Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Philosophy of Science

The Many-Worlds Interpretation and Quantum Computation

Armond Duwell

Published Dec 1, 2007• 14 citations
Publisher

Abstract

David Deutsch and others have suggested that the Many-Worlds Interpretation of quantum mechanics is the only interpretation capable of explaining the special efficiency quantum computers seem to enjoy over classical ones. I argue that this view is not tenable. Using a toy algorithm I show that the Many-Worlds Interpretation must crucially use the ontological status of the universal state vector to explain quantum computational efficiency, as opposed to the particular ontology of the MWI, that is, the computational histories of worlds. As such, any other interpretation that treats the state vector as representing real ontological features of a system can explain quantum speedup too.

DOI
10.1086/525640

Related papers

Why the Many-Worlds Interpretation?

Lev Vaidman A

A brief (subjective) description of the state of the art of the many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics (MWI) is presented. It is argued that the MWI is the only interpretation which removes action at a distance and randomness from quantum theory. Limitations of the MWI regarding questions of probability which can be legitimately asked are specified. The ontological picture of the MWI as a theory of the universal wave function decomposed into a superposition of world wave functions, the important parts of which are defined in three-dimensional space, is presented from the point of view of our particular branch. Some speculations about misconceptions, which apparently prevent the MWI from being in the consensus, are mentioned.

arXiv:2208.04618•Quantum Reports•Aug 4, 2022•24 citations

Pruned Histories and the Computational Multiverse: What Does Quantum Speedup Ontologically Require?

Ian Staley

Deutsch's influential argument holds that the exponential speedup of quantum algorithms such as Shor's is best explained by computation distributed across ontologically real parallel branches of the wavefunction. This paper interrogates that claim by asking what minimal ontological commitments are actually required to underwrite observed quantum computational advantages. Drawing on the framework of final-state constraints and informational pruning developed in prior work, we argue that Deutsch's computational argument depends on an unpruned Everettian ontology in which all branches persist as computational substrates. We show that pruned-histories interpretations—in which boundary conditions or decoherence-based selection mechanisms restrict the space of ontologically realized branches—can preserve the empirical predictions of quantum computation while denying the parallel-universes inference. The argument requires three positive commitments: a records-based criterion for ontological commitment, a thermodynamically graded boundary between unitary computation and outcome-stabilization, and a positive account of computational speedup grounded in global Hilbert-space structure and entanglement rather than in a population of parallel worlds. We situate this result within the ontological models framework and recent observer-dependence theorems—including Frauchiger-Renner, Bong et al., and Walleghem et al.—and engage directly with Hewitt-Horsman's functionalist defense of computational branch realism. We conclude that the Deutsch argument, while rhetorically powerful, is interpretation-laden rather than interpretation-neutral.

•May 11, 2026•0 citations

Pruned Histories and the Computational Multiverse: What Does Quantum Speedup Ontologically Require?

Ian Staley

Deutsch's influential argument holds that the exponential speedup of quantum algorithms such as Shor's is best explained by computation distributed across ontologically real parallel branches of the wavefunction. This paper interrogates that claim by asking what minimal ontological commitments are actually required to underwrite observed quantum computational advantages. Drawing on the framework of final-state constraints and informational pruning developed in prior work, we argue that Deutsch's computational argument depends on an unpruned Everettian ontology in which all branches persist as computational substrates. We show that pruned-histories interpretations—in which boundary conditions or decoherence-based selection mechanisms restrict the space of ontologically realized branches—can preserve the empirical predictions of quantum computation while denying the parallel-universes inference. The argument requires three positive commitments: a records-based criterion for ontological commitment, a thermodynamically graded boundary between unitary computation and outcome-stabilization, and a positive account of computational speedup grounded in global Hilbert-space structure and entanglement rather than in a population of parallel worlds. We situate this result within the ontological models framework and recent observer-dependence theorems—including Frauchiger-Renner, Bong et al., and Walleghem et al.—and engage directly with Hewitt-Horsman's functionalist defense of computational branch realism. We conclude that the Deutsch argument, while rhetorically powerful, is interpretation-laden rather than interpretation-neutral.

•Aug 11, 2026•0 citations

Many-Worlds Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics: A Paradoxical Picture

Amir Abbass Varshovi

The many-worlds interpretation (MWI) of quantum mechanics is studied from an unprecedented ontological perspective based on the reality of (semi-) deterministic parallel worlds in the interpretation. It is demonstrated that with thanks to the uncertainty principle there would be no consistent way to specify the correct ontology of the Universe, hence the MWI is subject to an inherent contradiction which claims that the world where we live in is unreal.

arXiv:2011.13928•Nov 27, 2020•0 citations

Branching Without Multiplicity: Structural Resolution of the Many-Worlds Assumption

Lisa Doumbouya

The Many-Worlds Interpretation (MWI) of quantum mechanics preserves unitary evolution by rejecting wavefunction collapse and treating all outcome branches as equally real. While mathematically consistent, this move elevates admissible descriptions of a system to ontological status without an accompanying principle of physical selection. In this paper, we argue that quantum branching need not imply ontological multiplicity once structural admissibility, temporal constraint, and recoverability are made explicit. Unitary evolution defines the space of allowable continuations, but only a subset of these persist forward in time due to structural resolution. Within this framework, the appearance of branching reflects under-resolved admissible paths rather than the realization of multiple worlds. Many-Worlds is thus reinterpreted as a transitional bookkeeping scaffold rather than a necessary ontological commitment.

•Dec 20, 2025•0 citations

Many Worlds? Everett, Quantum Theory, and Reality

Simon W. Saunders

Abstract What does realism about the quantum state imply? What follows when quantum theory is applied without restriction, if need be, to the whole universe? These are the questions which are debated in this book. All the chapters start from the point of realism, and based on the need, or the aspiration, for a theory that unites micro- and macroworlds, at least in principle. But the further claim argued by some is that if you allow the Schrödinger equation unrestricted application, supposing the quantum state to be something physically real, then this universe is one of countlessly many others, constantly branching in time, all of which are real. The result is the many worlds theory, also known as the Everett interpretation of quantum mechanics. The contrary claim sees this picture of many worlds as in no sense inherent in quantum mechanics, even when the latter is allowed unrestricted scope and even given that the quantum state itself is something physically real. For this picture of branching worlds fails to make physical sense, let alone common sense, even on its own terms. The status of these worlds, what they are made of, is never adequately explained. Ordinary ideas about time and identity over time become hopelessly compromised. The concept of probability itself is brought into question. This picture of many branching worlds is inchoate, it is a vision, an error. There are realist alternatives to many worlds, some even that preserve the Schrödinger equation unchanged. Twenty chapters, accompanied by commentaries and discussions, examine these claims and counterclaims in depth. They focus first on the question of ontology, the existence of worlds, second on the interpretation of probability, and third on alternatives or additions to many worlds. The introduction offers a helpful guide to the arguments for the Everett interpretation, particularly as they have been formulated in the last two decades.

•Jun 24, 2010•362 citations
David Deutsch and others have suggested that the Many-Worlds Interpretation of quantum mechanics is the only interpretation capable of explaining the special efficiency quantum computers seem to enjoy over classical ones. I argue that this view is not tenable. Using a toy algorithm I show that the Many-Worlds Interpretation must crucially use the ontological status of the universal state vector to explain quantum computational efficiency, as opposed to the particular ontology of the MWI, that is, the computational histories of worlds. As such, any other interpretation that treats the state vector as representing real ontological features of a system can explain quantum speedup too.
A brief (subjective) description of the state of the art of the many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics (MWI) is presented. It is argued that the MWI is the only interpretation which removes action at a distance and randomness from quantum theory. Limitations of the MWI regarding questions of probability which can be legitimately asked are specified. The ontological picture of the MWI as a theory of the universal wave function decomposed into a superposition of world wave functions, the important parts of which are defined in three-dimensional space, is presented from the point of view of our particular branch. Some speculations about misconceptions, which apparently prevent the MWI from being in the consensus, are mentioned.
Deutsch's influential argument holds that the exponential speedup of quantum algorithms such as Shor's is best explained by computation distributed across ontologically real parallel branches of the wavefunction. This paper interrogates that claim by asking what minimal ontological commitments are actually required to underwrite observed quantum computational advantages. Drawing on the framework of final-state constraints and informational pruning developed in prior work, we argue that Deutsch's computational argument depends on an unpruned Everettian ontology in which all branches persist as computational substrates. We show that pruned-histories interpretations—in which boundary conditions or decoherence-based selection mechanisms restrict the space of ontologically realized branches—can preserve the empirical predictions of quantum computation while denying the parallel-universes inference. The argument requires three positive commitments: a records-based criterion for ontological commitment, a thermodynamically graded boundary between unitary computation and outcome-stabilization, and a positive account of computational speedup grounded in global Hilbert-space structure and entanglement rather than in a population of parallel worlds. We situate this result within the ontological models framework and recent observer-dependence theorems—including Frauchiger-Renner, Bong et al., and Walleghem et al.—and engage directly with Hewitt-Horsman's functionalist defense of computational branch realism. We conclude that the Deutsch argument, while rhetorically powerful, is interpretation-laden rather than interpretation-neutral.
Deutsch's influential argument holds that the exponential speedup of quantum algorithms such as Shor's is best explained by computation distributed across ontologically real parallel branches of the wavefunction. This paper interrogates that claim by asking what minimal ontological commitments are actually required to underwrite observed quantum computational advantages. Drawing on the framework of final-state constraints and informational pruning developed in prior work, we argue that Deutsch's computational argument depends on an unpruned Everettian ontology in which all branches persist as computational substrates. We show that pruned-histories interpretations—in which boundary conditions or decoherence-based selection mechanisms restrict the space of ontologically realized branches—can preserve the empirical predictions of quantum computation while denying the parallel-universes inference. The argument requires three positive commitments: a records-based criterion for ontological commitment, a thermodynamically graded boundary between unitary computation and outcome-stabilization, and a positive account of computational speedup grounded in global Hilbert-space structure and entanglement rather than in a population of parallel worlds. We situate this result within the ontological models framework and recent observer-dependence theorems—including Frauchiger-Renner, Bong et al., and Walleghem et al.—and engage directly with Hewitt-Horsman's functionalist defense of computational branch realism. We conclude that the Deutsch argument, while rhetorically powerful, is interpretation-laden rather than interpretation-neutral.
The Many-Worlds Interpretation (MWI) of quantum mechanics preserves unitary evolution by rejecting wavefunction collapse and treating all outcome branches as equally real. While mathematically consistent, this move elevates admissible descriptions of a system to ontological status without an accompanying principle of physical selection. In this paper, we argue that quantum branching need not imply ontological multiplicity once structural admissibility, temporal constraint, and recoverability are made explicit. Unitary evolution defines the space of allowable continuations, but only a subset of these persist forward in time due to structural resolution. Within this framework, the appearance of branching reflects under-resolved admissible paths rather than the realization of multiple worlds. Many-Worlds is thus reinterpreted as a transitional bookkeeping scaffold rather than a necessary ontological commitment.
Abstract What does realism about the quantum state imply? What follows when quantum theory is applied without restriction, if need be, to the whole universe? These are the questions which are debated in this book. All the chapters start from the point of realism, and based on the need, or the aspiration, for a theory that unites micro- and macroworlds, at least in principle. But the further claim argued by some is that if you allow the Schrödinger equation unrestricted application, supposing the quantum state to be something physically real, then this universe is one of countlessly many others, constantly branching in time, all of which are real. The result is the many worlds theory, also known as the Everett interpretation of quantum mechanics. The contrary claim sees this picture of many worlds as in no sense inherent in quantum mechanics, even when the latter is allowed unrestricted scope and even given that the quantum state itself is something physically real. For this picture of branching worlds fails to make physical sense, let alone common sense, even on its own terms. The status of these worlds, what they are made of, is never adequately explained. Ordinary ideas about time and identity over time become hopelessly compromised. The concept of probability itself is brought into question. This picture of many branching worlds is inchoate, it is a vision, an error. There are realist alternatives to many worlds, some even that preserve the Schrödinger equation unchanged. Twenty chapters, accompanied by commentaries and discussions, examine these claims and counterclaims in depth. They focus first on the question of ontology, the existence of worlds, second on the interpretation of probability, and third on alternatives or additions to many worlds. The introduction offers a helpful guide to the arguments for the Everett interpretation, particularly as they have been formulated in the last two decades.