Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

American Journal of Physics

Remarks on the Theory of Measurement

Mutsuo M. Yanase

Published Mar 1, 1964• 18 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A new classification of quantum mechanical quantities according to their measurability is discussed. We have three different types of quantities: first, exactly measurable quantities which commute with all the conserved quantities; second, approximately measurable quantities which do not commute with all additive conserved quantities; and finally nonmeasurable quantities which are conjugate to the absolute invariants. The epistemological implications of the measurement process are discussed and it is pointed out that the quantum mechanical description of this process does not furnish an adequate explanation of the acquisition of knowledge.

DOI
10.1119/1.1970177

Related papers

Analysis of the Quantum Mechanical Measurement Process

Eugene Paul Wigner, Mutsuo M. Yanase

The quantum mechanical measurement process is analysed in detail, especially from the group theoretical point of view. The first three chapters review the results obtained before briefly. In §1, the classical theory of measurement, originated by von Neumann, is birefly described. The importance of considering more general schemes of measurements than the original one is, however, emphasized. In §2, the role of conservation laws, in imposing limitations on the possibility of measurements, is discussed. Accurately measurable quantities are defined in this context. In §3, the role of conservation laws is further analysed. It is shown that the conserved quantity of the apparatus cannot be used for a “pointer reading.” The following two chapters discuss the nature of the exactly measurable quantities. In §4, exactly measurable quantities are explicitly determined. It is shown that the measurement of projection operators in the Hilbert space of the object which commute with the operators of the restricted Poincaré group give all the information on the states of the object that can be obtained by accurate measurements. In §5, the measurement on objects which are composed of more than one particle is discussed. The last chapter, §6, deals with approximately measurable quantities, but no complete estimate of the unavoidable inaccuracy of the measurement of these is obtained. It also contains some concluding remarks.

Annals of the Japan Association for Philosophy of Science•Jan 1, 1973•2 citations

Measurement of Quantum Mechanical Operators

Huzihiro Araki, Mutsuo M. Yanase

The limitation on the measurement of an operator imposed by the presence of a conservation law is studied. It is shown that an operator which does not commute with a conserved (additive) quantity cannot be measured exactly (in the sense of von Neumann). It is also shown for a simple case that an approximate measurement of such an operator is possible to any desired accuracy.

Physical Review•Oct 15, 1960•356 citations

On the Theory of Measurement in Quantum Mechanical Systems

Loyal Durand

This paper is concerned with the description of the process of measurement within the context of a quantum theory of the physical world. It is noted that quantum mechanics permits a quasi-classical description (classical in the limited sense implied by the correspondence principle of Bohr) of those macroscopic phenomena in terms of which the observer forms his perceptions. Thus, the process of measurement in quantum mechanics can be understood on the quasi-classical level by transcribing from the strictly classical observables of Newtonian physics to their quasi-classical counterparts the known rules for the measurement of the former. The remaining physical problem is the delineation of the circumstances in which the correlation of a peculiarly quantum mechanical observable A with a classically measurable observable B can result in a significant measurement of A. This is undertaken within the context of quantum theory. The resulting clarification of the process of measurement has important implications relative to the philosophic interpretation of quantum mechanics.

Philosophy of Science•Apr 1, 1960•10 citations

The Problem of Measurement

Eugene Paul Wigner

The standard theory of measurements in quantum mechanics is reviewed with special emphasis on the conceptual and epistemological implications. It is concluded that the standard theory remains the only one which is compatible with present quantum mechanics. Hence, if one wants to avoid the conclusion that quantum mechanics only gives probability connections between subsequent observations, the quantum-mechanical equations would have to be modified. Particular attention is paid to the case that the measuring apparatus is macroscopic and its state vector not accurately known before the measurement.

American Journal of Physics•Jan 1, 1963•844 citations

INFORMATION CONTENTS OF DISTRIBUTIONS

Eugene Paul Wigner, Mutsuo M. Yanase

The entropy, as usually defined, is a measure of our ignorance and, if multiplied by — 1, can be considered as a measure of our knowledge of the state of a system.1 It is a measure of our total knowledge into which the knowledge of the value of any observable enters in the same way (cf. section 3). It is this last circumstance which prompted the considerations leading to the present note. According to quantum mechanical theory, some observables can be measured much more easily than others: the observables which commute with the additive conserved quantities (energy, components of the linear and angular momenta, electric charge) can be measured with microscopic apparatuses; those which do not commute with these quantities need for their measurement macroscopic systems.2 Hence, the problem of defining a measure of our knowledge with respect to the latter quantities arises. The present note will be restricted to the case in which there is only one conserved additive quantity; this will be denoted by k. The name “skew information” has been proposed3 for the amount of information which an ensemble described by a state vector or a statistical matrix contains with respect to the not easily measured quantities. This information relates to the transition probabilities into states which lie askew to the characteristic vectors of the additive conserved quantities.

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences•Jun 1, 1963•700 citations

Quantum Measurements in thePresence of Symmetry

Leon Loveridge

This thesis concerns how symmetries impinge on quantum mechanical measurements, \nand preclude certain self adjoint operators from representing observable \nquantities. After developing the requisite mathematical machinery and aspects \nof quantum measurement theory necessary for our analysis, we proceed to critically \nreview the literature surrounding the remarkable theorem of Wigner, \nAraki and Yanase (WAY) that prohibits accurate and repeatable measurements \nof any observable not commuting with an additive conserved quantity, as well \nas discussing the conditions under which approximate measurements with approximate \ndegrees of repeatability can be achieved. We strengthen the original \nstatement of the WAY theorem and generalise it to the case of position measurements \nobeying momentum conservation, leading to a solution of a long-standing \nproblem of Stein and Shimony. A superselection rule appearing as the existence \nof an observable which commutes with all others gives rise to a stronger \nrestriction than the WAY theorem, yielding self adjoint operators which do not \nrepresent observable quantities. We analyse various perspectives on superselection \nrules, aiming to clarify different viewpoints appearing in the literature \nsince the inception of the topic in 1952. We exploit an explicit description \nof relative phase observables which have been lacking in other contributions, \ndelineating conditions under which relative and (prohibited) absolute phases \nbecome statistically close. By providing simple models we are able to mimic a \nnumber of attempts to overcome superselection rules, in order to highlight the \ngeneric features of such attempts. We show that the statistical proximity of absolute \nand relative quantities arises only when there is a highly localised phase \nreference, and that the superselection rule compatible relative phase factors \nbetween certain superpositions takes on the appearence of a forbidden relative \nphase factor in this limit. However, we argue that these relative phase factors \ncan be determined fully within the confines of a superselection rule. \n

•Jul 1, 2012•4 citations
A new classification of quantum mechanical quantities according to their measurability is discussed. We have three different types of quantities: first, exactly measurable quantities which commute with all the conserved quantities; second, approximately measurable quantities which do not commute with all additive conserved quantities; and finally nonmeasurable quantities which are conjugate to the absolute invariants. The epistemological implications of the measurement process are discussed and it is pointed out that the quantum mechanical description of this process does not furnish an adequate explanation of the acquisition of knowledge.
The quantum mechanical measurement process is analysed in detail, especially from the group theoretical point of view. The first three chapters review the results obtained before briefly. In §1, the classical theory of measurement, originated by von Neumann, is birefly described. The importance of considering more general schemes of measurements than the original one is, however, emphasized. In §2, the role of conservation laws, in imposing limitations on the possibility of measurements, is discussed. Accurately measurable quantities are defined in this context. In §3, the role of conservation laws is further analysed. It is shown that the conserved quantity of the apparatus cannot be used for a “pointer reading.” The following two chapters discuss the nature of the exactly measurable quantities. In §4, exactly measurable quantities are explicitly determined. It is shown that the measurement of projection operators in the Hilbert space of the object which commute with the operators of the restricted Poincaré group give all the information on the states of the object that can be obtained by accurate measurements. In §5, the measurement on objects which are composed of more than one particle is discussed. The last chapter, §6, deals with approximately measurable quantities, but no complete estimate of the unavoidable inaccuracy of the measurement of these is obtained. It also contains some concluding remarks.
This paper is concerned with the description of the process of measurement within the context of a quantum theory of the physical world. It is noted that quantum mechanics permits a quasi-classical description (classical in the limited sense implied by the correspondence principle of Bohr) of those macroscopic phenomena in terms of which the observer forms his perceptions. Thus, the process of measurement in quantum mechanics can be understood on the quasi-classical level by transcribing from the strictly classical observables of Newtonian physics to their quasi-classical counterparts the known rules for the measurement of the former. The remaining physical problem is the delineation of the circumstances in which the correlation of a peculiarly quantum mechanical observable A with a classically measurable observable B can result in a significant measurement of A. This is undertaken within the context of quantum theory. The resulting clarification of the process of measurement has important implications relative to the philosophic interpretation of quantum mechanics.
The standard theory of measurements in quantum mechanics is reviewed with special emphasis on the conceptual and epistemological implications. It is concluded that the standard theory remains the only one which is compatible with present quantum mechanics. Hence, if one wants to avoid the conclusion that quantum mechanics only gives probability connections between subsequent observations, the quantum-mechanical equations would have to be modified. Particular attention is paid to the case that the measuring apparatus is macroscopic and its state vector not accurately known before the measurement.
The entropy, as usually defined, is a measure of our ignorance and, if multiplied by — 1, can be considered as a measure of our knowledge of the state of a system.1 It is a measure of our total knowledge into which the knowledge of the value of any observable enters in the same way (cf. section 3). It is this last circumstance which prompted the considerations leading to the present note. According to quantum mechanical theory, some observables can be measured much more easily than others: the observables which commute with the additive conserved quantities (energy, components of the linear and angular momenta, electric charge) can be measured with microscopic apparatuses; those which do not commute with these quantities need for their measurement macroscopic systems.2 Hence, the problem of defining a measure of our knowledge with respect to the latter quantities arises. The present note will be restricted to the case in which there is only one conserved additive quantity; this will be denoted by k. The name “skew information” has been proposed3 for the amount of information which an ensemble described by a state vector or a statistical matrix contains with respect to the not easily measured quantities. This information relates to the transition probabilities into states which lie askew to the characteristic vectors of the additive conserved quantities.
This thesis concerns how symmetries impinge on quantum mechanical measurements, \nand preclude certain self adjoint operators from representing observable \nquantities. After developing the requisite mathematical machinery and aspects \nof quantum measurement theory necessary for our analysis, we proceed to critically \nreview the literature surrounding the remarkable theorem of Wigner, \nAraki and Yanase (WAY) that prohibits accurate and repeatable measurements \nof any observable not commuting with an additive conserved quantity, as well \nas discussing the conditions under which approximate measurements with approximate \ndegrees of repeatability can be achieved. We strengthen the original \nstatement of the WAY theorem and generalise it to the case of position measurements \nobeying momentum conservation, leading to a solution of a long-standing \nproblem of Stein and Shimony. A superselection rule appearing as the existence \nof an observable which commutes with all others gives rise to a stronger \nrestriction than the WAY theorem, yielding self adjoint operators which do not \nrepresent observable quantities. We analyse various perspectives on superselection \nrules, aiming to clarify different viewpoints appearing in the literature \nsince the inception of the topic in 1952. We exploit an explicit description \nof relative phase observables which have been lacking in other contributions, \ndelineating conditions under which relative and (prohibited) absolute phases \nbecome statistically close. By providing simple models we are able to mimic a \nnumber of attempts to overcome superselection rules, in order to highlight the \ngeneric features of such attempts. We show that the statistical proximity of absolute \nand relative quantities arises only when there is a highly localised phase \nreference, and that the superselection rule compatible relative phase factors \nbetween certain superpositions takes on the appearence of a forbidden relative \nphase factor in this limit. However, we argue that these relative phase factors \ncan be determined fully within the confines of a superselection rule. \n