Security of distributed cryptographic protocols usually requires privacy (inputs of the honest parties remain hidden), correctness (the adversary cannot improperly affect the outcome), and fairness (if the adversary learns the output, all honest parties do also). Cleve's seminal result (STOC '86) implies that satisfying these properties simultaneously is impossible in the presence of dishonest majorities, and led to several proposals for relaxed notions of fairness. While these works also suggest completeness results (i.e., the ability to design protocols which achieve their fairness notion), their assessment is typically of an all-or-nothing nature. In this work we put forth a new approach for defining relaxed fairness guarantees that allows for a quantitative comparison between protocols with regard to the level of fairness they achieve. The basic idea is to use an appropriate utility function to express the preferences of an adversary who wants to violate fairness. We also show optimal protocols with respect to our notion, in both the two-party and multi-party settings.
Security of distributed cryptographic protocols usually requires privacy (inputs of the honest parties remain hidden), correctness (the adversary cannot improperly affect the outcome), and fairness (if the adversary learns the output, all honest parties do also). Cleve's seminal result (STOC '86) implies that satisfying these properties simultaneously is impossible in the presence of dishonest majorities, and led to several proposals for relaxed notions of fairness. While these works also suggest completeness results (i.e., the ability to design protocols which achieve their fairness notion), their assessment is typically of an all-or-nothing nature. In this work we put forth a new approach for defining relaxed fairness guarantees that allows for a quantitative comparison between protocols with regard to the level of fairness they achieve. The basic idea is to use an appropriate utility function to express the preferences of an adversary who wants to violate fairness. We also show optimal protocols with respect to our notion, in both the two-party and multi-party settings.
In the setting of secure two-party computation, two mutually distrusting parties wish to compute some function of their inputs while preserving, to the extent possible, various security properties such as privacy, correctness, and more. One desirable property is fairness which guarantees, informally, that if one party receives its output, then the other party does too. Cleve (STOC 1986) showed that complete fairness cannot be achieved in general without an honest majority. Since then, the accepted folklore has been that nothing non-trivial can be computed with complete fairness in the two-party setting, and the problem has been treated as closed since the late ’80s. In this paper, we demonstrate that this folklore belief is false by showing completely-fair protocols for various non-trivial functions in the two-party setting based on standard cryptographic assumptions. We first show feasibility of obtaining complete fairness when computing any function over polynomial-size domains that does not contain an “embedded XOR”; this class of functions includes boolean AND/OR as well as Yao’s “millionaires ’ problem”. We also demonstrate feasibility for certain functions that do contain an embedded XOR, and prove a lower bound showing that any completely-fair protocol for such functions must have round complexity super-logarithmic in the security parameter. Our results demonstrate that the question of completely-fair secure computation without an honest majority is far from closed.
In the setting of secure two-party computation, two mutually distrusting parties wish to compute some function of their inputs while preserving, to the extent possible, various security properties such as privacy, correctness, and more. One desirable property is fairness which guarantees, informally, that if one party receives its output, then the other party does too. Cleve [1986] showed that complete fairness cannot be achieved in general without an honest majority. Since then, the accepted folklore has been that nothing non-trivial can be computed with complete fairness in the two-party setting. We demonstrate that this folklore belief is false by showing completely fair protocols for various nontrivial functions in the two-party setting based on standard cryptographic assumptions. We first show feasibility of obtaining complete fairness when computing any function over polynomial-size domains that does not contain an “embedded XOR”; this class of functions includes boolean AND/OR as well as Yao’s “millionaires’ problem”. We also demonstrate feasibility for certain functions that do contain an embedded XOR, though we prove a lower bound showing that any completely fair protocol for such functions must have round complexity super-logarithmic in the security parameter. Our results demonstrate that the question of completely fair secure computation without an honest majority is far from closed.
In the setting of secure two-party computation, two mutually distrusting parties wish to compute some function of their inputs while preserving, to the extent possible, various security properties such as privacy, correctness, and more. One desirable property is fairness, which guarantees that if either party receives its output, then the other party does too. Cleve (STOC 1986) showed that complete fairness cannot be achieved in general in the two-party setting; specifically, he showed (essentially) that it is impossible to compute Boolean XOR with complete fairness. Since his work, the accepted folklore has been that nothing non-trivial can be computed with complete fairness, and the question of complete fairness in secure two-party computation has been treated as closed since the late '80s.
Secure coin-tossing is typically modeled as an input-less functionality, where parties with no private inputs jointly generate a fair coin. In the dishonest majority setting, however, a strongly fair coin-tossing protocol is impossible. To circumvent this barrier, recent work has adopted the weaker notion of game-theoretic fairness, where adversaries are rational parties with preferences for specific outcomes, seeking to bias the coin in their favor. Yet these preferences may encode secret information, making prior protocols that assume preferences are public, fundamentally incompatible with privacy. We initiate a comprehensive study of privacy-preserving game-theoretically fair coin-tossing, where the preferences of honest parties remain private. We propose a simulation-based security framework and a new ideal functionality that reconciles both preference-privacy and game-theoretic fairness. A key ingredient is a certifying authority that authenticates each party’s preference and publishes only aggregate statistics, preventing misreporting while hiding parties' preferences. The functionality guarantees that every honest party receives an output: either a uniform coin; or, if an adversary deviates, a coin that does not increase the adversarial coalition's expected utility. Within this framework, we construct a protocol realizing our ideal functionality under standard cryptographic assumptions that works for both binary and general m -sided coin-tossing. Our binary scheme matches the corruption threshold of Wu-Asharov-Shi (EUROCRYPT '22); our multi-sided scheme builds on Thyagarajan-Wu-Soni (CRYPTO '24) with a corruption guarantee depending on the coalition's preference counts. Technically, our protocols combine authenticated preferences with an anonymous communication layer that decouples identities from preference-dependent actions, together with a deviation-penalty mechanism that enforces game-theoretic fairness. Our work is the first to reconcile game-theoretic fairness with preference privacy, offering new definitional tools and efficient protocols for rational multi-party computation in dishonest majority settings.
Secure computation is a fundamental problem in modern cryptography in which multiple parties join to compute a function of their private inputs without revealing anything beyond the output of the function. A series of very strong results in the 1980's demonstrated that any polynomial-time function can be computed while guaranteeing essentially every desired security property. The only exception is the fairness property, which states that no player should receive their output from the computation unless all players receive their output. While it was shown that fairness can be achieved whenever a majority of players are honest, it was also shown that fairness is impossible to achieve in general when half or more of the players are dishonest. Indeed, it was proven that even boolean XOR cannot be computed fairly by two parties The fairness property is both natural and important, and as such it was one of the first questions addressed in modern cryptography (in the context of signature exchange). One contribution of this thesis is to survey the many approaches that have been used to guarantee different notions of partial fairness. We then revisit the topic of fairness within a modern security framework for secure computation. We demonstrate that, despite the strong impossibility result mentioned above, certain interesting functions can be computed fairly, even when half (or more) of the parties are malicious. We also provide a new notion of partial fairness, demonstrate feasibility of achieving this notion for a large class of functions, and show impossibility for certain functions outside this class. We consider fairness in the presence of rational adversaries, and, finally, we further study the difficulty of achieving fairness by exploring how much external help is necessary for enabling fair secure computation.
A protocol for computing a functionality is secure if an adversary in this protocol cannot cause more harm than in an ideal computation where parties give their inputs to a trusted party which returns the output of the functionality to all parties. In particular, in the ideal model such computation is fair -- all parties get the output. Cleve (STOC 1986) proved that, in general, fairness is not possible without an honest majority. To overcome this impossibility, Gordon and Katz (Eurocrypt 2010) suggested a relaxed definition -- 1/p-secure computation -- which guarantees partial fairness. For two parties, they construct 1/p-secure protocols for functionalities for which the size of either their domain or their range is polynomial (in the security parameter). Gordon and Katz ask whether their results can be extended to multiparty protocols. We study 1/p-secure protocols in the multiparty setting for general functionalities. Our main result is constructions of 1/p-secure protocols when the number of parties is constant provided that less than 2/3 of the parties are corrupt. Our protocols require that either (1) the functionality is deterministic and the size of the domain is polynomial (in the security parameter), or (2) the functionality can be randomized and the size of the range is polynomial. If the size of the domain is constant and the functionality is deterministic, then our protocol is efficient even when the number of parties is O(log log n) (where n is the security parameter). On the negative side, we show that when the number of parties is super-constant, 1/p-secure protocols are not possible when the size of the domain is polynomial.