Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Comment on the radiative level shift in the neoclassical radiation theory

R. van den Doel, J.J.J. Kokkedee

Published Mar 1, 1974• 6 citations
Publisher

Abstract

It is shown that when spin currents are included in the neoclassical radiation theory of Jaynes et al., radiative atomic level shifts are obtained which in the case of hydrogen are in strong disagreement with experiment.
DOI
10.1103/physreva.9.1468

Related papers

Test of the neoclassical theory of radiation in a weakly excited atomic system

Gilbert O. Brink

The neoclassical theory of radiation predicts that the decay rate of an excited atomic state depends on the population density of the lower state. Experimental evidence is presented here which shows that in the case of $^{39}\mathrm{K}$ the decay rate is in agreement with the predictions of quantum electrodynamics and definitely in disagreement with the neoclassical theory.

Physical Review A•Jul 1, 1975•1 citation

Comment on ‘‘Self-field quantum electrodynamics: The two-level atom’’

Michael D. Crisp

Barut and Dowling [Phys. Rev. A 41, 2284 (1990)] have raised questions concerning the ``illegal use'' of superposition in the neoclassical radiation theory of Crisp and Jaynes [Phys. Rev. 179, 1253 (1969)]. They also continue to use an expansion for their wave function that has been questioned as to its validity and interpretations [Bialynicki-Birula, Phys. Rev. A 34, 3500 (1986)]. Both of these points will be discussed in this Comment.

Physical Review A•Apr 1, 1991•3 citations

Spin in Neoclassical Radiation Theory

Michael D. Crisp

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 1996•0 citations

Implications of radiative equilibrium in neoclassical theory

Franklin R. Nash, J. P. Gordon

We discuss some implications of the description of spontaneous emission of radiation which has been offered by Jaynes and his collaborators in their "neoclassical" extension of semiclassical electrodynamics. In particular, we examine the thermal-equilibrium condition of radiation interacting with a tenuous gas of atoms. We argue that rate equations may be used to describe the interaction of such atoms with the chaotic thermal radiation field. For this situation the neoclassical spontaneous emission rate is incompatible with the well-secured laws of Boltzmann and Planck. Experimental evidence bearing on the accuracy of those laws as well as on the accepted level population dependence of the induced emission rate is reviewed.

Physical Review A•Dec 1, 1975•6 citations

QUANTUM THEORY OF RADIATION

Murray, Iii Sargent

In our preceding treatments of the interaction of radiation with matter, we assumed that the electric field is classical. In most cases, this assumption is validated by experiment. There are several instances, however, for which a classical field fails to give experimentally observed results, whereas a quantized field succeeds. This is true, for example, of spontaneous emission, a phenom­ enon which was described phenomenologically in our earlier work (see Chaps. 2 and 7). Another case involves the 2 and 2p \ states in the hydrogen atom, which are predicted to have the same energy not only by the simple theory of Chap. 1, but also by the more sophisticated Dirac theory. In both cases, a classical electric field was assumed. Experimentally, the two levels differ by approximately the Lamb shift, 1057 MHz. A fully quantized treatment of the field and atom system gives impressive agreement with the experimentally observed shift. Derivation of the fluctuations in intensity of a laser near threshold requires the quantum theory o f radiation. In addition there are other problems for which the concept of a “particle,” the photon, is either necessary or convenient. Despite a popular impression to the contrary, however the explanation of the photoelectric effect is not one of these (see Prob. 2-10).

CRC Press eBooks•Mar 5, 2018•880 citations

Comment on “Clock Shift in High Field Magnetic Resonance of Atomic Hydrogen”

A. I. Safonov, I. I. Safonova, Igor Stanislavovich Yasnikov

In this Comment, we reanalyze the experiments on the collision frequency shift of the b-c and a-d hyperfine transitions in three-dimensional atomic hydrogen in the presence of, respectively, a and b-state atoms. Accurate consideration of the symmetry of the spatial and spin part of the diatomic wavefunction yields the difference a_T-a_S=0.30(5) Åbetween the triplet and singlet s-wave scattering lengths of hydrogen atoms. This corrects the factor-of two error of the commented work [Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 263003 (2008)].

arXiv:1002.1534•Physical Review Letters•Mar 4, 2010•5 citations
The neoclassical theory of radiation predicts that the decay rate of an excited atomic state depends on the population density of the lower state. Experimental evidence is presented here which shows that in the case of 39K^{39}\mathrm{K}39K the decay rate is in agreement with the predictions of quantum electrodynamics and definitely in disagreement with the neoclassical theory.
We discuss some implications of the description of spontaneous emission of radiation which has been offered by Jaynes and his collaborators in their "neoclassical" extension of semiclassical electrodynamics. In particular, we examine the thermal-equilibrium condition of radiation interacting with a tenuous gas of atoms. We argue that rate equations may be used to describe the interaction of such atoms with the chaotic thermal radiation field. For this situation the neoclassical spontaneous emission rate is incompatible with the well-secured laws of Boltzmann and Planck. Experimental evidence bearing on the accuracy of those laws as well as on the accepted level population dependence of the induced emission rate is reviewed.
In our preceding treatments of the interaction of radiation with matter, we assumed that the electric field is classical. In most cases, this assumption is validated by experiment. There are several instances, however, for which a classical field fails to give experimentally observed results, whereas a quantized field succeeds. This is true, for example, of spontaneous emission, a phenom­ enon which was described phenomenologically in our earlier work (see Chaps. 2 and 7). Another case involves the 2 and 2p \ states in the hydrogen atom, which are predicted to have the same energy not only by the simple theory of Chap. 1, but also by the more sophisticated Dirac theory. In both cases, a classical electric field was assumed. Experimentally, the two levels differ by approximately the Lamb shift, 1057 MHz. A fully quantized treatment of the field and atom system gives impressive agreement with the experimentally observed shift. Derivation of the fluctuations in intensity of a laser near threshold requires the quantum theory o f radiation. In addition there are other problems for which the concept of a “particle,” the photon, is either necessary or convenient. Despite a popular impression to the contrary, however the explanation of the photoelectric effect is not one of these (see Prob. 2-10).
In this Comment, we reanalyze the experiments on the collision frequency shift of the b-c and a-d hyperfine transitions in three-dimensional atomic hydrogen in the presence of, respectively, a and b-state atoms. Accurate consideration of the symmetry of the spatial and spin part of the diatomic wavefunction yields the difference a_T-a_S=0.30(5) Åbetween the triplet and singlet s-wave scattering lengths of hydrogen atoms. This corrects the factor-of two error of the commented work [Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 263003 (2008)].