It is shown that the expressions for the free energy density of ideal quantum gases in the canonical and grand canonical ensembles, are identical up to additive terms which vanish in the thermodynamic limit.
A new method is proposed for a treatment of ideal quantum gases in the grand microcanonical ensemble near the thermodynamic limit. The method allows rigorous asymptotic calculations of the average number of particles and particle number fluctuations in the system with exactly fixed total energy. It also gives the finite-volume corrections for the total average number of particles and for higher moments of the particle number distribution in a grand microcanonical system approaching the thermodynamic limit. The present consideration confirms our previous findings that the scaled variance for particle number fluctuations in the grand microcanonical ensemble is different from that in the grand canonical ensemble even in the thermodynamic limit.
In this note an ideal Bose-Einstein and an ideal Fermi-Dirac gas are considered in the "limit L," i.e., in the limit in which the number of particles N and the volume V of the system are allowed to tend to infinity so as to keep VN a finite and nonzero constant. It is shown that, whatever the system of energy levels, the mean occupation numbers calculated on the basis of the grand canonical ensemble are in the limit L the same as those calculated on the basis of the canonical ensemble. The only requirement is that the mean total number of particles for the grand canonical ensemble be equal to the fixed total number of particles for the canonical ensemble.