Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Difficulty in detecting deviations from wave-function collapse

Seth Lloyd

Published Oct 1, 1988• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

We use the example of a Stern-Gerlach apparatus to show that the quantum-mechanical measurement problem ceases to be a physical problem for a measuring device with many degrees of freedom in the sense that deviations from wave-function collapse become virtually impossible to detect.
DOI
10.1103/physreva.38.3161

Related papers

Decoding the Mystery of Wave Function Collapse

Ping Wang

We provide a reasonable explanation for measurement where no wave function in the sense of quantum mechanics is collapsed. The wave functions of the particles in the measuring device should be considered together with the measured particle as one system. The measurement is actually a physical process, which makes the wave functions of different paths orthogonal. The collapsed wave function is just an equivalent one to explain certain physical phenomena. There is no physical transition or process from the wave function in quantum mechanics to the equivalent one. Our understanding of measurement also provides reasonable explanations for both EPR paradox and the experiments of delayed quantum eraser

Advances in Theoretical & Computational Physics•Nov 18, 2024•0 citations

Collapse of the wave function related to the use of Schmidt decomposition

Y. Ben-Aryeh

In the measurement process, certain degrees of freedom of the observables are selected and correlations are produced with corresponding degrees of freedom of the measuring macroscopic device. These correlations are described, in the present paper, by using the Schmidt decomposition, in which the eigenvalues of the reduced density matrices of these two systems are equal. The measurement process is related to the trace operation over the observable degrees of freedom, since we do not directly measure the microscopic system but its corresponding macroscopic part in the Schmidt decomposition. This trace operation leads only to partial information on the microscopic system referred to as the “collapse” of the wave function. This interpretation is demonstrated by analyzing Stern-Gerlach experiments.

Optics and Spectroscopy•Sep 1, 2001•0 citations

A note on the quantum measurement problem

N. David Mermin

The idea that wave-function collapse is a physical process stems from a misunderstanding of probability and the role it plays in quantum mechanics.

arXiv:2206.10741•Jun 21, 2022•1 citation

S-Matrix Theory and Entanglement

Kazuo Fujikawa

But no good and simple criterion of entanglement for more complicated cases is known. This situation is rather strange since everybody talks about entanglement. How to produce and how to measure the entanglement are also interesting issues. When one measures the spin of the electron, for example, there are three major operators one can think of [1] a) Wigner spin, b) Dirac spin, c) Magnetic moment. The notion of chirality is important to distinguish these operators. Incidentally, many people talk about the Stern-Gerlach apparatus to measure the spin polarization of the electron. This is also strange since N. Bohr and N. F. Mott and other prominent people have shown many years ago that one cannot measure the electron spin polarization by a Stern-Gerlach apparatus, since the inhomogeneous magnetic field disturbs the motion of the electron so much and it is impossible to detect the spin orientation. The Stern-Gerlach particles are electrically neutral. One may ask if novel features appear in high energy physics? Chiral symmetry (including the use of weak interaction) can become important such as in a neutrino-antineutrino pair in Z decay

•Jun 29, 2015•0 citations

There is no quantum measurement problem

N. David Mermin

The idea that the collapse of a quantum state is a physical process stems from a misunderstanding of probability and the role it plays in quantum mechanics.

Physics Today•Jun 1, 2022•32 citations

Stern-Gerlach Experiment and Bohm Limit

Marco Frasca

Stern-Gerlach experiment is a paradigm of measurement theory in quantum mechanics. Notwithstanding several analysis given in literature, no clear understanding of the apparent collapse has been given so far. Indeed, one can imagine a Stern-Gerlach device where all environmental effects are removed and ask the question on how the measurement goes on. In this letter we will prove that a the Stern-Gerlach device behaves as a true measurement apparatus, as expected by the Copenaghen interpretation, by the Ehrenfest theorem. In this way we recover, by other means, a limit on the Stern-Gerlach device, given by Bohm, based on scrambling of phases due to a large oscillation frequency.

arXiv:quant-ph/0402072•Feb 10, 2004•2 citations
We provide a reasonable explanation for measurement where no wave function in the sense of quantum mechanics is collapsed. The wave functions of the particles in the measuring device should be considered together with the measured particle as one system. The measurement is actually a physical process, which makes the wave functions of different paths orthogonal. The collapsed wave function is just an equivalent one to explain certain physical phenomena. There is no physical transition or process from the wave function in quantum mechanics to the equivalent one. Our understanding of measurement also provides reasonable explanations for both EPR paradox and the experiments of delayed quantum eraser
In the measurement process, certain degrees of freedom of the observables are selected and correlations are produced with corresponding degrees of freedom of the measuring macroscopic device. These correlations are described, in the present paper, by using the Schmidt decomposition, in which the eigenvalues of the reduced density matrices of these two systems are equal. The measurement process is related to the trace operation over the observable degrees of freedom, since we do not directly measure the microscopic system but its corresponding macroscopic part in the Schmidt decomposition. This trace operation leads only to partial information on the microscopic system referred to as the “collapse” of the wave function. This interpretation is demonstrated by analyzing Stern-Gerlach experiments.
But no good and simple criterion of entanglement for more complicated cases is known. This situation is rather strange since everybody talks about entanglement. How to produce and how to measure the entanglement are also interesting issues. When one measures the spin of the electron, for example, there are three major operators one can think of [1] a) Wigner spin, b) Dirac spin, c) Magnetic moment. The notion of chirality is important to distinguish these operators. Incidentally, many people talk about the Stern-Gerlach apparatus to measure the spin polarization of the electron. This is also strange since N. Bohr and N. F. Mott and other prominent people have shown many years ago that one cannot measure the electron spin polarization by a Stern-Gerlach apparatus, since the inhomogeneous magnetic field disturbs the motion of the electron so much and it is impossible to detect the spin orientation. The Stern-Gerlach particles are electrically neutral. One may ask if novel features appear in high energy physics? Chiral symmetry (including the use of weak interaction) can become important such as in a neutrino-antineutrino pair in Z decay
Stern-Gerlach experiment is a paradigm of measurement theory in quantum mechanics. Notwithstanding several analysis given in literature, no clear understanding of the apparent collapse has been given so far. Indeed, one can imagine a Stern-Gerlach device where all environmental effects are removed and ask the question on how the measurement goes on. In this letter we will prove that a the Stern-Gerlach device behaves as a true measurement apparatus, as expected by the Copenaghen interpretation, by the Ehrenfest theorem. In this way we recover, by other means, a limit on the Stern-Gerlach device, given by Bohm, based on scrambling of phases due to a large oscillation frequency.