Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics Conference Series

Possibility of realizing Bussey's thought experiment on collapse of the wave function at the microscopic level

Kouichi Toyoshima, Takasi Endo, Yutaka Hirayoshi

Published Jun 1, 2009• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We discuss on feasibility of experiments to test if the wave function collapses at the level of microscopic events. The original idea is Bussey's 'thought' experiment introduced in 1984. Bussey's proposal is to collide two particles and then two pairs of scattered and unscattered waves of each particle are examined by a pair of Mach-Zehnder type interferometers (MZI). Different coincidence rates between different sets of combinations of MZI outputs are expected depending on the collapse/non collapse assumption. In our proposition to realize this idea, a pair of low-energy electron beams is collided nearly head-on in a nanometer-size region. Then each combination of two waves scattered at small angles is thrown into the MZI. Each MZI is composed of Moellenstedt biprisms as two arms and mirrors, and then brought together at single crystal films which act as half reflecting mirrors (beam splitters). Coincidence counting is done among four outputs of the beam splitters. Another method to measure the position correlation after the biprisms is also proposed.

DOI
10.1088/1742-6596/174/1/012028

Related papers

Realistic interpretation of quantum mechanics and encounter-delayed-choice experiment

GuiLu Long, Wei Qin, Zhe Yang +1 more

In this paper, a realistic interpretation (REIN) of the wave function in quantum mechanics is briefly presented. We demonstrate that in the REIN, the wave function of a microscopic object is its real existence rather than a mere mathematical description. Specifically, the quantum object can exist in disjointed regions of space just as the wave function is distributed, travels at a finite speed, and collapses instantly upon a measurement. Furthermore, we analyze the single-photon interference in a Mach-Zehnder interferometer (MZI) using the REIN. Based on this, we propose and experimentally implement a generalized delayed-choice experiment, called the encounter-delayed-choice experiment, where the second beam splitter is decided whether or not to insert at the encounter of two sub-waves along the arms of the MZI. In such an experiment, the parts of the sub-waves, which do not travel through the beam splitter, show a particle nature, whereas the remaining parts interfere and thus show a wave nature. The predicted phenomenon is clearly demonstrated in the experiment, thus supporting the REIN idea.

arXiv:1410.4129•Science China Physics Mechanics and Astronomy•Dec 13, 2017•47 citations

Losses-based test of wave-particle duality with Mach-Zehnder interferometers

Yang Chen, Aiai Jia, Deng, Xue +4 more

Wave-particle duality of photons with losses in the Mach-Zehnder interferometer (MZI) is investigated experimentally and theoretically. The experiment is done with the standard MZI with the beam splitter or the beam merger being continuously varied. The losses are deliberately introduced either inside the MZI (the two arms between the beam splitter and beam mergers) or outside the MZI (after the beam merger). It is proved that the unbalanced losses have great influence on the predictability $P$ (particle nature) and visibility $V$ (wave nature). For the former case the duality inequality holds while for the later the duality inequality is ``violated''. We get $P^2+V^2>1$. This ``violation'' could be eliminated in principle by switching the two paths and detectors and then averaging the results. The observed results can be exactly explained theoretically. The experiment is done with coherent beam, instead of single photons, and we have proved that they are exactly equivalent in duality experiment with MZI.

arXiv:1402.0370•Feb 3, 2014•1 citation

Are Biprism Experiments Possible and Significant for Protons and Others?(Proposal of a New Application of Mass Spectroscopy) I.

Yujiro Koh

Electron biprism technique, if extended to any charged particles, will make comparison possible among two-beam interference fringes of electrons and other particles under the same(including wave length)geometrical condition. Combination of the technique with sharply focusing mass spectroscopy will realize such experiments. Due to the tradition since Young-Fresnel, it is believed that two-beam visibilities of particles of various masses under the same geometrical setup are constant and independent of each total sum of macroscopically separated path-lengths, which is not to be confused with ordinary path-difference.(See Fig. 2.)But the assumption of such constant visibility has never been verified experimentally and seems to become gradually unnatural as the masses increase. Experimental reexamination of the assumption is proposed with method of observing an expected mass effect on interdependence between visibility and pathlengths. The smaller visibilities are expected for the heavier masses and the longer path-lengths, contrary to conventional constant visibility; e.g., ≅0.4 for protons of wave length 0.02Å and beam width0.2μ in a realizable experimental setup. Technical problems for the experiment and effects to the observation theory are discussed.

Shitsuryou bunseki/Shitsuryo Bunseki•Jan 1, 1968•0 citations

Realization of Hardy’s Thought Experiment with Photons

William T. M. Irvine, Juan F. Hodelin, Christoph Simon +1 more

We present an experimental realization of Hardy's thought experiment [Phys. Rev. Lett. 68, 2981 (1992)], using photons. The experiment consists of a pair of Mach-Zehnder interferometers that interact through photon bunching at a beam splitter. A striking contradiction is created between the predictions of quantum mechanics and local hidden variables. The contradiction relies on nonmaximally entangled position states of two particles. A Clauser-Horne-type inequality is derived and violated.

arXiv:quant-ph/0410160•Physical Review Letters•Jul 11, 2005•38 citations

On an Atom-Interferometer Test of the Speed of Collapse of Wavefunctions in Relativistic Quantum Mechanics

Hans C. Ohanian

I propose to resolve the controversy over the speed of collapse of quantum-mechanical wavefunctions by means of an experimental test with a modified symmetric Mach-Zehnder atom interferometer, with non-intersecting, parallel, widely separated final beams. According to the conventional collapse scenario, the coherent twin-peak atomic wavefunction in the beams of the interferometer suffers an instantaneous collapse, at infinite speed, when the atom is captured by one of the two detectors at the ends of the beams, but it remains coherent until that instant. In contrast, according to the Hellwig-Kraus relativistic collapse scenario, the wavefunction collapses at the speed of light, backward in time along the past light cone of each detector. This leads to a premature collapse, or pre-collapse, which for a beam-to-beam separation of 3 m extends over a time span of 10 ns before arrival at the detectors. Within this time span the paired wavepackets in the two beams will be incoherent. The difference between the coherent wavepackets of the conventional scenario and the incoherent wavepackets of the relativistic scenario can be tested by probing the atomic beams with a transverse laser beam crossing them near the detectors. If the paired atomic wavepackets in the two beams are coherent, the light scattered by the two beams will also be coherent and generate a standing light wave in the space between the beams, with detectable interference fringes. If the paired wavepackets are incoherent, no such interference fringes will be generated, and the distribution of the scattered light will be that of two independent dipoles. The design parameters for this test seem to lie within reach of the techniques of atom interferometry.

arXiv:1311.5840•Nov 22, 2013•2 citations

The Mach–Zehnder Interferometer

William J. Mullin

The chapter discusses the Mach–Zehnder interferometer (MZI), which uses beam splitters in combination with mirrors to place a photon into a superposition of paths. In a final beam splitter, the two paths may be recombined to interfere, showing wave behavior. If the final beam splitter is removed, the photon is definitely in one path or the other, showing particle behavior. The polarization of light allows additional applications—one can use a polarizing beam splitter to separate and reconstitute the wave functions of a photon polarized at an angle. In a delayed-choice experiment, one decides which kind of experiment one is to do, particle or wave, after the photon has already entered the arms of the MZI. The chapter discusses a version of this that puts the MZI and a second-detector photon in an entangled state of particle and wave results.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Mar 16, 2017•3 citations
We discuss on feasibility of experiments to test if the wave function collapses at the level of microscopic events. The original idea is Bussey's 'thought' experiment introduced in 1984. Bussey's proposal is to collide two particles and then two pairs of scattered and unscattered waves of each particle are examined by a pair of Mach-Zehnder type interferometers (MZI). Different coincidence rates between different sets of combinations of MZI outputs are expected depending on the collapse/non collapse assumption. In our proposition to realize this idea, a pair of low-energy electron beams is collided nearly head-on in a nanometer-size region. Then each combination of two waves scattered at small angles is thrown into the MZI. Each MZI is composed of Moellenstedt biprisms as two arms and mirrors, and then brought together at single crystal films which act as half reflecting mirrors (beam splitters). Coincidence counting is done among four outputs of the beam splitters. Another method to measure the position correlation after the biprisms is also proposed.
In this paper, a realistic interpretation (REIN) of the wave function in quantum mechanics is briefly presented. We demonstrate that in the REIN, the wave function of a microscopic object is its real existence rather than a mere mathematical description. Specifically, the quantum object can exist in disjointed regions of space just as the wave function is distributed, travels at a finite speed, and collapses instantly upon a measurement. Furthermore, we analyze the single-photon interference in a Mach-Zehnder interferometer (MZI) using the REIN. Based on this, we propose and experimentally implement a generalized delayed-choice experiment, called the encounter-delayed-choice experiment, where the second beam splitter is decided whether or not to insert at the encounter of two sub-waves along the arms of the MZI. In such an experiment, the parts of the sub-waves, which do not travel through the beam splitter, show a particle nature, whereas the remaining parts interfere and thus show a wave nature. The predicted phenomenon is clearly demonstrated in the experiment, thus supporting the REIN idea.
Wave-particle duality of photons with losses in the Mach-Zehnder interferometer (MZI) is investigated experimentally and theoretically. The experiment is done with the standard MZI with the beam splitter or the beam merger being continuously varied. The losses are deliberately introduced either inside the MZI (the two arms between the beam splitter and beam mergers) or outside the MZI (after the beam merger). It is proved that the unbalanced losses have great influence on the predictability PPP (particle nature) and visibility VVV (wave nature). For the former case the duality inequality holds while for the later the duality inequality is ``violated''. We get P2+V2>1P^2+V^2>1P2+V2>1. This ``violation'' could be eliminated in principle by switching the two paths and detectors and then averaging the results. The observed results can be exactly explained theoretically. The experiment is done with coherent beam, instead of single photons, and we have proved that they are exactly equivalent in duality experiment with MZI.
Electron biprism technique, if extended to any charged particles, will make comparison possible among two-beam interference fringes of electrons and other particles under the same(including wave length)geometrical condition. Combination of the technique with sharply focusing mass spectroscopy will realize such experiments. Due to the tradition since Young-Fresnel, it is believed that two-beam visibilities of particles of various masses under the same geometrical setup are constant and independent of each total sum of macroscopically separated path-lengths, which is not to be confused with ordinary path-difference.(See Fig. 2.)But the assumption of such constant visibility has never been verified experimentally and seems to become gradually unnatural as the masses increase. Experimental reexamination of the assumption is proposed with method of observing an expected mass effect on interdependence between visibility and pathlengths. The smaller visibilities are expected for the heavier masses and the longer path-lengths, contrary to conventional constant visibility; e.g., ≅0.4 for protons of wave length 0.02Å and beam width0.2μ in a realizable experimental setup. Technical problems for the experiment and effects to the observation theory are discussed.
I propose to resolve the controversy over the speed of collapse of quantum-mechanical wavefunctions by means of an experimental test with a modified symmetric Mach-Zehnder atom interferometer, with non-intersecting, parallel, widely separated final beams. According to the conventional collapse scenario, the coherent twin-peak atomic wavefunction in the beams of the interferometer suffers an instantaneous collapse, at infinite speed, when the atom is captured by one of the two detectors at the ends of the beams, but it remains coherent until that instant. In contrast, according to the Hellwig-Kraus relativistic collapse scenario, the wavefunction collapses at the speed of light, backward in time along the past light cone of each detector. This leads to a premature collapse, or pre-collapse, which for a beam-to-beam separation of 3 m extends over a time span of 10 ns before arrival at the detectors. Within this time span the paired wavepackets in the two beams will be incoherent. The difference between the coherent wavepackets of the conventional scenario and the incoherent wavepackets of the relativistic scenario can be tested by probing the atomic beams with a transverse laser beam crossing them near the detectors. If the paired atomic wavepackets in the two beams are coherent, the light scattered by the two beams will also be coherent and generate a standing light wave in the space between the beams, with detectable interference fringes. If the paired wavepackets are incoherent, no such interference fringes will be generated, and the distribution of the scattered light will be that of two independent dipoles. The design parameters for this test seem to lie within reach of the techniques of atom interferometry.
The chapter discusses the Mach–Zehnder interferometer (MZI), which uses beam splitters in combination with mirrors to place a photon into a superposition of paths. In a final beam splitter, the two paths may be recombined to interfere, showing wave behavior. If the final beam splitter is removed, the photon is definitely in one path or the other, showing particle behavior. The polarization of light allows additional applications—one can use a polarizing beam splitter to separate and reconstitute the wave functions of a photon polarized at an angle. In a delayed-choice experiment, one decides which kind of experiment one is to do, particle or wave, after the photon has already entered the arms of the MZI. The chapter discusses a version of this that puts the MZI and a second-detector photon in an entangled state of particle and wave results.