Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Philosophy of Science

Is the Ψ-Function Description “Complete?” A Layman's Question

Horace S. Fries

Published Apr 1, 1952• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

On the side of Niels Bohr, not to mention a few other physicists, there is an honest acknowledgment of a difficulty in understanding Einstein's objection to the “completeness” of the Ψ-function description of the quantum phenomenon. Yet the weight which Bohr himself attaches to Einstein's insistence may indicate that if the latter's difficulty could be understood, then, through the cooperation of understanding physicists, another great accomplishment of unification might be obtained which would be as fruitful for the future as either or both the general theory of relativity and Bohr's statistical theory have been to the present.

DOI
10.1086/287188

Related papers

Quantum World Is Only Smoke and Mirrors

H. D. Zeh

David Mermin reported that nobody seems to know what Niels Bohr really said—or meant—or what the Copenhagen interpretation really is. I find that amusing. It appears typical for the confusion arising (necessarily?) from attempts to give Bohr’s ingenious pragmatism a consistent meaning.Could it be that three generations of physicists learned, accepted, and taught an ill-defined quantum theory, and that Einstein’s and Schrödinger’s reservations were justified—even though those two great men were not yet ready to accept a nonlocal (entangled) reality, as it is described by a general wave function? © 2004 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Oct 1, 2004•1 citation

A Simple Idea on the Unification of Einstein-Bohr Controversy

Weicheng Cui

Whether the world works regularly or not, and whether the nature of the world is knowable or unknowable, Einstein and Bohr have debated these two questions for more than 40 years and even up to now, physicists continue the debate.From my point of view, this controversy was created by Bohr's over claim.The purpose of this short note is to present my simple idea of unification of Einstein-Bohr controversy.

Annals of Social Sciences & Management studies•Jan 30, 2019•7 citations

Philosophy and Physics in the Discussions between Bohr and Einstein

Р. А. Аронов, B. Ia. Pakhomov

Niels Bohr was born on October 7, 1885. He was one of the great innovators in physical science in the twentieth century. It so happens that 1985 also marks fifty years since the long discussions, which had begun in the 1920s between Albert Einstein and Bohr on the philosophical problems of quantum physics, attained their apogee. An article co-authored by Einstein, B. Podolsky, and N. Rosen, "Can Quantum Mechanics Be Considered a Complete Description of Physical Reality?,"1 was published in 1935 in the journal Physical Review. According to Bohr, "by virtue of its clarity and, it would seem, flawless argumentation, the work of Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen has created excitement among physicists and played a great role in the discussion of general philosophical questions of physics."2 Precisely as a result of the publication of this article, the critical position of Einstein concerning quantum mechanics became known to a broader circle of physicists. (Prior to this not many physicists had participated in the discussions.)3 In the same year, Bohr responded to Einstein and his co-authors with an article under the same title.4

Soviet Studies in Philosophy•Oct 1, 1986•3 citations

Is Quantum Mechanics a Complete Theory?

Y. Tschang

Physics Essays•Sep 1, 1992•0 citations

Clarification of the Nature of Quantum Theory Based on Scientific Philosophy

Altayev Namaz Karabalievich

It is known that there was a disagreement between Bohr and Einstein about the nature of the fundamental equations of quantum mechanics. In 1949, in the work "Remarks on Articles," Einstein clearly expressed his thoughts on this issue. He wrote: "All this discussion was needed only to clarify the following. By attempting to defend the thesis that statistical quantum theory can in principle give a complete description of individual systems, we come to highly improbable theoretical concepts. On the other hand, the aforementioned interpretive difficulties of the theory disappear if quantum-theoretical descriptions are considered as descriptions of ensembles of systems".

Journal of Physics & Optics Sciences•May 24, 2024•1 citation

Is Quantum Mechanics a Complete Theory?

D. I. Blokhint︠s︡ev

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 1968•0 citations
On the side of Niels Bohr, not to mention a few other physicists, there is an honest acknowledgment of a difficulty in understanding Einstein's objection to the “completeness” of the Ψ-function description of the quantum phenomenon. Yet the weight which Bohr himself attaches to Einstein's insistence may indicate that if the latter's difficulty could be understood, then, through the cooperation of understanding physicists, another great accomplishment of unification might be obtained which would be as fruitful for the future as either or both the general theory of relativity and Bohr's statistical theory have been to the present.
David Mermin reported that nobody seems to know what Niels Bohr really said—or meant—or what the Copenhagen interpretation really is. I find that amusing. It appears typical for the confusion arising (necessarily?) from attempts to give Bohr’s ingenious pragmatism a consistent meaning.Could it be that three generations of physicists learned, accepted, and taught an ill-defined quantum theory, and that Einstein’s and Schrödinger’s reservations were justified—even though those two great men were not yet ready to accept a nonlocal (entangled) reality, as it is described by a general wave function? © 2004 American Institute of Physics.
Niels Bohr was born on October 7, 1885. He was one of the great innovators in physical science in the twentieth century. It so happens that 1985 also marks fifty years since the long discussions, which had begun in the 1920s between Albert Einstein and Bohr on the philosophical problems of quantum physics, attained their apogee. An article co-authored by Einstein, B. Podolsky, and N. Rosen, "Can Quantum Mechanics Be Considered a Complete Description of Physical Reality?,"1 was published in 1935 in the journal Physical Review. According to Bohr, "by virtue of its clarity and, it would seem, flawless argumentation, the work of Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen has created excitement among physicists and played a great role in the discussion of general philosophical questions of physics."2 Precisely as a result of the publication of this article, the critical position of Einstein concerning quantum mechanics became known to a broader circle of physicists. (Prior to this not many physicists had participated in the discussions.)3 In the same year, Bohr responded to Einstein and his co-authors with an article under the same title.4
It is known that there was a disagreement between Bohr and Einstein about the nature of the fundamental equations of quantum mechanics. In 1949, in the work "Remarks on Articles," Einstein clearly expressed his thoughts on this issue. He wrote: "All this discussion was needed only to clarify the following. By attempting to defend the thesis that statistical quantum theory can in principle give a complete description of individual systems, we come to highly improbable theoretical concepts. On the other hand, the aforementioned interpretive difficulties of the theory disappear if quantum-theoretical descriptions are considered as descriptions of ensembles of systems".