Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review C

Comparison between wave functions in the random phase approximation, renormalized random phase approximation, and self-consistent random phase approximation methods

Jorge G. Hirsch, Osvaldo Civitarese, M. Reboiro

Published Jul 16, 1999• 15 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The random phase approximation (RPA), the renormalized RPA (RRPA), and the self-consistent RPA (SCRPA) methods are applied to calculate the wave functions of the ground and excited states of an exactly solvable model. The approximated wave functions are expanded in the basis of the exact solutions. It is found that, when the RPA collapses, the RPA wave functions are orthogonal to the exact solutions while the RRPA and SCRPA ones have small but finite overlaps with the exact results. In spite of the apparently good agreement between the results of the RRPA, the SCRPA, and the exact solution, for the energy of the first excited state beyond the point of collapse, it is found that these approximations do not correctly describe the exact wave functions.

DOI
10.1103/physrevc.60.024309

Related papers

Consistency of the particle-particle random-phase approximation and renormalization

Nguyen Dinh Dang

The consistency condition is tested within the particle-particle random-phase approximation (RPA), renormalized RPA (RRPA), and the self-consistent RPA (SCRPA) making use of the Richardson model of pairing. The two-particle separation energy is calculated in two ways, namely, as the energy of the first addition mode, which adds two particles to a core with $N$ particles, and as the energy of the first removal mode, which removes two particles from the $N+2$ particle system to get back to the same $N$-particle core. The corresponding transitions generated by the pairing operators are also calculated. It is found that the results obtained in these two ways of calculations are close to each other only at large values of particle number $N$ and/or small interaction strength. At $N\ensuremath{\le}10$ for a given value of the interaction strength, the discrepancy between the results obtained in two ways of calculations within the SCRPA is much smaller than those given by the RPA and RRPA.

arXiv:nucl-th/0607043•Physical Review C•Aug 25, 2006•2 citations

Comparing many-body approaches against the helium atom exact solution

Jing Li, N. D. Drummond, Peter Schuck +1 more

Over time, many different theories and approaches have been developed to tackle the many-body problem in quantum chemistry, condensed-matter physics, and nuclear physics. Here we use the helium atom, a real system rather than a model, and we use the exact solution of its Schrödinger equation as a benchmark for comparison between methods. We present new results beyond the random-phase approximation (RPA) from a renormalized RPA (r-RPA) in the framework of the self-consistent RPA (SCRPA) originally developed in nuclear physics, and compare them with various other approaches like configuration interaction (CI), quantum Monte Carlo (QMC), time-dependent density-functional theory (TDDFT), and the Bethe-Salpeter equation on top of the \boldsymbol{GW} 𝐆 𝐖 approximation. Most of the calculations are consistently done on the same footing, e.g. using the same basis set, in an effort for a most faithful comparison between methods.

arXiv:1801.09977•SciPost Physics•Apr 1, 2019•30 citations

Extension of Self Consistent RPA method to off-site Hubbard Model

Said Harir, Mohamed Bennai, Y. Boughaleb

We are interested in the possibility that a generalization of Self Consistent Random Phase Approximation (SCRPA) to the Extended Hubbard Model can lead us to accurate estimations of the ground state energy, for closed chains in one dimension with periodic boundary conditions: N=2 (two states problem). We have considered an extended Hubbard model including on-site and off-site interactions, we have compared the SCRPA with a Direct Analytical(DA) results for the ground state energy, and have shown that SCRPA solves the two states problem exactly for any value of U (on-site interaction energy), V2 (off-site interaction energy with opposite spins) and (off-site interaction energy with same spins).

PRSM•Mar 17, 2011•0 citations

Comparative study on the validity of the renormalized random-phase approximation

Osvaldo Civitarese, M. Reboiro

The consistency of the renormalized random-phase approximation (RRPA), to treat correlations nearby a phase transition, is analyzed. The results of the RRPA and its quasiparticle version (RQRPA) for monopole and quadrupole particle-hole excitations and pairing vibrational modes, are compared with exact results and with results of the conventional quasiparticle random-phase approximation (QRPA). The calculations are performed in schematic models.

Physical Review C•Jun 1, 1998•9 citations

Random phase approximation vs exact shell-model correlation energies

Ionel Stetcu, Calvin W. Johnson

The random phase approximation (RPA) builds in correlations left out by mean-field theory. In full $0\ensuremath{\Elzxh}\ensuremath{\omega}$ shell-model spaces we calculate the Hartree-Fock $(\mathrm{HF})+\mathrm{RPA}$ binding energy, and compare it to exact diagonalization. We find that often, but not always, the $\mathrm{HF}+\mathrm{RPA}$ gives a good approximation to the ``exact'' ground state energy. In those cases where the RPA is less satisfactory, however, there is no obvious correlation with properties of the HF state, such as deformation or overlap with the exact ground state wave function. This weakens the reliability of the RPA for computing binding energies.

arXiv:nucl-th/0205029•Physical Review C•Sep 3, 2002•38 citations

Random-phase approximation and broken symmetry

E. D. D. Davis, W. D. Heiss

The validity of the random-phase approximation (RPA) in broken-symmetry bases is tested in an appropriate many-body system for which exact solutions are available. Initially the regions of stability of the self-consistent quasiparticle bases in this system are established and depicted in a 'phase' diagram. It is found that only stable bases can be used in an RPA calculation. This is particularly true for those RPA modes which are not associated with the onset of instability of the basis; the authors see that these modes do not describe any excited state when the basis is unstable, although from a formal point of view they remain acceptable. The RPA does well in a stable broken-symmetry basis provided one is not too close to a point where a phase transition occurs. This is true for both energies and matrix elements.

Journal of Physics G Nuclear Physics•Sep 1, 1986•27 citations
The random phase approximation (RPA), the renormalized RPA (RRPA), and the self-consistent RPA (SCRPA) methods are applied to calculate the wave functions of the ground and excited states of an exactly solvable model. The approximated wave functions are expanded in the basis of the exact solutions. It is found that, when the RPA collapses, the RPA wave functions are orthogonal to the exact solutions while the RRPA and SCRPA ones have small but finite overlaps with the exact results. In spite of the apparently good agreement between the results of the RRPA, the SCRPA, and the exact solution, for the energy of the first excited state beyond the point of collapse, it is found that these approximations do not correctly describe the exact wave functions.
The consistency condition is tested within the particle-particle random-phase approximation (RPA), renormalized RPA (RRPA), and the self-consistent RPA (SCRPA) making use of the Richardson model of pairing. The two-particle separation energy is calculated in two ways, namely, as the energy of the first addition mode, which adds two particles to a core with NNN particles, and as the energy of the first removal mode, which removes two particles from the N+2N+2N+2 particle system to get back to the same NNN-particle core. The corresponding transitions generated by the pairing operators are also calculated. It is found that the results obtained in these two ways of calculations are close to each other only at large values of particle number NNN and/or small interaction strength. At $N\ensuremath{\le}10$ for a given value of the interaction strength, the discrepancy between the results obtained in two ways of calculations within the SCRPA is much smaller than those given by the RPA and RRPA.
Over time, many different theories and approaches have been developed to tackle the many-body problem in quantum chemistry, condensed-matter physics, and nuclear physics. Here we use the helium atom, a real system rather than a model, and we use the exact solution of its Schrödinger equation as a benchmark for comparison between methods. We present new results beyond the random-phase approximation (RPA) from a renormalized RPA (r-RPA) in the framework of the self-consistent RPA (SCRPA) originally developed in nuclear physics, and compare them with various other approaches like configuration interaction (CI), quantum Monte Carlo (QMC), time-dependent density-functional theory (TDDFT), and the Bethe-Salpeter equation on top of the \boldsymbol{GW} 𝐆 𝐖 approximation. Most of the calculations are consistently done on the same footing, e.g. using the same basis set, in an effort for a most faithful comparison between methods.
We are interested in the possibility that a generalization of Self Consistent Random Phase Approximation (SCRPA) to the Extended Hubbard Model can lead us to accurate estimations of the ground state energy, for closed chains in one dimension with periodic boundary conditions: N=2 (two states problem). We have considered an extended Hubbard model including on-site and off-site interactions, we have compared the SCRPA with a Direct Analytical(DA) results for the ground state energy, and have shown that SCRPA solves the two states problem exactly for any value of U (on-site interaction energy), V2 (off-site interaction energy with opposite spins) and (off-site interaction energy with same spins).
The random phase approximation (RPA) builds in correlations left out by mean-field theory. In full $0\ensuremath{\Elzxh}\ensuremath{\omega}$ shell-model spaces we calculate the Hartree-Fock (HF)+RPA(\mathrm{HF})+\mathrm{RPA}(HF)+RPA binding energy, and compare it to exact diagonalization. We find that often, but not always, the HF+RPA\mathrm{HF}+\mathrm{RPA}HF+RPA gives a good approximation to the ``exact'' ground state energy. In those cases where the RPA is less satisfactory, however, there is no obvious correlation with properties of the HF state, such as deformation or overlap with the exact ground state wave function. This weakens the reliability of the RPA for computing binding energies.
The validity of the random-phase approximation (RPA) in broken-symmetry bases is tested in an appropriate many-body system for which exact solutions are available. Initially the regions of stability of the self-consistent quasiparticle bases in this system are established and depicted in a 'phase' diagram. It is found that only stable bases can be used in an RPA calculation. This is particularly true for those RPA modes which are not associated with the onset of instability of the basis; the authors see that these modes do not describe any excited state when the basis is unstable, although from a formal point of view they remain acceptable. The RPA does well in a stable broken-symmetry basis provided one is not too close to a point where a phase transition occurs. This is true for both energies and matrix elements.