Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing (STOC)

Quantum lower bound for the collision problem

Scott Aaronson

Published May 19, 2002• 117 citations
Publisher

Abstract

(MATH) The collision problem is to decide whether a function X: { 1,…,n} → { 1, …,n} is one-to-one or two-to-one, given that one of these is the case. We show a lower bound of Ω(n1/5) on the number of queries needed by a quantum computer to solve this problem with bounded error probability. The best known upper bound is O(n1/3), but obtaining any lower bound better than Ω(1) was an open problem since 1997. Our proof uses the polynomial method augmented by some new ideas. We also give a lower bound of Ω(n1/7) for the problem of deciding whether two sets are equal or disjoint on a constant fraction of elements. Finally we give implications of these results for quantum complexity theory.

DOI
10.1145/509907.509999

Related papers

Quantum lower bound for the collision problem

Scott Aaronson

(MATH) The collision problem is to decide whether a function X: { 1,…,n} → { 1, …,n} is one-to-one or two-to-one, given that one of these is the case. We show a lower bound of Ω(n1/5) on the number of queries needed by a quantum computer to solve this problem with bounded error probability. The best known upper bound is O(n1/3), but obtaining any lower bound better than Ω(1) was an open problem since 1997. Our proof uses the polynomial method augmented by some new ideas. We also give a lower bound of Ω(n1/7) for the problem of deciding whether two sets are equal or disjoint on a constant fraction of elements. Finally we give implications of these results for quantum complexity theory.

ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing (STOC)•Jan 1, 2002•14 citations

Quantum Lower Bound for the Collision Problem

Scott Aaronson

The collision problem is to decide whether a function X:{1,..,n}->{1,..,n} is one-to-one or two-to-one, given that one of these is the case. We show a lower bound of Theta(n^{1/5}) on the number of queries needed by a quantum computer to solve this problem with bounded error probability. The best known upper bound is O(n^{1/3}), but obtaining any lower bound better than Theta(1) was an open problem since 1997. Our proof uses the polynomial method augmented by some new ideas. We also give a lower bound of Theta(n^{1/7}) for the problem of deciding whether two sets are equal or disjoint on a constant fraction of elements. Finally we give implications of these results for quantum complexity theory.

arXiv:quant-ph/0111102•Nov 20, 2001•36 citations

Quantum lower bounds for the collision and the element distinctness problems

Scott Aaronson, Yaoyun Shi

Given a function f as an oracle, the collision problem is to find two distinct indexes i and j such that f ( i ) = f ( j ), under the promise that such indexes exist. Since the security of many fundamental cryptographic primitives depends on the hardness of finding collisions, our lower bounds provide evidence for the existence of cryptographic primitives that are immune to quantum cryptanalysis. We prove that any quantum algorithm for finding a collision in an r -to-one function must evaluate the function Ω(( n / r ) 1/3 ) times, where n is the size of the domain and r | n . This matches an upper bound of Brassard, Høyer, and Tapp. No lower bound better than constant was previously known. Our result also implies a quantum lower bound of Ω( n 2/3 ) queries for the element distinctness problem, which is to determine whether n integers are all distinct. The best previous lower bound was Ω(√ n ) queries.

Journal of the ACM•Jul 1, 2004•353 citations

Quantum lower bounds for the collision and the element distinctness problems

Yaoyun Shi

Given a function f as an oracle, the collision problem is to find two distinct inputs i and j such that f(i)=f(j), under the promise that such inputs exist. In this paper, we prove that any quantum algorithm for finding a collision in an r-to-one function must evaluate the function /spl Omega/ ((n/r)/sup 1/3/) times, where n is the size of the domain and r|n. This lower bound matches, up to a constant factor, the upper bound of Brassard, Hoyer and Tapp (1997), which uses the quantum algorithm of Grover (1996) in a novel way. The previously best quantum lower bound is /spl Omega/ ((n/r)/sup 1/5/) evaluations, due to Aaronson (2002). Our result implies a quantum lower bound of /spl Omega/ (n/sup 2/3/) queries to the inputs for another well studied problem, the element distinctness problem, which is to determine whether or not the given n real numbers are distinct. The previous best lower bound is /spl Omega/ (/spl radic/n) queries in the black-box model; and /spl Omega/ (/spl radic/n log n) comparisons in the comparisons-only model, due to Hoyer Neerbek, and Shi (2001).

arXiv:quant-ph/0112086•Annual Symposium on Foundations of Computer Science•Jun 26, 2003•122 citations

On finding quantum multi-collisions in non-uniform random functions

Tianci Peng, Rui Xue

Abstract Collision resistance is one of the most fundamental properties in cryptography. With the development of quantum computing, significant attention has been directed toward understanding the quantum query complexity of collision-finding problems in hash functions. The quantum query complexity of collision-finding in general non-uniform random functions remained an open problem until the recent work of Peng et al. (ASIACRYPT 2025), who nearly resolved it by introducing a novel parameter $$\gamma$$ γ . Based on this parameter, they established an upper bound of $$O(\gamma ^{1/6})$$ O ( γ 1 / 6 ) and a matching lower bound of $$\tilde{\Omega }(\gamma ^{1/6})$$ Ω ~ ( γ 1 / 6 ) . However, the quantum query complexity of finding multi-collisions in non-uniform random functions has remained open. A s -collision to a function f is a set of distinct input $$x_1,\dots , x_s$$ x 1 , ⋯ , x s such that $$f(x_1)=f(x_2)\dots =f(x_s)$$ f ( x 1 ) = f ( x 2 ) ⋯ = f ( x s ) . In this work, we address this challenge by similarly introducing a new generalized parameter $$\gamma _s$$ γ s . Based on this parameter, we establish nearly tight bounds—an upper bound of $$O(\gamma _s)$$ O ( γ s ) and a lower bound of $$\tilde{\Omega }(\gamma _s)$$ Ω ~ ( γ s ) —thereby nearly resolving this open problem. Moreover, although the existing results for 2-collisions do not generalize straightforwardly to the case of s -collision ( $$s>2$$ s > 2 ), we demonstrate that the result of Peng et al. can be viewed as a special case of our more general framework. This clearly establishes our work as a direct generalization of their contribution.

Cybersecurity•May 8, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Computational Complexity Theory and Lower Bounds

Phillip Kaye, Raymond Laflamme, Michele Mosca

We have seen in the previous chapters that quantum computers seem to be more powerful than classical computers for certain problems. There are limits on the power of quantum computers, however. Since a classical computer can simulate a quantum computer, a quantum computer can only compute the same set of functions that a classical computer can. The advantage of using a quantum computer is that the amount of resources needed by a quantum algorithm might be much less than what is needed by the best classical algorithm. In Section 9.1 we briefly define some classical and quantum complexity classes and give some relationships between them. Most of the interesting questions relating classical and quantum complexity classes remain open. For example, we do not yet know if a quantum computer is capable of efficiently solving an NP-complete problem (defined later). One can prove upper bounds on the difficulty of a problem by providing an algorithm that solves that problem, and proving that it will work within in a given running time. But how does one prove a lower bound on the computational complexity of a problem? For example, if we wish to find the product of two n-bit numbers, computing the answer requires outputting roughly 2n bits and that requires Ω(n) steps (in any computing model with finite-sized gates). The best-known upper bound for integer multiplication is O(n log n log log n) steps. It has proved extremely difficult to derive non-trivial lower bounds on the computational complexity of a problem. Most of the known non-trivial lower bounds are in the ‘black-box’ model (for both classical and quantum computing), where we only query the input via a ‘black-box’ of a specific form. We discuss the black-box model in more detail in Section 9.2. We then sketch several approaches for proving black-box lower bounds. The first technique has been called the ‘hybrid method’ and was used to prove that quantum searching requires Ω(√n) queries to succeed with constant probability. The second technique is called the ‘polynomial method’. We then describe a technique based on ‘block sensitivity’, and conclude with a technique known as the ‘adversary method’.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Nov 16, 2006•0 citations
(MATH) The collision problem is to decide whether a function X: { 1,…,n} → { 1, …,n} is one-to-one or two-to-one, given that one of these is the case. We show a lower bound of Ω(n1/5) on the number of queries needed by a quantum computer to solve this problem with bounded error probability. The best known upper bound is O(n1/3), but obtaining any lower bound better than Ω(1) was an open problem since 1997. Our proof uses the polynomial method augmented by some new ideas. We also give a lower bound of Ω(n1/7) for the problem of deciding whether two sets are equal or disjoint on a constant fraction of elements. Finally we give implications of these results for quantum complexity theory.
(MATH) The collision problem is to decide whether a function X: { 1,…,n} → { 1, …,n} is one-to-one or two-to-one, given that one of these is the case. We show a lower bound of Ω(n1/5) on the number of queries needed by a quantum computer to solve this problem with bounded error probability. The best known upper bound is O(n1/3), but obtaining any lower bound better than Ω(1) was an open problem since 1997. Our proof uses the polynomial method augmented by some new ideas. We also give a lower bound of Ω(n1/7) for the problem of deciding whether two sets are equal or disjoint on a constant fraction of elements. Finally we give implications of these results for quantum complexity theory.
The collision problem is to decide whether a function X:{1,..,n}->{1,..,n} is one-to-one or two-to-one, given that one of these is the case. We show a lower bound of Theta(n^{1/5}) on the number of queries needed by a quantum computer to solve this problem with bounded error probability. The best known upper bound is O(n^{1/3}), but obtaining any lower bound better than Theta(1) was an open problem since 1997. Our proof uses the polynomial method augmented by some new ideas. We also give a lower bound of Theta(n^{1/7}) for the problem of deciding whether two sets are equal or disjoint on a constant fraction of elements. Finally we give implications of these results for quantum complexity theory.
Given a function f as an oracle, the collision problem is to find two distinct indexes i and j such that f ( i ) = f ( j ), under the promise that such indexes exist. Since the security of many fundamental cryptographic primitives depends on the hardness of finding collisions, our lower bounds provide evidence for the existence of cryptographic primitives that are immune to quantum cryptanalysis. We prove that any quantum algorithm for finding a collision in an r -to-one function must evaluate the function Ω(( n / r ) 1/3 ) times, where n is the size of the domain and r | n . This matches an upper bound of Brassard, Høyer, and Tapp. No lower bound better than constant was previously known. Our result also implies a quantum lower bound of Ω( n 2/3 ) queries for the element distinctness problem, which is to determine whether n integers are all distinct. The best previous lower bound was Ω(√ n ) queries.
Given a function f as an oracle, the collision problem is to find two distinct inputs i and j such that f(i)=f(j), under the promise that such inputs exist. In this paper, we prove that any quantum algorithm for finding a collision in an r-to-one function must evaluate the function /spl Omega/ ((n/r)/sup 1/3/) times, where n is the size of the domain and r|n. This lower bound matches, up to a constant factor, the upper bound of Brassard, Hoyer and Tapp (1997), which uses the quantum algorithm of Grover (1996) in a novel way. The previously best quantum lower bound is /spl Omega/ ((n/r)/sup 1/5/) evaluations, due to Aaronson (2002). Our result implies a quantum lower bound of /spl Omega/ (n/sup 2/3/) queries to the inputs for another well studied problem, the element distinctness problem, which is to determine whether or not the given n real numbers are distinct. The previous best lower bound is /spl Omega/ (/spl radic/n) queries in the black-box model; and /spl Omega/ (/spl radic/n log n) comparisons in the comparisons-only model, due to Hoyer Neerbek, and Shi (2001).
Abstract Collision resistance is one of the most fundamental properties in cryptography. With the development of quantum computing, significant attention has been directed toward understanding the quantum query complexity of collision-finding problems in hash functions. The quantum query complexity of collision-finding in general non-uniform random functions remained an open problem until the recent work of Peng et al. (ASIACRYPT 2025), who nearly resolved it by introducing a novel parameter γ\gammaγ γ . Based on this parameter, they established an upper bound of O(γ1/6)O(\gamma ^{1/6})O(γ1/6) O ( γ 1 / 6 ) and a matching lower bound of Ω~(γ1/6)\tilde{\Omega }(\gamma ^{1/6})Ω~(γ1/6) Ω ~ ( γ 1 / 6 ) . However, the quantum query complexity of finding multi-collisions in non-uniform random functions has remained open. A s -collision to a function f is a set of distinct input x1,…,xsx_1,\dots , x_sx1​,…,xs​ x 1 , ⋯ , x s such that f(x1)=f(x2)⋯=f(xs)f(x_1)=f(x_2)\dots =f(x_s)f(x1​)=f(x2​)⋯=f(xs​) f ( x 1 ) = f ( x 2 ) ⋯ = f ( x s ) . In this work, we address this challenge by similarly introducing a new generalized parameter γs\gamma _sγs​ γ s . Based on this parameter, we establish nearly tight bounds—an upper bound of O(γs)O(\gamma _s)O(γs​) O ( γ s ) and a lower bound of Ω~(γs)\tilde{\Omega }(\gamma _s)Ω~(γs​) Ω ~ ( γ s ) —thereby nearly resolving this open problem. Moreover, although the existing results for 2-collisions do not generalize straightforwardly to the case of s -collision ( s>2s>2s>2 s > 2 ), we demonstrate that the result of Peng et al. can be viewed as a special case of our more general framework. This clearly establishes our work as a direct generalization of their contribution.
We have seen in the previous chapters that quantum computers seem to be more powerful than classical computers for certain problems. There are limits on the power of quantum computers, however. Since a classical computer can simulate a quantum computer, a quantum computer can only compute the same set of functions that a classical computer can. The advantage of using a quantum computer is that the amount of resources needed by a quantum algorithm might be much less than what is needed by the best classical algorithm. In Section 9.1 we briefly define some classical and quantum complexity classes and give some relationships between them. Most of the interesting questions relating classical and quantum complexity classes remain open. For example, we do not yet know if a quantum computer is capable of efficiently solving an NP-complete problem (defined later). One can prove upper bounds on the difficulty of a problem by providing an algorithm that solves that problem, and proving that it will work within in a given running time. But how does one prove a lower bound on the computational complexity of a problem? For example, if we wish to find the product of two n-bit numbers, computing the answer requires outputting roughly 2n bits and that requires Ω(n) steps (in any computing model with finite-sized gates). The best-known upper bound for integer multiplication is O(n log n log log n) steps. It has proved extremely difficult to derive non-trivial lower bounds on the computational complexity of a problem. Most of the known non-trivial lower bounds are in the ‘black-box’ model (for both classical and quantum computing), where we only query the input via a ‘black-box’ of a specific form. We discuss the black-box model in more detail in Section 9.2. We then sketch several approaches for proving black-box lower bounds. The first technique has been called the ‘hybrid method’ and was used to prove that quantum searching requires Ω(√n) queries to succeed with constant probability. The second technique is called the ‘polynomial method’. We then describe a technique based on ‘block sensitivity’, and conclude with a technique known as the ‘adversary method’.