The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science
That von Neumann Did Not Believe in a Physical Collapse
Lon Becker
Abstract
Many works intended to introduce interpretive issues in quantum mechanics present John von Neumann as having a view in which measurement produces a physical collapse in the system being measured. In this paper I argue that such a reading of von Neumann is inconsistent with what von Neumann actually says. I show that much of what he says makes no sense on the physical collapse reading, but falls into place if we assume he does not have such a view. I show that the physical collapse view is based on an understanding of ‘state’ which von Neumann does not share. 1. Introduction2. The standard reading of von Neumann3. The standard reading of von Neumann and Chapter VI4. The Chapter VI argument5. The Chapter V argument6. The Chapters III and IV argument7. Conclusion