Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Possible rigid rotations in two-electron atoms

Michel Poirier

Published Oct 1, 1989• 12 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The path-integral formulation of quantum mechanics has promoted the study of classical periodic trajectories. In this spirit, the three-body Coulomb problem with a nucleus of infinite mass is considered in the special case of a rigid rotation. Using only Newton's fundamental law for a classical atomic system, one can show that both electrons must be equidistant from the nucleus, and one obtains the solutions previously derived by Klar [Phys. Rev. Lett. 57, 66 (1986); Z. Phys. D 3, 353 (1986); J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 4, 788 (1987)]. Nevertheless, if one allows the charge at rest to be arbitrary, one finds that for Z less than unity unsymmetrical solutions may exist. The stability of each of these configurations is considered. In each case an exponentially increasing solution is present, but the unstable character is less marked in the unsymmetrical configuration. Possible consequences for atomic systems are discussed.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.40.3498

Related papers

Coulomb Interaction between Electrons and a New Concept of Atom

M. V. Krasinkova

It is shown that the approximation of a strong Coulomb interaction between electrons results in a new model of the atom with a spatial quantization of electrons accompanied by their quantization in energy. This model implies that electrons rotate in circular orbits centered outside the atomic nucleus and only orbit axes pass through it. The Coulomb interaction between electrons leads to a spherically symmetric distribution of their orbits on the surfaces of equipotential spheres of a spherically symmetric electrostatic field of the nucleus. The distribution is similar to “inscribing” electron orbits into faces of regular nucleus-centered polyhedra so each polyhedron corresponds to a certain electron state (s, p, d, f), and a certain set of polyhedra corresponds to a certain period of the Mendeleev Table. It is shown that a spherically symmetric distribution of electron orbits gives rise to the formation of electron pairs in which electron orbits with a common axis are located symmetrically with respect to the nucleus and the orbital magnetic moments of the electrons are oppositely directed. The physical meaning of the electron spin concept becomes clear. The spin turns out to be related to the orbital magnetic moment of an electron and reflects the fact that two electrons of a pair rotate in opposite directions relative to their common axis. So the spin is one of characteristics of the electron state in the atom associated with electron rotation in the orbit centered outside the nucleus. The atomic model gives an insight into the periodicity of changes in the atomic properties with increasing nuclear charge and the reasons for an electron double energy quantization associated with different states and periods. The model shows that the atomic structure and properties can be explained by using concepts of classical mechanics and classical electrodynamics which regard the electron as a particle.

Journal of Modern Physics•Jan 1, 2022•0 citations

A quantum rotator on a three-dimensional sphere

Yu. A. Kurochkin

In this work, the quantum-mechanical problem of the motion of two material points of different masses on a three-dimensional sphere with a non-fixed position of the center of mass of the system is formulated on the basis of the previously solved classical problem. It is shown that the established Schrödinger equation includes two different reduced masses, depending on the distance between the points. For the case of the interaction potential of points, depending only on the distance between them, this equation allows the separation of variables into a radial, depending on the relative distance and both the reduced masses and the spherical part. The equation for the spherical part depends only on one of the above reduced mass and allows one to formulate and solve the problem of a rigid rotator - the distance between the points is fixed. The solution and spectrum of the problem of a rigid rotator are found. It is shown that the spectrum of the system has an upper limit that does not depend on the distance between points, in contrast to the spectrum in a flat space.

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of Belarus Physics and Mathematics Series•Apr 4, 2022•0 citations

Bohr Model

Z. Ficek

This chapter illustrates Niels Bohr's ideas in some detail. In the formulation of his model, Bohr assumed that the electron in the hydrogen atom moves under the influence of the Coulomb attraction between it and the positively charged nucleus, as assumed in classical mechanics. The Bohr model was very successful in explaining the discrete atomic spectra of one-electron atoms. The Bohr model is, of course, a theoretical model of an atom. Using Bohr's quantization postulate, find the linear velocity of the electron's sphere. To find the radius of the orbit, Bohr postulated that the angular momentum of the electron is quantized, i.e., it can only take values that are integer multiples of ħ. The chapter begins with considering the classical equation of motion for the electron in a circular orbit, which is based on Newton's laws of motion and Coulomb's law of electric force.

•Mar 3, 2017•0 citations

Photon as a classical wave packet from classically stabilized electron orbits

Jan Olof Jonson

The fact that an orbiting electron does not collapse into the nucleus of its parent atom has thus far been considered a major obstacle to a classical interpretation of the stable states of orbiting electrons. Quantum mechanics avoids the very problem by discussing the probability of finding it, a method that confessedly has been very fruitful in the exploring the behaviour of elementary particles. Nonetheless, why should necessarily those two approaches be regarded as each others' enemies? In this paper it is shown that the classical mechanistic approach is still capable of explaining the eternal, circular movement of an electron around a nucleus. It is possible if reformulating the laws of action involved, returning to the simple electrostatic model, based upon Coulomb's law (1785, 1771). Further, in this paper it is also discussed, how electromagnetic radiation due to the de-excitation of excited electrons, orbiting around a positive nucleus, can be explained classically, as a sudden peak in the otherwise zero electric field, due to the inwards spiralling movement connected to the de-excitation. The concept of a distinct particle, the 'photon' is thereby rejected.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Aug 26, 2007•3 citations

The Schrödinger Hydrogen Atom

Don Shillady

In this chapter we hope that the previous rigid rotor derivation will pay off. Here we only have to solve the radial equation since we already know the Ql(u)Fm(f) ¼ Yml (u, f) solutions. We now have to relax the rigid potential to permit the Coulomb attraction between the electron and the nucleus.

CRC Press eBooks•Jul 27, 2011•0 citations

The Hydrogen-Like Atom

Uri Peskin

The mere existence of stable atoms, and their arrangement into many-atom nanoscale structures, can only be explained by the laws of quantum mechanics. Indeed, the accumulated evidence regarding the internal structure of atoms motivated the formulation of quantum mechanics at the early twentieth century. Here we focus on single-electron (hydrogen-like) atoms. The dominance of the Coulomb central potential between the electron and nucleus, translates into a simple Schrödinger equation for their relative position distribution. Solving rigorously this equation reveals quantized energy levels, which explains the emission spectra of hydrogen-like atoms (Rydberg formula). The corresponding stationary probability density distributions for the electron around the nucleus are reminiscent of the Bohr model, where classical trajectories (orbits) are replaced by single-electron wave functions (orbitals). The degeneracies of different orbitals, associated with three quantum numbers, will later turn out to be critical for understanding many-electron atoms and the periodic table of the elements.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•May 11, 2023•0 citations
The path-integral formulation of quantum mechanics has promoted the study of classical periodic trajectories. In this spirit, the three-body Coulomb problem with a nucleus of infinite mass is considered in the special case of a rigid rotation. Using only Newton's fundamental law for a classical atomic system, one can show that both electrons must be equidistant from the nucleus, and one obtains the solutions previously derived by Klar [Phys. Rev. Lett. 57, 66 (1986); Z. Phys. D 3, 353 (1986); J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 4, 788 (1987)]. Nevertheless, if one allows the charge at rest to be arbitrary, one finds that for Z less than unity unsymmetrical solutions may exist. The stability of each of these configurations is considered. In each case an exponentially increasing solution is present, but the unstable character is less marked in the unsymmetrical configuration. Possible consequences for atomic systems are discussed.
It is shown that the approximation of a strong Coulomb interaction between electrons results in a new model of the atom with a spatial quantization of electrons accompanied by their quantization in energy. This model implies that electrons rotate in circular orbits centered outside the atomic nucleus and only orbit axes pass through it. The Coulomb interaction between electrons leads to a spherically symmetric distribution of their orbits on the surfaces of equipotential spheres of a spherically symmetric electrostatic field of the nucleus. The distribution is similar to “inscribing” electron orbits into faces of regular nucleus-centered polyhedra so each polyhedron corresponds to a certain electron state (s, p, d, f), and a certain set of polyhedra corresponds to a certain period of the Mendeleev Table. It is shown that a spherically symmetric distribution of electron orbits gives rise to the formation of electron pairs in which electron orbits with a common axis are located symmetrically with respect to the nucleus and the orbital magnetic moments of the electrons are oppositely directed. The physical meaning of the electron spin concept becomes clear. The spin turns out to be related to the orbital magnetic moment of an electron and reflects the fact that two electrons of a pair rotate in opposite directions relative to their common axis. So the spin is one of characteristics of the electron state in the atom associated with electron rotation in the orbit centered outside the nucleus. The atomic model gives an insight into the periodicity of changes in the atomic properties with increasing nuclear charge and the reasons for an electron double energy quantization associated with different states and periods. The model shows that the atomic structure and properties can be explained by using concepts of classical mechanics and classical electrodynamics which regard the electron as a particle.
In this work, the quantum-mechanical problem of the motion of two material points of different masses on a three-dimensional sphere with a non-fixed position of the center of mass of the system is formulated on the basis of the previously solved classical problem. It is shown that the established Schrödinger equation includes two different reduced masses, depending on the distance between the points. For the case of the interaction potential of points, depending only on the distance between them, this equation allows the separation of variables into a radial, depending on the relative distance and both the reduced masses and the spherical part. The equation for the spherical part depends only on one of the above reduced mass and allows one to formulate and solve the problem of a rigid rotator - the distance between the points is fixed. The solution and spectrum of the problem of a rigid rotator are found. It is shown that the spectrum of the system has an upper limit that does not depend on the distance between points, in contrast to the spectrum in a flat space.
This chapter illustrates Niels Bohr's ideas in some detail. In the formulation of his model, Bohr assumed that the electron in the hydrogen atom moves under the influence of the Coulomb attraction between it and the positively charged nucleus, as assumed in classical mechanics. The Bohr model was very successful in explaining the discrete atomic spectra of one-electron atoms. The Bohr model is, of course, a theoretical model of an atom. Using Bohr's quantization postulate, find the linear velocity of the electron's sphere. To find the radius of the orbit, Bohr postulated that the angular momentum of the electron is quantized, i.e., it can only take values that are integer multiples of ħ. The chapter begins with considering the classical equation of motion for the electron in a circular orbit, which is based on Newton's laws of motion and Coulomb's law of electric force.
The fact that an orbiting electron does not collapse into the nucleus of its parent atom has thus far been considered a major obstacle to a classical interpretation of the stable states of orbiting electrons. Quantum mechanics avoids the very problem by discussing the probability of finding it, a method that confessedly has been very fruitful in the exploring the behaviour of elementary particles. Nonetheless, why should necessarily those two approaches be regarded as each others' enemies? In this paper it is shown that the classical mechanistic approach is still capable of explaining the eternal, circular movement of an electron around a nucleus. It is possible if reformulating the laws of action involved, returning to the simple electrostatic model, based upon Coulomb's law (1785, 1771). Further, in this paper it is also discussed, how electromagnetic radiation due to the de-excitation of excited electrons, orbiting around a positive nucleus, can be explained classically, as a sudden peak in the otherwise zero electric field, due to the inwards spiralling movement connected to the de-excitation. The concept of a distinct particle, the 'photon' is thereby rejected.
The mere existence of stable atoms, and their arrangement into many-atom nanoscale structures, can only be explained by the laws of quantum mechanics. Indeed, the accumulated evidence regarding the internal structure of atoms motivated the formulation of quantum mechanics at the early twentieth century. Here we focus on single-electron (hydrogen-like) atoms. The dominance of the Coulomb central potential between the electron and nucleus, translates into a simple Schrödinger equation for their relative position distribution. Solving rigorously this equation reveals quantized energy levels, which explains the emission spectra of hydrogen-like atoms (Rydberg formula). The corresponding stationary probability density distributions for the electron around the nucleus are reminiscent of the Bohr model, where classical trajectories (orbits) are replaced by single-electron wave functions (orbitals). The degeneracies of different orbitals, associated with three quantum numbers, will later turn out to be critical for understanding many-electron atoms and the periodic table of the elements.