Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Conference on the Foundations of Quantum Mechanics: Historical Analysis and Open Questions

MACH-ZEHNDER INTERFEROMETER AND QUANTITATIVE COMPLEMENTARITY

Carlo Tarsitani, Fabrizio Logiurato

Published Jun 1, 2006• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The complementarity principle is often stated as the impossibility to perform an experiment by which both the effects of the wave-like behaviour and the effects of the particle-like behaviour of quantum objects can be simultaneously tested. For instance, in the Mach-Zehnder two-way interferometer, the effect of interference is destroyed whenever we insert a device that allows us to know which of the two paths has been chosen by each photon. Interference effects and “which-way” experiments are mutually exclusive. In the present paper we focus our attention on an ideal situation in order to show the validity of a quantitative representation of complementarity principle, which has been recently introduced. On this basis, we develop a simple conceptual analysis of the intimate connection between complementarity and uncertainty principles.

DOI
10.1142/9789812773258_0027

Related papers

Complementarity and Uncertainty in Mach-Zehnder Interferometry and beyond

Paul Busch, C. R. Shilladay

A coherent account of the connections and contrasts between the principles of com-plementarity and uncertainty is developed starting from a survey of the various formalizations of these principles. The conceptual analysis is illustrated by means of a set of experimental schemes based on Mach-Zehnder interferometry. In particu-lar, path detection via entanglement with a probe system and (quantitative) quan-tum erasure are exhibited to constitute instances of joint unsharp measurements of complementary pairs of physical quantities, path and interference observables. The analysis uses the representation of observables as positive-operator-valued measures (POVMs). The reconciliation of complementary experimental options in the sense of simultaneous unsharp preparations and measurements is expressed in terms of uncertainty relations of different kinds. The feature of complementarity, manifest in the present examples in the mutual exclusivity of path detection and interference observation, is recovered as a limit case from the appropriate uncertainty relation. It is noted that the complementarity and uncertainty principles are neither completely logically independent nor logical consequences of one another. Since entanglement is an instance of the uncertainty of quantum properties (of compound systems), it is moot to play out uncertainty and entanglement against each other as possible mechanisms enforcing complementarity.

•Sep 6, 2006•60 citations

Complementarity and uncertainty in quantum interference

C. R. Shilladay

This thesis is concerned with the notions of complementarity and uncertainty encountered in quantum mechanics. Its starting point is an assessment of how these concepts have been represented and illustrated by various writers dating back to their inception. Following the survey a coherent account of the connections and contrasts between complementarity and uncertainty is developed in the context of Mach-Zehnder interferometry. The effect on the interference pattern contrast of path detection via entanglement with a probe system, is explored and a joint unsharp measurement scheme of the complementary pairs, path and interference, described. The Mach-Zehnder set-up proves sufficiently versatile to show that quantum erasure and quantitative quantum erasure constitute instances of joint unsharp measurement of complementary observables. The analysis uses the representation of observables as positive operator valued measures.Path detection and interference observation require different experimental set-ups but can be reconciled in the simultaneous unsharp measurement and preparation. This reconciliation is expressed as an uncertainty relation however the mutually exclusive feature of complementarity is not discarded. It is possible to recover strict complementarity as a limit case of the appropriate uncertainty relation.One motivation for this study is the effort some authors have made in trying to express the founding features of quantum mechanics in the form of a hierarchy of significance. Here it is shown that complementarity and uncertainty have separate identities but are not completely independent of each other. Consequently, establishing a hierarchy of these features within the present formalism of quantum mechanics is not possible.

•Jan 1, 2007•0 citations

Quantum Optical Discussion of Uncertainty and Complementarity in a Mach-Zehnder Interferometer

Doron ludwin, Y. Ben-Aryeh, A. Mann

We discuss complementarity and uncertainty in a gedanken Which-Way (Welcher-Weg) experiment in a Mach-Zehnder interferometer. Although a Welcher-Weg measurement can be performed with only a negligible amount of momentum change in the detector itself, the change in the interference pattern must correspond to a change in the momentum distribution of the particle. Entanglement between the Mach-Zehnder interferometer and the Welcher-Weg measurement introduces orthogonality that disables the interference of the particle, but simultaneously, it also generates a momentum transfer between the particle and other parts of the whole entangled system (including macroscopic parts). This analysis can be related to the Delayed Choice interpretation. We show where the momentum change takes place and we conclude that entanglement is the key to understand how complementarity (i.e. Which Way versus interference) and the position-momentum uncertainty relation are interwoven.

arXiv:quant-ph/0008096•Aug 23, 2000•0 citations

Elementary analysis of interferometers for wave—particle duality test and the prospect of going beyond the complementarity principle

Zhiyuan Li

A distinct method to show a quantum object behaving both as wave and as particle is proposed and described in some detail. We make a systematic analysis using the elementary methodology of quantum mechanics upon Young's two-slit interferometer and the Mach—Zehnder two-arm interferometer with the focus placed on how to measure the interference pattern (wave nature) and the which-way information (particle nature) of quantum objects. We design several schemes to simultaneously acquire the which-way information for an individual quantum object and the high-contrast interference pattern for an ensemble of these quantum objects by placing two sets of measurement instruments that are well separated in space and whose perturbation of each other is negligibly small within the interferometer at the same time. Yet, improper arrangement and cooperation of these two sets of measurement instruments in the interferometer would lead to failure of simultaneous observation of wave and particle behaviors. The internal freedoms of quantum objects could be harnessed to probe both the which-way information and the interference pattern for the center-of-mass motion. That quantum objects can behave beyond the wave—particle duality and the complementarity principle would stimulate new conceptual examination and exploration of quantum theory at a deeper level.

arXiv:1409.1652•Chinese Physics B•Nov 1, 2014•13 citations

Experimental analysis of the quantum complementarity principle

R. Auccaise, Roberto M. Serra, Jefferson Gonçalves Filgueiras +3 more

One of the milestones of quantum mechanics is Bohr's complementarity principle. It states that a single quantum can exhibit a particlelike $or$ a wavelike behavior, but never both at the same time. These are mutually exclusive and complementary aspects of the quantum system. This means that we need distinct experimental arrangements in order to measure the particle or the wave nature of a physical system. One of the most known representations of this principle is the single-photon Mach-Zehnder interferometer. When the interferometer is closed an interference pattern is observed (wave aspect of the quantum) while if it is open, the quantum behaves like a particle. Here, using a molecular quantum information processor and employing nuclear magnetic resonant (NMR) techniques, we analyze the quantum version of this principle by means of an interferometer that is in a quantum superposition of being closed and open, and confirm that we can indeed measure both aspects of the system with the same experimental apparatus. More specifically, we observe with a single apparatus the interference between the particle and the wave aspects of a quantum system.

arXiv:1201.5951•Physical Review A•Mar 21, 2012•75 citations

Estudio del borrador cuántico con interferómetro

Ámbar Pérez García

This end-of-degree work arises from the motivation to carry out a dual study in which a theoretical development and its corresponding experimental verification are complemented. For this purpose, the analysis of a quantum eraser using a Mach-Zehnder interferometer in order to reproduce the experiences predicted by quantum physics with the laboratory experiment. The strategy followed has consisted of a bibliographic review that allows the selection of the most relevant documentation, followed by the realization of the experimental assembly to begin with a series of qualitative tests on its functioning. It should be borne in mind that during the entire work two theories are being used simultaneously, quantum mechanics and classical electromagnetism. It is of great interest to carry out this task since it involves bringing closer, in a simple and visual way, certain phenomena of quantum physics that are difficult to understand because they are quite unintuitive, such as complementarity or non-locality. To this end, several schemes of quantum erasure have been described from the formalism of quantum physics using the Mach-Zehnder interferometer, making it easier to understand with different graphics and descriptive diagrams. It also includes photographs of the instrument used in the laboratory, together with explanations of the tests carried out. From the analysis exposed throughout the report, three fundamental aspects of quantum theory could be observed. Firstly, the wave-particle duality is present at all times as it is proven that the character of the particle depends on the capability of the experimenter to access the information of the path he has taken. When the paths are indistinguishable, the interference pattern can be observed as a consequence of the undulatory behavior of the particles. The wave function will be divided in two and each part will run through one of the arms, producing the interference between them at the output of the interferometer. If the paths are marked using polarizers, the particle will only be able to go through one of them, going on to behave like a corpuscle. Secondly, Bohr’s principle of complementarity has been confirmed. The complementary properties cannot be measured or observed simultaneously, in this case, the lines of interference and the path of the photon. When the polarizers are placed, a entangle state is generated between the path followed by the photon and its polarization. Under this circumstance, to know the polarization of the photon is to know the path it has taken, and therefore, its behavior must be corpuscular, disappearing the interference pattern. Thirdly, if we stopped having access to the information on the path followed by the particles, the undulatory character of the photons would be instantly recovered, this is a manifestation of the non-local character of quantum mechanics. Finally, the main objective has been achieved: to elaborate a Mach-Zehnder interferometer that meets the requirements to behave like a quantum eraser. Pending the extension of the project to use the quantum eraser with Mach-Zehnder interferometer to interpret the delayed choice measurements.

Scientia Insularum Revista de Ciencias Naturales en islas•Jan 1, 2019•0 citations
The complementarity principle is often stated as the impossibility to perform an experiment by which both the effects of the wave-like behaviour and the effects of the particle-like behaviour of quantum objects can be simultaneously tested. For instance, in the Mach-Zehnder two-way interferometer, the effect of interference is destroyed whenever we insert a device that allows us to know which of the two paths has been chosen by each photon. Interference effects and “which-way” experiments are mutually exclusive. In the present paper we focus our attention on an ideal situation in order to show the validity of a quantitative representation of complementarity principle, which has been recently introduced. On this basis, we develop a simple conceptual analysis of the intimate connection between complementarity and uncertainty principles.
A coherent account of the connections and contrasts between the principles of com-plementarity and uncertainty is developed starting from a survey of the various formalizations of these principles. The conceptual analysis is illustrated by means of a set of experimental schemes based on Mach-Zehnder interferometry. In particu-lar, path detection via entanglement with a probe system and (quantitative) quan-tum erasure are exhibited to constitute instances of joint unsharp measurements of complementary pairs of physical quantities, path and interference observables. The analysis uses the representation of observables as positive-operator-valued measures (POVMs). The reconciliation of complementary experimental options in the sense of simultaneous unsharp preparations and measurements is expressed in terms of uncertainty relations of different kinds. The feature of complementarity, manifest in the present examples in the mutual exclusivity of path detection and interference observation, is recovered as a limit case from the appropriate uncertainty relation. It is noted that the complementarity and uncertainty principles are neither completely logically independent nor logical consequences of one another. Since entanglement is an instance of the uncertainty of quantum properties (of compound systems), it is moot to play out uncertainty and entanglement against each other as possible mechanisms enforcing complementarity.
This thesis is concerned with the notions of complementarity and uncertainty encountered in quantum mechanics. Its starting point is an assessment of how these concepts have been represented and illustrated by various writers dating back to their inception. Following the survey a coherent account of the connections and contrasts between complementarity and uncertainty is developed in the context of Mach-Zehnder interferometry. The effect on the interference pattern contrast of path detection via entanglement with a probe system, is explored and a joint unsharp measurement scheme of the complementary pairs, path and interference, described. The Mach-Zehnder set-up proves sufficiently versatile to show that quantum erasure and quantitative quantum erasure constitute instances of joint unsharp measurement of complementary observables. The analysis uses the representation of observables as positive operator valued measures.Path detection and interference observation require different experimental set-ups but can be reconciled in the simultaneous unsharp measurement and preparation. This reconciliation is expressed as an uncertainty relation however the mutually exclusive feature of complementarity is not discarded. It is possible to recover strict complementarity as a limit case of the appropriate uncertainty relation.One motivation for this study is the effort some authors have made in trying to express the founding features of quantum mechanics in the form of a hierarchy of significance. Here it is shown that complementarity and uncertainty have separate identities but are not completely independent of each other. Consequently, establishing a hierarchy of these features within the present formalism of quantum mechanics is not possible.
We discuss complementarity and uncertainty in a gedanken Which-Way (Welcher-Weg) experiment in a Mach-Zehnder interferometer. Although a Welcher-Weg measurement can be performed with only a negligible amount of momentum change in the detector itself, the change in the interference pattern must correspond to a change in the momentum distribution of the particle. Entanglement between the Mach-Zehnder interferometer and the Welcher-Weg measurement introduces orthogonality that disables the interference of the particle, but simultaneously, it also generates a momentum transfer between the particle and other parts of the whole entangled system (including macroscopic parts). This analysis can be related to the Delayed Choice interpretation. We show where the momentum change takes place and we conclude that entanglement is the key to understand how complementarity (i.e. Which Way versus interference) and the position-momentum uncertainty relation are interwoven.
A distinct method to show a quantum object behaving both as wave and as particle is proposed and described in some detail. We make a systematic analysis using the elementary methodology of quantum mechanics upon Young's two-slit interferometer and the Mach—Zehnder two-arm interferometer with the focus placed on how to measure the interference pattern (wave nature) and the which-way information (particle nature) of quantum objects. We design several schemes to simultaneously acquire the which-way information for an individual quantum object and the high-contrast interference pattern for an ensemble of these quantum objects by placing two sets of measurement instruments that are well separated in space and whose perturbation of each other is negligibly small within the interferometer at the same time. Yet, improper arrangement and cooperation of these two sets of measurement instruments in the interferometer would lead to failure of simultaneous observation of wave and particle behaviors. The internal freedoms of quantum objects could be harnessed to probe both the which-way information and the interference pattern for the center-of-mass motion. That quantum objects can behave beyond the wave—particle duality and the complementarity principle would stimulate new conceptual examination and exploration of quantum theory at a deeper level.
One of the milestones of quantum mechanics is Bohr's complementarity principle. It states that a single quantum can exhibit a particlelike ororor a wavelike behavior, but never both at the same time. These are mutually exclusive and complementary aspects of the quantum system. This means that we need distinct experimental arrangements in order to measure the particle or the wave nature of a physical system. One of the most known representations of this principle is the single-photon Mach-Zehnder interferometer. When the interferometer is closed an interference pattern is observed (wave aspect of the quantum) while if it is open, the quantum behaves like a particle. Here, using a molecular quantum information processor and employing nuclear magnetic resonant (NMR) techniques, we analyze the quantum version of this principle by means of an interferometer that is in a quantum superposition of being closed and open, and confirm that we can indeed measure both aspects of the system with the same experimental apparatus. More specifically, we observe with a single apparatus the interference between the particle and the wave aspects of a quantum system.
This end-of-degree work arises from the motivation to carry out a dual study in which a theoretical development and its corresponding experimental verification are complemented. For this purpose, the analysis of a quantum eraser using a Mach-Zehnder interferometer in order to reproduce the experiences predicted by quantum physics with the laboratory experiment. The strategy followed has consisted of a bibliographic review that allows the selection of the most relevant documentation, followed by the realization of the experimental assembly to begin with a series of qualitative tests on its functioning. It should be borne in mind that during the entire work two theories are being used simultaneously, quantum mechanics and classical electromagnetism. It is of great interest to carry out this task since it involves bringing closer, in a simple and visual way, certain phenomena of quantum physics that are difficult to understand because they are quite unintuitive, such as complementarity or non-locality. To this end, several schemes of quantum erasure have been described from the formalism of quantum physics using the Mach-Zehnder interferometer, making it easier to understand with different graphics and descriptive diagrams. It also includes photographs of the instrument used in the laboratory, together with explanations of the tests carried out. From the analysis exposed throughout the report, three fundamental aspects of quantum theory could be observed. Firstly, the wave-particle duality is present at all times as it is proven that the character of the particle depends on the capability of the experimenter to access the information of the path he has taken. When the paths are indistinguishable, the interference pattern can be observed as a consequence of the undulatory behavior of the particles. The wave function will be divided in two and each part will run through one of the arms, producing the interference between them at the output of the interferometer. If the paths are marked using polarizers, the particle will only be able to go through one of them, going on to behave like a corpuscle. Secondly, Bohr’s principle of complementarity has been confirmed. The complementary properties cannot be measured or observed simultaneously, in this case, the lines of interference and the path of the photon. When the polarizers are placed, a entangle state is generated between the path followed by the photon and its polarization. Under this circumstance, to know the polarization of the photon is to know the path it has taken, and therefore, its behavior must be corpuscular, disappearing the interference pattern. Thirdly, if we stopped having access to the information on the path followed by the particles, the undulatory character of the photons would be instantly recovered, this is a manifestation of the non-local character of quantum mechanics. Finally, the main objective has been achieved: to elaborate a Mach-Zehnder interferometer that meets the requirements to behave like a quantum eraser. Pending the extension of the project to use the quantum eraser with Mach-Zehnder interferometer to interpret the delayed choice measurements.