Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical review. B, Condensed matter

Test of the Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer and the resonant-valence-bond wave functions as solutions of the Hubbard model: A small-cluster calculation

L. M. Falicov, César R. Proetto

Published Jun 1, 1993• 8 citations
Publisher

Abstract

With the purpose of assessing the validity of commonly used approximations, best variational solutions are calculated for a four-site (tetrahedral-cluster) Hubbard model with periodic boundary conditions and compared with exact results. In particular, the optimum number-conserving Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer-type variational solution is obtained for two, four, and six electrons, and the optimal resonanting-valence-bond state for four electrons. For an attractive interaction U, the exact ground state of the system is obtained in all four cases. If the interaction U is repulsive, the exact ground state is obtained only when the cluster contains two and six electrons. For four electrons the BCS approximation is only satisfactory for relatively small U. For any positive U the resonating-valence-bond state on the other hand, gives very good (albeit not exact) energies for the ground state.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.47.14407

Related papers

Numerical results for generalized resonating-valence-bond wave functions: Application to the Hubbard model

G. Fano, F. Ortolani, L. Ziosi

Numerical results are presented for a generalized resonance-valence-bond state which includes both ionic and covalent contributions in each bond; non-nearest-neighbor bonds are also considered. Variational calculations have been performed and the space-group symmetry has been taken into account. The results for the Hubbard Hamiltonian are compared with the exact ones for the 2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}2 and the 4\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}4 lattices. The agreement is quite satisfactory for large values of the interaction $U$ (for $U=40$ the overlap with the exact ground-state wave function is 0.999). Several correlation functions are also compared.

arXiv:cond-mat/9609284•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Dec 15, 1996•4 citations

Evaluation of the BCS approximation for the attractive Hubbard model in one dimension

F. Marsiglio

The ground-state energy and energy gap to the first excited state are calculated for the attractive Hubbard model in one dimension using both the Bethe ansatz equations and the variational BCS wave function. Comparisons are provided as a function of coupling strength and electron density. While the ground-state energies are always in very good agreement, the BCS energy gap is sometimes incorrect by an order of magnitude, particularly at half-filling. Finite-size effects are also briefly discussed for cases where an exact solution in the thermodynamic limit is not possible. In general, the BCS result for the energy gap is poor compared to the exact result.

arXiv:cond-mat/9609275•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Jan 1, 1997•40 citations

Canonical BCS approximation for the attractive Hubbard model

K. Tanaka, F. Marsiglio

We test the canonical BCS wave functions for fixed number of electrons for the attractive Hubbard model. We present results in one dimension for various chain lengths, electron densities, and coupling strengths. The ground-state energy and energy gap to the first excited state are compared with the exact solutions obtained by the Bethe ansatz as well as with the results from the conventional grand-canonical BCS approximations. While the canonical and grand-canonical BCS results are both in very good agreement with the exact results for the ground state energies, improvements due to conserving the electron number in finite systems are manifest in the energy gap. As the system size is increased, the canonical results converge to the grand-canonical ones. The ``parity'' effect that arises from the number parity (even or odd) of electrons are studied with our canonical scheme.

arXiv:cond-mat/9902285•AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 1999•0 citations

BCS and attractive Hubbard model comparative study

Nathan Salwen, Steven A. Sheets, Stephen R. Cotanch

We extend previous studies of the (BCS) canonical approach for the attractive Hubbard model. A derivation of the BCS formulation is presented for both the Hubbard model and a simpler reduced Hamiltonian. Using direct diagonalization, exact one- and two-dimensional solutions for both Hamiltonians are compared to BCS variational calculations. Approximate and exact ground state energies and energy gaps are computed for different electron number systems as well as correlation observables not previously predicted. Reproducing published one-dimensional findings, the BCS approach is an excellent approximation for the Hubbard ground state energy but not the energy gap, a finding that remains true in two dimensions. Propagators and correlators are found more sensitive to wave functions and appreciable differences are computed with the Hubbard model exhibiting a weaker degree of superconductivity than the BCS. Even for weak coupling pronounced differences are found between the BCS and Hubbard on-site correlators. Significantly, in the extreme strong coupling limit the Hubbard model exhibits no dimensional crossover, or density induced transitions, to long-range order in two dimensions. However, for the reduced Hamiltonian the BCS approach is an excellent approximation for all observables in both one and two dimensions.

arXiv:cond-mat/0305367•Physical Review B•Aug 24, 2004•8 citations

TWO-DIMENSIONAL ANTIFERROMAGNETIC HEISENBERG MODEL: EXACT AND RVB STATES

Didier Poilblanc

The exact many-body states of a 10-site square cluster with periodic boundary conditions of a S = 1/2 antiferromagnetic Heisenberg lattice model are investigated. A general form of a Resonating Valence Bond wavefunction (RVB), written in fermion representation is examined. It is shown that the optimum variational wavefunction has complex singlet bond distribution amplitudes of s+id symmetry . It has a very large overlap with the groundstate, belongs to the same space group representation and its energy functional has a minimum very close to the ground-state energy. On the other hand, if the amplitudes are restricted to real numbers, the local minimum has slightly higher energy and d-wave symmetry.

International Journal of Modern Physics B•Oct 1, 1988•1 citation

Exact solution of a periodic-cluster Hubbard model with an electron-lattice interaction

César R. Proetto, L. M. Falicov

An exact solution of a modified Hubbard model for a tetrahedral cluster with periodic boundary conditions is presented. It includes a static electron-lattice interaction in which the intersite bond-hopping parameter is a function of the bond electron occupation. It is found that the intrasite Coulomb repulsion and the effective attractive electron-lattice interaction have, generally speaking, opposite (although not identical) effects. They cancel each other exactly along a line of singularities in parameter space. The state vectors are easily obtained analytically. A study is made of magnetic and superconducting static correlation functions as functions of the parameters. Various forms of anisotropic superconducting fluctuations are favored in the various regimes. There is an indication of possible states with coexisting nonuniform, nonisotropic superconductivity and antiferromagnetism caused by a ``compromise'' between the competing forces.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Jul 15, 1988•9 citations
With the purpose of assessing the validity of commonly used approximations, best variational solutions are calculated for a four-site (tetrahedral-cluster) Hubbard model with periodic boundary conditions and compared with exact results. In particular, the optimum number-conserving Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer-type variational solution is obtained for two, four, and six electrons, and the optimal resonanting-valence-bond state for four electrons. For an attractive interaction U, the exact ground state of the system is obtained in all four cases. If the interaction U is repulsive, the exact ground state is obtained only when the cluster contains two and six electrons. For four electrons the BCS approximation is only satisfactory for relatively small U. For any positive U the resonating-valence-bond state on the other hand, gives very good (albeit not exact) energies for the ground state.
Numerical results are presented for a generalized resonance-valence-bond state which includes both ionic and covalent contributions in each bond; non-nearest-neighbor bonds are also considered. Variational calculations have been performed and the space-group symmetry has been taken into account. The results for the Hubbard Hamiltonian are compared with the exact ones for the 2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}2 and the 4\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}4 lattices. The agreement is quite satisfactory for large values of the interaction UUU (for U=40U=40U=40 the overlap with the exact ground-state wave function is 0.999). Several correlation functions are also compared.
The ground-state energy and energy gap to the first excited state are calculated for the attractive Hubbard model in one dimension using both the Bethe ansatz equations and the variational BCS wave function. Comparisons are provided as a function of coupling strength and electron density. While the ground-state energies are always in very good agreement, the BCS energy gap is sometimes incorrect by an order of magnitude, particularly at half-filling. Finite-size effects are also briefly discussed for cases where an exact solution in the thermodynamic limit is not possible. In general, the BCS result for the energy gap is poor compared to the exact result.
We test the canonical BCS wave functions for fixed number of electrons for the attractive Hubbard model. We present results in one dimension for various chain lengths, electron densities, and coupling strengths. The ground-state energy and energy gap to the first excited state are compared with the exact solutions obtained by the Bethe ansatz as well as with the results from the conventional grand-canonical BCS approximations. While the canonical and grand-canonical BCS results are both in very good agreement with the exact results for the ground state energies, improvements due to conserving the electron number in finite systems are manifest in the energy gap. As the system size is increased, the canonical results converge to the grand-canonical ones. The ``parity'' effect that arises from the number parity (even or odd) of electrons are studied with our canonical scheme.
We extend previous studies of the (BCS) canonical approach for the attractive Hubbard model. A derivation of the BCS formulation is presented for both the Hubbard model and a simpler reduced Hamiltonian. Using direct diagonalization, exact one- and two-dimensional solutions for both Hamiltonians are compared to BCS variational calculations. Approximate and exact ground state energies and energy gaps are computed for different electron number systems as well as correlation observables not previously predicted. Reproducing published one-dimensional findings, the BCS approach is an excellent approximation for the Hubbard ground state energy but not the energy gap, a finding that remains true in two dimensions. Propagators and correlators are found more sensitive to wave functions and appreciable differences are computed with the Hubbard model exhibiting a weaker degree of superconductivity than the BCS. Even for weak coupling pronounced differences are found between the BCS and Hubbard on-site correlators. Significantly, in the extreme strong coupling limit the Hubbard model exhibits no dimensional crossover, or density induced transitions, to long-range order in two dimensions. However, for the reduced Hamiltonian the BCS approach is an excellent approximation for all observables in both one and two dimensions.
The exact many-body states of a 10-site square cluster with periodic boundary conditions of a S = 1/2 antiferromagnetic Heisenberg lattice model are investigated. A general form of a Resonating Valence Bond wavefunction (RVB), written in fermion representation is examined. It is shown that the optimum variational wavefunction has complex singlet bond distribution amplitudes of s+id symmetry . It has a very large overlap with the groundstate, belongs to the same space group representation and its energy functional has a minimum very close to the ground-state energy. On the other hand, if the amplitudes are restricted to real numbers, the local minimum has slightly higher energy and d-wave symmetry.
An exact solution of a modified Hubbard model for a tetrahedral cluster with periodic boundary conditions is presented. It includes a static electron-lattice interaction in which the intersite bond-hopping parameter is a function of the bond electron occupation. It is found that the intrasite Coulomb repulsion and the effective attractive electron-lattice interaction have, generally speaking, opposite (although not identical) effects. They cancel each other exactly along a line of singularities in parameter space. The state vectors are easily obtained analytically. A study is made of magnetic and superconducting static correlation functions as functions of the parameters. Various forms of anisotropic superconducting fluctuations are favored in the various regimes. There is an indication of possible states with coexisting nonuniform, nonisotropic superconductivity and antiferromagnetism caused by a ``compromise'' between the competing forces.