical phase operator and describe some of its most important properties. We also provide brief discussions of some alternative approaches to the phase problem and to the question of phase measurements. The paper concludes with an extensive bibliography.

Journal of Modern Optics•Feb 1, 1997•93 citations

Operational Phase Operators and Hermitian Phase Operators

K. Kakazu

It is shown that there exist two kinds of operational (or measured) phase operators, those of the Hradil type [Phys. Rev. A 47 (1993), 4532], defined on the entire Hilbert space, and those of the Noh-Fougères-Mandel type [Phys. Rev. A 45 (1992), 424], defined only on a subspace. As a consequence, strictly speaking, the Noh-Fougères-Mandel measured phase cannot be defined in the case of, for example, coherent states, squeezed states and the vacuum. The difference between these operators is made clear by using the concept of the Bargmann distance between a quantum state and its “reduced” state. Since Noh et al. did not use the correct variances of the Susskind-Glogower and Pegg-Barnett phase operators when they compared their data with the results predicted through use of these operators, the correct expressions in that case are presented. Comparing the measured operators with the Hermitian phase operator in the extended Susskind-Glogower formalism, we show that the quantum phase given by the Hermitian phase operator is more appropriate than the measured phases. The variance of the Hermitian operator in the vacuum is consistent with the complementarity of the photon number and phase, which implies that the vacuum has a uniform phase distribution. Hradil's measured operator does not have such a property. Although the Noh-Fougères-Mandel operator has such a property in a particular limit, this operator does not represent, in principle, a meaningful measure of the phase measurement in a typical quantum region, because the Bargmann distance becomes large in such a region.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Oct 1, 2003•0 citations

Phase states and phase operators for the quantum harmonic oscillator

Antoine Royer

How does the classical notion of ``phase'' apply to a quantum harmonic oscillator H=1/2(q${\mathrm{^}}^{2}$+p${\mathrm{^}}^{2}$), [q^,p^]=i\ensuremath{\Elzxh}, which cannot have sharp position and momentum? A quantum state \ensuremath{\rho}^ can be assigned a definite classical phase only if it is a large-amplitude localized state. Our only demand, therefore, on a (Hermitian) phase operator \ensuremath{\varphi}^ is that the phase distribution P(\ensuremath{\Phi})= Tr{\ensuremath{\delta}(\ensuremath{\varphi}^-\ensuremath{\Phi})\ensuremath{\rho}^} attribute the correct sharp phase to any such ``classical phase'' state. This requires that the Weyl symbol [\ensuremath{\varphi}^${]}_{\mathit{w}}$(q,p) of \ensuremath{\varphi}^ tend to \ensuremath{\theta} mod2\ensuremath{\pi} as r\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}, where \ensuremath{\theta}=${\mathrm{tan}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}1}$(p/q) and r=(${\mathit{q}}^{2}$+${\mathit{p}}^{2}$${)}^{1/2}$. There are infinitely many such phase operators. Each is expressible as \ensuremath{\varphi}^=[${\mathrm{tan}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}1}$(p^/q^)${]}_{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}}$, where \ensuremath{\Omega} specifies an ordering rule for q^ and p^. The commutator -i[H^,\ensuremath{\varphi}^]=1-2\ensuremath{\pi}[\ensuremath{\delta}(${\mathrm{tan}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}1}$p^/q^)${]}_{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}}$ corresponds to the Poisson bracket {H,${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varphi}}}_{\mathrm{cl}}$${\mathrm{}}}_{\mathrm{}\mathrm{PB}}$=1-2\ensuremath{\pi}\ensuremath{\delta}(\ensuremath{\theta}) for the single-valued classical phase ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varphi}}}_{\mathrm{cl}}$=\ensuremath{\theta} mod2\ensuremath{\pi}. Phase states \ensuremath{\Gamma}^(\ensuremath{\Phi}) are defined by the condition that their Weyl symbols [\ensuremath{\Gamma}^(\ensuremath{\Phi})${]}_{\mathit{w}}$(r,\ensuremath{\theta})\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\delta}(\ensuremath{\theta}-\ensuremath{\Phi}) as r\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}. If moreover ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\int}}}_{0}^{2\mathrm{\ensuremath{\pi}}}$d\ensuremath{\Phi}\ensuremath{\Gamma}^(\ensuremath{\Phi})=1^, then \ensuremath{\Gamma}^(\ensuremath{\Phi}) is a phase probability operator measure (POM). In particular, \ensuremath{\delta}(\ensuremath{\varphi}^-\ensuremath{\Phi}) is a phase POM.Normalizable approximate phase states \ensuremath{\Gamma}${\mathrm{^}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}}$(\ensuremath{\Phi}) are defined by [\ensuremath{\Gamma}${\mathrm{^}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}}$(\ensuremath{\Phi})${]}_{\mathit{w}}$(r,\ensuremath{\theta}) =2\ensuremath{\pi}${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}}^{2}$${\mathit{e}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}\mathit{r}}$[\ensuremath{\Gamma}^(\ensuremath{\Phi})${]}_{\mathit{w}}$(r,\ensuremath{\theta}), \ensuremath{\varepsilon}\ensuremath{\ll}1. Phase states are not, in general, ``pure orthogonal'' in the sense \ensuremath{\Gamma}^(\ensuremath{\Phi})\ensuremath{\Gamma}^(\ensuremath{\Phi}\ensuremath{'})=\ensuremath{\delta}(\ensuremath{\Phi}-\ensuremath{\Phi}\ensuremath{'})\ensuremath{\Gamma}^(\ensuremath{\Phi}), unless they are of the form \ensuremath{\delta}(\ensuremath{\varphi}^-\ensuremath{\Phi}). However, any phase state \ensuremath{\Gamma}${\mathrm{^}}_{1}$(\ensuremath{\Phi}) is trace orthogonal to any phase POM \ensuremath{\Gamma}${\mathrm{^}}_{2}$(\ensuremath{\Phi}), in the sense that Tr{\ensuremath{\Gamma}${\mathrm{^}}_{2}$(\ensuremath{\Phi}\ensuremath{'})\ensuremath{\Gamma}${\mathrm{^}}_{1}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}}$(\ensuremath{\Phi})}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\delta}(\ensuremath{\Phi}-\ensuremath{\Phi}\ensuremath{'}) as \ensuremath{\varepsilon}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0. This implies that measurement of the POM \ensuremath{\Gamma}${\mathrm{^}}_{2}$(\ensuremath{\Phi}\ensuremath{'}) on the state \ensuremath{\Gamma}${\mathrm{^}}_{1}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}}$(\ensuremath{\Phi}) yields the outcome \ensuremath{\Phi} with probability 1 as \ensuremath{\varepsilon}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0. Phase measurements of the first kind are possible in principle; they would allow one to prepare (approximate) phase states and monitor their phase evolution in a quantum (phase) nondemolishing manner. Cases of special interest are the Susskind-Glogower and the Cahill-Glauber ordered phase states and operators. The energy-phase (or number-phase) uncertainty relation is \ensuremath{\Delta}H\ensuremath{\Delta}\ensuremath{\varphi}\ensuremath{\ge}0, the lower limit \ensuremath{\Delta}H\ensuremath{\Delta}\ensuremath{\varphi}=0 being realized by pure number states; however, for states whose Wigner functions are localized away from the origin and from the extremities of the (single-valued) phase window (0,2\ensuremath{\pi}), the uncertainty relation is effectively \ensuremath{\Delta}H\ensuremath{\Delta}\ensuremath{\varphi}\ensuremath{\ge}1/2. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.

Physical Review A•Jan 1, 1996•38 citations
It has long been believed that no Hermitian optical phase operator exists. However, such an operator can be constructed from the phase states. We demonstrate that its properties are precisely in accord with the results of semiclassical and phenomenological approaches when such approximate methods are valid. We find that the number-phase commutator differs from that originally postulated by Dirac. This difference allows the consistent use of the commutator for inherently quantum states. It also leads to the correct periodic phase behaviour of the Poisson bracket in the classical regime.
The usual mathematical model of the single-mode electromagnetic field is the harmonic oscillator with an infinite-dimensional state space, which unfortunately cannot accommodate the existence of a Hermitian phase operator. Recently we indicated that this difficulty may be circumvented by using an alternative, and physically indistinguishable, mathematical model of the single-mode field involving a finite but arbitrarily large state space, the dimension of which is allowed to tend to infinity after physically measurable results, such as expectation values, are calculated. In this paper we investigate the properties of a Hermitian phase operator which follows directly and uniquely from the form of the phase states in this space and find them to be well behaved. The phase-number commutator is not subject to the difficulties inherent in Dirac's original commutator, but still preserves the commutator--Poisson-bracket correspondence for physical field states. In the quantum regime of small field strengths, the phase operator predicts phase properties substantially different from those obtained using the conventional Susskind-Glogower operators. In particular, our results are consistent with the vacuum being a state of random phase and the phases of two vacuum fields being uncorrelated. For higher-intensity fields, the quantum phase properties agree with those previously obtained by phenomenological and semiclassical approaches, where such approximations are valid. We illustrate the properties of the phase with a discussion of partial phase states. The Hermitian phase operator also allows us to construct a unitary number-shift operator and phase-moment generating functions. We conclude that the alternative mathematical description of the single-mode field presented here provides a valid, and potentially useful, quantum-mechanical approach for calculating the phase properties of the electromagnetic field.
The widely accepted approach to the foundation of quantum mechanics is that the Poisson bracket, governing the non-commutative algebra of operators, is taken as a postulate with no underlying physics. In this manuscript, it is shown that this postulation is in fact unnecessary and may be replaced by a few deeper concepts, which ultimately lead to the derivation of Poisson bracket. One would only need to use Fourier transform pairs and Kramers-Kronig identities in the complex domain. We present a definition of Hermitian time-operator and discuss some of its basic properties.
in its historical context, and outline research that it inspired. We show how it led Pegg and Barnett to their quantum phase formalism, explaining the challenges that they overcame to define phase operators and phase eigenstates rigorously. We show how the formalism essentially constructs an extended rigged Hilbert space that supports strong limits of the phase operators and includes their eigenstates. We identify the complementarity structure (consisting of mutually unbiased bases and generators of cyclical permutations) underpinning Pegg and Barnett's general approach that gives a quantum-classical correspondence free of the ambiguity of Dirac's commutator-Poisson bracket correspondence.This article is part of the theme issue 'The quantum theory of light'.
The phase associated with a single mode of the electromagnetic field is complementary to the photon number. This simple idea leads us to construct a probability density for the phase. The phase operator cannot be represented exactly in the usual-infinite Hilbert space but can be constructed in a subspace of it and provides a valid representation of phase if used together with a suitable limiting procedure. We introduce the Hermitian optical phase operator and describe some of its most important properties. We also provide brief discussions of some alternative approaches to the phase problem and to the question of phase measurements. The paper concludes with an extensive bibliography.
It is shown that there exist two kinds of operational (or measured) phase operators, those of the Hradil type [Phys. Rev. A 47 (1993), 4532], defined on the entire Hilbert space, and those of the Noh-Fougères-Mandel type [Phys. Rev. A 45 (1992), 424], defined only on a subspace. As a consequence, strictly speaking, the Noh-Fougères-Mandel measured phase cannot be defined in the case of, for example, coherent states, squeezed states and the vacuum. The difference between these operators is made clear by using the concept of the Bargmann distance between a quantum state and its “reduced” state. Since Noh et al. did not use the correct variances of the Susskind-Glogower and Pegg-Barnett phase operators when they compared their data with the results predicted through use of these operators, the correct expressions in that case are presented. Comparing the measured operators with the Hermitian phase operator in the extended Susskind-Glogower formalism, we show that the quantum phase given by the Hermitian phase operator is more appropriate than the measured phases. The variance of the Hermitian operator in the vacuum is consistent with the complementarity of the photon number and phase, which implies that the vacuum has a uniform phase distribution. Hradil's measured operator does not have such a property. Although the Noh-Fougères-Mandel operator has such a property in a particular limit, this operator does not represent, in principle, a meaningful measure of the phase measurement in a typical quantum region, because the Bargmann distance becomes large in such a region.
How does the classical notion of ``phase'' apply to a quantum harmonic oscillator H=1/2(q${\mathrm{^}}^{2}$+p${\mathrm{^}}^{2}$), [q^,p^]=i\ensuremath{\Elzxh}, which cannot have sharp position and momentum? A quantum state \ensuremath{\rho}^ can be assigned a definite classical phase only if it is a large-amplitude localized state. Our only demand, therefore, on a (Hermitian) phase operator \ensuremath{\varphi}^ is that the phase distribution P(\ensuremath{\Phi})= Tr{\ensuremath{\delta}(\ensuremath{\varphi}^-\ensuremath{\Phi})\ensuremath{\rho}^} attribute the correct sharp phase to any such ``classical phase'' state. This requires that the Weyl symbol [\ensuremath{\varphi}^]w{]}_{\mathit{w}}]w​(q,p) of \ensuremath{\varphi}^ tend to \ensuremath{\theta} mod2\ensuremath{\pi} as r\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}, where \ensuremath{\theta}=${\mathrm{tan}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}1}$(p/q) and r=(q2{\mathit{q}}^{2}q2+p2{\mathit{p}}^{2}p2)1/2{)}^{1/2})1/2. There are infinitely many such phase operators. Each is expressible as \ensuremath{\varphi}^=[${\mathrm{tan}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}1}$(p^/q^)${]}_{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}}$, where \ensuremath{\Omega} specifies an ordering rule for q^ and p^. The commutator -i[H^,\ensuremath{\varphi}^]=1-2\ensuremath{\pi}[\ensuremath{\delta}(${\mathrm{tan}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}1}$p^/q^)${]}_{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}}$ corresponds to the Poisson bracket {H,${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varphi}}}_{\mathrm{cl}}$${\mathrm{}}}_{\mathrm{}\mathrm{PB}}$=1-2\ensuremath{\pi}\ensuremath{\delta}(\ensuremath{\theta}) for the single-valued classical phase ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varphi}}}_{\mathrm{cl}}$=\ensuremath{\theta} mod2\ensuremath{\pi}. Phase states \ensuremath{\Gamma}^(\ensuremath{\Phi}) are defined by the condition that their Weyl symbols [\ensuremath{\Gamma}^(\ensuremath{\Phi})]w{]}_{\mathit{w}}]w​(r,\ensuremath{\theta})\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\delta}(\ensuremath{\theta}-\ensuremath{\Phi}) as r\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}. If moreover ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\int}}}_{0}^{2\mathrm{\ensuremath{\pi}}}$d\ensuremath{\Phi}\ensuremath{\Gamma}^(\ensuremath{\Phi})=1^, then \ensuremath{\Gamma}^(\ensuremath{\Phi}) is a phase probability operator measure (POM). In particular, \ensuremath{\delta}(\ensuremath{\varphi}^-\ensuremath{\Phi}) is a phase POM.Normalizable approximate phase states \ensuremath{\Gamma}${\mathrm{^}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}}$(\ensuremath{\Phi}) are defined by [\ensuremath{\Gamma}${\mathrm{^}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}}$(\ensuremath{\Phi})]w{]}_{\mathit{w}}]w​(r,\ensuremath{\theta}) =2\ensuremath{\pi}${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}}^{2}$${\mathit{e}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}\mathit{r}}$[\ensuremath{\Gamma}^(\ensuremath{\Phi})]w{]}_{\mathit{w}}]w​(r,\ensuremath{\theta}), \ensuremath{\varepsilon}\ensuremath{\ll}1. Phase states are not, in general, ``pure orthogonal'' in the sense \ensuremath{\Gamma}^(\ensuremath{\Phi})\ensuremath{\Gamma}^(\ensuremath{\Phi}\ensuremath{'})=\ensuremath{\delta}(\ensuremath{\Phi}-\ensuremath{\Phi}\ensuremath{'})\ensuremath{\Gamma}^(\ensuremath{\Phi}), unless they are of the form \ensuremath{\delta}(\ensuremath{\varphi}^-\ensuremath{\Phi}). However, any phase state \ensuremath{\Gamma}${\mathrm{^}}_{1}$(\ensuremath{\Phi}) is trace orthogonal to any phase POM \ensuremath{\Gamma}${\mathrm{^}}_{2}$(\ensuremath{\Phi}), in the sense that Tr{\ensuremath{\Gamma}${\mathrm{^}}_{2}$(\ensuremath{\Phi}\ensuremath{'})\ensuremath{\Gamma}${\mathrm{^}}_{1}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}}$(\ensuremath{\Phi})}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\delta}(\ensuremath{\Phi}-\ensuremath{\Phi}\ensuremath{'}) as \ensuremath{\varepsilon}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0. This implies that measurement of the POM \ensuremath{\Gamma}${\mathrm{^}}_{2}$(\ensuremath{\Phi}\ensuremath{'}) on the state \ensuremath{\Gamma}${\mathrm{^}}_{1}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}}$(\ensuremath{\Phi}) yields the outcome \ensuremath{\Phi} with probability 1 as \ensuremath{\varepsilon}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0. Phase measurements of the first kind are possible in principle; they would allow one to prepare (approximate) phase states and monitor their phase evolution in a quantum (phase) nondemolishing manner. Cases of special interest are the Susskind-Glogower and the Cahill-Glauber ordered phase states and operators. The energy-phase (or number-phase) uncertainty relation is \ensuremath{\Delta}H\ensuremath{\Delta}\ensuremath{\varphi}\ensuremath{\ge}0, the lower limit \ensuremath{\Delta}H\ensuremath{\Delta}\ensuremath{\varphi}=0 being realized by pure number states; however, for states whose Wigner functions are localized away from the origin and from the extremities of the (single-valued) phase window (0,2\ensuremath{\pi}), the uncertainty relation is effectively \ensuremath{\Delta}H\ensuremath{\Delta}\ensuremath{\varphi}\ensuremath{\ge}1/2. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.