Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Mathematical Physics

An algebraic representation of continuous superselection rules

Renzo Cirelli, Franco Gallone, Bella Gubbay

Published Feb 1, 1975• 7 citations
Publisher

Abstract

From the logic approach to quantum and classical mechanics, the W*−algebraic approach is deduced in dependence of a suitable ’’prestate.’’ An algebraic representation of the logic description is in fact constructed in a framework in which continuous superselection rules can be present. Logic propositions, observables, and states are represented by decomposable projections, decomposable self−adjoint operators, and normal states in a direct integral of Hilbert spaces. In this representation each algebraic term becomes the representative of a homologous logic one and the expectation values as well as the superselection rules are conserved. When a principle of ’’undistinguishability’’ is taken into account, the representation is faithful. In the classical case, the representation results in Koopman’s formalism.

DOI
10.1063/1.522526

Related papers

The Trouble with Superselection Accounts of Measurement

Mariam Thalos

A superselection rule advanced in the course of a quantum-mechanical treatment of some phenomenon is an assertion to the effect that the superposition principle of quantum mechanics is to be restricted in the application at hand. Superselection accounts of measurement all have in common a decision to represent the indicator states of detectors by eigenspaces of superselection operators named in a superselection rule, on the grounds that the states in question are states of a so-called classical quantity and therefore not subject to quantum interference effects. By this strategy superselectionists of measurement expect to dispense with use of projection postulates in treatments of measurement. I shall argue that superselection accounts of measurement are self-contradictory, and that treatments of infinite systems, if they can avoid the contradiction, are not true superselection accounts.

Philosophy of Science•Sep 1, 1998•2 citations

Physical Observables and Superselection

M. P. Vaughan

It is well-known that a physical state may be represented by a unit vector in a Hilbert space, whilst a physical observable may be represented by a self-adjoint operator on that same space. However, the introduction of a superselection rule on a Hilbert space imposes constraints such that not all self-adjoint operators can represent observables, which has further consequences for the states themselves as well as the physical processes that transform them. In this article, we review the concept of superselection from the view of how such rules would affect what we consider to be physical. Arguments for the existence of a superselection rule due to charge or possibly energy conservation are given and the emergence of effective superselection rules due to decoherence or the lack of a shared reference frame are also discussed.

arXiv:2611.17051•Nov 12, 2026•0 citations

Mathematical Description of a System Consisting of Identical Quantum-Mechanical Particles

H. Kummer

In this paper a rigorous description of a system consisting of identical particles is given for which the particle number is a superselection rule. A state of such a system is described by a sequence of density operators D = (D0, D1, …, Dn, …), where Dn acts in n-particle space and the asymptotic behavior is determined by the requirement ∑ n=0∞kn|Dn|<∞ for all k=1,2,…,where | | denotes the trace norm. The (bounded) observables in turn are described by sequences of bounded self-adjoint operators: B = (B0, B1, …, Bn, …) such that sup lim nk−n ‖Bn‖<∞ for some k=1,2,…. The expectation value of the observable B in the state D can be expressed as 〈B〉D=(Γ(B)|D)=(B|L(D)),where (B|D)= ∑ n=0∞Tr(BnDn);Γ denotes the expansion operator, whereas L stands for its adjoint, the contraction operator. The analog to the n-representability problem, i.e., the so-called representability problem, is put forward and its solution is connected with the solutions of the n-representability problem for different n. Finally, a possible mathematical foundation of the BCS theory is given.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Feb 1, 1970•12 citations

Superselection Rules

K. Kong Wan

For orthodox quantum systems, pure states correspond one-to-one to all one-dimensional subspaces and observables correspond one-to-one to all selfadjoint operators in the state space. A relaxation of this one-to-one correspondence will bring about superselection rules. A general formulation of superselection rules is technically complicated. 1 We shall adopt an intuitive approach here and limit our discussion to some special cases to see how superselection rules can be incorporated in a Hilbert space structure of quantum theory.

•Jul 9, 2019•0 citations

Quantum logic

Alireza Moazzen

This article employs a descriptive-analytical method with an algebraic and axiomatic approach to address quantum logic. Through several thought experiments, it is demonstrated that the distributive law for propositions does not hold in quantum mechanics. Therefore, the logic governing this domain of science is not classical logic. In fact, the algebra corresponding to the logic of quantum propositions is an orthomodular lattice, which is why the distributive law is not necessarily valid for such propositions. In quantum logic, various definitions are offered for the implication operator. Since none of these operators satisfy the deduction theorem, a suitable implication operator with this property must be defined. This objective is achieved by defining a unified quantum logic. By constructing a Lindenbaum-Tarski algebra for this unified quantum logic, it can be shown that it is indeed a quantum logic. Dishkant presented an embedding of quantum logic into the Br-modal logic system. This provides an appropriate semantics for quantum logic. A suitable model for this logic is the closed subspaces of a Hilbert space.

•Nov 1, 2025•0 citations

Systems of observables in quantum mechanics

J. M. Jauch

The self adjoint linear operators which represent the observables of a physical system are in general not an irreducible system. Because a complete set of commuting observables must determine the state of a physical system unambiguously the observables generate an algebra of operators which must contain a maximal abelian subalgebra. The structure of such algebras is investigated and it is shown by applying the theory of the direct integral of Hilbert spaces that there exists always a unique canonical representation of the Hilbert space as a direct integral in such a way that the transformations which are induced by the observables in the component subspaces are irreducible.

Helvetica Physica Acta (Switzerland)•Nov 15, 1960•75 citations
From the logic approach to quantum and classical mechanics, the W*−algebraic approach is deduced in dependence of a suitable ’’prestate.’’ An algebraic representation of the logic description is in fact constructed in a framework in which continuous superselection rules can be present. Logic propositions, observables, and states are represented by decomposable projections, decomposable self−adjoint operators, and normal states in a direct integral of Hilbert spaces. In this representation each algebraic term becomes the representative of a homologous logic one and the expectation values as well as the superselection rules are conserved. When a principle of ’’undistinguishability’’ is taken into account, the representation is faithful. In the classical case, the representation results in Koopman’s formalism.
A superselection rule advanced in the course of a quantum-mechanical treatment of some phenomenon is an assertion to the effect that the superposition principle of quantum mechanics is to be restricted in the application at hand. Superselection accounts of measurement all have in common a decision to represent the indicator states of detectors by eigenspaces of superselection operators named in a superselection rule, on the grounds that the states in question are states of a so-called classical quantity and therefore not subject to quantum interference effects. By this strategy superselectionists of measurement expect to dispense with use of projection postulates in treatments of measurement. I shall argue that superselection accounts of measurement are self-contradictory, and that treatments of infinite systems, if they can avoid the contradiction, are not true superselection accounts.
It is well-known that a physical state may be represented by a unit vector in a Hilbert space, whilst a physical observable may be represented by a self-adjoint operator on that same space. However, the introduction of a superselection rule on a Hilbert space imposes constraints such that not all self-adjoint operators can represent observables, which has further consequences for the states themselves as well as the physical processes that transform them. In this article, we review the concept of superselection from the view of how such rules would affect what we consider to be physical. Arguments for the existence of a superselection rule due to charge or possibly energy conservation are given and the emergence of effective superselection rules due to decoherence or the lack of a shared reference frame are also discussed.
In this paper a rigorous description of a system consisting of identical particles is given for which the particle number is a superselection rule. A state of such a system is described by a sequence of density operators D = (D0, D1, …, Dn, …), where Dn acts in n-particle space and the asymptotic behavior is determined by the requirement ∑ n=0∞kn|Dn|<∞ for all k=1,2,…,where | | denotes the trace norm. The (bounded) observables in turn are described by sequences of bounded self-adjoint operators: B = (B0, B1, …, Bn, …) such that sup lim nk−n ‖Bn‖<∞ for some k=1,2,…. The expectation value of the observable B in the state D can be expressed as 〈B〉D=(Γ(B)|D)=(B|L(D)),where (B|D)= ∑ n=0∞Tr(BnDn);Γ denotes the expansion operator, whereas L stands for its adjoint, the contraction operator. The analog to the n-representability problem, i.e., the so-called representability problem, is put forward and its solution is connected with the solutions of the n-representability problem for different n. Finally, a possible mathematical foundation of the BCS theory is given.
For orthodox quantum systems, pure states correspond one-to-one to all one-dimensional subspaces and observables correspond one-to-one to all selfadjoint operators in the state space. A relaxation of this one-to-one correspondence will bring about superselection rules. A general formulation of superselection rules is technically complicated. 1 We shall adopt an intuitive approach here and limit our discussion to some special cases to see how superselection rules can be incorporated in a Hilbert space structure of quantum theory.
This article employs a descriptive-analytical method with an algebraic and axiomatic approach to address quantum logic. Through several thought experiments, it is demonstrated that the distributive law for propositions does not hold in quantum mechanics. Therefore, the logic governing this domain of science is not classical logic. In fact, the algebra corresponding to the logic of quantum propositions is an orthomodular lattice, which is why the distributive law is not necessarily valid for such propositions. In quantum logic, various definitions are offered for the implication operator. Since none of these operators satisfy the deduction theorem, a suitable implication operator with this property must be defined. This objective is achieved by defining a unified quantum logic. By constructing a Lindenbaum-Tarski algebra for this unified quantum logic, it can be shown that it is indeed a quantum logic. Dishkant presented an embedding of quantum logic into the Br-modal logic system. This provides an appropriate semantics for quantum logic. A suitable model for this logic is the closed subspaces of a Hilbert space.
The self adjoint linear operators which represent the observables of a physical system are in general not an irreducible system. Because a complete set of commuting observables must determine the state of a physical system unambiguously the observables generate an algebra of operators which must contain a maximal abelian subalgebra. The structure of such algebras is investigated and it is shown by applying the theory of the direct integral of Hilbert spaces that there exists always a unique canonical representation of the Hilbert space as a direct integral in such a way that the transformations which are induced by the observables in the component subspaces are irreducible.