Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Chemical Educator

Localization and Spread of the Particle in a Box

J. J. C. Mulder

Published Mar 22, 2002• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The most basic example of a quantum mechanical problem, the one-dimensional particle in a box, is revisited. Three aspects are treated. 1.It is shown that a number of textbooks give an incorrect result for the expectation value of x2, and, therefore, do not obtain the correct spread Δx. Consequently, the verification of the Heisenberg relation is also in error. 2. It is found that textbooks do not mention the origin dependence of expectation values, which is a nuisance, as the problem is evidently treated in the literature with two choices of origin. 3. Superposition of an infinite number of even (cosine) solutions of the one-dimensional particle in the box allows for an analytical demonstration of complete localization of the particle (Δx = 0).

DOI
10.1333/s00897020545a

Related papers

Solving the Schrödinger equation

Tony Hey, Patrick Walters

This appendix is intended for readers with some knowledge of calculus – mainly how to differentiate and integrate sines and cosines. We consider the problem of finding the quantum probability amplitudes for a particle ‘in a box’. This involves solving the Schrödinger equation for a particle of some energy E , confined to a certain region by an electrical potential V : We consider the case where the electron can only move in one space dimension, rather than in three dimensions as in real life. In spite of the apparent artificiality of this situation, this example illustrates many of the features that occur in more realistic problems. A straightforward three-dimensional generalization of this example can be used to illustrate many features of the quantum physics not only of electrons in a metal, but also of neutrons and protons in the nucleus. The one-dimensional box potential is shown in Fig. 4.8. Outside the box the potential is assumed to be infinitely high so that there is no probability of finding the particle in these regions. The particle is constrained to be within the box, i.e. the quantum amplitude can only be non-zero between x = 0 and x = L , the two ends of the box. Inside this region, the particle can move freely: in other words, the quantum amplitude for the particle in the box is determined by the Schrödinger equation with no potential term: To see what form of solution is allowed, we first ‘tidy up’ the equation by introducing the new variable k : In terms of k , the Schrödinger equation for the particle in the box now reads: which shows the mathematical structure more clearly.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Oct 23, 2003•0 citations

Complete solutions of particle in three dimensional box with variations in main quantum number

Bambang Supriadi, Lailatul Nuraini, A S R Maulani +3 more

Abstract Particle in a box is one of the applications of the Schrodinger equation. Schrodinger equation gives wave function which is used to determine the probability and expectation value of particle in a box. It is also can explain the energy levels of the particle. This study aimed to determine the probability, expectation values, and energy levels of a particle in a three-dimensional box with variations in main quantum numbers in each coordinate axis. The magnitude of the wave function and energy levels are influenced by the main quantum number and the width of the box. The results show that variations in the main quantum number influence the probability of particle in the three-dimensional box except for the width of the box <?CDATA $\frac{L}{2}$?> L 2 and L the probability of particle showing the same value in all variations of the main quantum number. Variations in the main quantum number also influence the expectation value of particle in a three-dimensional box except for the width of the box L the expectation value shows the same value in all variations of the main quantum number. All variations of the main quantum number also influence the magnitude of the energy level of the particle.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•May 1, 2020•1 citation

When the classical & quantum mechanical considerations hint to a single point; a microscopic particle in a one dimensional box with two infinite walls and a linear potential inside it

Majid Monajjemi, K. Zare, A.R. Zieglari

In this paper we have solved analytically the Schrodinger equation for a microscopic particle in a one-dimensional box with two infinite walls, which the potential function inside it, has a linear form. Based on the solutions of this special quantum mechanical system, we have shown that as the quantum number approaches infinity the expectation values of microscopic particle position and square of the linear momentum are equal to the classical time average of particle position and its square of the linear momentum, respectively.

Journal of Physical & Theoretical Chemistry•Feb 1, 2006•0 citations

The particle in a box in Koopman–von Neumann mechanics: a Hilbert space representation of classical mechanics

Abhijit Sen, Lev Kaplan

Abstract This paper revisits the textbook ‘particle in a box’, but from the point of view of Koopman–von Neumann (KvN) mechanics. KvN mechanics is a way to describe classical dynamics in a Hilbert space. That simple fact changes the usual expectation: hard walls do not force energy quantization here. We show, in a clear and physical way, why a KvN particle confined between two ideal walls still has a continuous range of energies. With the correct wall condition, one that captures ordinary elastic reflection rather than ‘vanishing at the boundary,’ the KvN description naturally produces spatial confinement without discrete energy levels. Beyond establishing this result, we also clarify a common root of confusion that can arise when one attempts to solve this problem: treating the KvN wavefunction as though it were a quantum probability amplitude in position space alone leads to the wrong boundary picture and, consequently, to the wrong conclusion about quantization.

arXiv:2510.26856•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jun 3, 2026•1 citation

Frustating use of the Laplace transform for the quantum states of a particle in a box

Antonio S. de Castro

In a recent paper diffused in the literature, the quantum problem of a particle in a infinite square well potential was claimed to be solved via Laplace transform. Surprisingly, the correct solutions were found for an eigenvalue problem with variable defined on a finite range. As a matter of fact, the authors have misused the Laplace transform of the time-independent Schrödinger equation, and they have also used incorrectly the inversion process. In the present paper it is pointed out carefully and clearly those mistakes that might occur with the use of inappropriate methods for a given eigenvalue problem.

Revista Brasileira de Ensino de Física•Jan 1, 2020•1 citation

Particle-in-a-Box and Related Problems

Vinod Kumar Khanna

A free particle is shown to possess any non-negative energy value. Its position is described by a localized wave function called a wave packet. The solution to the particle in infinite potential well problem displays how the concept of energy quantization appears in quantum mechanics. Like the particle in an infinite well, the particle in a finite well shows discretization of energy. But unlike the particle in an infinite well, the particle in a finite well exhibits a non-zero probability of being found outside the well leading to the concept of quantum-mechanical tunneling.

CRC Press eBooks•Jun 30, 2020•0 citations
The most basic example of a quantum mechanical problem, the one-dimensional particle in a box, is revisited. Three aspects are treated. 1.It is shown that a number of textbooks give an incorrect result for the expectation value of x2, and, therefore, do not obtain the correct spread Δx. Consequently, the verification of the Heisenberg relation is also in error. 2. It is found that textbooks do not mention the origin dependence of expectation values, which is a nuisance, as the problem is evidently treated in the literature with two choices of origin. 3. Superposition of an infinite number of even (cosine) solutions of the one-dimensional particle in the box allows for an analytical demonstration of complete localization of the particle (Δx = 0).
This appendix is intended for readers with some knowledge of calculus – mainly how to differentiate and integrate sines and cosines. We consider the problem of finding the quantum probability amplitudes for a particle ‘in a box’. This involves solving the Schrödinger equation for a particle of some energy E , confined to a certain region by an electrical potential V : We consider the case where the electron can only move in one space dimension, rather than in three dimensions as in real life. In spite of the apparent artificiality of this situation, this example illustrates many of the features that occur in more realistic problems. A straightforward three-dimensional generalization of this example can be used to illustrate many features of the quantum physics not only of electrons in a metal, but also of neutrons and protons in the nucleus. The one-dimensional box potential is shown in Fig. 4.8. Outside the box the potential is assumed to be infinitely high so that there is no probability of finding the particle in these regions. The particle is constrained to be within the box, i.e. the quantum amplitude can only be non-zero between x = 0 and x = L , the two ends of the box. Inside this region, the particle can move freely: in other words, the quantum amplitude for the particle in the box is determined by the Schrödinger equation with no potential term: To see what form of solution is allowed, we first ‘tidy up’ the equation by introducing the new variable k : In terms of k , the Schrödinger equation for the particle in the box now reads: which shows the mathematical structure more clearly.
Abstract Particle in a box is one of the applications of the Schrodinger equation. Schrodinger equation gives wave function which is used to determine the probability and expectation value of particle in a box. It is also can explain the energy levels of the particle. This study aimed to determine the probability, expectation values, and energy levels of a particle in a three-dimensional box with variations in main quantum numbers in each coordinate axis. The magnitude of the wave function and energy levels are influenced by the main quantum number and the width of the box. The results show that variations in the main quantum number influence the probability of particle in the three-dimensional box except for the width of the box <?CDATA L2\frac{L}{2}2L​?> L 2 and L the probability of particle showing the same value in all variations of the main quantum number. Variations in the main quantum number also influence the expectation value of particle in a three-dimensional box except for the width of the box L the expectation value shows the same value in all variations of the main quantum number. All variations of the main quantum number also influence the magnitude of the energy level of the particle.
In this paper we have solved analytically the Schrodinger equation for a microscopic particle in a one-dimensional box with two infinite walls, which the potential function inside it, has a linear form. Based on the solutions of this special quantum mechanical system, we have shown that as the quantum number approaches infinity the expectation values of microscopic particle position and square of the linear momentum are equal to the classical time average of particle position and its square of the linear momentum, respectively.
Abstract This paper revisits the textbook ‘particle in a box’, but from the point of view of Koopman–von Neumann (KvN) mechanics. KvN mechanics is a way to describe classical dynamics in a Hilbert space. That simple fact changes the usual expectation: hard walls do not force energy quantization here. We show, in a clear and physical way, why a KvN particle confined between two ideal walls still has a continuous range of energies. With the correct wall condition, one that captures ordinary elastic reflection rather than ‘vanishing at the boundary,’ the KvN description naturally produces spatial confinement without discrete energy levels. Beyond establishing this result, we also clarify a common root of confusion that can arise when one attempts to solve this problem: treating the KvN wavefunction as though it were a quantum probability amplitude in position space alone leads to the wrong boundary picture and, consequently, to the wrong conclusion about quantization.
In a recent paper diffused in the literature, the quantum problem of a particle in a infinite square well potential was claimed to be solved via Laplace transform. Surprisingly, the correct solutions were found for an eigenvalue problem with variable defined on a finite range. As a matter of fact, the authors have misused the Laplace transform of the time-independent Schrödinger equation, and they have also used incorrectly the inversion process. In the present paper it is pointed out carefully and clearly those mistakes that might occur with the use of inappropriate methods for a given eigenvalue problem.
A free particle is shown to possess any non-negative energy value. Its position is described by a localized wave function called a wave packet. The solution to the particle in infinite potential well problem displays how the concept of energy quantization appears in quantum mechanics. Like the particle in an infinite well, the particle in a finite well shows discretization of energy. But unlike the particle in an infinite well, the particle in a finite well exhibits a non-zero probability of being found outside the well leading to the concept of quantum-mechanical tunneling.