International Journal of Quantum Chemistry
Spin‐free quantum chemistry: What one can gain from fock's cyclic symmetry
Anatoliy V. Luzanov
Published Dec 7, 2010• 13 citations
Abstract
Abstract The spin‐free wave function due to Fock (Zh Eksp Teor Fiz, 1940, 10, 961) is re‐examined with a stress on the reduced density matrix (RDM) theory. The key notion of the Fock approach is the cyclic symmetry of wave functions. It is a specific algebraic identity involving transpositions of numbers taken from two different columns of the corresponding Young tableau. We show first how to construct symmetry adapted states by accounting for high‐order cyclic symmetry conditions. For Young's projectors, it gives a new expression including nothing but antisymmetrizers. Next, transforming the Fock spin‐free state by a duality operator (the star operator in exterior algebra), we arrive at the representation closely related to spin‐flip models. In such spin‐flip models, a coupling operator is the basic object for which we show that the cyclic symmetry is transformed into a tracelessness of the coupling operator. The main results are related to the spin‐free theory of spin properties. In particular, the theorem previously stated (Luzanov and Whyman, Int J Quantum Chem, 1981, 20, 1179) is refined by an explicit general representation of spin density operators through spin‐free (charge) RDMs. Some applications implicating high‐order RDMs (collectivity numbers, the unpaired electron problem, cumulant spin RDMs, spin correlators, etc.) are also considered. For spin‐free RDM components, a new projection procedure without constructing any symmetry adapted state is proposed. An unsolved problem of constructing orthogonal representation matrices within the Fock theory is raised. © 2010 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2010
- DOI
- 10.1002/qua.22943
Related papers
Spin structure of the first order reduced density matrix and spin‐polarized states
Igor V. Abarenkov, S. N. Zagoulaev
Abstract The spin structure of the first order reduced density matrix (RDM‐1) for an arbitrary many‐electron state with zero z‐projection of the total spin is examined. It is well known that for the state ΨS0(r1σ1,…,rN σN), which is an eigenstate of operators ${\widehat {S^2}}$ and ${\widehat S}_z$ with quantum numbers S and M = 0, the matrix elements for spins α and β are equal for any r and r′: ρ (r|r′) = ρ (r|r′). In the present article, it is shown that the same is true for any state ΦM = 0(r1σ1,…,rN,σN) with indefinite total spin if in the expansion ΦM = 0 = ∑S DS ΨS0 only spins S with the same parity are present. To prove the statement, it is shown that the wave function ΨS0 acquires the phase factor (−1)N/2−S when all spin functions α(σi) are changed for β(σi) and vice versa. In the developed proof, the Hamiltonian was not used at all and it was not even assumed that the wave function ΨS0 is an eigenfunction of some Hamiltonian. Therefore the obtained result is valid for the stationary and non‐stationary states, ground and excited states, with and without homogeneous magnetic field imposed, exact and approximate wave functions. From the result obtained it follows, in particular, that for the stationary state to be spin‐polarized (ρ (r|r) ≠ ρ (r|r)) it is necessary for the Hamiltonian to mix states with different parity spins. The consequences from the proved statement for the antiferromagnetic state are discussed. © 2008 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2008
International Journal of Quantum Chemistry•Jan 1, 2008•3 citations
Methods for electronic‐structure calculations: Overview from a reduced‐density‐matrix point of view
P. Ziesche, Ferenc Tasnádi
Abstract The methods of quantum chemistry and solid state theory to solve the many‐body problem are reviewed. We start with the definitions of reduced density matrices, their properties (contraction sum rules, spectral resolutions, cumulant expansion, and N‐representability), and their determining equations (contracted Schrödinger equations), and we summarize recent extensions and generalizations of the traditional quantum chemical methods, of the density functional theory, and of the quasiparticle theory: from finite to extended systems (incremental method), from density‐to‐density matrix (density matrix functional theory), from weak to strong correlation (dynamical mean field theory), from homogeneous (Kimball–Overhauser approach) to inhomogeneous and finite systems. Measures of the correlation strength are discussed. The cumulant two‐body reduced density matrix proves to be a key quantity. Its spectral resolution contains geminals, possibly the solutions of an approximate effective two‐body equation, and we sketch the idea of how its contraction sum rule can be used for a variational treatment. © 2004 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2004
arXiv:cond-mat/0312516•International Journal of Quantum Chemistry•Jan 1, 2004•3 citations
Spin‐free quantum electronic structure: Its second quantization and para‐Fermionics
Douglas J. Klein
Abstract First, the spin‐free formulation of electronic structure is reviewed within the standard first‐quantized framework, with special attention to its manner of correspondence to the standard antisymmetrized space‐spin (ASspin) formulation. Second, within this first‐quantized framework, note is made of some “discrepancies” in the correspondence, for example, regarding mismatches of symmetry‐related degeneracies. Third, a novel second‐quantized spin‐free formulation is introduced to overcome these “discrepancies,” and so achieve a one‐to‐one correspondence between ASspin wave functions and second‐quantized spin‐free wave functions. Yet further, this second‐quantized spin‐free description enables the identification of electrons as “para‐Fermions,” at least in the nonrelativistic limit of spin‐free interactions. From the point of view of elementary particle physics, a rather complete picture of the behavior of para‐Fermions emerges with electrons as a proxy, and so suggests that in fact para‐Fermions would be difficult to distinguish from ordinary Fermions, at least in this nonrelativistic limit or with but few such particles. © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2011
International Journal of Quantum Chemistry•Dec 15, 2009•4 citations
Integral–geometrical consideration of density matrices
Boris P. Zapol
Abstract The ensemble N‐representability problem for the k‐th order reduced density matrix (k‐RDM) as well as the problem of reconstruction of the N‐particle system density matrices (N‐DM) from a given k‐RDM are studied. The spatial parts of the k‐RDM expansion in terms of spin tensorial operators Θ are represented using particular values (at specially chosen ) of the Radon transform of the N‐DM spatial parts (or their sums) 𝒟Nλ(x′ | x″) (here, is a d‐plane in the n‐space ℝn of x = (x′, x″)), with n = 6N, d = 3 (N − k), x′ ≡ (r′1, ⃛, r′N), x′ ≡ (r1″, ⃛, r″N ()). In this way, the problem is reduced to investigation of the properties of the functions . For a normalizable N – DM, it is proved that are bounded functions. The properties of implied by the N‐DM permutational symmetry, Hermiticity, and positive definiteness are found. A formal procedure of reconstruction of all N‐DM corresponding to a given k‐RDM is proposed. © 1995 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
International Journal of Quantum Chemistry•Dec 5, 1995•2 citations
Early stage of the development of quantum chemistry without spin and its recent applications
Ilya G. Kaplan
Abstract General ideas, on which the quantum chemistry without spin is based, are discussed. Three important applications of quantum chemistry without spin are presented in detail: (1) the methods for finding the molecular spin‐multiplets allowed by the Pauli principle; (2) the symmetry properties of the electron density that determines the Kohn‐Sham equations in the density functional theory; and (3) the foundations of the Pauli principle. In particular, it was demonstrated that, on the one hand, the Pauli exclusion principle cannot be derived from other fundamental principles of quantum mechanics; on the other hand, it cannot be considered as a postulate, since all other symmetry options for the total wave function of identical particles, except the one‐dimensional representations, are forbidden. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. This article was published online on 18 June 2012. An error was subsequently identified. This notice is included in the online and print version to indicate that both have been corrected on 25 July 2012.
International Journal of Quantum Chemistry•Jun 18, 2012•3 citations
Abstract The spin‐free wave function due to Fock (Zh Eksp Teor Fiz, 1940, 10, 961) is re‐examined with a stress on the reduced density matrix (RDM) theory. The key notion of the Fock approach is the cyclic symmetry of wave functions. It is a specific algebraic identity involving transpositions of numbers taken from two different columns of the corresponding Young tableau. We show first how to construct symmetry adapted states by accounting for high‐order cyclic symmetry conditions. For Young's projectors, it gives a new expression including nothing but antisymmetrizers. Next, transforming the Fock spin‐free state by a duality operator (the star operator in exterior algebra), we arrive at the representation closely related to spin‐flip models. In such spin‐flip models, a coupling operator is the basic object for which we show that the cyclic symmetry is transformed into a tracelessness of the coupling operator. The main results are related to the spin‐free theory of spin properties. In particular, the theorem previously stated (Luzanov and Whyman, Int J Quantum Chem, 1981, 20, 1179) is refined by an explicit general representation of spin density operators through spin‐free (charge) RDMs. Some applications implicating high‐order RDMs (collectivity numbers, the unpaired electron problem, cumulant spin RDMs, spin correlators, etc.) are also considered. For spin‐free RDM components, a new projection procedure without constructing any symmetry adapted state is proposed. An unsolved problem of constructing orthogonal representation matrices within the Fock theory is raised. © 2010 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2010
Abstract The spin structure of the first order reduced density matrix (RDM‐1) for an arbitrary many‐electron state with zero z‐projection of the total spin is examined. It is well known that for the state ΨS0(r1σ1,…,rN σN), which is an eigenstate of operators
S2 and
Sz with quantum numbers S and M = 0, the matrix elements for spins α and β are equal for any r and r′: ρ (r|r′) = ρ (r|r′). In the present article, it is shown that the same is true for any state ΦM = 0(r1σ1,…,rN,σN) with indefinite total spin if in the expansion ΦM = 0 = ∑S DS ΨS0 only spins S with the same parity are present. To prove the statement, it is shown that the wave function ΨS0 acquires the phase factor (−1)N/2−S when all spin functions α(σi) are changed for β(σi) and vice versa. In the developed proof, the Hamiltonian was not used at all and it was not even assumed that the wave function ΨS0 is an eigenfunction of some Hamiltonian. Therefore the obtained result is valid for the stationary and non‐stationary states, ground and excited states, with and without homogeneous magnetic field imposed, exact and approximate wave functions. From the result obtained it follows, in particular, that for the stationary state to be spin‐polarized (ρ (r|r) ≠ ρ (r|r)) it is necessary for the Hamiltonian to mix states with different parity spins. The consequences from the proved statement for the antiferromagnetic state are discussed. © 2008 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2008
Abstract We present the closed form of the reduced density matrices (RDMs) of arbitrary order for configuration interaction (CI) wave functions at any excitation level, up to the full CI. A special operator technique due to Bogoliubov is applied and extended. It focuses on constructions of matrix‐covariant expressions independent of the basis set used. The corresponding variational CI equations are given in an explicit form containing the matrices related to conventional excitation operators. A subsequent transformation of the latter to an irreducible form makes it possible to generate the matrix‐covariant representation for coupled cluster (CC) models. Here this transformation is performed for a simplified high‐order CC scheme somewhat reminiscent of the quadratic CI model. A generalized spin‐flip approximation closely related to high‐order CI and CC models is presented, stressing on a possible inclusion of nondynamical and dynamical correlation effects for multiple bond breaking. A derivation of the full CI and simple CC models for systems involving effective three‐electron interactions is also given, thereby demonstrating the capability of the proposed method to deal with complicated many‐body problem. © 2007 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2008
Abstract The methods of quantum chemistry and solid state theory to solve the many‐body problem are reviewed. We start with the definitions of reduced density matrices, their properties (contraction sum rules, spectral resolutions, cumulant expansion, and N‐representability), and their determining equations (contracted Schrödinger equations), and we summarize recent extensions and generalizations of the traditional quantum chemical methods, of the density functional theory, and of the quasiparticle theory: from finite to extended systems (incremental method), from density‐to‐density matrix (density matrix functional theory), from weak to strong correlation (dynamical mean field theory), from homogeneous (Kimball–Overhauser approach) to inhomogeneous and finite systems. Measures of the correlation strength are discussed. The cumulant two‐body reduced density matrix proves to be a key quantity. Its spectral resolution contains geminals, possibly the solutions of an approximate effective two‐body equation, and we sketch the idea of how its contraction sum rule can be used for a variational treatment. © 2004 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2004
Abstract First, the spin‐free formulation of electronic structure is reviewed within the standard first‐quantized framework, with special attention to its manner of correspondence to the standard antisymmetrized space‐spin (ASspin) formulation. Second, within this first‐quantized framework, note is made of some “discrepancies” in the correspondence, for example, regarding mismatches of symmetry‐related degeneracies. Third, a novel second‐quantized spin‐free formulation is introduced to overcome these “discrepancies,” and so achieve a one‐to‐one correspondence between ASspin wave functions and second‐quantized spin‐free wave functions. Yet further, this second‐quantized spin‐free description enables the identification of electrons as “para‐Fermions,” at least in the nonrelativistic limit of spin‐free interactions. From the point of view of elementary particle physics, a rather complete picture of the behavior of para‐Fermions emerges with electrons as a proxy, and so suggests that in fact para‐Fermions would be difficult to distinguish from ordinary Fermions, at least in this nonrelativistic limit or with but few such particles. © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2011
Abstract The ensemble N‐representability problem for the k‐th order reduced density matrix (k‐RDM) as well as the problem of reconstruction of the N‐particle system density matrices (N‐DM) from a given k‐RDM are studied. The spatial parts of the k‐RDM expansion in terms of spin tensorial operators Θ are represented using particular values (at specially chosen ) of the Radon transform of the N‐DM spatial parts (or their sums) 𝒟Nλ(x′ | x″) (here, is a d‐plane in the n‐space ℝn of x = (x′, x″)), with n = 6N, d = 3 (N − k), x′ ≡ (r′1, ⃛, r′N), x′ ≡ (r1″, ⃛, r″N ()). In this way, the problem is reduced to investigation of the properties of the functions . For a normalizable N – DM, it is proved that are bounded functions. The properties of implied by the N‐DM permutational symmetry, Hermiticity, and positive definiteness are found. A formal procedure of reconstruction of all N‐DM corresponding to a given k‐RDM is proposed. © 1995 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Abstract General ideas, on which the quantum chemistry without spin is based, are discussed. Three important applications of quantum chemistry without spin are presented in detail: (1) the methods for finding the molecular spin‐multiplets allowed by the Pauli principle; (2) the symmetry properties of the electron density that determines the Kohn‐Sham equations in the density functional theory; and (3) the foundations of the Pauli principle. In particular, it was demonstrated that, on the one hand, the Pauli exclusion principle cannot be derived from other fundamental principles of quantum mechanics; on the other hand, it cannot be considered as a postulate, since all other symmetry options for the total wave function of identical particles, except the one‐dimensional representations, are forbidden. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. This article was published online on 18 June 2012. An error was subsequently identified. This notice is included in the online and print version to indicate that both have been corrected on 25 July 2012.