Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

European Journal of Physics

Compton scattering and the complementarity principle

G. P. Sastry

Published Nov 1, 1993• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We explain briefly why Compton scattering from a crystal gives a featureless continuous x-ray background while Bragg scattering from the same crystal produces sharp diffraction peaks. It is shown that the answer lies at the heart of quantum mechanics, namely the uncertainty and the complementarity principles.
DOI
10.1088/0143-0807/14/6/009

Related papers

Compton scattering and Heisenberg’s microscope revisited

Brian Gerard Williams

Compton scattering figures prominently in the introductory chapters of textbooks on quantum mechanics as providing evidence for the ‘‘particulate’’ nature of light. It also arises in discussions of ‘‘Heisenberg’s microscope,’’ in which it is shown that attempts to measure the position and the momentum of an electron simultaneously are governed by the uncertainty principle. However, recent developments in Compton scattering have not yet found their way into the textbooks. In this paper we review the history of the Compton effect and describe briefly some of the modern developments in x-ray and electron Compton scattering and their application to the study of electron momentum densities which we believe to have a pedagogical value. Finally, we return to Heisenberg’s microscope, and show how it has now become a reality. A complete analysis for all scattering angles depends crucially on the different expressions for the resolution and the depth of focus of the microscope.

American Journal of Physics•May 1, 1984•6 citations

Compton scattering of photons from standing wave fields in the Bragg case of X-ray diffraction

Winfried Schülke

Physics Letters A•Jun 1, 1981•29 citations

The Reduced Compton Wavelength and the Energy-Position/Momentum- Time Uncertainties

Pavle Ilija Premović

The Compton scattering is an elastic collision of the x-ray or gamma photons with free electrons (or loosely bound valence shell electrons). This scattering is demonstrated in Fig. 1. In this communication we are combining Heisenberg's uncertainty principle and the Compton scattering. Note, that some of the expressions (including their derivations) of this communication can be found in modern physics textbooks. Figure 1. Schematic representation of Compton scattering, in which an incoming photon scatters from an electron at rest. The electron of the rest mass m e has the rest energy of E r = m e c 2. The Compton scattered electron (hereinafter the Compton electron) posses a relativistic kinetic energy, the relativistic speed υ e and the linear momentum p e = m e υ e. Before scattering, let the photon moves along the positive x-axis having an energy E 0 = hν 0 , frequency ν 0 , wavelength λ 0 and linear momentum p 0 = hν 0 /c, where h (= 6.63 × 10-34 J s) is the Planck constant and c (= 2.99792×10 8 m s-1) is the speed of light. After scattering, the photon moves at an angle θ off the x-axis with an energy E = hν, frequency ν, wavelength λ and momentum p = hν/c. The conservation of linear momentum of the electron after the collision yields, p e 2 = p 0 2 + p 2-2p 0 pcosθ.

•Jan 1, 2018•0 citations

A Classical Explanation of Compton Scattering

Jean Louis Van Belle

In this paper, we bring the Zitterbewegung electron model and our photon model together to provide a classical explanation of the scattering of photons by electrons. We understand electron-photon interference (which is usually referred to as Compton scattering) as two electromagnetic oscillations interfering (classically) with each other. While developing the model, we offer some reflections on the Uncertainty Principle (Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics). We conclude there is no need for it: God doesn’t play dice.

•Dec 1, 2019•0 citations

Uncertainty and Complementarity

Kurt Gottfried

The creation of quantum mechanics in the period 1924–1928 restored logical consistency to its rightful place in theoretical physics. The study of interaction between light and electrons provided most of the important clues in the development of the quantum theory. This chapter shows that in the interference experiments the statistical distribution of quanta is correctly given by the intensity of the wave field as computed from classical electromagnetic theory. It also shows that under special circumstances the classical theory also makes contact with some of the empirical facts in Compton's experiment. The chapter discusses a famous example due to W. Heisenberg, in which Compton scattered γ-rays are brought to focus by a microscope. It provides the uncertainty relations for the dynamical variables of a particle from the conservation laws and the properties of photons. Because the motion of charged particles can be deduced from their attendant fields, it is clear that fields cannot be measured to arbitrary precision.

CRC Press eBooks•Mar 9, 2018•2 citations

Bragg Diffraction and the Interference of Two Atom Lasers: An Analogy

Roger A. Hegstrom

The interference pattern produced by the beams from two atom lasers can be understood in a relatively easy way by exploiting a formal equivalence between the expression for the quantum mechanical probability density for the atoms in the laser pair and the expression for the intensity of x-rays diffracted from a crystal lattice.

ACS symposium series•Aug 7, 2002•0 citations
Compton scattering figures prominently in the introductory chapters of textbooks on quantum mechanics as providing evidence for the ‘‘particulate’’ nature of light. It also arises in discussions of ‘‘Heisenberg’s microscope,’’ in which it is shown that attempts to measure the position and the momentum of an electron simultaneously are governed by the uncertainty principle. However, recent developments in Compton scattering have not yet found their way into the textbooks. In this paper we review the history of the Compton effect and describe briefly some of the modern developments in x-ray and electron Compton scattering and their application to the study of electron momentum densities which we believe to have a pedagogical value. Finally, we return to Heisenberg’s microscope, and show how it has now become a reality. A complete analysis for all scattering angles depends crucially on the different expressions for the resolution and the depth of focus of the microscope.
The Compton scattering is an elastic collision of the x-ray or gamma photons with free electrons (or loosely bound valence shell electrons). This scattering is demonstrated in Fig. 1. In this communication we are combining Heisenberg's uncertainty principle and the Compton scattering. Note, that some of the expressions (including their derivations) of this communication can be found in modern physics textbooks. Figure 1. Schematic representation of Compton scattering, in which an incoming photon scatters from an electron at rest. The electron of the rest mass m e has the rest energy of E r = m e c 2. The Compton scattered electron (hereinafter the Compton electron) posses a relativistic kinetic energy, the relativistic speed υ e and the linear momentum p e = m e υ e. Before scattering, let the photon moves along the positive x-axis having an energy E 0 = hν 0 , frequency ν 0 , wavelength λ 0 and linear momentum p 0 = hν 0 /c, where h (= 6.63 × 10-34 J s) is the Planck constant and c (= 2.99792×10 8 m s-1) is the speed of light. After scattering, the photon moves at an angle θ off the x-axis with an energy E = hν, frequency ν, wavelength λ and momentum p = hν/c. The conservation of linear momentum of the electron after the collision yields, p e 2 = p 0 2 + p 2-2p 0 pcosθ.
In this paper, we bring the Zitterbewegung electron model and our photon model together to provide a classical explanation of the scattering of photons by electrons. We understand electron-photon interference (which is usually referred to as Compton scattering) as two electromagnetic oscillations interfering (classically) with each other. While developing the model, we offer some reflections on the Uncertainty Principle (Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics). We conclude there is no need for it: God doesn’t play dice.
The creation of quantum mechanics in the period 1924–1928 restored logical consistency to its rightful place in theoretical physics. The study of interaction between light and electrons provided most of the important clues in the development of the quantum theory. This chapter shows that in the interference experiments the statistical distribution of quanta is correctly given by the intensity of the wave field as computed from classical electromagnetic theory. It also shows that under special circumstances the classical theory also makes contact with some of the empirical facts in Compton's experiment. The chapter discusses a famous example due to W. Heisenberg, in which Compton scattered γ-rays are brought to focus by a microscope. It provides the uncertainty relations for the dynamical variables of a particle from the conservation laws and the properties of photons. Because the motion of charged particles can be deduced from their attendant fields, it is clear that fields cannot be measured to arbitrary precision.