We show that the wave functions that describe the ground states of putative p-wave-paired phases in quantum Hall bilayers, like the Pfaffian at νT = 1/2 or the paired phase at νT = 1, are more likely to describe the excited states of Fermi liquids at these filling factors. We point out to the close competition between Fermi liquid and paired phases, which leads to the conclusion that in the experiments only direct transitions from the correlated 111 and 331 states into Fermi liquid(s) are likely to be observed.
The phase diagram of a quantum Hall bilayer at total filling ν = 1 contains an incompressible superfluid for small distances d between the layers, as well as the compressible phase corresponding to two uncoupled Fermi liquids for large d. Using exact diagonalization on the sphere and torus geometry, we investigate a long-standing question of the nature of the transition between the two regimes, and the possibility for the existence of a paired phase in the transition region. We find considerable evidence for a direct transition between the superfluid and the Fermi liquid phase, based in particular on the behavior of the ground state energy on the sphere (including appropriate finite-size corrections) as a function of d. At the critical distance dC ≈ 11.6ℓB the topological number ("shift") of the ground state changes, suggesting that tuning the layer separation d in experiment likely leads to a direct transition between the superfluid and the Fermi liquid phase.
The Quantum Hall Bilayers (QHB) at filling factor $\ensuremath{\nu}=1$ represents a competition between Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) at small distances between layers and fermionic condensation, whose influence grows with distance and results in two separate Fermi liquid states for the underlying quasiparticles at very large (or infinite) distances. The question that can be raised is whether, at intermediate distances between layers, a distinct phase exists or if a singular transition occurs, with the possibility that this happens at infinite distances. Here, using a dipole representation for fermionic quasiparticles, we find support for the latter scenario: Within a large and relevant range of distances, BEC condensation, identified as Cooper
s-wave pairing of dipole quasiparticles, prevails over both Cooper
p-wave pairing and
s-wave excitonic pairing of the same quasiparticles.
We discuss monolayer and bilayer quantum Hall systems in which each layer is a half-filled Landau level (LL) system. In the mean field approximation of the Son's formalism, there is a common pairing structure that underlines the possibilities for paired ground states in both systems. We argue that the particle-hole (PH) Pfaffian state in the (particle-hole symmetric) half-filled LL of a monolayer, and analogous state in the PH symmetric bilayer (in which each layer is half-filled LL) can be considered as critical states, i.e., states that cannot describe a phase under PH symmetry. We point out that the inclusion of a PH symmetry breaking (like LL mixing) may stabilize the PH Pfaffian in a monolayer. In the bilayer case, in numerical experiments on a sphere, by choosing the PH symmetric shift, we can stabilize the interlayer correlated (111) excitonic state or critical state, for any distance between the layers, but in general, with no bias, the evolution of the bilayer includes other phases.
One of the most dominant candidates for the paired quantum Hall (QH) state at filling factor $\ensuremath{\nu}=5/2$ is the Moore-Read (MR) Pfaffian state. A salient problem, however, is that it does not occur exactly at the Coulomb interaction, but rather at a modified interaction, which favors particle-hole-symmetry breaking. In an effort to find a better state, in this work, we investigate the possible connection between the paired QH state and the antisymmetrized bilayer ground state, which is inspired by the intriguing identity that the MR Pfaffian state is entirely equivalent to the antisymmetrized projection of the bilayer QH state called the Halperin (331) state, which is valid at interlayer distance,
d, roughly equal to the magnetic length,
lB. Specifically, by using exact diagonalization in the torus geometry, we show that the exact
5/2 state at a given Haldane pseudopotential variation is intimately connected with the antisymmetrized bilayer ground state at a corresponding
d/lB via one-to-one mapping, which we call the bilayer mapping. One of the most important discoveries in this work is that the paired QH state occurring at the Coulomb interaction is mapped onto the antisymmetrized bilayer ground state at $d\ensuremath{\gg}{l}_{\mathrm{B}}$, which is equivalent to the antisymmetrized product state of two composite fermion seas at quarter filling, not the MR Pfaffian state. While maintaining high overlap with the paired QH state, the antisymmetrized bilayer ground state at $d\ensuremath{\gg}{l}_{\mathrm{B}}$ exhibits an abrupt change under the influence of small anisotropy. This suggests that the paired QH state occurring at the Coulomb interaction might be susceptible to anisotropic instability, opening up the possibility of anisotropic
px- or
py-wave pairing instead of ${p}_{x}\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}i{p}_{y}$-wave pairing in the MR Pfaffian/anti-Pfaffian state.