The eigenvalues of the matrix operator S⋅Π for a constant magnetic field are derived in a parallel way for spins 1/2, 1, and 3/2 using only the algebra of the spin matrices and the commutation relations of the components of Π.
Exploiting the intimate connection of the problem of a charged spin-1 particle in a homogeneous magnetic field to that of a harmonic oscillator, it is demonstrated that the eigenvalues of the matrix operator S. pi for spin-1 and for a constant magnetic field are governed by a Hermitian matrix defined on the space of the particle number n and spin and are thus constrained to be real for any intensity of the external magnetic field H, thereby contradicting a recent affirmation of Weaver (1978) that for n=0, complex eigenvalues are present for sufficiently intense magnetic fields. The errors in Weaver's analysis which have led to complex eigenvalues as well as to an excessive number of eigenvalues compared with that demanded by the spin degrees of freedom are pointed out.
Utilising the intimate connection of a charged particle in a homogeneous magnetic field to that of a harmonic oscillator, the authors demonstrate explicitly that the eigenvalue spectrum for the matrix operator S. pi for arbitrary spin in a uniform magnetic field in the z direction is governed, for its discrete part, by that of a Hermitian matrix defined on the space of the particle number and spin operators and is thus constrained to be real for any intensity of the external magnetic field. The present analysis generalises to arbitrary spin their previously reported results applied to the case of a spin-1 particle.