Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

American Journal of Physics

Vindications of Dirac’s electron, 1932–1934

Donald Franklin Moyer

Published Dec 1, 1981• 23 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This is the last of a three-part series. The first essay in the series described Dirac’s generalizations of quantum mechanics leading to his theory of the electron. The second essay surveyed evaluations of Dirac’s theory by other physicists, especially by Bohr who used Dirac’s speculations about negative energy electrons as evidence for the failure of quantum mechanics at nuclear dimensions. This essay shows how the material reality of positrons vindicated quantum mechanics and opened new paths for physics.

DOI
10.1119/1.12559

Related papers

Evaluations of Dirac’s electron, 1928–1932

Donald Franklin Moyer

This the second of a three-part series. This essay surveys evaluations of Dirac’s theory by other physicists, especially by Bohr who used Dirac’s speculations about negative energy electrons as evidence for the failure of quantum mechanics at nuclear dimensions.

American Journal of Physics•Nov 1, 1981•34 citations

Origins of Dirac’s electron, 1925–1928

Donald Franklin Moyer

This is the first of a three-part series. This essay describes Dirac’s generalizations of quantum mechanics leading to his theory of the electron.

American Journal of Physics•Oct 1, 1981•31 citations

Quantum Mechanics

RICHARD E. FITZPATRICK

Quantum mechanics was developed during the first few decades of the twentieth century via a series of inspired guesses made by various physicists, including Planck, Einstein, Bohr, Schroedinger, Heisenberg, Pauli, and Dirac. All these scientists were trying to construct a self-consistent theory of microscopic dynamics that was compatible with experimental observations. The purpose of this book is to present quantum mechanics in a clear, concise, and systematic fashion, starting from the fundamental postulates, and developing the theory in as logical manner as possible. Topics covered in the book include the fundamental postulates of quantum mechanics, angular momentum, time-dependent and time-dependent perturbation theory, scattering theory, identical particles, and relativistic electron theory.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Apr 18, 2015•20 citations

Observability, Unobservability and the Copenhagen Interpretation in Dirac's Methodology of Physics

Andréa Oldofredi, Michaël Esfeld

Paul Dirac has been undoubtedly one of the central figures of the last century physics, contributing in several and remarkable ways to the development of quantum mechanics; he was also at the centre of an active community of physicists, with whom he had extensive interactions and correspondence. In particular, Dirac was in close contact with Bohr, Heisenberg and Pauli. For this reason, among others, Dirac is generally considered a supporter of the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics. Similarly, he was considered a physicist sympathetic with the positivistic attitude which shaped the development of quantum theory in the 1920s. Against this background, the aim of the present essay is twofold: on the one hand, we will argue that, analyzing specific examples taken from Dirac's published works, he can neither be considered a positivist nor a physicist methodologically guided by the observability doctrine. On the other hand, we will try to disentangle Dirac's figure from the mentioned Copenhagen interpretation, since in his long career he employed remarkably different—and often contradicting—methodological principles and philosophical perspectives with respect to those followed by the supporters of that interpretation. Quanta 2019; 8: 68–87.

arXiv:1911.02426•Quanta•Nov 10, 2019•4 citations

Quantum mechanics

Clive W. Kilmister

I conclude the first part of this book by carrying the story up to 1928, to the lightning flash in Eddington's mind produced by Dirac's paper on the wave equation of the electron. Setting out the context and Eddington's thinking about it is a very different matter for quantum mechanics and relativity. Both theories are commonly expressed in austere mathematical language. In the case of relativity the basic ideas behind the mathematics are now well understood and can be set out with little complication. These ideas were mostly already clear to Eddington. But for quantum mechanics the mathematics, yoked to the wealth of experimental results, drove the development of the theory at a breakneck speed, mostly without anyone pausing for deeper understanding. It is indeed only in the last decade that it has become generally accepted that quantum mechanics still lacks any coherent interpretation. To explain Eddington's context it is therefore necessary to say something about the mathematical formalism. It is true, as will become clear, that Eddington was a little more sceptical than most, but by and large the mathematics drove him as it did those directly working in the theory.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jan 26, 1995•0 citations

Antihydrogen

John Eades, Richard Hughes, Claus Zimmermann

In 1898, respectable physicists were permitted to speculate in Nature to an extent that would never be allowed today. Schuster's conjectures about “antiatoms” predate Dirac's prediction of “a new kind of particle, unknown to experimental physics, having the same mass and opposite charge to an electron” by 30 years. This new particle was needed to explain certain additional solutions of Dirac's relativistic version of quantum mechanics. Since them antielectrons (positrons), antiprotons and antineutrons have all been produced and detected. Today there is no known particle for which a corresponding antiparticle has not been observed, although in some cases, such as the photon, particle and antiparticle are identical. Almost a century after Schuster wrote to Nature, it at last appears feasible to synthesise the simplest antiatom, the positron-antiproton bound state known as antihydrogen. The prospect of applying high-precision spectroscopic techniques, perfected on hydrogen, to antihydrogen to test fundamental physical principles, makes antihydrogen much more interesting to the physicist than antigold.

Physics World•Jul 1, 1993•17 citations
This is the last of a three-part series. The first essay in the series described Dirac’s generalizations of quantum mechanics leading to his theory of the electron. The second essay surveyed evaluations of Dirac’s theory by other physicists, especially by Bohr who used Dirac’s speculations about negative energy electrons as evidence for the failure of quantum mechanics at nuclear dimensions. This essay shows how the material reality of positrons vindicated quantum mechanics and opened new paths for physics.
Quantum mechanics was developed during the first few decades of the twentieth century via a series of inspired guesses made by various physicists, including Planck, Einstein, Bohr, Schroedinger, Heisenberg, Pauli, and Dirac. All these scientists were trying to construct a self-consistent theory of microscopic dynamics that was compatible with experimental observations. The purpose of this book is to present quantum mechanics in a clear, concise, and systematic fashion, starting from the fundamental postulates, and developing the theory in as logical manner as possible. Topics covered in the book include the fundamental postulates of quantum mechanics, angular momentum, time-dependent and time-dependent perturbation theory, scattering theory, identical particles, and relativistic electron theory.
Paul Dirac has been undoubtedly one of the central figures of the last century physics, contributing in several and remarkable ways to the development of quantum mechanics; he was also at the centre of an active community of physicists, with whom he had extensive interactions and correspondence. In particular, Dirac was in close contact with Bohr, Heisenberg and Pauli. For this reason, among others, Dirac is generally considered a supporter of the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics. Similarly, he was considered a physicist sympathetic with the positivistic attitude which shaped the development of quantum theory in the 1920s. Against this background, the aim of the present essay is twofold: on the one hand, we will argue that, analyzing specific examples taken from Dirac's published works, he can neither be considered a positivist nor a physicist methodologically guided by the observability doctrine. On the other hand, we will try to disentangle Dirac's figure from the mentioned Copenhagen interpretation, since in his long career he employed remarkably different—and often contradicting—methodological principles and philosophical perspectives with respect to those followed by the supporters of that interpretation. Quanta 2019; 8: 68–87.
I conclude the first part of this book by carrying the story up to 1928, to the lightning flash in Eddington's mind produced by Dirac's paper on the wave equation of the electron. Setting out the context and Eddington's thinking about it is a very different matter for quantum mechanics and relativity. Both theories are commonly expressed in austere mathematical language. In the case of relativity the basic ideas behind the mathematics are now well understood and can be set out with little complication. These ideas were mostly already clear to Eddington. But for quantum mechanics the mathematics, yoked to the wealth of experimental results, drove the development of the theory at a breakneck speed, mostly without anyone pausing for deeper understanding. It is indeed only in the last decade that it has become generally accepted that quantum mechanics still lacks any coherent interpretation. To explain Eddington's context it is therefore necessary to say something about the mathematical formalism. It is true, as will become clear, that Eddington was a little more sceptical than most, but by and large the mathematics drove him as it did those directly working in the theory.
In 1898, respectable physicists were permitted to speculate in Nature to an extent that would never be allowed today. Schuster's conjectures about “antiatoms” predate Dirac's prediction of “a new kind of particle, unknown to experimental physics, having the same mass and opposite charge to an electron” by 30 years. This new particle was needed to explain certain additional solutions of Dirac's relativistic version of quantum mechanics. Since them antielectrons (positrons), antiprotons and antineutrons have all been produced and detected. Today there is no known particle for which a corresponding antiparticle has not been observed, although in some cases, such as the photon, particle and antiparticle are identical. Almost a century after Schuster wrote to Nature, it at last appears feasible to synthesise the simplest antiatom, the positron-antiproton bound state known as antihydrogen. The prospect of applying high-precision spectroscopic techniques, perfected on hydrogen, to antihydrogen to test fundamental physical principles, makes antihydrogen much more interesting to the physicist than antigold.