Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE

Open quantum systems with linear dynamics: optimal unravellings for optimal feedback control

Howard M. Wiseman, Andrew C. Doherty

Published May 25, 2004• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Quantum feedback control is the control of the dynamics of a quantum system by feeding back (in real time) the results of monitoring that system. For systems with linear dynamics, the control problem is amenable to exact analysis. In these cases, the quantum system is equivalent to a stochastic system of classical phase-space variables with linear drift and constant diffusion, and with a measured current (e.g. a homodyne photocurrent) linear in the system variables. However, the classical evolution is constrained in order to represent valid quantum evolution. We quantify this in terms of a linear matrix inequality (LMI) relating the drift and diffusion (a sort of zero temperature fluctuation-dissipation theorem), and another LMI for the covariance matrix of the possible conditioned states (i.e. under all possible monitoring schemes consistent with the master equation). For manipulable systems (i.e. where the experimenter has arbitrary control over the parameters in a Hamiltonian linear in the system variables) the covariance of the conditioned state is all that is needed to calculate the effectiveness of the feedback. In this case the double optimization problem reduces to a semidefinite program, which can be solved efficiently in general. We illustrate this with an example drawn from quantum optics.

DOI
10.1117/12.547492

Related papers

Quantum limits to feedback control of linear systems

Andrew C. Doherty, Howard M. Wiseman

In many optical and atomic systems it is now possible to monitor an individual quantum system with high signal to noise and feed back by altering the system dynamics in real time. This motivates further development of quantum mechanical descriptions of feedback control. We discuss recent work on closed loop control of open quantum systems, focusing on general linear systems for which the statistics of the problem are Gaussian. Such systems may be realized with linear optics, parametric amplifiers and homodyne detection. This problem allows a direct comparison with the classical linear, quadratic cost, Gaussian noise (LQG) optimal control problem. This highlights the key distinction between the quantum and classical theories for linear systems: that increased measurement sensitivity may run counter to the control objectives since it increases the backaction noise. While in an idealized classical control problem it is always preferable to obtain a better sensor, quantum mechanical problems generically have an optimal sensitivity since quantum mechanical measurements irreducibly disturb the system. The general theory will be illustrated by reference to specific simple examples.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•May 25, 2004•1 citation

Optimal Unravellings for Feedback Control in Linear Quantum Systems

Howard M. Wiseman, Andrew C. Doherty

For quantum systems with linear dynamics in phase space much of classical feedback control theory applies. However, there are some questions that are sensible only for the quantum case: Given a fixed interaction between the system and the environment what is the optimal measurement on the environment for a particular control problem? We show that for a broad class of optimal (state-based) control problems (the stationary linear-quadratic-Gaussian class), this question is a semidefinite program. Moreover, the answer also applies to Markovian (current-based) feedback.

arXiv:quant-ph/0408099•Physical Review Letters•Feb 25, 2005•148 citations

State-based quantum feedback control

Howard M. Wiseman, Gerard J Milburn

In the preceding chapter we introduced quantum feedback control, devoting most space to the continuous feedback control of a localized quantum system. That is, we considered feeding back the current resulting from the monitoring of that system to control a parameter in the system Hamiltonian. We described feedback both in terms of Heisenberg-picture operator equations and in terms of the stochastic evolution of the conditional state. The former formulation was analytically solvable for linear systems. However, the latter could also be solved analytically for simple linear systems, and had the advantage of giving an explanation for how well the feedback could perform.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 12, 2009•0 citations

TOWARDS QUANTUM CYBERNETICS: OPTIMAL FEEDBACK CONTROL IN QUANTUM BIO INFORMATICS

V. P. Belavkin

A brief account of the quantum information dynamics and dynamical programming methods for the purpose of optimal control in quantum cybernetics with convex constraints and cońcave cost and bequest functions of the quantum state is given. Consideration is given to both open loop and feedback control schemes corresponding respectively to deterministic and stochastic semi-Markov dynamics of stable or unstable systems. For the quantum feedback control scheme with continuous observations we exploit the separation theorem of filtering and control aspects for quantum stochastic micro-dynamics of the total system. This allows to start with the Belavkin quantum filtering equation and derive the generalized Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman equation using standard arguments of classical control theory. This is equivalent to a Hamilton-Jacobi equation with an extra linear dissipative term if the control is restricted to only Hamiltonian terms in the filtering equation. A controlled qubit is considered as an example throughout the development of the formalism. Finally, we discuss optimum observation strategies to obtain a pure quantum qubit state from a mixed one.

Quantum Bio-Informatics•Feb 1, 2009•1 citation

Measurement-Based Feedback of Open Quantum Systems: A Control-Theoretic Review and Tutorial

Weichao Liang, Jing Zhang, Gaoyue Guo +1 more

This review develops a control-theoretic perspective on measurement-based feedback for continuously monitored open quantum systems, with the main analysis focused on finite-dimensional systems governed by diffusive stochastic master equations. We introduce the relevant state-space, invariant-subspace, and quantum non-demolition structures, interpret quantum filtering as nonlinear observer dynamics, and review open-loop asymptotics, filter stability, state-feedback stabilization, robustness, and reduced-order observer-based control. Particular emphasis is placed on a recurrence--contraction framework, in which Hamiltonian feedback removes non-target invariant obstructions while measurement-induced dynamics provide local exponential contraction. Although the detailed analysis is developed for finite-dimensional diffusive models, the underlying measurement--estimation--feedback architecture is relevant across a broad range of quantum platforms. We further discuss implementation challenges and open problems involving scalable estimation, sampling and delay, adaptation, hybrid and non-Markovian dynamics, practical stability, optimal control, and learning-based design. By organizing these developments around invariance, estimation, recurrence, and contraction, the review provides a tutorial bridge between measurement-based quantum feedback and nonlinear stochastic control.

quant-pharXiv:2609.06111•Sep 8, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Filtering and Optimal Control

V. P. Belavkin, Simon Edwards

Quantum mechanical systems exhibit an inherently probabilistic nature upon measurement which excludes in principle the singular direct observability case. Quantum theory of time continuous measurements and quantum filtering developed by VPB on the basis of semi-Markov independent increment models for quantum noise and quantum nondemolition (QND) observability is generalized for demolition indirect measurements of quantum unstable systems satisfying the microcausality principle. The reduced quantum feedback-controlled dynamics is described both by linear semi-Markov and nonlinear conditionally-Markov stochastic master equations. Using this scheme for diffusive and counting measurement to describe the stochastic evolution of the open quantum system under the continuous indirect observation and working in parallel with classical indeterministic control theory, we show the conditionally-Markov Bellman equations for optimal feedback control of the a posteriori stochastic quantum states conditioned upon these measurements. The resulting Bellman equation for the diffusive observation is then applied to the explicitly solvable quantum linear-quadratic-Gaussian (LQG) problem which emphasizes many similarities with the corresponding classical control problem.

Quantum Stochastics and Information•Aug 1, 2008•41 citations
Quantum feedback control is the control of the dynamics of a quantum system by feeding back (in real time) the results of monitoring that system. For systems with linear dynamics, the control problem is amenable to exact analysis. In these cases, the quantum system is equivalent to a stochastic system of classical phase-space variables with linear drift and constant diffusion, and with a measured current (e.g. a homodyne photocurrent) linear in the system variables. However, the classical evolution is constrained in order to represent valid quantum evolution. We quantify this in terms of a linear matrix inequality (LMI) relating the drift and diffusion (a sort of zero temperature fluctuation-dissipation theorem), and another LMI for the covariance matrix of the possible conditioned states (i.e. under all possible monitoring schemes consistent with the master equation). For manipulable systems (i.e. where the experimenter has arbitrary control over the parameters in a Hamiltonian linear in the system variables) the covariance of the conditioned state is all that is needed to calculate the effectiveness of the feedback. In this case the double optimization problem reduces to a semidefinite program, which can be solved efficiently in general. We illustrate this with an example drawn from quantum optics.
In many optical and atomic systems it is now possible to monitor an individual quantum system with high signal to noise and feed back by altering the system dynamics in real time. This motivates further development of quantum mechanical descriptions of feedback control. We discuss recent work on closed loop control of open quantum systems, focusing on general linear systems for which the statistics of the problem are Gaussian. Such systems may be realized with linear optics, parametric amplifiers and homodyne detection. This problem allows a direct comparison with the classical linear, quadratic cost, Gaussian noise (LQG) optimal control problem. This highlights the key distinction between the quantum and classical theories for linear systems: that increased measurement sensitivity may run counter to the control objectives since it increases the backaction noise. While in an idealized classical control problem it is always preferable to obtain a better sensor, quantum mechanical problems generically have an optimal sensitivity since quantum mechanical measurements irreducibly disturb the system. The general theory will be illustrated by reference to specific simple examples.
For quantum systems with linear dynamics in phase space much of classical feedback control theory applies. However, there are some questions that are sensible only for the quantum case: Given a fixed interaction between the system and the environment what is the optimal measurement on the environment for a particular control problem? We show that for a broad class of optimal (state-based) control problems (the stationary linear-quadratic-Gaussian class), this question is a semidefinite program. Moreover, the answer also applies to Markovian (current-based) feedback.
In the preceding chapter we introduced quantum feedback control, devoting most space to the continuous feedback control of a localized quantum system. That is, we considered feeding back the current resulting from the monitoring of that system to control a parameter in the system Hamiltonian. We described feedback both in terms of Heisenberg-picture operator equations and in terms of the stochastic evolution of the conditional state. The former formulation was analytically solvable for linear systems. However, the latter could also be solved analytically for simple linear systems, and had the advantage of giving an explanation for how well the feedback could perform.
A brief account of the quantum information dynamics and dynamical programming methods for the purpose of optimal control in quantum cybernetics with convex constraints and cońcave cost and bequest functions of the quantum state is given. Consideration is given to both open loop and feedback control schemes corresponding respectively to deterministic and stochastic semi-Markov dynamics of stable or unstable systems. For the quantum feedback control scheme with continuous observations we exploit the separation theorem of filtering and control aspects for quantum stochastic micro-dynamics of the total system. This allows to start with the Belavkin quantum filtering equation and derive the generalized Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman equation using standard arguments of classical control theory. This is equivalent to a Hamilton-Jacobi equation with an extra linear dissipative term if the control is restricted to only Hamiltonian terms in the filtering equation. A controlled qubit is considered as an example throughout the development of the formalism. Finally, we discuss optimum observation strategies to obtain a pure quantum qubit state from a mixed one.
This review develops a control-theoretic perspective on measurement-based feedback for continuously monitored open quantum systems, with the main analysis focused on finite-dimensional systems governed by diffusive stochastic master equations. We introduce the relevant state-space, invariant-subspace, and quantum non-demolition structures, interpret quantum filtering as nonlinear observer dynamics, and review open-loop asymptotics, filter stability, state-feedback stabilization, robustness, and reduced-order observer-based control. Particular emphasis is placed on a recurrence--contraction framework, in which Hamiltonian feedback removes non-target invariant obstructions while measurement-induced dynamics provide local exponential contraction. Although the detailed analysis is developed for finite-dimensional diffusive models, the underlying measurement--estimation--feedback architecture is relevant across a broad range of quantum platforms. We further discuss implementation challenges and open problems involving scalable estimation, sampling and delay, adaptation, hybrid and non-Markovian dynamics, practical stability, optimal control, and learning-based design. By organizing these developments around invariance, estimation, recurrence, and contraction, the review provides a tutorial bridge between measurement-based quantum feedback and nonlinear stochastic control.
Quantum mechanical systems exhibit an inherently probabilistic nature upon measurement which excludes in principle the singular direct observability case. Quantum theory of time continuous measurements and quantum filtering developed by VPB on the basis of semi-Markov independent increment models for quantum noise and quantum nondemolition (QND) observability is generalized for demolition indirect measurements of quantum unstable systems satisfying the microcausality principle. The reduced quantum feedback-controlled dynamics is described both by linear semi-Markov and nonlinear conditionally-Markov stochastic master equations. Using this scheme for diffusive and counting measurement to describe the stochastic evolution of the open quantum system under the continuous indirect observation and working in parallel with classical indeterministic control theory, we show the conditionally-Markov Bellman equations for optimal feedback control of the a posteriori stochastic quantum states conditioned upon these measurements. The resulting Bellman equation for the diffusive observation is then applied to the explicitly solvable quantum linear-quadratic-Gaussian (LQG) problem which emphasizes many similarities with the corresponding classical control problem.