Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

The Inverse-Cube Central Force Field in Quantum Mechanics

George H. Shortley

Published Jul 1, 1931• 53 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The problem of the motion of a particle in an inverse-cube central force field is fully treated by quantum mechanics and the results compared with the classical theory. Taking the effective radial potential energy as $\frac{S}{{r}^{2}}$, although the solutions for negative energy for $0\ensuremath{\geqq}S\ensuremath{\geqq}\frac{\ensuremath{-}{h}^{2}}{32{\ensuremath{\pi}}^{2}\ensuremath{\mu}}$ satisfy the usual boundary conditions, they can not be admitted because the Hamiltonian is not Hermitian in these solutions. This corresponds to taking ${(l+\frac{1}{2})}^{2}$ in place of $l(l+1)$ as the analogue of the square of the classical angular momentum. If we do this, we get a complete analogy between the classical and quantum mechanically allowed solutions, with no quantization. The solutions involve Bessel functions of both real and imaginary orders with both real and imaginary arguments.

DOI
10.1103/physrev.38.120

Related papers

Correctness of Coupling Theory on the Angular Momentum by the Motion of a Spinning Particle

Dai Meng-kun

We discuss the motion of a particle which spin is 1/2 in a central force field in two different methods. We can get the wave function of a particle by matrix operating and vector coupling theory of the angular momentum. The results is the same, so that the coupling theory of the angular momentum is correct.

Journal of Kunming University of Science and Technology•Jan 1, 2000•0 citations

Quantum versus classical angular momentum

Jan Mostowski, Joanna Pietraszewicz

Abstract Angular momentum in classical mechanics is given by a vector. The plane perpendicular to this vector, in accordance to central field theory, determines the space in which particle motion takes place. No such simple picture exists in quantum mechanics. The states of a particle in a central field are proportional to spherical harmonics which do not define any plane of motion. In the first part of this paper we discuss the angular distribution of particle position and compare it to the classical probabilistic approach. In the second part, the matter of addition of angular momenta is discussed. In classical mechanics this means addition of vectors, while in quantum mechanics Clebsch–Gordan coefficients have to be used. We have found classical approximations to quantum coefficients and the limit of their applicability. This analysis gives a basis for the so-called ‘vector addition model’ used in some elementary textbooks on atomic physics. It can help to better understand the addition of angular momenta in quantum mechanics.

arXiv:1907.09930•European Journal of Physics•Oct 4, 2019•0 citations

Natural relationship between classical orbits and quantum Hamiltonians for the Kepler problem

Jason D. Tran, Leanne Doughty, James K. Freericks

Central force problems involve coupled linear differential equations of motion. By decoupling the differential equations, we show how to efficiently solve for the orbits of the Kepler problem without any complicated integrals. Introducing quantization provides a deep connection between the solution for these classical orbits and the quantum Hamiltonian of hydrogen for states that have definite total angular momentum.

American Journal of Physics•Apr 22, 2025•1 citation

Particle in a central potential

P. C. W. Davies, David S. Betts

One of the most important problems in quantum mechanics concerns the motion of a particle in a potential of the form V ( r ) = V ( r ), where r ≡ | r | https://s3-euw1-ap-pe-df-pch-content-public-p.s3.eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/9780203741481/4ab22e1a-c1c5-4151-9df7-a6d7ea2b05e0/content/eq763.tif"/> . This system has the simplifying feature of spherical symmetry, which allows the angular dependence of the motion to be reduced to purely geometrical considerations and hence solved once and for all, while the physics enters only through the radial motion. Treating this problem in detail also provides a good opportunity to illustrate the quantum mechanical formalism.

Routledge eBooks•Apr 27, 2018•0 citations

Generalization of adding angular momenta and circular potential in quaternionic quantum mechanics

R. Deepika, Krishnan Muthunagai

Complex numbers were created by introducing the imaginary unit i to represent the square root of -1, allowing solutions to equations that involved square roots of negative numbers. Complex numbers were further extended to quaternionic numbers by introducing additional imaginary units, namely " j " and " k ". Quaternions are non-commutative and involve four components, with each component being a real number or a multiple of an imaginary unit. Usually complex numbers are used to represent wave functions in quantum mechanics. Solutions using quaternions to square well, spin and angular momentum, Dirac equations have been obtained by many researchers. In this article, we have made use of quaternions to study the generalization of adding angular momenta, the digital signal processing of a quaternionic function and circular potential of a particle in real Hilbert space and have obtained quaternionic solutions in terms of Bessel functions.

Heliyon•Feb 1, 2024•5 citations

The “Radial Kinetic Energy” Term in the Schrödinger Equation for a Central Force

Frank S. Crawford

A straightforward derivation is given for the Hermitian operator pr ≡ 1r ħi δδrr corresponding to the radial component of linear momentum in the central force problem. The purpose is purely pedagogical; we believe that the radial term of the Schrödinger equation in spherical coordinates is more comprehensible when it appears in the form (pr2/2m)ψ = [(1r ħi δδrr)2/2m]ψ than when it appears, as it does in most textbooks, in the form −ħ22mr2 δδr[r2δδr]ψ. The latter expression is usually arrived at by a tedious transformation of variable done “in the appendix”; instead one may derive pr with a minimum of algebra and with the focus where it belongs, on the concepts of quantum mechanics.

American Journal of Physics•Aug 1, 1964•2 citations
The problem of the motion of a particle in an inverse-cube central force field is fully treated by quantum mechanics and the results compared with the classical theory. Taking the effective radial potential energy as Sr2\frac{S}{{r}^{2}}r2S​, although the solutions for negative energy for 0\ensuremath≧S\ensuremath≧\ensuremath−h232\ensuremathπ2\ensuremathμ0\ensuremath{\geqq}S\ensuremath{\geqq}\frac{\ensuremath{-}{h}^{2}}{32{\ensuremath{\pi}}^{2}\ensuremath{\mu}}0\ensuremath≧S\ensuremath≧32\ensuremathπ2\ensuremathμ\ensuremath−h2​ satisfy the usual boundary conditions, they can not be admitted because the Hamiltonian is not Hermitian in these solutions. This corresponds to taking (l+12)2{(l+\frac{1}{2})}^{2}(l+21​)2 in place of l(l+1)l(l+1)l(l+1) as the analogue of the square of the classical angular momentum. If we do this, we get a complete analogy between the classical and quantum mechanically allowed solutions, with no quantization. The solutions involve Bessel functions of both real and imaginary orders with both real and imaginary arguments.
Abstract Angular momentum in classical mechanics is given by a vector. The plane perpendicular to this vector, in accordance to central field theory, determines the space in which particle motion takes place. No such simple picture exists in quantum mechanics. The states of a particle in a central field are proportional to spherical harmonics which do not define any plane of motion. In the first part of this paper we discuss the angular distribution of particle position and compare it to the classical probabilistic approach. In the second part, the matter of addition of angular momenta is discussed. In classical mechanics this means addition of vectors, while in quantum mechanics Clebsch–Gordan coefficients have to be used. We have found classical approximations to quantum coefficients and the limit of their applicability. This analysis gives a basis for the so-called ‘vector addition model’ used in some elementary textbooks on atomic physics. It can help to better understand the addition of angular momenta in quantum mechanics.
One of the most important problems in quantum mechanics concerns the motion of a particle in a potential of the form V ( r ) = V ( r ), where r ≡ | r | https://s3-euw1-ap-pe-df-pch-content-public-p.s3.eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/9780203741481/4ab22e1a-c1c5-4151-9df7-a6d7ea2b05e0/content/eq763.tif"/> . This system has the simplifying feature of spherical symmetry, which allows the angular dependence of the motion to be reduced to purely geometrical considerations and hence solved once and for all, while the physics enters only through the radial motion. Treating this problem in detail also provides a good opportunity to illustrate the quantum mechanical formalism.
Complex numbers were created by introducing the imaginary unit i to represent the square root of -1, allowing solutions to equations that involved square roots of negative numbers. Complex numbers were further extended to quaternionic numbers by introducing additional imaginary units, namely " j " and " k ". Quaternions are non-commutative and involve four components, with each component being a real number or a multiple of an imaginary unit. Usually complex numbers are used to represent wave functions in quantum mechanics. Solutions using quaternions to square well, spin and angular momentum, Dirac equations have been obtained by many researchers. In this article, we have made use of quaternions to study the generalization of adding angular momenta, the digital signal processing of a quaternionic function and circular potential of a particle in real Hilbert space and have obtained quaternionic solutions in terms of Bessel functions.
A straightforward derivation is given for the Hermitian operator pr ≡ 1r ħi δδrr corresponding to the radial component of linear momentum in the central force problem. The purpose is purely pedagogical; we believe that the radial term of the Schrödinger equation in spherical coordinates is more comprehensible when it appears in the form (pr2/2m)ψ = [(1r ħi δδrr)2/2m]ψ than when it appears, as it does in most textbooks, in the form −ħ22mr2 δδr[r2δδr]ψ. The latter expression is usually arrived at by a tedious transformation of variable done “in the appendix”; instead one may derive pr with a minimum of algebra and with the focus where it belongs, on the concepts of quantum mechanics.