Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical review. B, Condensed matter

Pairing phenomena in strongly correlated Fermi liquids

E. Krotscheck, R. A. Smith, Andrew David Jackson

Published Dec 1, 1981• 29 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The correlated-basis-function method is extended to deal with pairing phenomena in strongly correlated Fermi liquids. With a variational ansatz for the model wave function we derive the "correlated" analog of the conventional Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (or Balian-Werthamer), Anderson-Brinkman-Morel theory of pairing. A suitable (and well-controlled) set of approximations brings the theory into a form identical to the conventional theories, but with the bare interaction replaced by a weak effective interaction and the bare single-particle energies replaced by an effective single-particle spectrum. As usual, liquid $^{3}\mathrm{He}$ provides a very stringent test of the theory, as both the interaction and the experimental facts are pretty clear. The variational estimates for the pairing interaction are improved by nonorthogonal perturbation theory. We find the expected enhancement of the attraction in $P$ waves, although the restriction to effective two-body interactions appears to be insufficient to generate $P$-wave pairing.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.24.6404

Related papers

Theory of inhomogeneous quantum systems. III. Variational wave functions for Fermi fluids

E. Krotscheck

We develop a general variational theory for inhomogeneous Fermi systems such as the electron gas in a metal surface, the surface of liquid $^{3}\mathrm{He}$, or simple models of heavy nuclei. The ground-state wave function is expressed in terms of two-body correlations, a one-body attenuation factor, and a model-system Slater determinant. Massive partial summations of cluster expansions are performed by means of Born-Green-Yvon and hypernetted-chain techniques. An optimal single-particle basis is generated by a generalized Hartree-Fock equation in which the two-body correlations screen the bare interparticle interaction. The optimization of the pair correlations leads to a state-averaged random-phase-approximation equation and a strictly microscopic determination of the particle-hole interaction.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Apr 1, 1985•40 citations

Possible Superfluidity of a System of Strongly Interacting Fermions

Leon N. Cooper, Robert L. Mills, Andrew M. Sessler

The possible superfluidity of a system of strongly interacting fermions is investigated on the assumption that an adequate description of the system in its "normal" state is given by independent fermions in a momentum-dependent potential. On the basis of this assumption we have investigated whether a correlated wave function of the form used by Bardeen, Cooper, and Schrieffer minimizes the ground-state energy. The nonzero terms in the expectation value of the Hamiltonian contain the modified kinetic energy and the full two-body potential between the fermion pairs. An integral equation is obtained in configuration space for the correlation function between pairs. This integral equation is meaningful even for potentials with hard cores, and a nonzero solution implies the existence of a superfluid state. A variational method is devised which provides a criterion for superfluidity and a lower bound for the transition temperature into the superfluid state. We find that a repulsive hard core does not in principle forbid the existence of a superfluid state, but whereas in the absence of a hard core an attractive two-body potential always leads to a superfluid state at sufficiently low temperatures, in the presence of a repulsive core there appears to be a critical strength of attraction needed to form a superfluid state. When the variational principle is applied to liquid ${\mathrm{He}}^{3}$ or to nuclear matter, it is found for a wide class of trial functions that the system does not become a superfluid.

Physical Review•Jun 15, 1959•94 citations

Correlations in the low-density Fermi gas: Fermi-liquid state, dimerization, and Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer pairing

Hsuan‐Hao Fan, E. Krotscheck, T. Lichtenegger +2 more

We present ground-state calculations for low-density Fermi gases described by two model interactions, an attractive square-well potential and a Lennard-Jones potential, of varying strength. We use the optimized Fermi-hypernetted chain integral equation method, which has been proved to provide, in the density regimes of interest here, an accuracy of better than 1%. We first examine the low-density expansion of the energy and compare it with the exact answer of H. Huang and C. N. Yang [Phys. Rev. 105, 767 (1957)]. It is shown that a locally correlated wave function of the Jastrow-Feenberg type does not recover the quadratic term in the expansion of the energy in powers of ${a}_{0}{k}_{F}$, where ${a}_{0}$ is the vacuum $s$-wave scattering length and ${k}_{F}$ the Fermi wave number. The problem is cured by adding second-order perturbation corrections in a correlated basis. Going to higher densities and/or more strongly coupled systems, we encounter an instability of the normal state of the system which is characterized by a divergence of the in-medium scattering length. We interpret this divergence as a phonon-exchange-driven dimerization of the system, similar to what occurs at zero density when the vacuum scattering length ${a}_{0}$ diverges. We then study, in the stable regime, the superfluid gap and its dependence on the density and the interaction strength. We identify two corrections to low-density expansions: One is medium corrections to the pairing interaction, and the other is finite-range corrections. We show that the most important finite-range corrections are a direct manifestation of the many-body nature of the system.

arXiv:1409.5649•Physical Review A•Aug 28, 2015•11 citations

THEORY OF CORRELATED BASIS FUNCTIONS

E. Krotscheck

We describe the development of perturbation theory in a basis of correlated wave functions. The formulation of the basic theory is generic in the sense that it does not depend on a specific choice of correlation operator. We will, however, elaborate on the intricate relationships between cluster expansions for Jastrow–Feenberg wave functions on the one side, and perturbative expansions within the basis of Jastrow–Feenberg generated states. The first part of this lecture series sets the general scene of perturbation theroy in a non–orthogonal basis, as laid out by Feshbach, Feenberg, Clark, and others. We then turn to the calculation of effective interactions, which will require the same technical tools that were developed for the Fermi-Hypernetted-Chain theory of the ground state. We then look at the interpretation of these effective interactions from various points of view and draw the connections to phenomenological theories like Landau's Fermi liquid theory, or the BCS theory of superconductivity. We also demonstrate that Fermi–sea averages of the CBF effective interaction vanish for optimized correlation functions. Finally, we turn to cases where CBF theory to infinite order is necessary. Employing ideas of the coupled cluster theory, we develop a method for generating CBF perturbative corrections to infinite order by integral equations. Specializing to ring diagrams, we demonstrate that the "chain" diagrams of the FHNC theory are approximations for the ring diagrams of (CBF-)perturbation theory. The generalization of the time–dependent Hartree–Fock theory to correlated states will allow the formulation of a linear response theory for strongly interacting systems or, alternatively, provide the tools for mapping strong, bare interactions onto weak, effective interactions that can be used in phenomenological theories.

Series on advances in quantum many-body theory•Aug 1, 2002•9 citations

Generalized Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer States and the Proposed Low-Temperature Phase of Liquid He 3

P. W. Anderson, P. Morel

Particle interactions in a Fermi gas may be such as to attract pairs near the Fermi surface more strongly in $l=1, 2, 3$ or higher states than in the simple spherically symmetrical $s$ state. In that case the Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer condensed state must be generalized, and the resulting state is an anisotropic superfluid. We have studied the properties of this type of state in considerable detail, especially for $l=1 \mathrm{and} 2$. We have derived expressions for the energy, the moment of inertia, the magnetic susceptibility and the specific heat. We also derive the density correlation function and the density-current density correlation; in some cases the latter implies that the liquid has net surface currents and a net orbital angular momentum. The ground state for $l=2$ is different from those previously considered, and has cubic symmetry and no net angular momentum. A general method for replacing the possibly rather complicated potential by a simple scattering matrix is given. A brief discussion of possible collective effects is included. We apply our results to liquid ${\mathrm{He}}^{3}$; after correction for scattering by a method due to Suhl, it is found that the predicted transition should take place below 0.02\ifmmode^\circ\else\textdegree\fi{}K. Other possible applications are suggested.

Physical Review•Sep 15, 1961•661 citations

Model of a Two-Dimensional Marginal Fermi Liquid Superconductor

Yu-Liang Liu, Tai Kai Ng

In this paper we study a model of an $s$-wave marginal Fermi liquid superconductor in two dimensions. Besides the usual Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) point attractive interaction, the fermions in our system also interact via a long-range repulsive interaction $v(q){\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}g}_{D}/{q}^{2}$. We find that although superconductivity is not destroyed by the long-ranged repulsive interaction (demonstrated by the response to electromagnetic magnetic fields), the BCS pairing function ${\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{\mathrm{BCS}}$ is strongly suppressed, resulting in a power-law correlation $〈{\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{\mathrm{BCS}}(\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{x}){\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{\mathrm{BCS}}(0)〉\ensuremath{\sim}|\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{x}{|}^{\ensuremath{-}2\ensuremath{\gamma}}$. This observation is explained within a general picture of the marginal Fermi liquid.

arXiv:cond-mat/9908162•Physical Review Letters•Dec 27, 1999•9 citations
The correlated-basis-function method is extended to deal with pairing phenomena in strongly correlated Fermi liquids. With a variational ansatz for the model wave function we derive the "correlated" analog of the conventional Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (or Balian-Werthamer), Anderson-Brinkman-Morel theory of pairing. A suitable (and well-controlled) set of approximations brings the theory into a form identical to the conventional theories, but with the bare interaction replaced by a weak effective interaction and the bare single-particle energies replaced by an effective single-particle spectrum. As usual, liquid 3He^{3}\mathrm{He}3He provides a very stringent test of the theory, as both the interaction and the experimental facts are pretty clear. The variational estimates for the pairing interaction are improved by nonorthogonal perturbation theory. We find the expected enhancement of the attraction in PPP waves, although the restriction to effective two-body interactions appears to be insufficient to generate PPP-wave pairing.
We develop a general variational theory for inhomogeneous Fermi systems such as the electron gas in a metal surface, the surface of liquid 3He^{3}\mathrm{He}3He, or simple models of heavy nuclei. The ground-state wave function is expressed in terms of two-body correlations, a one-body attenuation factor, and a model-system Slater determinant. Massive partial summations of cluster expansions are performed by means of Born-Green-Yvon and hypernetted-chain techniques. An optimal single-particle basis is generated by a generalized Hartree-Fock equation in which the two-body correlations screen the bare interparticle interaction. The optimization of the pair correlations leads to a state-averaged random-phase-approximation equation and a strictly microscopic determination of the particle-hole interaction.
The possible superfluidity of a system of strongly interacting fermions is investigated on the assumption that an adequate description of the system in its "normal" state is given by independent fermions in a momentum-dependent potential. On the basis of this assumption we have investigated whether a correlated wave function of the form used by Bardeen, Cooper, and Schrieffer minimizes the ground-state energy. The nonzero terms in the expectation value of the Hamiltonian contain the modified kinetic energy and the full two-body potential between the fermion pairs. An integral equation is obtained in configuration space for the correlation function between pairs. This integral equation is meaningful even for potentials with hard cores, and a nonzero solution implies the existence of a superfluid state. A variational method is devised which provides a criterion for superfluidity and a lower bound for the transition temperature into the superfluid state. We find that a repulsive hard core does not in principle forbid the existence of a superfluid state, but whereas in the absence of a hard core an attractive two-body potential always leads to a superfluid state at sufficiently low temperatures, in the presence of a repulsive core there appears to be a critical strength of attraction needed to form a superfluid state. When the variational principle is applied to liquid He3{\mathrm{He}}^{3}He3 or to nuclear matter, it is found for a wide class of trial functions that the system does not become a superfluid.
We present ground-state calculations for low-density Fermi gases described by two model interactions, an attractive square-well potential and a Lennard-Jones potential, of varying strength. We use the optimized Fermi-hypernetted chain integral equation method, which has been proved to provide, in the density regimes of interest here, an accuracy of better than 1%. We first examine the low-density expansion of the energy and compare it with the exact answer of H. Huang and C. N. Yang [Phys. Rev. 105, 767 (1957)]. It is shown that a locally correlated wave function of the Jastrow-Feenberg type does not recover the quadratic term in the expansion of the energy in powers of a0kF{a}_{0}{k}_{F}a0​kF​, where a0{a}_{0}a0​ is the vacuum sss-wave scattering length and kF{k}_{F}kF​ the Fermi wave number. The problem is cured by adding second-order perturbation corrections in a correlated basis. Going to higher densities and/or more strongly coupled systems, we encounter an instability of the normal state of the system which is characterized by a divergence of the in-medium scattering length. We interpret this divergence as a phonon-exchange-driven dimerization of the system, similar to what occurs at zero density when the vacuum scattering length a0{a}_{0}a0​ diverges. We then study, in the stable regime, the superfluid gap and its dependence on the density and the interaction strength. We identify two corrections to low-density expansions: One is medium corrections to the pairing interaction, and the other is finite-range corrections. We show that the most important finite-range corrections are a direct manifestation of the many-body nature of the system.
We describe the development of perturbation theory in a basis of correlated wave functions. The formulation of the basic theory is generic in the sense that it does not depend on a specific choice of correlation operator. We will, however, elaborate on the intricate relationships between cluster expansions for Jastrow–Feenberg wave functions on the one side, and perturbative expansions within the basis of Jastrow–Feenberg generated states. The first part of this lecture series sets the general scene of perturbation theroy in a non–orthogonal basis, as laid out by Feshbach, Feenberg, Clark, and others. We then turn to the calculation of effective interactions, which will require the same technical tools that were developed for the Fermi-Hypernetted-Chain theory of the ground state. We then look at the interpretation of these effective interactions from various points of view and draw the connections to phenomenological theories like Landau's Fermi liquid theory, or the BCS theory of superconductivity. We also demonstrate that Fermi–sea averages of the CBF effective interaction vanish for optimized correlation functions. Finally, we turn to cases where CBF theory to infinite order is necessary. Employing ideas of the coupled cluster theory, we develop a method for generating CBF perturbative corrections to infinite order by integral equations. Specializing to ring diagrams, we demonstrate that the "chain" diagrams of the FHNC theory are approximations for the ring diagrams of (CBF-)perturbation theory. The generalization of the time–dependent Hartree–Fock theory to correlated states will allow the formulation of a linear response theory for strongly interacting systems or, alternatively, provide the tools for mapping strong, bare interactions onto weak, effective interactions that can be used in phenomenological theories.
Particle interactions in a Fermi gas may be such as to attract pairs near the Fermi surface more strongly in l=1,2,3l=1, 2, 3l=1,2,3 or higher states than in the simple spherically symmetrical sss state. In that case the Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer condensed state must be generalized, and the resulting state is an anisotropic superfluid. We have studied the properties of this type of state in considerable detail, especially for l=1and2l=1 \mathrm{and} 2l=1and2. We have derived expressions for the energy, the moment of inertia, the magnetic susceptibility and the specific heat. We also derive the density correlation function and the density-current density correlation; in some cases the latter implies that the liquid has net surface currents and a net orbital angular momentum. The ground state for l=2l=2l=2 is different from those previously considered, and has cubic symmetry and no net angular momentum. A general method for replacing the possibly rather complicated potential by a simple scattering matrix is given. A brief discussion of possible collective effects is included. We apply our results to liquid He3{\mathrm{He}}^{3}He3; after correction for scattering by a method due to Suhl, it is found that the predicted transition should take place below 0.02\ifmmode^\circ\else\textdegree\fi{}K. Other possible applications are suggested.
In this paper we study a model of an sss-wave marginal Fermi liquid superconductor in two dimensions. Besides the usual Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) point attractive interaction, the fermions in our system also interact via a long-range repulsive interaction v(q)=gD/q2v(q){\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}g}_{D}/{q}^{2}v(q)=gD​/q2. We find that although superconductivity is not destroyed by the long-ranged repulsive interaction (demonstrated by the response to electromagnetic magnetic fields), the BCS pairing function ${\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{\mathrm{BCS}}$ is strongly suppressed, resulting in a power-law correlation $〈{\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{\mathrm{BCS}}(\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{x}){\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{\mathrm{BCS}}(0)〉\ensuremath{\sim}|\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{x}{|}^{\ensuremath{-}2\ensuremath{\gamma}}$. This observation is explained within a general picture of the marginal Fermi liquid.