We investigate the relative merits of techniques for recovery of density matrices of two qubits from experimental data. Our results are applied to measure the states of photons produced in down-conversion experiments.
We describe in detail the theory underpinning the measurement of density matrices of a pair of quantum two-level systems (``qubits''). Our particular emphasis is on qubits realized by the two polarization degrees of freedom of a pair of entangled photons generated in a down-conversion experiment; however the discussion applies in general, regardless of the actual physical realization. Two techniques are discussed, namely a tomographic reconstruction (in which the density matrix is linearly related to a set of measured quantities) and a maximum likelihood technique which requires numerical optimization (but has the advantage of producing density matrices which are always non-negative definite). In addition a detailed error analysis is presented, allowing errors in quantities derived from the density matrix, such as the entropy or entanglement of formation, to be estimated. Examples based on down-conversion experiments are used to illustrate our results.
We describe in detail the theory underpinning the measurement of density matrices of a pair of quantum two-level systems (``qubits''). Our particular emphasis is on qubits realized by the two polarization degrees of freedom of a pair of entangled photons generated in a down-conversion experiment; however, the discussion applies in general, regardless of the actual physical realization. Two techniques are discussed, namely, a tomographic reconstruction (in which the density matrix is linearly related to a set of measured quantities) and a maximum likelihood technique which requires numerical optimization (but has the advantage of producing density matrices that are always non-negative definite). In addition, a detailed error analysis is presented, allowing errors in quantities derived from the density matrix, such as the entropy or entanglement of formation, to be estimated. Examples based on down-conversion experiments are used to illustrate our results.
Summary form only given. Experimental techniques for measurement of the quantum state of light have been the subject of intensive investigation for some time. Tomographic techniques have been applied to experiments such as the homodyne measurement of the Wigner function of a single mode of light and of the density matrix of the polarization degrees of freedom of a pair of entangled photons. In this technique, the density matrix (or Wigner function) which characterizes the quantum state of the system being measured is found from a linear transformation of experimental data. There are a number of drawbacks to the method, principally in that the recovered state might not, because of experimental noise, correspond to a physical state. For example, density matrices for any quantum state must be Hermitian, positive semi-definite matrices with unit trace. The tomographically measured matrices often fail to be positive semi-definite. To avoid this problem, the maximum likelihood approach to the estimation of quantum states has been developed. We evaluate two different approaches to the maximum likelihood technique, namely defining the likelihood function f as a weighted sum of squared variances from measured data, and defining it in terms of information content. These are compared with results of standard tomographical schemes.