Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General

Comment on `Semiclassical dynamics of a spin-½ in an arbitrary magnetic field'

E. A. Kochetov

Published May 3, 2000• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

In a recent paper Alscher and Grabert claim to prove that a dominant (tree-level) stationary phase approximation to the Wiener regularized continuum su(2) coherent-state path integral for the quantum propagator : = ⟨zF | T exp (-i∫0τH ds ) | zI⟩ becomes exact, provided H is a linear combination of the su(2) generators with arbitrary time-dependent coefficients. I find the derivation of this in fact obvious result unduly complicated and somewhat obscure. The authors start from a classical spin action inconsistent with necessary boundary conditions and therefore are forced to invoke a nontrivial regularization of the action to render the latter meaningful. Alternatively, when a su(2) symplectic potential consistent with the boundary conditions is employed, no regularization is required to obtain the leading quasiclassical asymptotics.

DOI
10.1088/0305-4470/33/17/4n1

Related papers

Semiclassical dynamics of a spin-½ in an arbitrary magnetic field

Adrian Alscher, Hermann Grabert

The spin coherent state path integral describing the dynamics of a spin-½ system in a magnetic field of arbitrary time dependence is considered. Defining the path integral as the limit of a Wiener regularized expression, the semiclassical approximation leads to a continuous minimal action path with jumps at the endpoints. The resulting semiclassical propagator is shown to coincide with the exact quantum mechanical propagator. A nonlinear transformation of the angle variables allows for a determination of the semiclassical path and the jumps without solving a boundary-value problem. The semiclassical spin dynamics is thus readily amenable to numerical methods.

arXiv:quant-ph/9904102•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Jan 1, 1999•19 citations

Coherent states, path integral, and semiclassical approximation

Kunio Funahashi, Tarō Kashiwa, Seiji Sakoda +1 more

Using the generalized coherent states it is shown that the path integral formulas for SU(2) and SU(1,1) (in the discrete series) are WKB exact, if it is started from the trace of e−iTĤ, where Ĥ is given by a linear combination of generators. In this case, the WKB approximation is achieved by taking a large ‘‘spin’’ limit: J,K→∞, under which it is found that each coefficient vanishes except the leading term which indeed gives the exact result. It is further pointed out that the discretized form of path integral is indispensable, in other words, the continuum path integral expression sometimes leads to a wrong result. Therefore great care must be taken when some geometrical action would be adopted, even if it is so beautiful as the starting ingredient of path integral. Discussions on generalized coherent states are also presented both from geometrical and simple oscillator (Schwinger boson) points of view.

arXiv:hep-th/9409116•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Jul 1, 1995•50 citations

On the stationary phase evaluation of path integrals in the coherent states representation

Yitzhak Weissman

The extremal paths that arise in the stationary phase evaluation of coherent state path integrals do not seem to have a simple physical interpretation, in contrast to the extremal paths that occur in the conventional path integrals. On the other hand, a recently derived semiclassical formula for the coherent state propagator involves a path that is determined in exactly the same manner as the extremal paths of the conventional path integrals. Since both the semiclassical and the stationary phase analyses yield asymptotic (h(cross) to 0) approximations, the stationary phase and the semiclassical expressions for the propagator should be identical. The author presents a simple and direct proof that, in spite of the apparent differences, this is indeed the case. The simplification in the semiclassical formula is due to the utilisation of an appropriate set of canonical variables to describe the classical dynamics. In order to illustrate the usefulness of the semiclassical formula they present an application to the problem of the degenerate parametric amplifier, which had been treated before by operator ordering and path integral methods. The semiclassical approach has a simple classical interpretation that is absent in the alternative treatments.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Aug 21, 1983•36 citations

Semiclassical propagators for quantum coherent states and applications of extra quantum phase to large-spin tunneling of magnetic molecules

Kee-Su Park

A continuous path integral is used to obtain the semiclassical expressions of quantum propagators by means of coherent states in the holomorphic representation together with the appropriate boundary conditions. It allows us to express the total actions including boundary terms, classical trajectories, and extra phases in the stationary phase approximation. In particular, in the semiclassical expression for the quantum spin propagator, we pay attention to the extra quantum phase discovered by Solari and Kochetov. It is shown that this extra phase is related to an anomaly in the fluctuation determinant. It is verified that once this extra phase is included, the semiclassical propagator leads to the correct short time behaviour to O(T²), and shows its consistency under dissection of the path. In the application to the instanton methods, the extra quantum phase yields the correct formula for the tunnel splitting including both the exponential factor and the prefactor. The quantum phase leads to the correct spectrum with a shift of the spin quantum number by 1/2. We apply the semiclassical propagators and the tunnel splitting to a few models in magnetic molecular systems. It is shown that the formula gives the correct exponential factor and prefactors for quantum tunneling of a large spin if the extra quantum phase is taken into account.

•Jan 1, 2001•0 citations

SU(2) coherent-state path integral

E. A. Kochetov

The SU(2) coherent-state path integral is used to represent the matrix element of a propagator in the SU(2) coherent-state basis. It is argued that the continuum representation of this integral is correct provided the necessary boundary term is taken into account. In the case of the SU(2) dynamical symmetry the path integral is explicitly computed by means of a change of variables, the SU(2) motion of the underlying phase space. The correct stationary-phase expansion for the propagator in terms of the total action including boundary term and classical trajectories is obtained.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Sep 1, 1995•79 citations

Semiclassical coherent-states propagator

Alejandro M. F. Rivas

In this work, we derived a semiclassical approximation for the matrix elements of a quantum propagator in coherent states (CS) basis that avoids complex trajectories; it only involves real ones. For that purpose, we used the symplectically invariant semiclassical Weyl propagator obtained by performing a stationary phase approximation (SPA) for the path integral in the Weyl representation. After that, for the transformation to CS representation SPA is avoided; instead a quadratic expansion of the complex exponent is used. This procedure also allows us to express the semiclassical CS propagator uniquely in terms of the classical evolution of the initial point without the need of any root search typical of van Vleck--Gutzwiller-based propagators. For the case of chaotic Hamiltonian systems, the explicit time dependence of the CS propagator has been obtained. The comparison with a realistic chaotic system that derives from a quadratic Hamiltonian, the cat map, reveals that the expression here derived is exact up to quadratic Hamiltonian systems.

arXiv:1207.0012•Physical Review A•Jul 8, 2013•3 citations
In a recent paper Alscher and Grabert claim to prove that a dominant (tree-level) stationary phase approximation to the Wiener regularized continuum su(2) coherent-state path integral for the quantum propagator : = ⟨zF | T exp (-i∫0τH ds ) | zI⟩ becomes exact, provided H is a linear combination of the su(2) generators with arbitrary time-dependent coefficients. I find the derivation of this in fact obvious result unduly complicated and somewhat obscure. The authors start from a classical spin action inconsistent with necessary boundary conditions and therefore are forced to invoke a nontrivial regularization of the action to render the latter meaningful. Alternatively, when a su(2) symplectic potential consistent with the boundary conditions is employed, no regularization is required to obtain the leading quasiclassical asymptotics.
The spin coherent state path integral describing the dynamics of a spin-½ system in a magnetic field of arbitrary time dependence is considered. Defining the path integral as the limit of a Wiener regularized expression, the semiclassical approximation leads to a continuous minimal action path with jumps at the endpoints. The resulting semiclassical propagator is shown to coincide with the exact quantum mechanical propagator. A nonlinear transformation of the angle variables allows for a determination of the semiclassical path and the jumps without solving a boundary-value problem. The semiclassical spin dynamics is thus readily amenable to numerical methods.
Using the generalized coherent states it is shown that the path integral formulas for SU(2) and SU(1,1) (in the discrete series) are WKB exact, if it is started from the trace of e−iTĤ, where Ĥ is given by a linear combination of generators. In this case, the WKB approximation is achieved by taking a large ‘‘spin’’ limit: J,K→∞, under which it is found that each coefficient vanishes except the leading term which indeed gives the exact result. It is further pointed out that the discretized form of path integral is indispensable, in other words, the continuum path integral expression sometimes leads to a wrong result. Therefore great care must be taken when some geometrical action would be adopted, even if it is so beautiful as the starting ingredient of path integral. Discussions on generalized coherent states are also presented both from geometrical and simple oscillator (Schwinger boson) points of view.
The extremal paths that arise in the stationary phase evaluation of coherent state path integrals do not seem to have a simple physical interpretation, in contrast to the extremal paths that occur in the conventional path integrals. On the other hand, a recently derived semiclassical formula for the coherent state propagator involves a path that is determined in exactly the same manner as the extremal paths of the conventional path integrals. Since both the semiclassical and the stationary phase analyses yield asymptotic (h(cross) to 0) approximations, the stationary phase and the semiclassical expressions for the propagator should be identical. The author presents a simple and direct proof that, in spite of the apparent differences, this is indeed the case. The simplification in the semiclassical formula is due to the utilisation of an appropriate set of canonical variables to describe the classical dynamics. In order to illustrate the usefulness of the semiclassical formula they present an application to the problem of the degenerate parametric amplifier, which had been treated before by operator ordering and path integral methods. The semiclassical approach has a simple classical interpretation that is absent in the alternative treatments.
A continuous path integral is used to obtain the semiclassical expressions of quantum propagators by means of coherent states in the holomorphic representation together with the appropriate boundary conditions. It allows us to express the total actions including boundary terms, classical trajectories, and extra phases in the stationary phase approximation. In particular, in the semiclassical expression for the quantum spin propagator, we pay attention to the extra quantum phase discovered by Solari and Kochetov. It is shown that this extra phase is related to an anomaly in the fluctuation determinant. It is verified that once this extra phase is included, the semiclassical propagator leads to the correct short time behaviour to O(T²), and shows its consistency under dissection of the path. In the application to the instanton methods, the extra quantum phase yields the correct formula for the tunnel splitting including both the exponential factor and the prefactor. The quantum phase leads to the correct spectrum with a shift of the spin quantum number by 1/2. We apply the semiclassical propagators and the tunnel splitting to a few models in magnetic molecular systems. It is shown that the formula gives the correct exponential factor and prefactors for quantum tunneling of a large spin if the extra quantum phase is taken into account.
The SU(2) coherent-state path integral is used to represent the matrix element of a propagator in the SU(2) coherent-state basis. It is argued that the continuum representation of this integral is correct provided the necessary boundary term is taken into account. In the case of the SU(2) dynamical symmetry the path integral is explicitly computed by means of a change of variables, the SU(2) motion of the underlying phase space. The correct stationary-phase expansion for the propagator in terms of the total action including boundary term and classical trajectories is obtained.
In this work, we derived a semiclassical approximation for the matrix elements of a quantum propagator in coherent states (CS) basis that avoids complex trajectories; it only involves real ones. For that purpose, we used the symplectically invariant semiclassical Weyl propagator obtained by performing a stationary phase approximation (SPA) for the path integral in the Weyl representation. After that, for the transformation to CS representation SPA is avoided; instead a quadratic expansion of the complex exponent is used. This procedure also allows us to express the semiclassical CS propagator uniquely in terms of the classical evolution of the initial point without the need of any root search typical of van Vleck--Gutzwiller-based propagators. For the case of chaotic Hamiltonian systems, the explicit time dependence of the CS propagator has been obtained. The comparison with a realistic chaotic system that derives from a quadratic Hamiltonian, the cat map, reveals that the expression here derived is exact up to quadratic Hamiltonian systems.