Paper 6.2: "Significance of Potentials in Quantum Theory," W. H. Furry and N. F. Ramsey, Phys. Rev. 118, 623–626 (1960)
In 1959 Y. Aharonov and D. Bohm [ Phys. Rev. 115 , 485–490 (1959)] shocked most of the physics community by inventing two " gedanken " (thought) experiments for which the electrons in a beam never exposed to an electric or magnetic field would have their interference fringes shifted by differences of either electrostatic scalar potential V or vector potential A between the two paths that produced the interference pattern. Most physicists disbelieved the paper since, in classical electromagnetic theory, the physical phenomena are all produced by the fields and the potentials are introduced as mathematical functions from which the fields are obtained by differentiation. Wendell Furry and I at first doubted the Aharonov–Bohm (AB) paper but tried to understand it. Eventually we convinced ourselves that their paper was correct and the AB effects were essential for assuring the consistency of quantum mechanics and of complementarity. We showed (Paper 6.2) that the two gedanken devices invented by Aharonov and Bohm could, with modifications, be used to detect along which of the two interfering paths the electron traveled. But, by complementarity, it must be impossible both to observe interference fringes and to know through which path the electron passed. This contradiction is prevented by the AB effects of potentials since the zero point oscillations of the potentials, through the AB effects, destroy the interference pattern just as the device becomes sufficiently sensitive to detect the electron path. We pointed out that a key difference between a classical and a quantum particle is that a quantum particle, through its wave function, can be affected simultaneously by potentials along two different paths while this is impossible for a classical point particle. This peculiarity gave me the opportunity to project, at scientific meetings, the then new Charles Addams cartoon of a skier coming down a slope with one track on one each side of a tree. I pointed out that for classical particles such a picture was a joke whereas a quantum particle could be affected by the potentials on both paths. This cartoon was later reproduced in one of my published papers [ Quantum Coherence and Reality (p. 39), edited by J. S. Anandam, World Scientific Publishing Co., 1994]. The night before I first presented this work at a meeting, I learned that L. Marton and his associates had that day presented a postdeadline paper claiming to show that the AB effects did not exist. As an experimentalist presenting a theoretical paper, I felt uncomfortable on learning that our paper had possibly been disproved experimentally, so I arranged a meeting with Marton before my talk. Initially their experiment appeared convincing, but I discovered they had omitted a direct magnetic effect; with its inclusion their experimental results could be explained only by including both the direct and the AB effects. Later, Marton and his associates presented their experiment as evidence for, rather than against, the AB effect.
World Scientific series in 20th century physics•Jun 1, 1998•0 citations