Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics Conference Series

Quantum zeno paradox: Survival and decay

Charles B. Chiu

Published Nov 1, 2009• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Quantum mechanics enables the calculation of the time evolution of a dynamical system provided the Hamiltonian is defined and the initial state is specified. Due to the time reversal invariance, the time evolution of a given initial state at t=0 does not have a time-arrow. These problems have been extensively studied by E. C. G. Sudarshan and collaborators, including myself. Here the survival probability, which is the square of the survival amplitude, is an even function of t. Using the survival amplitude as a common framework, we discuss Zeno effects in several processes: the decay of an unstable particle, pion productions in proton-nucleus collisions and the Aharonov-Vardi effect which is another manifestation of the Zeno effect.

DOI
10.1088/1742-6596/196/1/012019

Related papers

Understanding the quantum Zeno effect

Hiromichi Nakazato, Mikio Namiki, Saverio Pascazio +1 more

The quantum Zeno effect consists in the hindrance of the evolution of a quantum system that is very frequently monitored and found to be in its initial state at every single measurement. On the basis of the correct formula for the survival probability, i.e. the probability of finding the system in its initial state at every single measurement, we critically analyze a recent proposal and experimental test, that make use of an oscillating system. PACS: 03.65.Bz, 42.50.-p 1 The seminal formulation of the quantum Zeno effect, due to Misra and Sudarshan [1], deals with the probability of observing an unstable system in its initial state throughout a time interval ∆ = [0, t]. The purpose of this note is to point out that the quantum Zeno effect has not been experimentally observed, yet, in its original formulation. Indeed, we shall argue that the interesting proposal by Cook [2], that makes use of a two-level system undergoing Rabi oscillations, as well as the beautiful experiment performed by Itano et al. [3], investigate the probability of finding the

•May 13, 1996•35 citations

TEMPORAL BEHAVIOR OF QUANTUM MECHANICAL SYSTEMS

Hiromichi Nakazato, Mikio Namiki, Saverio Pascazio

The temporal behavior of quantum mechanical systems is reviewed. We mainly focus our attention on the time development of the so-called “survival” probability of those systems that are initially prepared in eigenstates of the unperturbed Hamiltonian, by assuming that the latter has a continuous spectrum. The exponential decay of the survival probability, familiar, for example, in radioactive decay phenomena, is representative of a purely probabilistic character of the system under consideration and is naturally expected to lead to a master equation. This behavior, however, can be found only at intermediate times, for deviations from it exist both at short and long times and can have significant consequences. After a short introduction to the long history of the research on the temporal behavior of such quantum mechanical systems, the short-time behavior and its controversial consequences when it is combined with von Neumann’s projection postulate in quantum measurement theory are critically overviewed from a dynamical point of view. We also discuss the so-called quantum Zeno effect from this standpoint. The behavior of the survival amplitude is then scrutinized by investigating the analytic properties of its Fourier and Laplace transforms. The analytic property that there is no singularity except a branch cut running along the real energy axis in the first Riemannian sheet is an important reflection of the time-reversal invariance of the dynamics governing the whole process. It is shown that the exponential behavior is due to the presence of a simple pole in the second Riemannian sheet, while the contribution of the branch point yields a power behavior for the amplitude. The exponential decay form is cancelled at short times and dominated at very long times by the branch-point contributions, which give a Gaussian behavior for the former and a power behavior for the latter. In order to realize the exponential law in quantum theory, it is essential to take into account a certain kind of macroscopic nature of the total system, since the exponential behavior is regarded as a manifestation of a complete loss of coherence of the quantum subsystem under consideration. In this respect, a few attempts at extracting the exponential decay form on the basis of quantum theory, aiming at the master equation, are briefly reviewed, including van Hove’s pioneering work and his well-known “λ2T” limit. In the attempt to further clarify the mechanism of the appearance of a purely probabilistic behavior without resort to any approximation, a solvable dynamical model is presented and extensively studied. The model describes an ultrarelativistic particle interacting with N two-level systems (called “spins”) and is shown to exhibit an exponential behavior at all times in the weak-coupling, macroscopic limit. Furthermore, it is shown that the model can even reproduce the short-time Gaussian behavior followed by the exponential law when an appropriate initial state is chosen. The analysis is exact and no approximation is involved. An interpretation for the change of the temporal behavior in quantum systems is drawn from the results obtained. Some implications for the quantum measurement problem are also discussed, in particular in connection with dissipation.

arXiv:quant-ph/9509016•International Journal of Modern Physics B•Jan 30, 1996•203 citations

Time evolution of unstable quantum states and a resolution of Zeno's paradox

Charles B. Chiu, E. C. G. Sudarshan, Baidyanath Misra

The time evolution of quantum states for unstable particles can be conveniently divided into three domains: the very short time where Zeno's paradox is relevant, the intermediate interval where the exponential decay holds more or less, and the very long time where the decay is governed by a power law. In this work, we reexamine several questions relating to the deviations from the simple exponential decay law. On the basis of general considerations, we demonstrate that deviations from exponential decay near $t=0$ are inevitable. We formulate general resonance models for the decay. From analytic solutions to specific narrow-width models, we estimate the time parameters ${T}_{1}$ and ${T}_{2}$ separating the three domains. The parameter ${T}_{1}$ is found to be much much less than the lifetime ${\ensuremath{\Gamma}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$, while ${T}_{2}$ is much greater than the lifetime. For instance, for the charged pion decay, ${T}_{1}\ensuremath{\sim}\frac{{10}^{\ensuremath{-}14}}{\ensuremath{\Gamma}}$ and ${T}_{2}\ensuremath{\sim}\frac{190}{\ensuremath{\Gamma}}$. A resolution of Zeno's paradox provided by the present consideration and its limitaions are discussed.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Jul 15, 1977•341 citations

True quantum face of the “exponential” decay law

K. Urbanowski

Results of theoretical studies of the quantum unstable systems caused that there are rather widespread belief that a universal feature of the quantum decay process is the presence of three time regimes of the decay process: the early time (initial) leading to the Quantum Zeno (or Anti Zeno) Effects, “exponential” (or “canonical”) described by the decay law of the exponential form, and late time characterized by the decay law having inverse-power law form. Based on the fundamental principles of the quantum theory we give the proof that there is no time interval in which the survival probability (decay law) could be a decreasing function of time of the purely exponential form but even at the “exponential” regime the decay curve is oscillatory modulated with a smaller or a large amplitude of oscillations depending on parameters of the model considered.

arXiv:1606.07301•The European Physical Journal D•May 1, 2017•10 citations

Real measurements and the quantum Zeno effect

Julius Ruseckas, B. Kaulakys

In 1977, Mishra and Sudarshan [J. Math. Phys. 18, 756 (1977)] showed that an unstable particle would never be found decayed while it was continuously observed. They called this effect the quantum Zeno effect (or paradox). Later it was realized that the frequent measurements could also accelerate the decay (quantum anti-Zeno effect). In this paper, we investigate the quantum Zeno effect using the definite model of the measurement. We take into account the finite duration and the finite accuracy of the measurement. A general equation for the jump probability during the measurement is derived. We find that the measurements can cause inhibition (quantum Zeno effect) or acceleration (quantum anti-Zeno effect) of the evolution, depending on the strength of the interaction with the measuring device and on the properties of the system. However, the evolution cannot be fully stopped.

arXiv:quant-ph/0105138•Physical Review A•May 8, 2001•20 citations

The Zeno’s paradox in quantum theory

Baidyanath Misra, E. C. G. Sudarshan

We seek a quantum-theoretic expression for the probability that an unstable particle prepared initially in a well defined state ρ will be found to decay sometime during a given interval. It is argued that probabilities like this which pertain to continuous monitoring possess operational meaning. A simple natural approach to this problem leads to the conclusion that an unstable particle which is continuously observed to see whether it decays will never be found to decay!. Since recording the track of an unstable particle (which can be distinguished from its decay products) approximately realizes such continuous observations, the above conclusion seems to pose a paradox which we call Zeno’s paradox in quantum theory. The relation of this result to that of some previous works and its implications and possible resolutions are briefly discussed. The mathematical transcription of the above-mentioned conclusion is a structure theorem concerning semigroups. Although special cases of this theorem are known, the general formulation and the proof given here are believed to be new. We also note that the known ’’no-go’’ theorem concerning the semigroup law for the reduced evolution of any physical system (including decaying systems) is subsumed under our theorem as a direct corollary.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Apr 1, 1977•2,299 citations
Quantum mechanics enables the calculation of the time evolution of a dynamical system provided the Hamiltonian is defined and the initial state is specified. Due to the time reversal invariance, the time evolution of a given initial state at t=0 does not have a time-arrow. These problems have been extensively studied by E. C. G. Sudarshan and collaborators, including myself. Here the survival probability, which is the square of the survival amplitude, is an even function of t. Using the survival amplitude as a common framework, we discuss Zeno effects in several processes: the decay of an unstable particle, pion productions in proton-nucleus collisions and the Aharonov-Vardi effect which is another manifestation of the Zeno effect.
The quantum Zeno effect consists in the hindrance of the evolution of a quantum system that is very frequently monitored and found to be in its initial state at every single measurement. On the basis of the correct formula for the survival probability, i.e. the probability of finding the system in its initial state at every single measurement, we critically analyze a recent proposal and experimental test, that make use of an oscillating system. PACS: 03.65.Bz, 42.50.-p 1 The seminal formulation of the quantum Zeno effect, due to Misra and Sudarshan [1], deals with the probability of observing an unstable system in its initial state throughout a time interval ∆ = [0, t]. The purpose of this note is to point out that the quantum Zeno effect has not been experimentally observed, yet, in its original formulation. Indeed, we shall argue that the interesting proposal by Cook [2], that makes use of a two-level system undergoing Rabi oscillations, as well as the beautiful experiment performed by Itano et al. [3], investigate the probability of finding the
The temporal behavior of quantum mechanical systems is reviewed. We mainly focus our attention on the time development of the so-called “survival” probability of those systems that are initially prepared in eigenstates of the unperturbed Hamiltonian, by assuming that the latter has a continuous spectrum. The exponential decay of the survival probability, familiar, for example, in radioactive decay phenomena, is representative of a purely probabilistic character of the system under consideration and is naturally expected to lead to a master equation. This behavior, however, can be found only at intermediate times, for deviations from it exist both at short and long times and can have significant consequences. After a short introduction to the long history of the research on the temporal behavior of such quantum mechanical systems, the short-time behavior and its controversial consequences when it is combined with von Neumann’s projection postulate in quantum measurement theory are critically overviewed from a dynamical point of view. We also discuss the so-called quantum Zeno effect from this standpoint. The behavior of the survival amplitude is then scrutinized by investigating the analytic properties of its Fourier and Laplace transforms. The analytic property that there is no singularity except a branch cut running along the real energy axis in the first Riemannian sheet is an important reflection of the time-reversal invariance of the dynamics governing the whole process. It is shown that the exponential behavior is due to the presence of a simple pole in the second Riemannian sheet, while the contribution of the branch point yields a power behavior for the amplitude. The exponential decay form is cancelled at short times and dominated at very long times by the branch-point contributions, which give a Gaussian behavior for the former and a power behavior for the latter. In order to realize the exponential law in quantum theory, it is essential to take into account a certain kind of macroscopic nature of the total system, since the exponential behavior is regarded as a manifestation of a complete loss of coherence of the quantum subsystem under consideration. In this respect, a few attempts at extracting the exponential decay form on the basis of quantum theory, aiming at the master equation, are briefly reviewed, including van Hove’s pioneering work and his well-known “λ2T” limit. In the attempt to further clarify the mechanism of the appearance of a purely probabilistic behavior without resort to any approximation, a solvable dynamical model is presented and extensively studied. The model describes an ultrarelativistic particle interacting with N two-level systems (called “spins”) and is shown to exhibit an exponential behavior at all times in the weak-coupling, macroscopic limit. Furthermore, it is shown that the model can even reproduce the short-time Gaussian behavior followed by the exponential law when an appropriate initial state is chosen. The analysis is exact and no approximation is involved. An interpretation for the change of the temporal behavior in quantum systems is drawn from the results obtained. Some implications for the quantum measurement problem are also discussed, in particular in connection with dissipation.
The time evolution of quantum states for unstable particles can be conveniently divided into three domains: the very short time where Zeno's paradox is relevant, the intermediate interval where the exponential decay holds more or less, and the very long time where the decay is governed by a power law. In this work, we reexamine several questions relating to the deviations from the simple exponential decay law. On the basis of general considerations, we demonstrate that deviations from exponential decay near t=0t=0t=0 are inevitable. We formulate general resonance models for the decay. From analytic solutions to specific narrow-width models, we estimate the time parameters T1{T}_{1}T1​ and T2{T}_{2}T2​ separating the three domains. The parameter T1{T}_{1}T1​ is found to be much much less than the lifetime ${\ensuremath{\Gamma}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$, while T2{T}_{2}T2​ is much greater than the lifetime. For instance, for the charged pion decay, ${T}_{1}\ensuremath{\sim}\frac{{10}^{\ensuremath{-}14}}{\ensuremath{\Gamma}}$ and ${T}_{2}\ensuremath{\sim}\frac{190}{\ensuremath{\Gamma}}$. A resolution of Zeno's paradox provided by the present consideration and its limitaions are discussed.
Results of theoretical studies of the quantum unstable systems caused that there are rather widespread belief that a universal feature of the quantum decay process is the presence of three time regimes of the decay process: the early time (initial) leading to the Quantum Zeno (or Anti Zeno) Effects, “exponential” (or “canonical”) described by the decay law of the exponential form, and late time characterized by the decay law having inverse-power law form. Based on the fundamental principles of the quantum theory we give the proof that there is no time interval in which the survival probability (decay law) could be a decreasing function of time of the purely exponential form but even at the “exponential” regime the decay curve is oscillatory modulated with a smaller or a large amplitude of oscillations depending on parameters of the model considered.
In 1977, Mishra and Sudarshan [J. Math. Phys. 18, 756 (1977)] showed that an unstable particle would never be found decayed while it was continuously observed. They called this effect the quantum Zeno effect (or paradox). Later it was realized that the frequent measurements could also accelerate the decay (quantum anti-Zeno effect). In this paper, we investigate the quantum Zeno effect using the definite model of the measurement. We take into account the finite duration and the finite accuracy of the measurement. A general equation for the jump probability during the measurement is derived. We find that the measurements can cause inhibition (quantum Zeno effect) or acceleration (quantum anti-Zeno effect) of the evolution, depending on the strength of the interaction with the measuring device and on the properties of the system. However, the evolution cannot be fully stopped.
We seek a quantum-theoretic expression for the probability that an unstable particle prepared initially in a well defined state ρ will be found to decay sometime during a given interval. It is argued that probabilities like this which pertain to continuous monitoring possess operational meaning. A simple natural approach to this problem leads to the conclusion that an unstable particle which is continuously observed to see whether it decays will never be found to decay!. Since recording the track of an unstable particle (which can be distinguished from its decay products) approximately realizes such continuous observations, the above conclusion seems to pose a paradox which we call Zeno’s paradox in quantum theory. The relation of this result to that of some previous works and its implications and possible resolutions are briefly discussed. The mathematical transcription of the above-mentioned conclusion is a structure theorem concerning semigroups. Although special cases of this theorem are known, the general formulation and the proof given here are believed to be new. We also note that the known ’’no-go’’ theorem concerning the semigroup law for the reduced evolution of any physical system (including decaying systems) is subsumed under our theorem as a direct corollary.