Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of physics. A, Proceedings of the Physical Society. General

Extension of Wheeler-Feynman quantum theory to the relativistic domain. I. Scattering processes

P. C. W. Davies

Published Nov 1, 1971• 45 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The quantization of Wheeler-Feynman direct interparticle action electrodynamics is refined and extended to the relativistic domain, using the S-matrix technique developed previously. The analysis is effected on the exact expression for S, rather than the perturbation expansion. Source particles are treated as indistinguishable fermions with antiparticles. The response of the universe is incorporated in a general way, without allusion to specific absorber mechanisms. All the results of conventional QED emerge, provided one makes certain cosmological assumptions.

DOI
10.1088/0305-4470/4/6/009

Related papers

Hamiltonian Formulation of Action at a Distance in Electrodynamics

B. P. Nigam

The Hamiltonian formulation of the Wheeler-Feynman theory of action at a distance in classical electrodynamics as carried out by Kerner, who has derived the nonrelativistic classical Hamiltonian for the interaction of two spinless charged particles interacting by means of half-retarded plus half-advanced potentials, has been generalized to obtain the corresponding relativistic classical Hamiltonian to order ${e}^{4}$ and ${c}^{\ensuremath{-}4}$. Using the procedure of Daughaday and Nigam, the classical Hamiltonian is transformed into the quantum-mechanical Hamiltonian operator.

Physical Review•May 27, 1966•1 citation

First quantized pair interactions, fermion loops and entanglement

Aaron Bennett

Quantum Electrodynamics may be formulated as a Quantum Field Theory , and also as relativistic quantum mechanics by introduction of the Feynman-Stueckelberg parameter. As stated by M. Srednicki ({\it Quantum Field Theory}, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge and New York, 2007), "\dots any relativistic quantum physics that can be treated in one formalism can also be treated in the other". Entanglement of electrons at macroscopic spacelike separation has been observed (B. Hensen {\it et al.}, Nature, $\bf{526}$, 2015, doi:10.1038.nature/15759), yet according to Quantum Field Theory is restricted to separations of the order of the Compton wavelength $\hbar/m_e c$ (see e.g., S. J. Summers and R. Werner, Commun. Math. Phys. $\bf{110}$,247,1987). There is no restriction on entanglement in parametrized relativistic quantum mechanics (A. F. Bennett, Ann. Phys. $\bf{345}$, 1, 2014). The parametrized formalism is extended here to pair annihilation and pair creation. The {\it ansatz} used in the formalism to develop the correct higher order corrections is justified here with plane wave summations. The conflict over entanglement is further discussed in terms of the Klein-Gordon propagator, and an invariant Bell's inequality is developed for spin -1/2.

arXiv:1406.2310•Jun 8, 2014•1 citation

Three level Lambda system, Feynman amplitudes and relativistic invariance

Navin Khaneja

In this paper, we develop an analogy between the three level atomic system so called Lambda system and scattering processes in quantum electrodynamics (QED). In a Lambda system we have two ground state levels $|1 \rangle$ and $|3 \rangle$ at energy $E_1$ and excited level $|2 \rangle$ at energy $E_2$. The transition from $|1 \rangle$ to $|2 \rangle$ has strength $\Omega_1$ and transition from $|2 \rangle$ to $|3 \rangle$ has strength $\Omega_2$. When we adiabatically eliminate the excited state, i.e. go in the interaction frame of natural Hamiltonian of the system, we get a second order term connecting level $|1 \rangle$ to $|3 \rangle$ with strength $\frac{\Omega_1\Omega_2}{2(E_1-E_2)}$. This term creates an effective coupling between ground state levels and drives transition from $|1 \rangle$ to $| 3\rangle$. Scattering processes in QED can be modelled like this. Feynman amplitudes are calculation of second order term ${\cal M} = \frac{\Omega_1\Omega_2}{2(E_1-E_2)}$. In the rest frame $O'$ ({\bf CM} frame) where sum of momentum of incoming particles is $0$, if the Feynman amplitude is ${\cal M'}$, then in a frame $O$ in which $O'$ moves with velocity $v$ , the time gets dilated to $t = \frac{t'}{\sqrt{1-\frac{v^2}{c^2}}}$ and hence it must be true that ${\cal M} = {\cal M'} \sqrt{1-\frac{v^2}{c^2}}$. We show that to make this relativistic invariance of $\mathcal{M}$ to work, we have to modify the QED interaction Hamiltonian. Using this modification, we calculate the scattering amplitude for QED processes, Compton scattering and M{\o}ller Scattering.

arXiv:1801.08393•Jan 25, 2018•0 citations

A Causal Alternative to Feynman's Propagator

Jurjen F. Koksma, W. Westra

The Feynman propagator used in the conventional in-out formalism in quantum field theory is not a causal propagator as wave packets are propagated virtually instantaneously outside the causal region of the initial state. We formulate a causal in-out formalism in quantum field theory by making use of the Wheeler propagator, the time ordered commutator propagator, which is manifestly causal. Only free scalar field theories and their first quantization are considered. We identify the real Klein Gordon field itself as the wave function of a neutral spinless relativistic particle. Furthermore, we derive a probability density for our relativistic wave packet using the inner product between states that live on a suitably defined Hilbert space of real quantum fields. We show that the time evolution of our probability density is governed by the Wheeler propagator, such that it behaves causally too.

arXiv:1012.3473•Dec 15, 2010•11 citations

Quantum field theory

T. H. R. Skyrme

Abstract A functional expression resembling the scattering matrix is introduced into classical field theory, and with this foundation a postulate of quantization is introduced analogous to the definitions of Feynmann. From this are derived some alternative and more familiar forms of field theory. A variational principle is introduced which provides a relativistic analogue of the familiar non-relativistie variational principle for the Schrödinger equation.

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A Mathematical and Physical Sciences•Sep 6, 1955•6 citations

Why the Quantum Absorber Condition is Not a Light-Tight Box

Ruth E. Kastner

This paper discusses the nature of the boundary condition applying to the direct-action theory of fields, also known as the 'absorber' theory, first developed in a classical version by Wheeler and Feynman. The traditional understanding of these authors and others who followed is that the direct-action theory requires that 'all emitted radiation be absorbed,' or that 'the universe is a perfect (or complete) of absorber of radiation,' implying the need for a specific sort of cosmological boundary condition that may or may not obtain in our universe. It is pointed out that this interpretation requires critical scrutiny even at the classical level, and in any case does not apply to the fully quantum form of the direct-action theory (QDAT), which involves discrete energy transfers by way of photons. In the latter case, the absorption boundary condition describes a specific interactive relationship between emitters and absorbers that is independent of cosmological boundary conditions. Thus, the quantum direct-action theory does not require any special cosmological boundary condition in order for it describe the physical world.

•Feb 23, 2020•1 citation
The quantization of Wheeler-Feynman direct interparticle action electrodynamics is refined and extended to the relativistic domain, using the S-matrix technique developed previously. The analysis is effected on the exact expression for S, rather than the perturbation expansion. Source particles are treated as indistinguishable fermions with antiparticles. The response of the universe is incorporated in a general way, without allusion to specific absorber mechanisms. All the results of conventional QED emerge, provided one makes certain cosmological assumptions.
The Hamiltonian formulation of the Wheeler-Feynman theory of action at a distance in classical electrodynamics as carried out by Kerner, who has derived the nonrelativistic classical Hamiltonian for the interaction of two spinless charged particles interacting by means of half-retarded plus half-advanced potentials, has been generalized to obtain the corresponding relativistic classical Hamiltonian to order e4{e}^{4}e4 and ${c}^{\ensuremath{-}4}$. Using the procedure of Daughaday and Nigam, the classical Hamiltonian is transformed into the quantum-mechanical Hamiltonian operator.
Quantum Electrodynamics may be formulated as a Quantum Field Theory , and also as relativistic quantum mechanics by introduction of the Feynman-Stueckelberg parameter. As stated by M. Srednicki ({\it Quantum Field Theory}, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge and New York, 2007), "\dots any relativistic quantum physics that can be treated in one formalism can also be treated in the other". Entanglement of electrons at macroscopic spacelike separation has been observed (B. Hensen {\it et al.}, Nature, 526\bf{526}526, 2015, doi:10.1038.nature/15759), yet according to Quantum Field Theory is restricted to separations of the order of the Compton wavelength ℏ/mec\hbar/m_e cℏ/me​c (see e.g., S. J. Summers and R. Werner, Commun. Math. Phys. 110\bf{110}110,247,1987). There is no restriction on entanglement in parametrized relativistic quantum mechanics (A. F. Bennett, Ann. Phys. 345\bf{345}345, 1, 2014). The parametrized formalism is extended here to pair annihilation and pair creation. The {\it ansatz} used in the formalism to develop the correct higher order corrections is justified here with plane wave summations. The conflict over entanglement is further discussed in terms of the Klein-Gordon propagator, and an invariant Bell's inequality is developed for spin -1/2.
In this paper, we develop an analogy between the three level atomic system so called Lambda system and scattering processes in quantum electrodynamics (QED). In a Lambda system we have two ground state levels ∣1⟩|1 \rangle∣1⟩ and ∣3⟩|3 \rangle∣3⟩ at energy E1E_1E1​ and excited level ∣2⟩|2 \rangle∣2⟩ at energy E2E_2E2​. The transition from ∣1⟩|1 \rangle∣1⟩ to ∣2⟩|2 \rangle∣2⟩ has strength Ω1\Omega_1Ω1​ and transition from ∣2⟩|2 \rangle∣2⟩ to ∣3⟩|3 \rangle∣3⟩ has strength Ω2\Omega_2Ω2​. When we adiabatically eliminate the excited state, i.e. go in the interaction frame of natural Hamiltonian of the system, we get a second order term connecting level ∣1⟩|1 \rangle∣1⟩ to ∣3⟩|3 \rangle∣3⟩ with strength Ω1Ω22(E1−E2)\frac{\Omega_1\Omega_2}{2(E_1-E_2)}2(E1​−E2​)Ω1​Ω2​​. This term creates an effective coupling between ground state levels and drives transition from ∣1⟩|1 \rangle∣1⟩ to ∣3⟩| 3\rangle∣3⟩. Scattering processes in QED can be modelled like this. Feynman amplitudes are calculation of second order term M=Ω1Ω22(E1−E2){\cal M} = \frac{\Omega_1\Omega_2}{2(E_1-E_2)}M=2(E1​−E2​)Ω1​Ω2​​. In the rest frame O′O'O′ ({\bf CM} frame) where sum of momentum of incoming particles is 000, if the Feynman amplitude is M′{\cal M'}M′, then in a frame OOO in which O′O'O′ moves with velocity vvv , the time gets dilated to t=t′1−v2c2t = \frac{t'}{\sqrt{1-\frac{v^2}{c^2}}}t=1−c2v2​​t′​ and hence it must be true that M=M′1−v2c2{\cal M} = {\cal M'} \sqrt{1-\frac{v^2}{c^2}}M=M′1−c2v2​​. We show that to make this relativistic invariance of M\mathcal{M}M to work, we have to modify the QED interaction Hamiltonian. Using this modification, we calculate the scattering amplitude for QED processes, Compton scattering and M{\o}ller Scattering.
The Feynman propagator used in the conventional in-out formalism in quantum field theory is not a causal propagator as wave packets are propagated virtually instantaneously outside the causal region of the initial state. We formulate a causal in-out formalism in quantum field theory by making use of the Wheeler propagator, the time ordered commutator propagator, which is manifestly causal. Only free scalar field theories and their first quantization are considered. We identify the real Klein Gordon field itself as the wave function of a neutral spinless relativistic particle. Furthermore, we derive a probability density for our relativistic wave packet using the inner product between states that live on a suitably defined Hilbert space of real quantum fields. We show that the time evolution of our probability density is governed by the Wheeler propagator, such that it behaves causally too.
This paper discusses the nature of the boundary condition applying to the direct-action theory of fields, also known as the 'absorber' theory, first developed in a classical version by Wheeler and Feynman. The traditional understanding of these authors and others who followed is that the direct-action theory requires that 'all emitted radiation be absorbed,' or that 'the universe is a perfect (or complete) of absorber of radiation,' implying the need for a specific sort of cosmological boundary condition that may or may not obtain in our universe. It is pointed out that this interpretation requires critical scrutiny even at the classical level, and in any case does not apply to the fully quantum form of the direct-action theory (QDAT), which involves discrete energy transfers by way of photons. In the latter case, the absorption boundary condition describes a specific interactive relationship between emitters and absorbers that is independent of cosmological boundary conditions. Thus, the quantum direct-action theory does not require any special cosmological boundary condition in order for it describe the physical world.