Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Soviet Physics Uspekhi

WHY IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO INTRODUCE HIDDEN PARAMETERS INTO QUANTUM MECHANICS

Alexander I. Akhiezer, R.V. Polovin

Published Apr 30, 1973• 10 citations
Publisher

Abstract

CONTENTS 1. The Statistical Character of the Behavior of Microobjects 500 2. The Mathematical Foundations of Quantum Mechanics 501 3. The Measurement Process 502 4. The Hypothesis of Parameters 503 5. Interference of Probabilities and Hidden Parameters 505 6. Von Neumann's Proof of von Neumann's Theorem 507 7. A Proof of von Neumann's Theorem which does not use the Postulate of Additivity of Incompatible Observables 508 8. Classical and Quantum Logic 509 References 511

DOI
10.1070/pu1973v015n04abeh004999

Related papers

Hidden Variables in Quantum Mechanics

I. I. Zinnes

The hidden variable theorem due to von Neumann is deduced in a physically transparent manner. As a result it is clear that the theorem is correct only if one requires that these hidden variables merely enlarge the set of observables employed at present in quantum mechanics. The theorem cannot be interpreted to mean that one cannot introduce such additional variables in order (1) to specify a state with classical completeness and (2) to define the usual observables as statistical parameters.

American Journal of Physics•Jan 1, 1958•5 citations

Von Neumann's Hidden-Parameter Proof

James S. Albertson

Because the mathematical form of von Neumann's hidden-parameter proof is not well known, its scope has sometimes been unjustifiably narrowed by commentators. The proof is here reproduced in the more familiar Dirac calculus and its precise import made clearer. In particular, it is emphasized that the proof proceeds independently of both the basic statistical assumption of quantum mechanics: 〈R〉av = 〈φ|R|φ〉, and the extension of this assumption to mixtures: 〈R〉av = Tr(UR), where U = Σn|φn〉wn〈φn|. Mention is also made of some recent criticisms of the von Neumann proof.

American Journal of Physics•Aug 1, 1961•18 citations

Quantum mechanics with the permitted hidden parameters

D. A. Slavnov

Within the framework of the algebraic approach the problem of hidden parameters in quantum mechanics is surveyed. It is shown that the algebraic formulation of quantum mechanics permits introduction of a specific hidden parameter, which has the form of nonlinear functional on the algebra of observables. It is found out that the reasoning of von Neumann and of Bell about incompatibility of quantum mechanics with hidden parameters is inapplicable to the present case.

arXiv:quant-ph/0010069•Oct 19, 2000•2 citations

A retrospective review of von Neumann’s analysis of hidden variables in quantum mechanics

Robert Golub, S. K. Lamoreaux

This article reviews the history of J. von Neumann’s analysis of hidden variables in quantum mechanics and the subsequent analysis by others. In his book The Mathematical Foundations of Quantum Mechanics, published in 1932, von Neumann performed an analysis of the consequences of introducing hidden parameters (hidden variables) into quantum mechanics. He arrived at two principal conclusions: first, hidden variables cannot be incorporated into the existing theory of quantum mechanics without major modifications, and second, if they did exist, the theory would have already failed in situations where it has been successfully applied. This analysis has been taken as an “incorrect proof” against the existence of hidden variables, possibly due to a mistranslation of the German word prufen. von Neumann’s so-called proof isn’t even wrong as such a proof does not exist, but it is an examination of the limitations imposed by internal consistency of the Hilbert space formulation of the theory. One of the earliest attempts to eliminate uncertainty, by D. Bohm, requires a major modification of quantum mechanics (observables are not represented by Hermitian operators), which supports von Neumann’s first principal conclusion. However, testing the Bohm theory requires constructing a physically impossible initial state. As such, the theory has no experimental consequences, so W. Pauli referred to it as an “uncashable check”. As there are no observable consequences, the Bohm theory is possibly a counterexample to von Neumann’s second conclusion that hidden variables in particular would have already led to a failure of the theory.

Academia quantum.•Aug 26, 2024•8 citations

About Hidden Variables

J. C. Aron

The problem of hidden variables, purely conceptual at the start, has been early influenced by the practical aims of “causal theories” towards a mathematical scheme broader than the quantum formalism. Thus several authors have examined if a new formalism, built in the same spirit as that of quantum mechanics, however more general, might admit a determination by means of hidden parameters, and concluded negatively. In the present paper the two aspects (conceptual and practical) are considered separately. It first contains a study of the unrestricted proofs (Von Neumann, Jauch and Piron), given for the non-existence of hidden parameters. They are focussed on the dispersion-free states bound to them. Thus a preliminary stage consists in analyzing what properties these states should have. A method is given here for displaying these; they are shown to have an artificial character, which fits neither Von Neumann's proof nor that of Jauch and Piron and other authors (Misra). Thus, these proofs do not establish the inexistence of hidden variables, but only that of dispersion free states built more or less on the pattern of the quantum states. Suggestions are then proposed on the probable features of hidden parameters. They lead us to regard as improbable the hope of building a new deterministic scheme to be substituted for the quantum formalism. Thus, the determinism which can be maintained appears as purely conceptual. The question of a “deeper level” and the relation between determination and pictorial description are discussed briefly.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Sep 1, 1969•2 citations

Hidden Variables: Rehabilitation of von Neumann's Analysis, and Pauli's Uncashable Check

Robert Golub, S. K. Lamoreaux

In his book \textit{The Mathematical Foundations of Quantum Mechanics}, published in 1932, J. von Neumann performed an analysis of the consequences of introducing hidden parameters (hidden variables) into quantum mechanics. He showed that hidden variables cannot be incorporated into the existing theory of quantum mechanics without major modifications, and concluded that if they did exist, the theory would have already failed in situations where it has been successfully applied. von Neumann left open the possibility that the theory is not complete, and his analysis for internal consistency is the best that can be done for a self-referenced logical system (Gödel's theorem). This analysis had been taken as an ``incorrect proof" against the existence of hidden variables. von Neumann's so-called proof isn't even wrong as such a proof does not exist. One of the earliest attempts at a hidden variable theory was by D. Bohm, and because there were no experimental consequences, W. Pauli referred to it as an ``uncashable check." To our knowledge, a successful hidden variable extension to quantum mechanics with testable consequences has not yet been produced, suggesting that von Neumann's analysis is worthy of rehabilitation, which we attempt to provide in a straightforward manner.

arXiv:2401.04002•Jan 8, 2024•1 citation
CONTENTS 1. The Statistical Character of the Behavior of Microobjects 500 2. The Mathematical Foundations of Quantum Mechanics 501 3. The Measurement Process 502 4. The Hypothesis of Parameters 503 5. Interference of Probabilities and Hidden Parameters 505 6. Von Neumann's Proof of von Neumann's Theorem 507 7. A Proof of von Neumann's Theorem which does not use the Postulate of Additivity of Incompatible Observables 508 8. Classical and Quantum Logic 509 References 511
Because the mathematical form of von Neumann's hidden-parameter proof is not well known, its scope has sometimes been unjustifiably narrowed by commentators. The proof is here reproduced in the more familiar Dirac calculus and its precise import made clearer. In particular, it is emphasized that the proof proceeds independently of both the basic statistical assumption of quantum mechanics: 〈R〉av = 〈φ|R|φ〉, and the extension of this assumption to mixtures: 〈R〉av = Tr(UR), where U = Σn|φn〉wn〈φn|. Mention is also made of some recent criticisms of the von Neumann proof.
This article reviews the history of J. von Neumann’s analysis of hidden variables in quantum mechanics and the subsequent analysis by others. In his book The Mathematical Foundations of Quantum Mechanics, published in 1932, von Neumann performed an analysis of the consequences of introducing hidden parameters (hidden variables) into quantum mechanics. He arrived at two principal conclusions: first, hidden variables cannot be incorporated into the existing theory of quantum mechanics without major modifications, and second, if they did exist, the theory would have already failed in situations where it has been successfully applied. This analysis has been taken as an “incorrect proof” against the existence of hidden variables, possibly due to a mistranslation of the German word prufen. von Neumann’s so-called proof isn’t even wrong as such a proof does not exist, but it is an examination of the limitations imposed by internal consistency of the Hilbert space formulation of the theory. One of the earliest attempts to eliminate uncertainty, by D. Bohm, requires a major modification of quantum mechanics (observables are not represented by Hermitian operators), which supports von Neumann’s first principal conclusion. However, testing the Bohm theory requires constructing a physically impossible initial state. As such, the theory has no experimental consequences, so W. Pauli referred to it as an “uncashable check”. As there are no observable consequences, the Bohm theory is possibly a counterexample to von Neumann’s second conclusion that hidden variables in particular would have already led to a failure of the theory.
The problem of hidden variables, purely conceptual at the start, has been early influenced by the practical aims of “causal theories” towards a mathematical scheme broader than the quantum formalism. Thus several authors have examined if a new formalism, built in the same spirit as that of quantum mechanics, however more general, might admit a determination by means of hidden parameters, and concluded negatively. In the present paper the two aspects (conceptual and practical) are considered separately. It first contains a study of the unrestricted proofs (Von Neumann, Jauch and Piron), given for the non-existence of hidden parameters. They are focussed on the dispersion-free states bound to them. Thus a preliminary stage consists in analyzing what properties these states should have. A method is given here for displaying these; they are shown to have an artificial character, which fits neither Von Neumann's proof nor that of Jauch and Piron and other authors (Misra). Thus, these proofs do not establish the inexistence of hidden variables, but only that of dispersion free states built more or less on the pattern of the quantum states. Suggestions are then proposed on the probable features of hidden parameters. They lead us to regard as improbable the hope of building a new deterministic scheme to be substituted for the quantum formalism. Thus, the determinism which can be maintained appears as purely conceptual. The question of a “deeper level” and the relation between determination and pictorial description are discussed briefly.
In his book \textit{The Mathematical Foundations of Quantum Mechanics}, published in 1932, J. von Neumann performed an analysis of the consequences of introducing hidden parameters (hidden variables) into quantum mechanics. He showed that hidden variables cannot be incorporated into the existing theory of quantum mechanics without major modifications, and concluded that if they did exist, the theory would have already failed in situations where it has been successfully applied. von Neumann left open the possibility that the theory is not complete, and his analysis for internal consistency is the best that can be done for a self-referenced logical system (Gödel's theorem). This analysis had been taken as an ``incorrect proof" against the existence of hidden variables. von Neumann's so-called proof isn't even wrong as such a proof does not exist. One of the earliest attempts at a hidden variable theory was by D. Bohm, and because there were no experimental consequences, W. Pauli referred to it as an ``uncashable check." To our knowledge, a successful hidden variable extension to quantum mechanics with testable consequences has not yet been produced, suggesting that von Neumann's analysis is worthy of rehabilitation, which we attempt to provide in a straightforward manner.