Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields

Stochastic dynamical reduction theories and superluminal communication

Philip Pearle

Published Apr 15, 1986• 38 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In theories which describe the reduction of the state vector as a physical process, the possibility exists, for certain experiments, of predictions which differ from those of quantum theory. These are ``interrupted reduction interference'' experiments, characterized by an interaction which triggers the reduction, followed rapidly (before the reduction is completed) by a measurement of interference between the superposed states that make up the state vector (possible examples: double Stern-Gerlach experiment, two-slit neutron interference). We consider the general class of stochastic reduction theories, and ask whether they allow superluminal communication by means of such experiments. We show that, if the state vector that precedes reduction is precisely reproducible, then superluminal communication can occur in certain circumstances, unless the off-diagonal elements of the density matrix decay exponentially, with a universal time constant. We also show, in that case, that no state vector ever reduces in a finite time, so such a theory is not satisfactory. However, superluminal communication can be avoided if reduction is triggered only in irreproducible state vectors, of such complexity that prior to reduction the ``effective'' density matrix, constructed from the ensemble of such state vectors and traced over the variables outside the experimenter's control, is diagonal. Then predictions are identical to those of quantum theory for ``interrupted reduction interference'' experiments and thus apparently for all experiments. The lesson of this paper is that the ``effective'' density matrix must always be used to make physical predictions in dynamical reduction theories. This supplies a resolution of the problem of reconciling state-vector reduction with relativity: even if the reduction dynamics is not relativistically invariant, its experimental predictions are. It also implies that the ``effective'' entropy increases during a measurement, but remains constant during reduction, which is the reverse of a common dictum.

DOI
10.1103/physrevd.33.2240

Related papers

Experimental tests of dynamical state-vector reduction

Philip Pearle

We consider theories in which the Schr\"odinger equation is modified so that the reduction of the state vector becomes a dynamical process characterized by a mean reduction time ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{R}$. It is generally believed that such a theory and quantum theory differently predict the outcome of any two experiments performed in rapid enough succession (separated by a time interval $\ensuremath{\lesssim}{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{R}$), such as Papaliolios's successive measurements of a photon's polarization. It is shown that the predictions of a plausible class of dynamical reduction theories (for which the ensemble average of ${|〈{\ensuremath{\varphi}}_{n}|\ensuremath{\psi}〉|}^{2}$ remains constant during the reduction process, where $|\ensuremath{\psi}〉$ is the state vector, and $|{\ensuremath{\varphi}}_{n}〉$ is any one of the basis states to which it may reduce) and quantum theory do not differ for any Papaliolios-type experiment. However, there are deviations from the predictions of quantum theory if the second experiment measures interference between the superposed states created by the first measurement. As an example, the result of a recent two-slit neutron interference experiment by Zeilinger et al. is applied to the theory of Pearle, placing an upper limit ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{R}\ensuremath{\gtrsim}5$ sec on the neutron self-reduction time.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Jan 15, 1984•118 citations

LOCAL CAUSALITY AND THE FOUNDATIONS OF QUANTUM MECHANICS

Robert S. Goldstein

Quantum mechanics implies the existence of correlations which cannot be described by any local theory. These nonlocal correlations possibly suggest the existence of particles traveling faster than light (tachyons). But the potential paradoxes associated with their existence imply that, even i f these tachyons do exist, it should not be possible to control them in a manner necessary for human superluminal (faster than light) communication. Indeed, the unitary nature of the time development operator precludes the possibility of using non-local correlations to communicate superluminally within the quantum formalism. A simplified model which preserves unitary time development i s shown to be useful in studying 'thought experiments' which appear init ially to allow for superluminal communication. The consistency of quantum mechanics is questioned when measurements of retarded fields are considered. I f certain idealized measurements are possible in principle, then the quantum formalism appears inconsistent. I f the measurements are not possible in principle, then 'state reduct ion' (non-unitary time evolution of the state operator) in a pragmatic sense can be said to have occurred. The suggestion that tachyons be used to explain the non-local correlations i s abandoned in favor of another model whose philosophy is supported by the tenets of relativity theory. Such a model may imply the existence of a more general quantum theory where a quantum system itself can be taken as a (generalized) frame of reference.

•Jan 1, 1987•0 citations

Dynamical state reduction in an EPR experiment

Daniel Bedingham

A model is developed to describe state reduction in an EPR experiment as a continuous, relativistically invariant, dynamical process. The system under consideration consists of two entangled isospin particles each of which undergoes isospin measurements at spacelike separated locations. The equations of motion take the form of stochastic differential equations. These equations are solved explicitly in terms of random variables with a priori known probability distribution in the physical probability measure. In the course of solving these equations a correspondence is made between the state reduction process and the problem of classical nonlinear filtering. It is shown that the solution is covariant, violates Bell inequalities and does not permit superluminal signalling. It is demonstrated that the model is not governed by the free will theorem and it is argued that the claims of Conway and Kochen, that there can be no relativistic theory providing a mechanism for state reduction, are false.

arXiv:0907.2327•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Oct 22, 2009•14 citations

Can we make sense out of the measurement process in relativistic quantum mechanics?

Yakir Aharonov, David Z. Albert

We study the instantaneity of the state-reduction process in relativistic quantum mechanics. The conclusion of various authors that this instantaneity will restrict the set of relativistic observables to purely local ones (i.e., that the measurement of any nonlocal property of a system at a well-defined time would give rise to violations of relativistic causality) is found to be erroneous, and experiments (of a kind not encountered before in measurement theory) are described whereby certain nonlocal properties of some simple physical systems can be measured at a well-defined time without violating causality. The attempts of certain authors to reconcile the reduction process with the covariance of the relativistic quantum state are considered and found wanting, and it is argued that the covariance of relativistic quantum theories resides exclusively in the experimental probabilities, and not in the underlying quantum states. The problem of nonlocal measurement is considered in general: distinctions (which are not to be met with in the nonrelativistic case) arise in relativistic quantum mechanics between what can be measured for fermions and what can be measured for bosons, between what can be measured for individual systems and what can be measured for ensembles, and between what kinds of states can be verified by measurement and what kinds of states can be prepared by measurement; and these pose difficult questions about the nature of measurement itself.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Jul 15, 1981•219 citations

Martingale models for quantum state reduction

Stephen L. Adler, Dorje C. Brody, Todd A. Brun +1 more

Stochastic models for quantum state reduction give rise to statistical laws that are in most respects in agreement with those of quantum measurement theory. Here we examine the correspondence of the two theories in detail, making a systematic use of the methods of martingale theory. An analysis is carried out to determine the magnitude of the fluctuations experienced by the expectation of the observable during the course of the reduction process and an upper bound is established for the ensemble average of the greatest fluctuations incurred. We consider the general projection postulate of Lüders applicable in the case of a possibly degenerate eigenvalue spectrum, and derive this result rigorously from the underlying stochastic dynamics for state reduction in the case of both a pure and a mixed initial state. We also analyse the associated Lindblad equation for the evolution of the density matrix, and obtain an exact time-dependent solution for the state reduction that explicitly exhibits the transition from a general initial density matrix to the Lüders density matrix. Finally, we apply Girsanov's theorem to derive a set of simple formulae for the dynamics of the state in terms of a family of geometric Brownian motions, thereby constructing an explicit unravelling of the Lindblad equation.

arXiv:quant-ph/0107153•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Oct 15, 2001•114 citations

Superluminal signaling witness for quantum state reduction

Aritro Mukherjee, Lisa Lenstra, Lotte Mertens +1 more

Models for quantum state reduction address the quantum measurement problem by suggesting weak modifications to Schrödinger's equation that have no observable effect at microscopic scales but dominate the dynamics of macroscopic objects. Enforcing linearity of the master equation for such models has long been used as a way of ensuring that modifications to Schrödinger's equation do not introduce a possibility for superluminal signaling. In large classes of quantum-state-reduction models, however, and in particular in models employing correlated noise, formulating a master equation for the quantum state is prohibitively difficult or impossible. Here, we formulate a witness for superluminal signaling that is applicable to generic quantum-state-reduction models, including those involving correlated as well as uncorrelated noise. Surprisingly, application of the witness to known models described by linear master equations shows that they may still admit superluminal signaling, unless a particular locality condition is obeyed. In contrast, we show that the witness introduced here provides a necessary and sufficient condition for excluding superluminal signals under all circumstances. We further apply the witness to several models driven by physical, correlated noise, for which linear master equations are not analytically obtainable, and find that they allow for superluminal signaling. We suggest how specific correlated-noise models may be able to avoid it and that the witness introduced here provides a stringent guide for constructing such models.

arXiv:2410.08844•Physical Review A•Nov 11, 2025•4 citations
In theories which describe the reduction of the state vector as a physical process, the possibility exists, for certain experiments, of predictions which differ from those of quantum theory. These are interrupted reduction interference'' experiments, characterized by an interaction which triggers the reduction, followed rapidly (before the reduction is completed) by a measurement of interference between the superposed states that make up the state vector (possible examples: double Stern-Gerlach experiment, two-slit neutron interference). We consider the general class of stochastic reduction theories, and ask whether they allow superluminal communication by means of such experiments. We show that, if the state vector that precedes reduction is precisely reproducible, then superluminal communication can occur in certain circumstances, unless the off-diagonal elements of the density matrix decay exponentially, with a universal time constant. We also show, in that case, that no state vector ever reduces in a finite time, so such a theory is not satisfactory. However, superluminal communication can be avoided if reduction is triggered only in irreproducible state vectors, of such complexity that prior to reduction the effective'' density matrix, constructed from the ensemble of such state vectors and traced over the variables outside the experimenter's control, is diagonal. Then predictions are identical to those of quantum theory for interrupted reduction interference'' experiments and thus apparently for all experiments. The lesson of this paper is that the effective'' density matrix must always be used to make physical predictions in dynamical reduction theories. This supplies a resolution of the problem of reconciling state-vector reduction with relativity: even if the reduction dynamics is not relativistically invariant, its experimental predictions are. It also implies that the ``effective'' entropy increases during a measurement, but remains constant during reduction, which is the reverse of a common dictum.
We consider theories in which the Schr\"odinger equation is modified so that the reduction of the state vector becomes a dynamical process characterized by a mean reduction time ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{R}$. It is generally believed that such a theory and quantum theory differently predict the outcome of any two experiments performed in rapid enough succession (separated by a time interval $\ensuremath{\lesssim}{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{R}$), such as Papaliolios's successive measurements of a photon's polarization. It is shown that the predictions of a plausible class of dynamical reduction theories (for which the ensemble average of ${|〈{\ensuremath{\varphi}}_{n}|\ensuremath{\psi}〉|}^{2}$ remains constant during the reduction process, where $|\ensuremath{\psi}〉$ is the state vector, and $|{\ensuremath{\varphi}}_{n}〉$ is any one of the basis states to which it may reduce) and quantum theory do not differ for any Papaliolios-type experiment. However, there are deviations from the predictions of quantum theory if the second experiment measures interference between the superposed states created by the first measurement. As an example, the result of a recent two-slit neutron interference experiment by Zeilinger et al. is applied to the theory of Pearle, placing an upper limit ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{R}\ensuremath{\gtrsim}5$ sec on the neutron self-reduction time.
Quantum mechanics implies the existence of correlations which cannot be described by any local theory. These nonlocal correlations possibly suggest the existence of particles traveling faster than light (tachyons). But the potential paradoxes associated with their existence imply that, even i f these tachyons do exist, it should not be possible to control them in a manner necessary for human superluminal (faster than light) communication. Indeed, the unitary nature of the time development operator precludes the possibility of using non-local correlations to communicate superluminally within the quantum formalism. A simplified model which preserves unitary time development i s shown to be useful in studying 'thought experiments' which appear init ially to allow for superluminal communication. The consistency of quantum mechanics is questioned when measurements of retarded fields are considered. I f certain idealized measurements are possible in principle, then the quantum formalism appears inconsistent. I f the measurements are not possible in principle, then 'state reduct ion' (non-unitary time evolution of the state operator) in a pragmatic sense can be said to have occurred. The suggestion that tachyons be used to explain the non-local correlations i s abandoned in favor of another model whose philosophy is supported by the tenets of relativity theory. Such a model may imply the existence of a more general quantum theory where a quantum system itself can be taken as a (generalized) frame of reference.
A model is developed to describe state reduction in an EPR experiment as a continuous, relativistically invariant, dynamical process. The system under consideration consists of two entangled isospin particles each of which undergoes isospin measurements at spacelike separated locations. The equations of motion take the form of stochastic differential equations. These equations are solved explicitly in terms of random variables with a priori known probability distribution in the physical probability measure. In the course of solving these equations a correspondence is made between the state reduction process and the problem of classical nonlinear filtering. It is shown that the solution is covariant, violates Bell inequalities and does not permit superluminal signalling. It is demonstrated that the model is not governed by the free will theorem and it is argued that the claims of Conway and Kochen, that there can be no relativistic theory providing a mechanism for state reduction, are false.
We study the instantaneity of the state-reduction process in relativistic quantum mechanics. The conclusion of various authors that this instantaneity will restrict the set of relativistic observables to purely local ones (i.e., that the measurement of any nonlocal property of a system at a well-defined time would give rise to violations of relativistic causality) is found to be erroneous, and experiments (of a kind not encountered before in measurement theory) are described whereby certain nonlocal properties of some simple physical systems can be measured at a well-defined time without violating causality. The attempts of certain authors to reconcile the reduction process with the covariance of the relativistic quantum state are considered and found wanting, and it is argued that the covariance of relativistic quantum theories resides exclusively in the experimental probabilities, and not in the underlying quantum states. The problem of nonlocal measurement is considered in general: distinctions (which are not to be met with in the nonrelativistic case) arise in relativistic quantum mechanics between what can be measured for fermions and what can be measured for bosons, between what can be measured for individual systems and what can be measured for ensembles, and between what kinds of states can be verified by measurement and what kinds of states can be prepared by measurement; and these pose difficult questions about the nature of measurement itself.
Stochastic models for quantum state reduction give rise to statistical laws that are in most respects in agreement with those of quantum measurement theory. Here we examine the correspondence of the two theories in detail, making a systematic use of the methods of martingale theory. An analysis is carried out to determine the magnitude of the fluctuations experienced by the expectation of the observable during the course of the reduction process and an upper bound is established for the ensemble average of the greatest fluctuations incurred. We consider the general projection postulate of Lüders applicable in the case of a possibly degenerate eigenvalue spectrum, and derive this result rigorously from the underlying stochastic dynamics for state reduction in the case of both a pure and a mixed initial state. We also analyse the associated Lindblad equation for the evolution of the density matrix, and obtain an exact time-dependent solution for the state reduction that explicitly exhibits the transition from a general initial density matrix to the Lüders density matrix. Finally, we apply Girsanov's theorem to derive a set of simple formulae for the dynamics of the state in terms of a family of geometric Brownian motions, thereby constructing an explicit unravelling of the Lindblad equation.
Models for quantum state reduction address the quantum measurement problem by suggesting weak modifications to Schrödinger's equation that have no observable effect at microscopic scales but dominate the dynamics of macroscopic objects. Enforcing linearity of the master equation for such models has long been used as a way of ensuring that modifications to Schrödinger's equation do not introduce a possibility for superluminal signaling. In large classes of quantum-state-reduction models, however, and in particular in models employing correlated noise, formulating a master equation for the quantum state is prohibitively difficult or impossible. Here, we formulate a witness for superluminal signaling that is applicable to generic quantum-state-reduction models, including those involving correlated as well as uncorrelated noise. Surprisingly, application of the witness to known models described by linear master equations shows that they may still admit superluminal signaling, unless a particular locality condition is obeyed. In contrast, we show that the witness introduced here provides a necessary and sufficient condition for excluding superluminal signals under all circumstances. We further apply the witness to several models driven by physical, correlated noise, for which linear master equations are not analytically obtainable, and find that they allow for superluminal signaling. We suggest how specific correlated-noise models may be able to avoid it and that the witness introduced here provides a stringent guide for constructing such models.