The observation of charge stripe order in the doped nickelate and cuprate materials has motivated much theoretical effort to understand the underlying mechanism of the stripe phase. Numerical studies of the Hubbard model show two possibilities: (i) stripe order arises from a tendency toward phase separation and its competition with the long-range Coulomb interaction or (ii) stripe order inherently arises as a compromise between itinerancy and magnetic interactions. Here we determine the restricted phase diagram of the two-dimensional Falicov-Kimball model and see that it displays rich behavior illustrating both possibilities in different regions.
We employ large-scale density-matrix renormalization group (DMRG) simulations to investigate the quantum phase diagram of the hole-doped Hubbard model on square lattices. By implementing a diagonally oriented square lattice and GPU-accelerated DMRG with up to
48000 states, we identify three distinct quantum phases across
δ=5% to
15% doping: (i) A diagonal stripe phase with short-range uniform superconductivity (SC) at lower doping
δ≲9%; (ii) An intermediate holon Wigner crystal (WC*) phase exhibiting bidirectional charge-density order and short-range SC with spatial oscillating correlations; (iii) An unprecedented infinite-length stripe (i-stripe) phase at
δ≳12% hosting long stripes spanning the whole lattice. Remarkably, as doping increases, the short-range SC in WC* phase evolves into a 2D-like pair density wave (PDW) with divergent susceptibility in the i-stripe phase, constituting probably the first controlled numerical evidence of dominant PDW in the single-band square-lattice Hubbard model. The established 2D-like PDW and its interplay with charge orders provide new perspectives on dynamical layer decoupling phenomena in cuprates and multifaceted relationships between charge, spin and SC orders in quantum materials.