Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of the Optical Society of America

Photoelectric counting measurements as a test for the existence of photons*

L. Mandeļ

Published Aug 1, 1977• 11 citations
Publisher

Abstract

It is pointed out that it is impossible to distinguish between photons and classical wave packets by measurement of photoelectric counting statistics for any state of a light beam for which a classical description exists. Therefore, an experiment with a thermal light source recently proposed by Karp as a test for the existence of photons can yield no information on this question, even if it should be able to distinguish between two different statistical models of a light beam. The quantum nature of the optical field can, however, be inferred from other photoelectric measurements, some of which are briefly discussed.

DOI
10.1364/josa.67.001101

Related papers

“Test for the nonexistence of photons” and “Photoelectric counting measurements as a test for the existence of photons”

Sherman Karp

In recent articles by this author, [ S. Karp , Statistical properties of ensembles of classical wave packets, J. Opt. Soc. Am.65, 421 ( 1975); S. Karp , Test for the nonexistence of photons, J. Opt. Soc. Am.66, 1421 ( 1976)], a radiation model was proposed that could lead to the identification of certain classical properties of the field, based upon photoelectric counting experiments. Mandel [ L. Mandel , Photoelectric counting measurements as a test for the existence of photons, J. Opt. Soc. Am.67, 1101 ( 1977)] responded by asserting that “It follows that for any field for which a classical wave description exists, in the sense that the phase-space density ϕ({ν}), and therefore P(u), are non-negative it is impossible to distinguish between photons and light waves in photoelectric counting experiments.” This statement is based upon the derivation of similar photoelectron counting equations using quantum and classical techniques. It is the mathematically loose associations and subsequent rigid physical interpretation implied in relating the two equations that is under contention. It seems to us that the model-computation-effect approach to physics is still solvent. In particular, if we can model an effect as small as the radiation from an individual electron and produce a predictable effect, then the physics underlying the model must be seriously considered.

Journal of the Optical Society of America•Sep 1, 1979•0 citations

Photon Statistics and Classical Fields

L. Mandeļ, E. Wolf

In view of the misunderstanding which surrounds the use of semiclassical methods in the treatment of optical coherence problems, a simple analysis is given which illustrates the generality of these methods. In particular, it is pointed out that, under commonly occurring circumstances, these methods apply at arbitrarily low light levels, and give correct results for the photoelectric counting of photons. The conclusions are illustrated by treating the interference between laser light and thermal light to demonstrate that this nontrivial case, recently treated by quantum field theory, is correctly described by semiclassical methods.

Physical Review•Sep 30, 1966•39 citations

Analysis of Light Fluctuations from Photon Counting Statistics*

Gabriel Bédard

It is well known that photoelectric measurements yield information about the statistical behavior of fluctuating light beams. The probability of n photoelectrons being ejected, in a fixed time interval, from the photosensitive surface of the photoelectric detector, upon which the light beam is normally incident, is a linear (Poisson) transform of the probability density for the intensity of the beam. With the help of some plausible assumptions, the present analysis provides solutions to the problem of inverting the Poisson transform, thus determining the probability density for the intensity from experimentally obtained photocounting distributions. The effectiveness of the method is demonstrated by an actual inversion of a typical experimental counting distribution. The technique is of particular interest in connection with efforts to understand the statistical behavior of optical fields, especially of laser fields.

Journal of the Optical Society of America•Oct 1, 1967•32 citations

Observing the quantum behavior of light in an undergraduate laboratory

J Thorn, Matthew Stephen Neel, V. W. Donato +3 more

While the classical, wavelike behavior of light (interference and diffraction) has been easily observed in undergraduate laboratories for many years, explicit observation of the quantum nature of light (i.e., photons) is much more difficult. For example, while well-known phenomena such as the photoelectric effect and Compton scattering strongly suggest the existence of photons, they are not definitive proof of their existence. Here we present an experiment, suitable for an undergraduate laboratory, that unequivocally demonstrates the quantum nature of light. Spontaneously downconverted light is incident on a beamsplitter and the outputs are monitored with single-photon counting detectors. We observe a near absence of coincidence counts between the two detectors—a result inconsistent with a classical wave model of light, but consistent with a quantum description in which individual photons are incident on the beamsplitter. More explicitly, we measured the degree of second-order coherence between the outputs to be g(2)(0)=0.0177±0.0026, which violates the classical inequality g(2)(0)⩾1 by 377 standard deviations.

American Journal of Physics•Aug 13, 2004•133 citations

Basic Photon and Quantum Optics

Sofia E. Acosta-Ortiz

In 1905, Albert Einstein showed that the photoelectric effect could be explained by the hypothesis that the energy of a light beam was distributed in discrete bundles, later known as photons. Photon-counting experiments provide a fairly direct measurement of the photon probability distribution for all kinds of light embraced by the quantum theory. The field of quantum optics occupies a central position involving the interaction of atoms with the electromagnetic field. Young's experiment is one example of a phenomenon that can be explained by both classical and quantum theory. In Young's experiment, each photon must be capable of interfering with itself in such a way that its probability of striking the second screen at a particular point is proportional to the calculated intensity at that point. Multiphoton transitions are found whenever electrons bound in atoms or molecules interact with sufficiently intense electromagnetic radiation.

CRC Press eBooks•Nov 22, 2017•0 citations

Photons: The Motivation to Go Beyond Classical Optics

Hans‐A. Bachor, Timothy C. Ralph

Many fascinating effects are due to the quantum nature of light; they are the foundation of quantum optics. This chapter introduces the concept of the photon as the smallest detectable quantity of light and develops some of the basics required for modelling quantum optics experiments. It shows two examples of images that are typical for the detection of individual photons in one laser beam at very low light intensity. The chapter focuses on the example of light emitted by a broadband thermal source. The classical description provides the tools for describing the statistical properties of light. The measurement of interference, made accessible through the use of instruments such as a Michelson interferometer, clearly demonstrates the wave nature and the coherence properties of light. The nature of the light depends on the type of experiment: a single beamsplitter can often be well described by the photon picture, and a complete interferometer requires the wave picture.

Wiley eBooks•Jul 5, 2019•0 citations
It is pointed out that it is impossible to distinguish between photons and classical wave packets by measurement of photoelectric counting statistics for any state of a light beam for which a classical description exists. Therefore, an experiment with a thermal light source recently proposed by Karp as a test for the existence of photons can yield no information on this question, even if it should be able to distinguish between two different statistical models of a light beam. The quantum nature of the optical field can, however, be inferred from other photoelectric measurements, some of which are briefly discussed.
In recent articles by this author, [ S. Karp , Statistical properties of ensembles of classical wave packets, J. Opt. Soc. Am.65, 421 ( 1975); S. Karp , Test for the nonexistence of photons, J. Opt. Soc. Am.66, 1421 ( 1976)], a radiation model was proposed that could lead to the identification of certain classical properties of the field, based upon photoelectric counting experiments. Mandel [ L. Mandel , Photoelectric counting measurements as a test for the existence of photons, J. Opt. Soc. Am.67, 1101 ( 1977)] responded by asserting that “It follows that for any field for which a classical wave description exists, in the sense that the phase-space density ϕ({ν}), and therefore P(u), are non-negative it is impossible to distinguish between photons and light waves in photoelectric counting experiments.” This statement is based upon the derivation of similar photoelectron counting equations using quantum and classical techniques. It is the mathematically loose associations and subsequent rigid physical interpretation implied in relating the two equations that is under contention. It seems to us that the model-computation-effect approach to physics is still solvent. In particular, if we can model an effect as small as the radiation from an individual electron and produce a predictable effect, then the physics underlying the model must be seriously considered.
In view of the misunderstanding which surrounds the use of semiclassical methods in the treatment of optical coherence problems, a simple analysis is given which illustrates the generality of these methods. In particular, it is pointed out that, under commonly occurring circumstances, these methods apply at arbitrarily low light levels, and give correct results for the photoelectric counting of photons. The conclusions are illustrated by treating the interference between laser light and thermal light to demonstrate that this nontrivial case, recently treated by quantum field theory, is correctly described by semiclassical methods.
It is well known that photoelectric measurements yield information about the statistical behavior of fluctuating light beams. The probability of n photoelectrons being ejected, in a fixed time interval, from the photosensitive surface of the photoelectric detector, upon which the light beam is normally incident, is a linear (Poisson) transform of the probability density for the intensity of the beam. With the help of some plausible assumptions, the present analysis provides solutions to the problem of inverting the Poisson transform, thus determining the probability density for the intensity from experimentally obtained photocounting distributions. The effectiveness of the method is demonstrated by an actual inversion of a typical experimental counting distribution. The technique is of particular interest in connection with efforts to understand the statistical behavior of optical fields, especially of laser fields.
While the classical, wavelike behavior of light (interference and diffraction) has been easily observed in undergraduate laboratories for many years, explicit observation of the quantum nature of light (i.e., photons) is much more difficult. For example, while well-known phenomena such as the photoelectric effect and Compton scattering strongly suggest the existence of photons, they are not definitive proof of their existence. Here we present an experiment, suitable for an undergraduate laboratory, that unequivocally demonstrates the quantum nature of light. Spontaneously downconverted light is incident on a beamsplitter and the outputs are monitored with single-photon counting detectors. We observe a near absence of coincidence counts between the two detectors—a result inconsistent with a classical wave model of light, but consistent with a quantum description in which individual photons are incident on the beamsplitter. More explicitly, we measured the degree of second-order coherence between the outputs to be g(2)(0)=0.0177±0.0026, which violates the classical inequality g(2)(0)⩾1 by 377 standard deviations.
In 1905, Albert Einstein showed that the photoelectric effect could be explained by the hypothesis that the energy of a light beam was distributed in discrete bundles, later known as photons. Photon-counting experiments provide a fairly direct measurement of the photon probability distribution for all kinds of light embraced by the quantum theory. The field of quantum optics occupies a central position involving the interaction of atoms with the electromagnetic field. Young's experiment is one example of a phenomenon that can be explained by both classical and quantum theory. In Young's experiment, each photon must be capable of interfering with itself in such a way that its probability of striking the second screen at a particular point is proportional to the calculated intensity at that point. Multiphoton transitions are found whenever electrons bound in atoms or molecules interact with sufficiently intense electromagnetic radiation.
Many fascinating effects are due to the quantum nature of light; they are the foundation of quantum optics. This chapter introduces the concept of the photon as the smallest detectable quantity of light and develops some of the basics required for modelling quantum optics experiments. It shows two examples of images that are typical for the detection of individual photons in one laser beam at very low light intensity. The chapter focuses on the example of light emitted by a broadband thermal source. The classical description provides the tools for describing the statistical properties of light. The measurement of interference, made accessible through the use of instruments such as a Michelson interferometer, clearly demonstrates the wave nature and the coherence properties of light. The nature of the light depends on the type of experiment: a single beamsplitter can often be well described by the photon picture, and a complete interferometer requires the wave picture.