Speculation on Energy and Potential Energy and Their Direct Link to Force
Francesco R. Ruggeri
In Newtonian mechanics, force and energy are clearly separated. For example, pp/2m = Integral F dx = Integral dp/dt dx = m/2 vv = pp/2m. The equation pp/2m + V(x) = E is considered to be strictly an energy equation. In special relativity, mocc is considered to be strictly an energy. We have suggested in previous notes that mo is proportional to inertia which is a force. Thus, mo and mocc are thought of in two very different manners simultaneouly, i.e. as an energy and as a force. We propose that it might be beneficial to think of both mo and V(x) in terms of energy and force distribution simultaneously. In particular, we consider that V(x) is not only potential energy at x, but is also linked to force or interaction at x through -d/dx V(x). The reason this duality of energy-force may be important is that it is directly linked to quantum mechanics, we argue. In general, it is argued that classical mechanics is a high energy level limit of quantum mechanics, We argue, however, that for a single particle bound state, the energy linked with a momentum p (at any energy level) is pp/2m (nonrelativistic) which is deterministic (and also follows from special relativity) and has nothing to do with quantum mechanics. The difference between classical mechanics and quantum, is that there exists an interaction (impulse hit) probability of exp(ipx) which means that instead of a hit occurring at the center-of-mass point, it may occur within an hbar/p range. Thus, one may have a particle interact and move through either of two slits if they are separated by about hbar/p. If p, however, is changed in an interaction, p1->p2, then the change in energy p2p2/2m - p1p1/2m (one dimension) is classical-deterministic. It is, however, the duality of V(x) with force that force one to consider not only energy pp/2m (deterministic), but also its associated force distribution given by exp(ipx) / W(x), where W(x) = Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx). As a result, one creates the average kinetic energy term: {Sum over p a(p) pp/2m exp(ipx) } / W(x). One may call exp(ipx)/W(x) a probability and so formally one has KEave(x), but physically exp(ipx) represents a force distribution. The balance to V(x) is a combination of a deterministic energy pp/2m with a force distribution exp(ipx)/W(x). This, we argue, is a physical statement and helps to describe why V(x) may be expanded as a series of virtual particles (e.g. photons etc). It is not just energy, but force that must be considered together. It is only in classical physics, pp/2m + V(x) = E that one solely considers the energy aspects, i.e. pp/2m and V(x) only as energy, but the more general picture, we argue, is to consider not only energy, but force distribution together. This is the quantum picture and it incorporates not only probability, but deterministic Newtonian mechanics (or special relativity) through the use of pp/2m.
•Apr 9, 2026•0 citations