Physical Review A
Comment on ‘‘Quantum coherent states and the second-order susceptibility’’
Edwin Albert Power
Abstract
It is shown that the minimal coupling interaction and the multipolar interaction -\ensuremath{\mu}\ensuremath{\cdot}E give identical predictions for the second-order susceptibility. This contrasts with differing results obtained by Hammond [R. T. Hammond, Phys. Rev. A 39, 2544 (1989)]. The unique answer is obtained in the most straightforward way from the multipolar Hamiltonian. Complicated sum rules are needed to demonstrate the correct result from the minimal coupling form of the interaction.