Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Europhysics Letters (EPL)

Popper's experiment with randomly paired photons in thermal state

Tao Peng, Jason Simon, Hui Chen, Roger H. French, Yanhua H. Shih

Published Jan 1, 2015• 7 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We realized Popper's thought experiment via the photon number fluctuation correlation measurement of random paired photons in thermal state. The experiment produces the same results as that of Kim and Shih in 1998 with entangled photon pairs, which agreed with Popper's prediction. Although the observation cannot be considered as a violation of the uncertainty relation as Popper believed, this experiment reveals a concern about nonlocal interference of a random photon pair, which involves the superposition of multi-photon amplitudes, and multi-photon detection events at a distance.

DOI
10.1209/0295-5075/109/14003

Related papers

Realism in the Realized Popper's Experiment

Geoffrey Hunter

The realization of Karl Popper's experiment by Shih and Kim (published 1999) produced the result that Popper hoped for: no ``action at a distance'' on one photon of an entangled pair when a measurement is made on the other photon. This experimental result is interpretable in local realistic terms: each photon has a definite position and transverse momentum most of the time; the position measurement on one photon (localization in a slit) disturbs the transverse momentum of that photon in a non-predictable way in accordance with the uncertainty principle; however, there is no effect on the other photon (the photon that is not in a slit) no action at a distance. The position measurement (localization within a slit) of the one photon destroys the coherence (entanglement) between the photons; i.e. decoherence occurs. This can be understood physically as an electromagnetic interaction between the photon in the slit and the electrons of the atoms in the surface of the solid that forms the slit.

arXiv:quant-ph/0507009•Jul 1, 2005•1 citation

Experimental Realization of Popper’s Experiment: Violation of Uncertainty Principle?

Yoon-Ho Kim, Rong Yu, Yanhua H. Shih

An entangled pair of photon 1 and 2 are emitted in opposite directions along the positive and negative x -axis. A narrow slit is placed in the path of photon 1 which provides precise knowledge about its position along the y -axis and because of the quantum entanglement this in turn provides precise knowledge of the position y of its twin, photon 2. Does photon 2 experience a greater uncertainty in its momentum, i.e., a greater Δ p y , due to the precise knowledge of its position y ? This is the historical thought experiment of Sir Karl Popper which was aimed to undermine the Copenhagen interpretation in favor of a realistic viewpoint of quantum mechanics. Thispaper reports an experimental realization of the Popper’s experiment. One may not agree with Popper’s position on quantum mechanics; however, it calls for a correct understanding and interpretation of the experimental results. These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

Kluwer Academic Publishers eBooks•Dec 19, 2005•4 citations

Experimental Realization of Popper's Experiment - Violation of The Uncertainty Principle?

Yanhua H. Shih, Yoon-Ho Kim

Uncertainty, being perhaps the most basic principle of quantum mechanics, distinguishes the world of quantum phenomena from the realm of classical physics. Quantum entanglement, being perhaps the most surprising consequence of quantum mechanics, on the other hand apparently suggests paradoxes relating to or violations of the quantum mechanical uncertainty principle in some experimental situations. Popper's thought experiment is an example. We wish to report a recent realization of Popper's experiment. The experimental data show that there appears to be a violation of the uncertainty principle. This is, however as we shall argue in this paper, only an illusion provided that we take the teachings of quantum mechanics seriously.

Fortschritte der Physik•May 1, 2000•49 citations

Experimental realization of Popper's Experiment: Violation of the Uncertainty Principle?

Yoon-Ho Kim, Yanhua H. Shih

An entangled pair of photons (1 and 2) are emitted to opposite directions. A narrow slit is placed in the path of photon 1 to provide precise knowledge of its position on the $y$ axis and this also determines the precise $y$ position of its twin, photon 2, due to quantum entanglement. Is photon 2 going to experience a greater uncertainty in momentum, i.e., a greater $Δp_{y}$, due to the precise knowledge of its position $y$? The experimental data shows $ΔyΔp_{y}

arXiv:quant-ph/9905039•May 11, 1999•10 citations

Experimental realization of Popper's experiment

Y.-H. Kim, Yanhua H. Shih

Summary form only given. In early 1930's, Karl Popper, a metaphysical realist, proposed a thought experiment to support his realistic interpretation of quantum mechanics, which shared the same goal of the EPR gedankenexperiment. Based on the same EPR two-particle entangled state, Popper asked: if the precise position of particle 2 is known due to the precise measurement of the position for its entangled twin particle 1, does particle 2 experience a greater uncertainty in its momentum? This question has been ignored for many years. One may not like Popper's philosophy of quantum mechanics; however, his question is closely related to an important problem in recent hot applications: what one can predict for the remaining parts of an entangled state if one of the subsystems is measured alone? We have realized Popper's experiment with the use of entangled two-photon source of spontaneous parametric down conversion. We conclude from this experiment: in an entangled two-particle system, the precise knowledge of the position of a particle, which is determined by the two-particle entanglement, does not necessarily produce an uncertainty in its momentum.

Quantum Electronics and Laser Science Conference•Jan 20, 2003•0 citations

Two-Photon Interferometry II: Two-Photon Interference of Thermal Field

Yanhua H. Shih

The study of entangled states greatly advanced our understanding about two-photon interferometry. Two-photon interference is not the interference between two photons, it is about a pair of photons interfering with the pair itself. In the language of quantum theory, two-photon interference is the result of superposition between different yet indistinguishable two-photon probability amplitudes. Under certain conditions, the observed second-order interference can be factorized into a product of two individual classic first-order interferences. In this case, the interference is not only observable from the intensity fluctuation correlation measurement, or from the photon number fluctuation correlation measurement, of two photodetectors, but also observable in the counting rate of each individual photodetector. It may not be uneasy to accept the quantum concept of two-photon interference for “classical” thermal radiation. Indeed, the radiation Planck dealt with was “classical” thermal light. Perhaps, no one would even expect observing nontrivial second-order correlation from a laser beam, since laser field is non-Gaussin.

CRC Press eBooks•Dec 16, 2020•0 citations
We realized Popper's thought experiment via the photon number fluctuation correlation measurement of random paired photons in thermal state. The experiment produces the same results as that of Kim and Shih in 1998 with entangled photon pairs, which agreed with Popper's prediction. Although the observation cannot be considered as a violation of the uncertainty relation as Popper believed, this experiment reveals a concern about nonlocal interference of a random photon pair, which involves the superposition of multi-photon amplitudes, and multi-photon detection events at a distance.
The realization of Karl Popper's experiment by Shih and Kim (published 1999) produced the result that Popper hoped for: no ``action at a distance'' on one photon of an entangled pair when a measurement is made on the other photon. This experimental result is interpretable in local realistic terms: each photon has a definite position and transverse momentum most of the time; the position measurement on one photon (localization in a slit) disturbs the transverse momentum of that photon in a non-predictable way in accordance with the uncertainty principle; however, there is no effect on the other photon (the photon that is not in a slit) no action at a distance. The position measurement (localization within a slit) of the one photon destroys the coherence (entanglement) between the photons; i.e. decoherence occurs. This can be understood physically as an electromagnetic interaction between the photon in the slit and the electrons of the atoms in the surface of the solid that forms the slit.
An entangled pair of photon 1 and 2 are emitted in opposite directions along the positive and negative x -axis. A narrow slit is placed in the path of photon 1 which provides precise knowledge about its position along the y -axis and because of the quantum entanglement this in turn provides precise knowledge of the position y of its twin, photon 2. Does photon 2 experience a greater uncertainty in its momentum, i.e., a greater Δ p y , due to the precise knowledge of its position y ? This is the historical thought experiment of Sir Karl Popper which was aimed to undermine the Copenhagen interpretation in favor of a realistic viewpoint of quantum mechanics. Thispaper reports an experimental realization of the Popper’s experiment. One may not agree with Popper’s position on quantum mechanics; however, it calls for a correct understanding and interpretation of the experimental results. These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.
Uncertainty, being perhaps the most basic principle of quantum mechanics, distinguishes the world of quantum phenomena from the realm of classical physics. Quantum entanglement, being perhaps the most surprising consequence of quantum mechanics, on the other hand apparently suggests paradoxes relating to or violations of the quantum mechanical uncertainty principle in some experimental situations. Popper's thought experiment is an example. We wish to report a recent realization of Popper's experiment. The experimental data show that there appears to be a violation of the uncertainty principle. This is, however as we shall argue in this paper, only an illusion provided that we take the teachings of quantum mechanics seriously.
An entangled pair of photons (1 and 2) are emitted to opposite directions. A narrow slit is placed in the path of photon 1 to provide precise knowledge of its position on the yyy axis and this also determines the precise yyy position of its twin, photon 2, due to quantum entanglement. Is photon 2 going to experience a greater uncertainty in momentum, i.e., a greater ΔpyΔp_{y}Δpy​, due to the precise knowledge of its position yyy? The experimental data shows $ΔyΔp_{y}
Summary form only given. In early 1930's, Karl Popper, a metaphysical realist, proposed a thought experiment to support his realistic interpretation of quantum mechanics, which shared the same goal of the EPR gedankenexperiment. Based on the same EPR two-particle entangled state, Popper asked: if the precise position of particle 2 is known due to the precise measurement of the position for its entangled twin particle 1, does particle 2 experience a greater uncertainty in its momentum? This question has been ignored for many years. One may not like Popper's philosophy of quantum mechanics; however, his question is closely related to an important problem in recent hot applications: what one can predict for the remaining parts of an entangled state if one of the subsystems is measured alone? We have realized Popper's experiment with the use of entangled two-photon source of spontaneous parametric down conversion. We conclude from this experiment: in an entangled two-particle system, the precise knowledge of the position of a particle, which is determined by the two-particle entanglement, does not necessarily produce an uncertainty in its momentum.
The study of entangled states greatly advanced our understanding about two-photon interferometry. Two-photon interference is not the interference between two photons, it is about a pair of photons interfering with the pair itself. In the language of quantum theory, two-photon interference is the result of superposition between different yet indistinguishable two-photon probability amplitudes. Under certain conditions, the observed second-order interference can be factorized into a product of two individual classic first-order interferences. In this case, the interference is not only observable from the intensity fluctuation correlation measurement, or from the photon number fluctuation correlation measurement, of two photodetectors, but also observable in the counting rate of each individual photodetector. It may not be uneasy to accept the quantum concept of two-photon interference for “classical” thermal radiation. Indeed, the radiation Planck dealt with was “classical” thermal light. Perhaps, no one would even expect observing nontrivial second-order correlation from a laser beam, since laser field is non-Gaussin.