Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Mathematical Physics

Mixed states with positive Wigner functions

T. Bröcker, Reinhard F. Werner

Published Jan 1, 1995• 70 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The Wigner distribution function of a pure quantum state is everywhere positive if and only if the state is coherent, according to a result of Hudson. The characterization of mixed states with a positive Wigner function is a special case of the problem of determining functions satisfying a twisted positive definiteness condition for a prescribed set of twisting parameters (i.e., functions with given ‘‘Wigner spectrum’’ in the sense of Narcowich). If a state is a convex combination of coherent states, it has the property that the Wigner spectrum contains the unit interval, which in turn implies that the Wigner function is positive. It is shown by explicit examples that the converses of both implications are false. The examples are taken from a low-dimensional section of the state space, in which all Wigner spectra can be computed. In this set counterexamples to a conjecture by Narcowich concerning the Wigner spectrum of products are also found, as well as a state whose Wigner spectrum is a convergent sequence of discrete points.

DOI
10.1063/1.531326

Related papers

Hudson’s theorem for finite-dimensional quantum systems

D. Gross

We show that, on a Hilbert space of odd dimension, the only pure states to possess a non-negative Wigner function are stabilizer states. The Clifford group is identified as the set of unitary operations which preserve positivity. The result can be seen as a discrete version of Hudson’s theorem. Hudson established that for continuous variable systems, the Wigner function of a pure state has no negative values if and only if the state is Gaussian. Turning to mixed states, it might be surmised that only convex combinations of stabilizer states give rise to non-negative Wigner distributions. We refute this conjecture by means of a counterexample. Further, we give an axiomatic characterization which completely fixes the definition of the Wigner function and compare two approaches to stabilizer states for Hilbert spaces of prime-power dimensions. In the course of the discussion, we derive explicit formulas for the number of stabilizer codes defined on such systems.

arXiv:quant-ph/0602001•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Dec 1, 2006•425 citations

Non-negative discrete Wigner functions

Gross, D

We show that, on a Hilbert space of odd dimension, the only pure states to possess a non-negative Wigner function are stabilizer states. The Clifford group is identified as the set of unitary operations which preserve positivity. The result can be seen as a discrete version of Hudson's Theorem. Hudson established that for continuous variable systems, the Wigner function of a pure state has no negative values if and only if the state is Gaussian. Turning to mixed states, it might be surmised that only convex combinations of stabilizer states give rise to non-negative Wigner distributions. We refute this conjecture by means of a counter-example. Further, we give an axiomatic characterization which completely fixes the definition of the Wigner function and compare two approaches to stabilizer states for Hilbert spaces of prime-power dimensions. In the course of the discussion, we derive explicit formulas for the number of stabilizer codes defined on such systems.

•Feb 1, 2006•1 citation

Extreme non-negative Wigner functions

Zacharie Van Herstraeten, Jack Davis, Nuno C. Dias +3 more

Providing an operational characterization of the Wigner-positive states (WPS), i.e., the set of quantum states with non-negative Wigner function, is a longstanding open problem. For pure states, the only WPS are Gaussian states, but the situation is considerably more subtle for mixed states. Here, we approach the problem using convex geometry, reducing the question to the characterization of the extreme points of the set of WPS. We give a constructive method to generate a large class of such extreme WPS, which combines the following steps: (i) we characterize the phase-invariant extreme points of the superset of Wigner-positive quasi-states (WPQS); (ii) we introduce a new quantum map, named Vertigo map, which maps extreme WPQS to extreme WPS while preserving phase invariance; (iii) we identify families of extremality-preserving maps and use them to obtain extreme WPS while relaxing phase invariance. Our construction generates all extreme WPS of low dimension, starting from a specific kind of WPS known as beam-splitter states. Our results build upon new mathematical properties of the set of WPS derived in a companion paper and unveil the remarkable structure of mixed states with non-negative Wigner functions.

quant-pharXiv:2512.14831•Dec 18, 2025•5 citations

Gaussianity bounds for quantum mixed states with a positive Wigner function

Aikaterini Mandilara, Evgueni Karpov, Nicolas J. Cerf

According to Hudson's theorem, the only quantum pure states with a positive Wigner function are Gaussian states. We summarize and compare some recent attempts at extending this theorem to the space of quantum mixed states, and complement them with new results obtained from numerical observations. Specifically, we look for upper bounds on the admissible non-Gaussianity of mixed states with a positive Wigner function. © 2010 IOP Publishing Ltd.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Nov 1, 2010•7 citations

Extending Hudson’s theorem to mixed quantum states

Aikaterini Mandilara, Evgueni Karpov, Nicolas J. Cerf

According to Hudson's theorem, any pure quantum state with a positive Wigner function is necessarily a Gaussian state. Here, we make a step toward the extension of this theorem to mixed quantum states by finding upper and lower bounds on the degree of non-Gaussianity of states with positive Wigner functions. The bounds are expressed in the form of parametric functions relating the degree of non-Gaussianity of a state, its purity, and the purity of the Gaussian state characterized by the same covariance matrix. Although our bounds are not tight, they permit us to visualize the set of states with positive Wigner functions.

arXiv:0808.2501•Physical Review A•Jun 3, 2009•64 citations

Characterising the sets of quantum states with non-negative Wigner function

Nicolas J. Cerf, Ulysse Chabaud, Jack Davis +3 more

For Hilbert spaces $\mathcal H\subseteq L^2(\mathbb R)$ we consider the convex sets $\mathcal D_+(\mathcal H)$ of Wigner-positive states (WPS), i.e.~density matrices over $\mathcal H$ with non-negative Wigner function. We investigate the topological structure of these sets, namely concerning closure, compactness, interior and boundary (in a relative topology induced by the trace norm). We also study their geometric structure and construct minimal sets of states that generate $\mathcal D_+(\mathcal H)$ through convex combinations. If $\mathcal H$ is finite-dimensional, the existence of such sets follows from a central result in convex analysis, namely the Krein-Milman theorem. In the infinite-dimensional case $\mathcal H=L^2(\mathbb R)$ this is not so, due to lack of compactness of the set $\mathcal D_+(\mathcal H)$. Nevertheless, we prove that a Krein-Milman theorem holds in this case, which allows us to extend most of the results concerning the sets of generators to the infinite-dimensional setting. Finally, we study the relation between the finite and infinite-dimensional sets of WPS, and prove that the former provide a hierarchy of closed subsets, which are also proper faces of the latter. These results provide a basis for an operational characterisation of the extreme points of the sets of WPS, which we undertake in a companion paper. Our work offers a unified perspective on the topological and geometric properties of the sets of WPS in finite and infinite dimensions, along with explicit constructions of minimal sets of generators.

math-phCross-listedarXiv:2512.14820•Dec 18, 2025•1 citation
The Wigner distribution function of a pure quantum state is everywhere positive if and only if the state is coherent, according to a result of Hudson. The characterization of mixed states with a positive Wigner function is a special case of the problem of determining functions satisfying a twisted positive definiteness condition for a prescribed set of twisting parameters (i.e., functions with given ‘‘Wigner spectrum’’ in the sense of Narcowich). If a state is a convex combination of coherent states, it has the property that the Wigner spectrum contains the unit interval, which in turn implies that the Wigner function is positive. It is shown by explicit examples that the converses of both implications are false. The examples are taken from a low-dimensional section of the state space, in which all Wigner spectra can be computed. In this set counterexamples to a conjecture by Narcowich concerning the Wigner spectrum of products are also found, as well as a state whose Wigner spectrum is a convergent sequence of discrete points.
We show that, on a Hilbert space of odd dimension, the only pure states to possess a non-negative Wigner function are stabilizer states. The Clifford group is identified as the set of unitary operations which preserve positivity. The result can be seen as a discrete version of Hudson’s theorem. Hudson established that for continuous variable systems, the Wigner function of a pure state has no negative values if and only if the state is Gaussian. Turning to mixed states, it might be surmised that only convex combinations of stabilizer states give rise to non-negative Wigner distributions. We refute this conjecture by means of a counterexample. Further, we give an axiomatic characterization which completely fixes the definition of the Wigner function and compare two approaches to stabilizer states for Hilbert spaces of prime-power dimensions. In the course of the discussion, we derive explicit formulas for the number of stabilizer codes defined on such systems.
We show that, on a Hilbert space of odd dimension, the only pure states to possess a non-negative Wigner function are stabilizer states. The Clifford group is identified as the set of unitary operations which preserve positivity. The result can be seen as a discrete version of Hudson's Theorem. Hudson established that for continuous variable systems, the Wigner function of a pure state has no negative values if and only if the state is Gaussian. Turning to mixed states, it might be surmised that only convex combinations of stabilizer states give rise to non-negative Wigner distributions. We refute this conjecture by means of a counter-example. Further, we give an axiomatic characterization which completely fixes the definition of the Wigner function and compare two approaches to stabilizer states for Hilbert spaces of prime-power dimensions. In the course of the discussion, we derive explicit formulas for the number of stabilizer codes defined on such systems.
Providing an operational characterization of the Wigner-positive states (WPS), i.e., the set of quantum states with non-negative Wigner function, is a longstanding open problem. For pure states, the only WPS are Gaussian states, but the situation is considerably more subtle for mixed states. Here, we approach the problem using convex geometry, reducing the question to the characterization of the extreme points of the set of WPS. We give a constructive method to generate a large class of such extreme WPS, which combines the following steps: (i) we characterize the phase-invariant extreme points of the superset of Wigner-positive quasi-states (WPQS); (ii) we introduce a new quantum map, named Vertigo map, which maps extreme WPQS to extreme WPS while preserving phase invariance; (iii) we identify families of extremality-preserving maps and use them to obtain extreme WPS while relaxing phase invariance. Our construction generates all extreme WPS of low dimension, starting from a specific kind of WPS known as beam-splitter states. Our results build upon new mathematical properties of the set of WPS derived in a companion paper and unveil the remarkable structure of mixed states with non-negative Wigner functions.
According to Hudson's theorem, any pure quantum state with a positive Wigner function is necessarily a Gaussian state. Here, we make a step toward the extension of this theorem to mixed quantum states by finding upper and lower bounds on the degree of non-Gaussianity of states with positive Wigner functions. The bounds are expressed in the form of parametric functions relating the degree of non-Gaussianity of a state, its purity, and the purity of the Gaussian state characterized by the same covariance matrix. Although our bounds are not tight, they permit us to visualize the set of states with positive Wigner functions.
For Hilbert spaces H⊆L2(R)\mathcal H\subseteq L^2(\mathbb R)H⊆L2(R) we consider the convex sets D+(H)\mathcal D_+(\mathcal H)D+​(H) of Wigner-positive states (WPS), i.e.~density matrices over H\mathcal HH with non-negative Wigner function. We investigate the topological structure of these sets, namely concerning closure, compactness, interior and boundary (in a relative topology induced by the trace norm). We also study their geometric structure and construct minimal sets of states that generate D+(H)\mathcal D_+(\mathcal H)D+​(H) through convex combinations. If H\mathcal HH is finite-dimensional, the existence of such sets follows from a central result in convex analysis, namely the Krein-Milman theorem. In the infinite-dimensional case H=L2(R)\mathcal H=L^2(\mathbb R)H=L2(R) this is not so, due to lack of compactness of the set D+(H)\mathcal D_+(\mathcal H)D+​(H). Nevertheless, we prove that a Krein-Milman theorem holds in this case, which allows us to extend most of the results concerning the sets of generators to the infinite-dimensional setting. Finally, we study the relation between the finite and infinite-dimensional sets of WPS, and prove that the former provide a hierarchy of closed subsets, which are also proper faces of the latter. These results provide a basis for an operational characterisation of the extreme points of the sets of WPS, which we undertake in a companion paper. Our work offers a unified perspective on the topological and geometric properties of the sets of WPS in finite and infinite dimensions, along with explicit constructions of minimal sets of generators.