Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Nonlinear Schrödinger equation and wave-function collapse: An unreliable consequence of the semiclassical approximation

Luca Bonci, Paolo Grigolini, Roberto Roncaglia, David Vitali

Published May 1, 1993• 25 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We consider the spin-boson model as a measurement device, with the 1/2-spin system acting as a pointer and the influence of the environment simulated by means of the interaction between the 1/2-spin system and a dissipative oscillator. In accordance with the recent finding of Bonilla and Guinea [L. L. Bonilla and F. Guinea, Phys. Rev. A 45, 7718 (1992)] the assumption that the oscillator is classical results, under specific conditions, in the occurrence of a wave-function collapse. However, our theoretical analysis shows that the wave-function collapse is provoked by the action exerted by the 1/2-spin system on the oscillator (reaction field) and that the reaction field is as intense as the quantum-mechanical fluctuation neglected by the semiclassical approximation. A numerical treatment shows that no collapse occurs within a fully-quantum-mechanical treatment.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.47.3538

Related papers

THE SPIN-BOSON MODEL AS A PROBLEM OF NONLINEAR STOCHASTIC PHYSICS

Paolo Grigolini

The semiclassical approximation to the spin-boson model leads to interesting nonlinear effects, triggered by the important action of the reaction field, namely the influence that the boson "bath" exerts on the spin system. This paper illustrates the quantum mechanical mamifestations of the semiclassical nonlinearity in a variety of conditions.

International Journal of Modern Physics B•Jan 20, 1992•11 citations

Beyond the semiclassical approximation of the discrete nonlinear Schrödinger equation: Collapses and revivals as a sign of quantum fluctuations

Luca Bonci, Paolo Grigolini, David Vitali

We study a two-state quantum-mechanical system, equivalent to a 1/2-spin dipole, with frequency ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\omega}}}_{0}$, linearly interacting with a set of quantum oscillators. The corresponding discrete nonlinear Schr\"odinger equation (DNSE) has been given an analytical solution by Kenkre and Campbell [Phys. Rev. B 34, 4959 (1986)]. We show that in the strong-coupling limit their analytical expression is recovered from our microscopic approach when the thermal and quantum fluctuations of the bath of oscillators are neglected. To take into account the influence of thermal and quantum fluctuations on the prediction of the DNSE in the strong-coupling limit, we adopt a straightforward procedure based on the direct evaluation of 〈${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}_{\mathit{x}}$(t)〉, under the assumption alone that the frequency ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\omega}}}_{0}$ is very weak. A special initial condition is used, with 〈${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}_{\mathit{x}}$(t)〉=1 and the oscillator at equilibrium in the corresponding effective potential. It is shown that in the strong-coupling limit this expression coincides with the noninteracting-blip approximation of Leggett et al. [Rev. Mod. Phys. 59, 1 (1987)] and the result of the equivalent projection approach of Aslangul, Pottier, and Saint-James [J. Phys. (Paris) 46, 2031 (1985); 47, 1657 (1986)]. Then, this expression is used to study the special case where the 1/2 spin interacts with only one oscillator at zero temperature. It is shown that the fast oscillations predicted by Kenkre and Campbell in the strong-coupling limit are damped by a Gaussian-like relaxation process provoked by the quantum fluctuations of the oscillator, which eventually lead to the destruction of the trapped state. These collapses are followed by periodical revivals reminiscent of those observed in quantum optics.

Physical Review A•Oct 1, 1990•23 citations

Wave-function collapse and the quantum fluctuation-dissipation process

David Vitali, L. Tessieri, Paolo Grigolini

We study the effect that the state-vector reduction of Ghirardi, Rimini, and Weber (GRW) [Phys. Rev. D 34, 470 (1986)] has on the quantum fluctuation-dissipation process. A conventional fluctuation-dissipation process stems from the interaction between a system of interest and a macroscopic number of microscopic variables, thereby suggesting the possible occurrence of an enhancement of the GRW wave-function collapse. We carry out an exact treatment of the joint action of conventional quantum dissipation and GRW wave-function collapse in the special case where the system of interest is a harmonic oscillator. We prove that the GRW dynamics does not lead to any significant departure from the predictions of ordinary quantum mechanics, if the region of astronomically large times is disregarded, where the energy of the system diverges as an effect of a slow but steady increase caused by the GRW collapses.

Physical Review A•Aug 1, 1994•5 citations

A model of wave function collapse in a quantum measurement of spin as the Schroedinger equation solution of a system with a simple harmonic oscillator in a bath

Li Hua Yu

We present a set of exact system solutions to a model we developed to study wave function collapse in the quantum spin measurement process. Specifically, we calculated the wave function evolution for a simple harmonic oscillator of spin \frac{1}{2}, with its magnetic moment in interaction with a magnetic field, coupled to an environment that is a bath of harmonic oscillators. The system's time evolution is described by the direct product of two independent Hilbert spaces: one that is defined by an effective Hamiltonian, which represents a damped simple harmonic oscillator with its potential well divided into two, based on the spin and the other that represents the effect of the bath, i.e., the Brownian motion. The initial states of this set of wave functions form an orthonormal basis, defined as the eigenstates of the system. If the system is initially in one of these states, the final result is predetermined, i.e., the measurement is deterministic. If the bath is initially in the ground state,and the wave function is initially a wave packet at the origin, it collapses into one of the two potential wells depending on the initial spin. If the initial spin is a vector in the Bloch sphere not parallel to the magnetic field, the final distribution among the two potential wells is given by the Born rule applied to the initial spin state with the well-known ground state width. Hence, the result is also predetermined. We discuss its implications to the Bell theorem[1]. We end with a summary of the implications for the understanding of the statistical interpretation of quantum mechanics.

arXiv:2304.03865•Apr 7, 2023•0 citations

Nonlinearity of Quantum Mechanics and Solution of the Problem of Wave Function Collapse

Alexey V. Melkikh

Abstract The problem of the wave function collapse (a problem of measurement in quantum mechanics) is considered. It is shown that it can be solved based on quantum mechanics and does not require any additional assumptions or new theories. The particle creation and annihilation processes, which are described based on quantum field theory, play a key role in the measurement processes. Superposition principle is not valid for the system of equations of quantum field theory for particles and fields, because this system is a non-linear. As a result of the creation (annihilation) of a particle, an additional uncertainty arises, which “smears” the interference pattern. The imposition of such a large number of uncertainties in the repetitive measurements leads to the classical behavior of particles. The decoherence theory also implies the creation and annihilation of particles, and this processes are the consequence of non-linearity of quantum mechanics. In this case, the term “collapse of the wave function” becomes a consequence of the other statements of quantum mechanics instead of a separate postulate of quantum mechanics.

Communications in Theoretical Physics•Jul 1, 2015•26 citations

Nonlinear effects in quantum dissipation

David Vitali, Paolo Grigolini

We study a two-level system linearly interacting with a set of quantum-mechanical oscillators, referred to as the ``bath.'' This system is formally equivalent to a magnetic dipole, with spin 1/2, precessing with the Larmor frequency ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\omega}}}_{0}$ around a fixed magnetic field along the z axis and undergoing the influence of a fluctuating field along the x axis. These bath fluctuations are not independent of the state of the spin, and the crucial problem to be studied in this paper is precisely how to take the reaction field, i.e., the influence of the bath on the system, into account. We find a general result based on neglecting a contribution to the reaction field proportional to ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}_{\mathit{x}}$(t)-〈${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}_{\mathit{x}}$(t)〉, where the angle brackets denote averaging on both the spin and the bath space, with a density matrix corresponding to the spin polarized along the x axis. We show that under the special condition that the spin does not significantly depart from its initial state, our general result turns out to coincide with the noninteracting-blip approximation (NBA) of Leggett and co-workers [Rev. Mod. Phys. 59, 1 (1987)]. When we make the assumption that both quantum and thermal fluctuations of the bath can be neglected and that the time scale of the bath is virtually zero (adiabatic assumption), our general result turns out to coincide with the prediction of the discrete nonlinear Schr\"odinger equation (DNSE) of Davydov and Kislukha [Phys. Status Solidi B 59, 465 (1973)] and Davydov $[---Biology and Quantum Mechanics (Pergamon, Oxford, 1982)] in the two-sites case.This means that the nonlinear effects proven by Kenkre and co-workers [Phys. Rev. B 34, 4959 (1986); 35, 1473 (1987)] to accompany a significant departure of the spin from the initial state are lost by the NBA. On the other hand, our approach provides a rigorous evaluation of the effects of the oscillator fluctuations on the predictions of the DNSE. It is shown that the quantum fluctuations might have a significant role also in the region of high temperature to which the nonadiabatic corrections of Kenkre and co-workers apply. Finally, it is shown that a still more accurate approximation would be that of neglecting a reaction field proportional to ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}_{\mathit{x}}$(t)-〈${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}_{\mathit{x}}$(t)${\mathrm{〉}}_{\mathit{s}}$, where 〈${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}_{\mathit{x}}$(t)${\mathrm{〉}}_{\mathit{s}}$ denotes an average carried out only on the spin space. This approximation leads our approach to coincide with the exact result in the special case where both the spin and its bath are replaced by their classical counterparts. Under this approximation, the detrapping would be equivalent to an Arrhenius-like thermal-activation process. When the coupling strength between the system and its bath is decreased, the spin is expected to depart from the initial trapped state. The dynamics of this process is expected to be influenced by the joint action of the bath fluctuations (both thermal and quantum mechanical) and of the nonlinearity stemming from the reaction field, and ignored by the NBA. This intriguing problem should be the subject of further investigations.

Physical Review A•Dec 1, 1990•21 citations
We consider the spin-boson model as a measurement device, with the 1/2-spin system acting as a pointer and the influence of the environment simulated by means of the interaction between the 1/2-spin system and a dissipative oscillator. In accordance with the recent finding of Bonilla and Guinea [L. L. Bonilla and F. Guinea, Phys. Rev. A 45, 7718 (1992)] the assumption that the oscillator is classical results, under specific conditions, in the occurrence of a wave-function collapse. However, our theoretical analysis shows that the wave-function collapse is provoked by the action exerted by the 1/2-spin system on the oscillator (reaction field) and that the reaction field is as intense as the quantum-mechanical fluctuation neglected by the semiclassical approximation. A numerical treatment shows that no collapse occurs within a fully-quantum-mechanical treatment.
We study a two-state quantum-mechanical system, equivalent to a 1/2-spin dipole, with frequency ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\omega}}}_{0}$, linearly interacting with a set of quantum oscillators. The corresponding discrete nonlinear Schr\"odinger equation (DNSE) has been given an analytical solution by Kenkre and Campbell [Phys. Rev. B 34, 4959 (1986)]. We show that in the strong-coupling limit their analytical expression is recovered from our microscopic approach when the thermal and quantum fluctuations of the bath of oscillators are neglected. To take into account the influence of thermal and quantum fluctuations on the prediction of the DNSE in the strong-coupling limit, we adopt a straightforward procedure based on the direct evaluation of 〈${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}_{\mathit{x}}$(t)〉, under the assumption alone that the frequency ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\omega}}}_{0}$ is very weak. A special initial condition is used, with 〈${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}_{\mathit{x}}$(t)〉=1 and the oscillator at equilibrium in the corresponding effective potential. It is shown that in the strong-coupling limit this expression coincides with the noninteracting-blip approximation of Leggett et al. [Rev. Mod. Phys. 59, 1 (1987)] and the result of the equivalent projection approach of Aslangul, Pottier, and Saint-James [J. Phys. (Paris) 46, 2031 (1985); 47, 1657 (1986)]. Then, this expression is used to study the special case where the 1/2 spin interacts with only one oscillator at zero temperature. It is shown that the fast oscillations predicted by Kenkre and Campbell in the strong-coupling limit are damped by a Gaussian-like relaxation process provoked by the quantum fluctuations of the oscillator, which eventually lead to the destruction of the trapped state. These collapses are followed by periodical revivals reminiscent of those observed in quantum optics.
We study the effect that the state-vector reduction of Ghirardi, Rimini, and Weber (GRW) [Phys. Rev. D 34, 470 (1986)] has on the quantum fluctuation-dissipation process. A conventional fluctuation-dissipation process stems from the interaction between a system of interest and a macroscopic number of microscopic variables, thereby suggesting the possible occurrence of an enhancement of the GRW wave-function collapse. We carry out an exact treatment of the joint action of conventional quantum dissipation and GRW wave-function collapse in the special case where the system of interest is a harmonic oscillator. We prove that the GRW dynamics does not lead to any significant departure from the predictions of ordinary quantum mechanics, if the region of astronomically large times is disregarded, where the energy of the system diverges as an effect of a slow but steady increase caused by the GRW collapses.
We present a set of exact system solutions to a model we developed to study wave function collapse in the quantum spin measurement process. Specifically, we calculated the wave function evolution for a simple harmonic oscillator of spin \frac{1}{2}, with its magnetic moment in interaction with a magnetic field, coupled to an environment that is a bath of harmonic oscillators. The system's time evolution is described by the direct product of two independent Hilbert spaces: one that is defined by an effective Hamiltonian, which represents a damped simple harmonic oscillator with its potential well divided into two, based on the spin and the other that represents the effect of the bath, i.e., the Brownian motion. The initial states of this set of wave functions form an orthonormal basis, defined as the eigenstates of the system. If the system is initially in one of these states, the final result is predetermined, i.e., the measurement is deterministic. If the bath is initially in the ground state,and the wave function is initially a wave packet at the origin, it collapses into one of the two potential wells depending on the initial spin. If the initial spin is a vector in the Bloch sphere not parallel to the magnetic field, the final distribution among the two potential wells is given by the Born rule applied to the initial spin state with the well-known ground state width. Hence, the result is also predetermined. We discuss its implications to the Bell theorem[1]. We end with a summary of the implications for the understanding of the statistical interpretation of quantum mechanics.
Abstract The problem of the wave function collapse (a problem of measurement in quantum mechanics) is considered. It is shown that it can be solved based on quantum mechanics and does not require any additional assumptions or new theories. The particle creation and annihilation processes, which are described based on quantum field theory, play a key role in the measurement processes. Superposition principle is not valid for the system of equations of quantum field theory for particles and fields, because this system is a non-linear. As a result of the creation (annihilation) of a particle, an additional uncertainty arises, which “smears” the interference pattern. The imposition of such a large number of uncertainties in the repetitive measurements leads to the classical behavior of particles. The decoherence theory also implies the creation and annihilation of particles, and this processes are the consequence of non-linearity of quantum mechanics. In this case, the term “collapse of the wave function” becomes a consequence of the other statements of quantum mechanics instead of a separate postulate of quantum mechanics.
We study a two-level system linearly interacting with a set of quantum-mechanical oscillators, referred to as the ``bath.'' This system is formally equivalent to a magnetic dipole, with spin 1/2, precessing with the Larmor frequency ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\omega}}}_{0}$ around a fixed magnetic field along the z axis and undergoing the influence of a fluctuating field along the x axis. These bath fluctuations are not independent of the state of the spin, and the crucial problem to be studied in this paper is precisely how to take the reaction field, i.e., the influence of the bath on the system, into account. We find a general result based on neglecting a contribution to the reaction field proportional to ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}_{\mathit{x}}$(t)-〈${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}_{\mathit{x}}$(t)〉, where the angle brackets denote averaging on both the spin and the bath space, with a density matrix corresponding to the spin polarized along the x axis. We show that under the special condition that the spin does not significantly depart from its initial state, our general result turns out to coincide with the noninteracting-blip approximation (NBA) of Leggett and co-workers [Rev. Mod. Phys. 59, 1 (1987)]. When we make the assumption that both quantum and thermal fluctuations of the bath can be neglected and that the time scale of the bath is virtually zero (adiabatic assumption), our general result turns out to coincide with the prediction of the discrete nonlinear Schr\"odinger equation (DNSE) of Davydov and Kislukha [Phys. Status Solidi B 59, 465 (1973)] and Davydov $[---Biology and Quantum Mechanics (Pergamon, Oxford, 1982)] in the two-sites case.This means that the nonlinear effects proven by Kenkre and co-workers [Phys. Rev. B 34, 4959 (1986); 35, 1473 (1987)] to accompany a significant departure of the spin from the initial state are lost by the NBA. On the other hand, our approach provides a rigorous evaluation of the effects of the oscillator fluctuations on the predictions of the DNSE. It is shown that the quantum fluctuations might have a significant role also in the region of high temperature to which the nonadiabatic corrections of Kenkre and co-workers apply. Finally, it is shown that a still more accurate approximation would be that of neglecting a reaction field proportional to ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}_{\mathit{x}}$(t)-〈${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}_{\mathit{x}}$(t)〉s{\mathrm{〉}}_{\mathit{s}}〉s​, where 〈${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}_{\mathit{x}}$(t)〉s{\mathrm{〉}}_{\mathit{s}}〉s​ denotes an average carried out only on the spin space. This approximation leads our approach to coincide with the exact result in the special case where both the spin and its bath are replaced by their classical counterparts. Under this approximation, the detrapping would be equivalent to an Arrhenius-like thermal-activation process. When the coupling strength between the system and its bath is decreased, the spin is expected to depart from the initial trapped state. The dynamics of this process is expected to be influenced by the joint action of the bath fluctuations (both thermal and quantum mechanical) and of the nonlinearity stemming from the reaction field, and ignored by the NBA. This intriguing problem should be the subject of further investigations.