Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE

Exploring divisibility and summability of 'photon' wave packets in nonlinear optical phenomena

Narasimha S. Prasad, Chandrasekhar Roychoudhuri

Published Aug 20, 2009• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

Formulations for second and higher harmonic frequency up & down conversions, as well as multi photon processes directly assume summability and divisibility of photons. Quantum mechanical (QM) interpretations are completely congruent with these assumptions. However, for linear optical phenomena (interference, diffraction, refraction, material dispersion, spectral dispersion, etc.), we have a profound dichotomy. Most optical engineers innovate and analyze all optical instruments by propagating pure classical electromagnetic (EM) fields using Maxwell's equations and gives only 'lip-service' to the concept "indivisible light quanta". Further, irrespective of linearity or nonlinearity of the phenomena, the final results are always registered through some photo-electric or photo-chemical effects. This is mathematically well modeled by a quadratic action (energy absorption) relation. Since QM does not preclude divisibility or summability of photons in nonlinear & multi-photon effects, it cannot have any foundational reason against these same possibilities in linear optical phenomena. It implies that we must carefully revisit the fundamental roots behind all lightmatter interaction processes and understand the common origin of "graininess" and "discreteness' of light energy.

DOI
10.1117/12.828557

Related papers

Do we count indivisible photons or discrete quantum events experienced by detectors?

Chandrasekhar Roychoudhuri, Negussie Tirfessa

As low light detection technologies are advancing, novel experiments like single molecule spectroscopy, quantum computation, quantum encryption are proliferating. Quantum mechanical detectors can produce only discrete "clicks" at different rates based on the propagating field energy through them, irrespective of whether the photons are divisible or indivisible packets of energy. This is because electrons are quantized elementary particles and they are always bound in quantized energy levels in different quantum systems. Highly successful quantum formalism is not capable of providing the microscopic picture of the processes undergoing during QM interactions; that is left to human imaginations allowing for sustained controversies and mis-interpretations. This paper underscores the paradoxes that arise with the assumption that photons are indivisible elementary particles based on the obvious but generally ignored fact that EM fields do not operate on (interfere with) each other. Then we propose that atomic or molecular emissions emerge and propagate out as space and time finite classical wave packets. We also suggest experiments to validate that the amplitude of a photon wave packet can be split and combined by classical optical components using the specific example of an N-slit grating.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Oct 18, 2006•16 citations

If superposed light beams do not re-distribute each others energy in the absence of detectors (material dipoles), can an indivisible single photon interfere by/with itself?

Chandrasekhar Roychoudhuri

The intention of this paper is to underscore that to understand fundamentally new properties of light beams, we must first find the limits of semi classical model to explain optical interference phenomena. We claim that we have not yet reached that limit. Careful analysis of the processes behind detecting fringes indicate that the effect of superposition of multiple optical beams can become manifest only through the mediation of the detecting dipoles. Since the detectors are quantum mechanical, (i) the observed effects are different for different detectors for the same superposed light beams, and further, (ii) they are only capable of registering discrete number of "clicks", whose rate will vary with the incident intensity. A reduced rate of "clicks" at very low intensity does not prove that light consists of indivisible packets of energy. We have also experimentally demonstrated that (i) neither Fourier synthesis, nor, (ii) Fourier decomposition actually model the behavior of EM fields under all possible circumstances. Superposed light beams of different frequencies do not synthesize a new average optical frequency. A pure amplitude modulated pulse does not contain any of the mathematical, Fourier analyzed frequencies. The QED definition of photon being a Fourier mode in the vacuum, it necessarily becomes non-local. Since we have demonstrated that the Fourier theorem has various limitations in classical physics, its indiscriminate use in quantum mechanics should also be critically reviewed.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Aug 1, 2005•6 citations

Indivisibility of the photon

Ashok Muthukrishnan, Chandrasekhar Roychoudhuri

The 'graininess' in the energy content of light is reported in experiments ranging from the blackbody spectrum and photo-electric effect to revivals in the Jaynes-Cummings model. Laser shot noise and antibunching of correlations in resonance fluorescence signify a departure from continuous wave behavior for light. Such phenomena underlie the unique sense in which a photon is regarded as an indivisible particle, experimentally tied to the fact that a beam splitter does not split a single photon of a two-photon pair. We consider three arguments for indivisibility - quantization of energy, particle-like fluctuations, and which-way measurements. We argue that in each case, photon indivisibility is an inference based on energy conserving interactions where the detection mechanism involves countable electrons subject to space and bandwidth limitations. The indivisibility of the photon thus remains an open question, and one that we can use to probe the foundations of quantum electrodynamics.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Aug 20, 2009•5 citations

Introduction

Guang S. He

This chapter describes the formation, development, and major subjects of nonlinear optics and photonics. The semiclassical theory treats the light as a classical electromagnetic field governed by Maxwell equations, while the optical medium is a molecular system governed by quantum mechanics; the key parameters for this theory are various-order nonlinear susceptibilities. The quantum theory of radiation treats light as an ensemble of photons and the medium as a molecular system, both of which are described by quantum mechanics, and the key aspect is the concept of the so-called intermediate state represented by a virtual energy state level. The semiclassical theory gives a concise quantitative description of various nonlinear multi-wave mixing effects as well as those nonlinear processes related to the induced refractive-index changes. In contrast, the quantum theory of radiation can provide a conceptual interpretation for almost all known nonlinear optical effects and phenomena.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Oct 30, 2014•0 citations

Optical nonlinearities. Materials with quadratic nonlinearities

Luigi A. Lugiato, Franco Prati, Massimo Brambilla

In the previous chapter we examined nonlinear propagation in a two-level medium, which leads to amplification or absorption of the radiation field. As we will see further on in this volume, when the medium is placed in an optical cavity one realizes a laser in the case of amplification or an optically bistable system in the absorptive configuration. On the other hand, the nonlinear response of the atomic polarization to the electric field leads to further fascinating scenarios [29, 51–60]. For example, a field with central ω 0 can generate harmonic components with central frequencies 2 ω 0 , 3 ω 0 etc., processes that are called second-harmonic generation, third-harmonic generation etc. Furthermore, the interaction of two fields with central frequencies ω 1 and ω 2 , with ω 1 > ω 2 , can generate components with central frequency ω 1 + ω 2 (sum-frequency generation) and ω 1 − ω 2 (difference-frequency generation). Such phenomena have not yet appeared in this volume because we have assumed that the electric field corresponds to a narrow frequency band around a central frequency ω 0 only, whereas to describe them it is necessary to assume that the electric field is the superposition of a number of frequency bands. In this chapter we will provide a description of the basic elements which are necessary to describe these phenomena and we will discuss a small number of them for the case of materials with a quadratic nonlinearity, referring to textbooks in nonlinear optics for the description of other phenomena. The following chapter is devoted, instead, to the case of materials with cubic nonlinearities. The starting point of nonlinear optics is the expansion of the atomic polarization in powers of the electric field, when the electric field is not too intense. In our treatment in Chapter 5 we saw that the expansion of the nonlinear susceptibility contains only even powers of the electric field (see Eq. (5.27)), and therefore the expansion of the polarization includes only odd powers.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 28, 2015•0 citations

Quantizing Maxwell's Equations

Thomas A. Garrity

: Our goal is to quantize Maxwell's equations, leading to a natural interpretation of light as being composed of photons. The key is that the quantization of harmonic oscillators (or, more prosaically, the mathematics of springs) is critical to understanding light. In particular, we show that the possible energies of light form a discrete set, linked to the classical frequency, giving us an interpretation for the photoelectric effect. Our Approach From Einstein's explanation of the photoelectric effect, light seems to be made up of photons, which in turn are somewhat particle-like. Can we start with the classical description of light as an electromagnetic wave solution to Maxwell's equations when there are no charges or currents, quantize, and then get something that can be identified with photons? That is the goal of this chapter. (As in the previous chapter, while all of this is standard, we will be following the outline given in chapter 2 of [41].) Maxwell's equations are linear. We will concentrate on the ‘monochromatic’ solutions, those with fixed frequency and direction. We will see that the Hamiltonians of these monochromatic solutions will have the same mathematical structure as a Hamiltonian for a harmonic oscillator. We know from the last chapter how to quantize the harmonic oscillator. More importantly, we saw that there are discrete eigenvalues and eigenvectors for the corresponding Hamiltonian operator. When we quantize the Hamiltonians for the monochromatic waves in an analogous fashion, we will again have discrete eigenvalues and eigenvectors. It is these eigenvectors that we can interpret as photons.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jan 19, 2015•0 citations
Formulations for second and higher harmonic frequency up & down conversions, as well as multi photon processes directly assume summability and divisibility of photons. Quantum mechanical (QM) interpretations are completely congruent with these assumptions. However, for linear optical phenomena (interference, diffraction, refraction, material dispersion, spectral dispersion, etc.), we have a profound dichotomy. Most optical engineers innovate and analyze all optical instruments by propagating pure classical electromagnetic (EM) fields using Maxwell's equations and gives only 'lip-service' to the concept "indivisible light quanta". Further, irrespective of linearity or nonlinearity of the phenomena, the final results are always registered through some photo-electric or photo-chemical effects. This is mathematically well modeled by a quadratic action (energy absorption) relation. Since QM does not preclude divisibility or summability of photons in nonlinear & multi-photon effects, it cannot have any foundational reason against these same possibilities in linear optical phenomena. It implies that we must carefully revisit the fundamental roots behind all lightmatter interaction processes and understand the common origin of "graininess" and "discreteness' of light energy.
As low light detection technologies are advancing, novel experiments like single molecule spectroscopy, quantum computation, quantum encryption are proliferating. Quantum mechanical detectors can produce only discrete "clicks" at different rates based on the propagating field energy through them, irrespective of whether the photons are divisible or indivisible packets of energy. This is because electrons are quantized elementary particles and they are always bound in quantized energy levels in different quantum systems. Highly successful quantum formalism is not capable of providing the microscopic picture of the processes undergoing during QM interactions; that is left to human imaginations allowing for sustained controversies and mis-interpretations. This paper underscores the paradoxes that arise with the assumption that photons are indivisible elementary particles based on the obvious but generally ignored fact that EM fields do not operate on (interfere with) each other. Then we propose that atomic or molecular emissions emerge and propagate out as space and time finite classical wave packets. We also suggest experiments to validate that the amplitude of a photon wave packet can be split and combined by classical optical components using the specific example of an N-slit grating.
The intention of this paper is to underscore that to understand fundamentally new properties of light beams, we must first find the limits of semi classical model to explain optical interference phenomena. We claim that we have not yet reached that limit. Careful analysis of the processes behind detecting fringes indicate that the effect of superposition of multiple optical beams can become manifest only through the mediation of the detecting dipoles. Since the detectors are quantum mechanical, (i) the observed effects are different for different detectors for the same superposed light beams, and further, (ii) they are only capable of registering discrete number of "clicks", whose rate will vary with the incident intensity. A reduced rate of "clicks" at very low intensity does not prove that light consists of indivisible packets of energy. We have also experimentally demonstrated that (i) neither Fourier synthesis, nor, (ii) Fourier decomposition actually model the behavior of EM fields under all possible circumstances. Superposed light beams of different frequencies do not synthesize a new average optical frequency. A pure amplitude modulated pulse does not contain any of the mathematical, Fourier analyzed frequencies. The QED definition of photon being a Fourier mode in the vacuum, it necessarily becomes non-local. Since we have demonstrated that the Fourier theorem has various limitations in classical physics, its indiscriminate use in quantum mechanics should also be critically reviewed.
The 'graininess' in the energy content of light is reported in experiments ranging from the blackbody spectrum and photo-electric effect to revivals in the Jaynes-Cummings model. Laser shot noise and antibunching of correlations in resonance fluorescence signify a departure from continuous wave behavior for light. Such phenomena underlie the unique sense in which a photon is regarded as an indivisible particle, experimentally tied to the fact that a beam splitter does not split a single photon of a two-photon pair. We consider three arguments for indivisibility - quantization of energy, particle-like fluctuations, and which-way measurements. We argue that in each case, photon indivisibility is an inference based on energy conserving interactions where the detection mechanism involves countable electrons subject to space and bandwidth limitations. The indivisibility of the photon thus remains an open question, and one that we can use to probe the foundations of quantum electrodynamics.
This chapter describes the formation, development, and major subjects of nonlinear optics and photonics. The semiclassical theory treats the light as a classical electromagnetic field governed by Maxwell equations, while the optical medium is a molecular system governed by quantum mechanics; the key parameters for this theory are various-order nonlinear susceptibilities. The quantum theory of radiation treats light as an ensemble of photons and the medium as a molecular system, both of which are described by quantum mechanics, and the key aspect is the concept of the so-called intermediate state represented by a virtual energy state level. The semiclassical theory gives a concise quantitative description of various nonlinear multi-wave mixing effects as well as those nonlinear processes related to the induced refractive-index changes. In contrast, the quantum theory of radiation can provide a conceptual interpretation for almost all known nonlinear optical effects and phenomena.
In the previous chapter we examined nonlinear propagation in a two-level medium, which leads to amplification or absorption of the radiation field. As we will see further on in this volume, when the medium is placed in an optical cavity one realizes a laser in the case of amplification or an optically bistable system in the absorptive configuration. On the other hand, the nonlinear response of the atomic polarization to the electric field leads to further fascinating scenarios [29, 51–60]. For example, a field with central ω 0 can generate harmonic components with central frequencies 2 ω 0 , 3 ω 0 etc., processes that are called second-harmonic generation, third-harmonic generation etc. Furthermore, the interaction of two fields with central frequencies ω 1 and ω 2 , with ω 1 > ω 2 , can generate components with central frequency ω 1 + ω 2 (sum-frequency generation) and ω 1 − ω 2 (difference-frequency generation). Such phenomena have not yet appeared in this volume because we have assumed that the electric field corresponds to a narrow frequency band around a central frequency ω 0 only, whereas to describe them it is necessary to assume that the electric field is the superposition of a number of frequency bands. In this chapter we will provide a description of the basic elements which are necessary to describe these phenomena and we will discuss a small number of them for the case of materials with a quadratic nonlinearity, referring to textbooks in nonlinear optics for the description of other phenomena. The following chapter is devoted, instead, to the case of materials with cubic nonlinearities. The starting point of nonlinear optics is the expansion of the atomic polarization in powers of the electric field, when the electric field is not too intense. In our treatment in Chapter 5 we saw that the expansion of the nonlinear susceptibility contains only even powers of the electric field (see Eq. (5.27)), and therefore the expansion of the polarization includes only odd powers.
: Our goal is to quantize Maxwell's equations, leading to a natural interpretation of light as being composed of photons. The key is that the quantization of harmonic oscillators (or, more prosaically, the mathematics of springs) is critical to understanding light. In particular, we show that the possible energies of light form a discrete set, linked to the classical frequency, giving us an interpretation for the photoelectric effect. Our Approach From Einstein's explanation of the photoelectric effect, light seems to be made up of photons, which in turn are somewhat particle-like. Can we start with the classical description of light as an electromagnetic wave solution to Maxwell's equations when there are no charges or currents, quantize, and then get something that can be identified with photons? That is the goal of this chapter. (As in the previous chapter, while all of this is standard, we will be following the outline given in chapter 2 of [41].) Maxwell's equations are linear. We will concentrate on the ‘monochromatic’ solutions, those with fixed frequency and direction. We will see that the Hamiltonians of these monochromatic solutions will have the same mathematical structure as a Hamiltonian for a harmonic oscillator. We know from the last chapter how to quantize the harmonic oscillator. More importantly, we saw that there are discrete eigenvalues and eigenvectors for the corresponding Hamiltonian operator. When we quantize the Hamiltonians for the monochromatic waves in an analogous fashion, we will again have discrete eigenvalues and eigenvectors. It is these eigenvectors that we can interpret as photons.