Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

Remarks on the Possibility of Quantum Electrodynamics without Potentials

Yakir Aharonov, David Böhm

Published Mar 15, 1962• 56 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In this article, we reply to a suggestion of DeWitt for formulating a nonlocal quantum electrodynamics without potentials, showing that his proposal is not a real elimination of potentials, but only a substitution with the aid of which the essential role of potentials is somewhat obscured. Thus, we are not led to change our conclusion that potentials are significant in the formulation of quantum electrodynamics. We do, however, discuss some of the conditions that would have to be satisfied by an essentially nonlocal electrodynamics, and show that such a theory, if it could be developed, would very probably bring about profound modifications in the forms of the laws of quantum mechanics.

DOI
10.1103/physrev.125.2192

Related papers

Further Considerations on Electromagnetic Potentials in the Quantum Theory

Yakir Aharonov, David Böhm

In this article, we discuss in further detail the significance of potentials in the quantum theory, and in so doing, we answer a number of arguments that have been raised against the conclusions of our first paper on the same subject. We then proceed to extend our treatment to include the sources of potentials quantum-mechanically, and we show that when this is done, the same results are obtained as those of our first paper, in which the potential was taken to be a specified function of space and time. In this way, we not only answer certain additional criticisms that have been made of the original treatment, but we also bring out more clearly the importance of the potential in the expression of the local character of the interaction of charged particles and the electromagnetic field.

Physical Review•Aug 15, 1961•415 citations

Significance of Electromagnetic Potentials in the Quantum Theory

Yakir Aharonov, David Böhm

In this paper, we discuss some interesting properties of the electromagnetic potentials in the quantum domain. We shall show that, contrary to the conclusions of classical mechanics, there exist effects of potentials on charged particles, even in the region where all the fields (and therefore the forces on the particles) vanish. We shall then discuss possible experiments to test these conclusions; and, finally, we shall suggest further possible developments in the interpretation of the potentials.

Physical Review•Aug 1, 1959•7,074 citations

Quantum theory of an electromagnetic observer: Classically behaving macroscopic systems and the emergence of the classical world in quantum electrodynamics

Lev I. Plimak, Misha Ivanov, Andrea Aiello +1 more

Quantum electrodynamics under conditions of distinguishability of interacting matter entities, and of controlled actions and back-actions between them, is considered. Such ``mesoscopic quantum electrodynamics'' is shown to share its dynamical structure with the classical stochastic electrodynamics. In formal terms, we demonstrate that all general relations of the mesoscopic quantum electrodynamics may be recast in a form lacking Planck's constant. Mesoscopic quantum electrodynamics is therefore subject to ``doing quantum electrodynamics while thinking classically,'' allowing one to substitute essentially classical considerations for quantum ones without any loss in generality. Implications of these results for the quantum measurement theory are discussed.

arXiv:1507.05466•Physical Review A•Aug 25, 2015•0 citations

No Drama Quantum Theory?

Andrey Akhmeteli

Is it possible to offer a "no drama" quantum theory? Something as simple (in principle) as classical electrodynamics - a theory described by a system of partial differential equations in 3+1 dimensions, but reproducing unitary evolution of a quantum field theory in the configuration space? The following results suggest an affirmative answer: 1. The scalar field can be algebraically eliminated from scalar electrodynamics; the resulting equations describe independent evolution of the electromagnetic field. 2. After introduction of a complex 4-potential (producing the same electromagnetic field as the standard real 4-potential), the spinor field can be algebraically eliminated from spinor electrodynamics; the resulting equations describe independent evolution of the electromagnetic field. 3. The resulting theories for the electromagnetic field can be embedded into quantum field theories. Another fundamental result: in a general case, the Dirac equation is equivalent to a 4th order partial differential equations for just one component, which can be made real by a gauge transform. Issues related to the Bell theorem are discussed.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•May 10, 2012•1 citation

Deflating the Aharonov-Bohm Effect

David Wallace

I argue that the metaphysical import of the Aharonov-Bohm effect has been overstated: correctly understood, it does not require either rejection of gauge invariance or any novel form of nonlocality. The conclusion that it does require one or the other follows from a failure to keep track, in the analysis, of the complex scalar field to which the magnetic vector potential is coupled. Once this is recognised, the way is clear to a local account of the ontology of electrodynamics (or at least, to an account no more nonlocal than quantum theory in general requires); I sketch a possible such account.

arXiv:1407.5073•Jul 18, 2014•36 citations

Study of the Presence Probability Distribution in Autointerference States

Mioara Mugur-Schächter, Daniel Evrard, F. Thieffine

An argument by one of us is first reproduced, demonstrating that the bare negation of the consequences imposed by the completeness hypothesis, concerning the particular formal fact that a quantum-mechanical free wave packet can spread out indefinitely, leads necessarily to predictions on the presence probability distribution in interference states that diverge from the corresponding quantum-mechanical predictions. It follows that, contrary to what seemed to be almost generally accepted, it is erroneous to admit systematically that the completeness problems are essentially unconnected to observation. This result is similar to one previously established by Bell and seems to support a suggestion by Ballentine, that any hidden-variable theory might necessarily lead to predictive divergences from quantum mechanics, if internal "pathologies" are not admitted. The above-mentioned argument entails a first minimal definition of a nonorthodox significance of a state vector. In the continuation of this work this definition is tentatively developed in a constructive way. This development is realized by a modification of de Broglie's model of a microsystem. This modification, imposed by an examination of de Broglie's double-solution theory in the light of our conclusion demonstrated before, is in fact rather profound; in particular, it forces the abandonment of the central idea of two solutions with distinct physical meanings, of a unique evolution law. However, the theory called into consideration by this modification may be capable of leading to objective proofs of the specific descriptive power of the essence of de Broglie's conception on the structure of microsystems. Indeed, inside the general nonorthodox framework tentatively outlined, a detailed definition of the presence probability distribution is elaborated that coincides with the quantum-mechanical one outside interference states, but diverges from it in interference states, in an experimentally testable way. This is a verifiable constructive embodiment of the conclusion only critically obtained at the beginning of this work. A final verdict on the value of the specific basic conception of the outlined theory and of the new perspectives it brings forth can be obtained only by a further systematic theoretical elaboration and by the corresponding experimental tests.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Dec 15, 1972•5 citations
In this article, we reply to a suggestion of DeWitt for formulating a nonlocal quantum electrodynamics without potentials, showing that his proposal is not a real elimination of potentials, but only a substitution with the aid of which the essential role of potentials is somewhat obscured. Thus, we are not led to change our conclusion that potentials are significant in the formulation of quantum electrodynamics. We do, however, discuss some of the conditions that would have to be satisfied by an essentially nonlocal electrodynamics, and show that such a theory, if it could be developed, would very probably bring about profound modifications in the forms of the laws of quantum mechanics.
In this article, we discuss in further detail the significance of potentials in the quantum theory, and in so doing, we answer a number of arguments that have been raised against the conclusions of our first paper on the same subject. We then proceed to extend our treatment to include the sources of potentials quantum-mechanically, and we show that when this is done, the same results are obtained as those of our first paper, in which the potential was taken to be a specified function of space and time. In this way, we not only answer certain additional criticisms that have been made of the original treatment, but we also bring out more clearly the importance of the potential in the expression of the local character of the interaction of charged particles and the electromagnetic field.
In this paper, we discuss some interesting properties of the electromagnetic potentials in the quantum domain. We shall show that, contrary to the conclusions of classical mechanics, there exist effects of potentials on charged particles, even in the region where all the fields (and therefore the forces on the particles) vanish. We shall then discuss possible experiments to test these conclusions; and, finally, we shall suggest further possible developments in the interpretation of the potentials.
Quantum electrodynamics under conditions of distinguishability of interacting matter entities, and of controlled actions and back-actions between them, is considered. Such ``mesoscopic quantum electrodynamics'' is shown to share its dynamical structure with the classical stochastic electrodynamics. In formal terms, we demonstrate that all general relations of the mesoscopic quantum electrodynamics may be recast in a form lacking Planck's constant. Mesoscopic quantum electrodynamics is therefore subject to ``doing quantum electrodynamics while thinking classically,'' allowing one to substitute essentially classical considerations for quantum ones without any loss in generality. Implications of these results for the quantum measurement theory are discussed.
Is it possible to offer a "no drama" quantum theory? Something as simple (in principle) as classical electrodynamics - a theory described by a system of partial differential equations in 3+1 dimensions, but reproducing unitary evolution of a quantum field theory in the configuration space? The following results suggest an affirmative answer: 1. The scalar field can be algebraically eliminated from scalar electrodynamics; the resulting equations describe independent evolution of the electromagnetic field. 2. After introduction of a complex 4-potential (producing the same electromagnetic field as the standard real 4-potential), the spinor field can be algebraically eliminated from spinor electrodynamics; the resulting equations describe independent evolution of the electromagnetic field. 3. The resulting theories for the electromagnetic field can be embedded into quantum field theories. Another fundamental result: in a general case, the Dirac equation is equivalent to a 4th order partial differential equations for just one component, which can be made real by a gauge transform. Issues related to the Bell theorem are discussed.
I argue that the metaphysical import of the Aharonov-Bohm effect has been overstated: correctly understood, it does not require either rejection of gauge invariance or any novel form of nonlocality. The conclusion that it does require one or the other follows from a failure to keep track, in the analysis, of the complex scalar field to which the magnetic vector potential is coupled. Once this is recognised, the way is clear to a local account of the ontology of electrodynamics (or at least, to an account no more nonlocal than quantum theory in general requires); I sketch a possible such account.
An argument by one of us is first reproduced, demonstrating that the bare negation of the consequences imposed by the completeness hypothesis, concerning the particular formal fact that a quantum-mechanical free wave packet can spread out indefinitely, leads necessarily to predictions on the presence probability distribution in interference states that diverge from the corresponding quantum-mechanical predictions. It follows that, contrary to what seemed to be almost generally accepted, it is erroneous to admit systematically that the completeness problems are essentially unconnected to observation. This result is similar to one previously established by Bell and seems to support a suggestion by Ballentine, that any hidden-variable theory might necessarily lead to predictive divergences from quantum mechanics, if internal "pathologies" are not admitted. The above-mentioned argument entails a first minimal definition of a nonorthodox significance of a state vector. In the continuation of this work this definition is tentatively developed in a constructive way. This development is realized by a modification of de Broglie's model of a microsystem. This modification, imposed by an examination of de Broglie's double-solution theory in the light of our conclusion demonstrated before, is in fact rather profound; in particular, it forces the abandonment of the central idea of two solutions with distinct physical meanings, of a unique evolution law. However, the theory called into consideration by this modification may be capable of leading to objective proofs of the specific descriptive power of the essence of de Broglie's conception on the structure of microsystems. Indeed, inside the general nonorthodox framework tentatively outlined, a detailed definition of the presence probability distribution is elaborated that coincides with the quantum-mechanical one outside interference states, but diverges from it in interference states, in an experimentally testable way. This is a verifiable constructive embodiment of the conclusion only critically obtained at the beginning of this work. A final verdict on the value of the specific basic conception of the outlined theory and of the new perspectives it brings forth can be obtained only by a further systematic theoretical elaboration and by the corresponding experimental tests.