Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Philosophy of Science

Relativistic Invariance and Modal Interpretations

John Earman, Laura Ruetsche

Published Oct 1, 2005• 53 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A number of arguments have been given to show that the modal interpretation of ordinary nonrelativistic quantum mechanics cannot be consistently extended to the relativistic setting. We find these arguments inconclusive. However, there is a prima facie reason to think that a tension exists between the modal interpretation and relativistic invariance; namely, the best candidate for a modal interpretation adapted to relativistic quantum field theory, a prescription due to Rob Clifton (2000), comes out trivial when applied to a number of systems of physical interest. However, it is far from clear whether this difficulty for the modal interpretation is traceable to relativistic invariance per se or to the infinite number of degrees of freedom involved. In any case, the proponents of the modal interpretation have work to do.

DOI
10.1086/505448

Related papers

Chasing Chimeras

Wayne C. Myrvold

Earman and Ruetsche ([2005]) have cast their gaze upon existing no-go theorems for relativistic modal interpretations, and have found them inconclusive. They suggest that it would be more fruitful to investigate modal interpretations proposed for ‘really relativistic theories,’ that is, algebraic relativistic quantum field theories. They investigate the proposal of (Clifton [2000]), and extend Clifton's result that, for a host of states, his proposal yields no definite observables other than multiples of the identity. This leads Earman and Ruetsche to a suspicion that troubles for modal interpretations of such relativistic theories ‘are due less to the Poincaré invariance of relativistic QFT vs. the Galilean invariance of ordinary nonrelativistic QM than to the infinite number of degrees of freedom of former vs. the finite number of degrees of freedom of the latter’ (pp. 577–8). I am skeptical of this suggestion. Though there are troubles for modal interpretations of relativistic quantum field theory that are due to its being a field theory—that is, due to infinitude of the degrees of freedom—they are not the only troubles faced by modal interpretations of quantum theories set in relativistic spacetime; there are also troubles traceable to relativistic causal structure. 1. Introduction 2. Relativity and Causal Structure 3. The Theorems Purified 4. Evolving States in a Relativistic Context

The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science•May 22, 2009•4 citations

A Galilei-invariant Version of the Modal-Hamiltonian Interpretation

Olímpia Lombardi

Abstract Although it is usual to read that non-relativistic quantum mechanics is covariant, and even invariant, under the Galilei transformations, this topic has scarcely been addressed in the standard literature on the theory. This fact has, at least, two undesirable consequences. On the one hand, the meanings of the concepts of covariance and invariance are not precisely elucidated. On the other hand, one is left without a clear idea about in what sense the covariance and/or invariance of quantum mechanics can be asserted. This situation has its counterpart in the field of the interpretation of quantum mechanics: the relevance of the Galilei group is rarely discussed in the impressive amount of literature on the subject. The general premise underlying the present chapter is that the relationship between interpretation and Galilei transformations deserves to be seriously analyzed: the fact that the theory is covariant under the Galilei group does not guarantee the same property for the interpretation because, in general, interpretations add interpretative postulates to the formal structure of the theory. On this basis, and after clarifying the concepts of covariance and invariance, this chapter considers in what sense quantum mechanics is covariant and under what conditions it is invariant under the transformations of the Galilei group. This conceptual framework will provide the tools to study the result of the application of the Galilei transformations to the Modal-Hamiltonian interpretative postulates.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Feb 19, 2026•0 citations

Consistent histories and relativistic invariance in the modal interpretation of quantum mechanics

Dennis Dieks

arXiv:quant-ph/9912075•Physics Letters A•Feb 1, 2000•37 citations

A Look at Quantum Field Theory

Simon Friederich

The therapeutic approach to quantum theory developed here is meant to be applicable not only to non-relativistic quantum mechanics, but to more advanced quantum theories as well. More specifically, it is meant to be applicable to the quantum theories of systems with infinitely many degrees of freedom, quantum field theories in particular. However, the quantum theories of systems with infinitely many degrees of freedom harbour additional philosophical challenges besides those that are already present in non-relativistic quantum mechanics, and it is to be hoped that the approach suggested here may help to clarify and address those challenges as well. The present chapter turns to some aspects of the interpretation of quantum field theory and assesses them in the light of the Rule Perspective. These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

Palgrave Macmillan UK eBooks•Nov 7, 2014•0 citations

Relativistic Constraints on Interpretations of Quantum Mechanics

Wayne C. Myrvold

Nonrelativistic quantum mechanics is conceptually and mathematically simpler, and does, after all, work very well in a low-energy regime. Any solution of the measurement problem, or any account of the ontology of quantum theory, must yield sensible results in this regime, and so nonrelativistic quantum mechanics can serve as a testing ground for the viability of interpretations. On any approach, empirical adequacy requires recovery of at least an approximation to the quantum probabilities for outcomes of experiments, insofar as these have been verified by experiment. A quantum-mechanical theory is what results when one subjects a classical theory of a system with finitely many degrees of freedom to quantization. The task of extending additional beables theories to the context of quantum field theories remains a work in progress. A dynamical collapse theory modifies the evolution of the quantum state. Standard quantum theory predicts correlations between outcomes of spacelike separated experiments that violate Bell inequalities.

Routledge eBooks•Aug 11, 2021•10 citations

Modal interpretation of quantum mechanics, measurements, and macroscopic behavior

Dennis Dieks

The modal interpretation explained here construes the mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics in terms of physical properties (``be-ables,'' ``existents'') in such a way that the property attribution reflects the mathematical structure as much as possible---no additional structure is superimposed on the formalism. We generalize the interpretation by specifying a dynamics of physical properties, and also extend it while replying to recent objections by Albert and Loewer 2 [Proceedings of the 1990 Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association, edited by A. Fine, M. Forbes, and L. Wessels (Philosophy of Science Association, East Lansing, MI, 1990), Vol. 1, p. 277], and by Elby [Found. Phys. Lett. 6, 5 (1993)]. I also discuss questions relating to relativistic aspects and casuality.

Physical Review A•Apr 1, 1994•71 citations
A number of arguments have been given to show that the modal interpretation of ordinary nonrelativistic quantum mechanics cannot be consistently extended to the relativistic setting. We find these arguments inconclusive. However, there is a prima facie reason to think that a tension exists between the modal interpretation and relativistic invariance; namely, the best candidate for a modal interpretation adapted to relativistic quantum field theory, a prescription due to Rob Clifton (2000), comes out trivial when applied to a number of systems of physical interest. However, it is far from clear whether this difficulty for the modal interpretation is traceable to relativistic invariance per se or to the infinite number of degrees of freedom involved. In any case, the proponents of the modal interpretation have work to do.
Earman and Ruetsche ([2005]) have cast their gaze upon existing no-go theorems for relativistic modal interpretations, and have found them inconclusive. They suggest that it would be more fruitful to investigate modal interpretations proposed for ‘really relativistic theories,’ that is, algebraic relativistic quantum field theories. They investigate the proposal of (Clifton [2000]), and extend Clifton's result that, for a host of states, his proposal yields no definite observables other than multiples of the identity. This leads Earman and Ruetsche to a suspicion that troubles for modal interpretations of such relativistic theories ‘are due less to the Poincaré invariance of relativistic QFT vs. the Galilean invariance of ordinary nonrelativistic QM than to the infinite number of degrees of freedom of former vs. the finite number of degrees of freedom of the latter’ (pp. 577–8). I am skeptical of this suggestion. Though there are troubles for modal interpretations of relativistic quantum field theory that are due to its being a field theory—that is, due to infinitude of the degrees of freedom—they are not the only troubles faced by modal interpretations of quantum theories set in relativistic spacetime; there are also troubles traceable to relativistic causal structure. 1. Introduction 2. Relativity and Causal Structure 3. The Theorems Purified 4. Evolving States in a Relativistic Context
Abstract Although it is usual to read that non-relativistic quantum mechanics is covariant, and even invariant, under the Galilei transformations, this topic has scarcely been addressed in the standard literature on the theory. This fact has, at least, two undesirable consequences. On the one hand, the meanings of the concepts of covariance and invariance are not precisely elucidated. On the other hand, one is left without a clear idea about in what sense the covariance and/or invariance of quantum mechanics can be asserted. This situation has its counterpart in the field of the interpretation of quantum mechanics: the relevance of the Galilei group is rarely discussed in the impressive amount of literature on the subject. The general premise underlying the present chapter is that the relationship between interpretation and Galilei transformations deserves to be seriously analyzed: the fact that the theory is covariant under the Galilei group does not guarantee the same property for the interpretation because, in general, interpretations add interpretative postulates to the formal structure of the theory. On this basis, and after clarifying the concepts of covariance and invariance, this chapter considers in what sense quantum mechanics is covariant and under what conditions it is invariant under the transformations of the Galilei group. This conceptual framework will provide the tools to study the result of the application of the Galilei transformations to the Modal-Hamiltonian interpretative postulates.
The therapeutic approach to quantum theory developed here is meant to be applicable not only to non-relativistic quantum mechanics, but to more advanced quantum theories as well. More specifically, it is meant to be applicable to the quantum theories of systems with infinitely many degrees of freedom, quantum field theories in particular. However, the quantum theories of systems with infinitely many degrees of freedom harbour additional philosophical challenges besides those that are already present in non-relativistic quantum mechanics, and it is to be hoped that the approach suggested here may help to clarify and address those challenges as well. The present chapter turns to some aspects of the interpretation of quantum field theory and assesses them in the light of the Rule Perspective. These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.
Nonrelativistic quantum mechanics is conceptually and mathematically simpler, and does, after all, work very well in a low-energy regime. Any solution of the measurement problem, or any account of the ontology of quantum theory, must yield sensible results in this regime, and so nonrelativistic quantum mechanics can serve as a testing ground for the viability of interpretations. On any approach, empirical adequacy requires recovery of at least an approximation to the quantum probabilities for outcomes of experiments, insofar as these have been verified by experiment. A quantum-mechanical theory is what results when one subjects a classical theory of a system with finitely many degrees of freedom to quantization. The task of extending additional beables theories to the context of quantum field theories remains a work in progress. A dynamical collapse theory modifies the evolution of the quantum state. Standard quantum theory predicts correlations between outcomes of spacelike separated experiments that violate Bell inequalities.
The modal interpretation explained here construes the mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics in terms of physical properties (``be-ables,'' ``existents'') in such a way that the property attribution reflects the mathematical structure as much as possible---no additional structure is superimposed on the formalism. We generalize the interpretation by specifying a dynamics of physical properties, and also extend it while replying to recent objections by Albert and Loewer 2 [Proceedings of the 1990 Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association, edited by A. Fine, M. Forbes, and L. Wessels (Philosophy of Science Association, East Lansing, MI, 1990), Vol. 1, p. 277], and by Elby [Found. Phys. Lett. 6, 5 (1993)]. I also discuss questions relating to relativistic aspects and casuality.