Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Foundations of Physics

The determination of the past and the future of a physical system in quantum mechanics

Paul Busch, PEKKA J. LAHTI

Published Jun 1, 1989• 90 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1007/bf00731904

Related papers

Knowledge of Past and Future in Quantum Mechanics

Science•Mar 27, 1931•1 citation

Knowledge of Past and Future in Quantum Mechanics

Science•Mar 27, 1931•0 citations

Past, Future And Elsewhere In Quantum Mechanics

Y. Srivastava

•Jan 1, 1994•1 citation

Temporal Symmetry of Quantum Uncertainty: A Reinterpretation of the Heisenberg Principle

Justin L Dickinson

The Heisenberg uncertainty principle is conventionally interpreted as a constraint on the precision of future measurement outcomes. We argue that this temporal asymmetry is not justified by the underlying mathematics of quantum mechanics, which is fundamentally time-symmetric. We propose that uncertainty applies equally in both temporal directions: the past has no greater ontological determinacy than the future. Between collapse events, prior states were no more determined than future states are now. Only the present moment of collapse constitutes anything approaching a definite physical state, and that moment is immediately receding into a past that was never fully determined before collapse occurred. We formalize this interpretation through a timesymmetric reading of the existing uncertainty relations and discuss its implications for the ontological status of the past, the measurement problem, and the foundations of physical determinism.

•Feb 25, 2026•0 citations

FREE WILL IN HUMAN BEHAVIOR AND PHYSICS

Vasil Dinev Penchev

If the concept of “free will” is reduced to that of “choice” all physical world share the latter quality. Anyway the “free will” can be distinguished from the “choice”: The “free will” involves implicitly a certain goal, and the choice is only the mean, by which the aim can be achieved or not by the one who determines the target. Thus, for example, an electron has always a choice but not free will unlike a human possessing both. Consequently, and paradoxically, the determinism of classical physics is more subjective and more anthropomorphic than the indeterminism of quantum mechanics for the former presupposes certain deterministic goal implicitly following the model of human freewill behavior. Quantum mechanics introduces the choice in the fundament of physical world involving a generalized case of choice, which can be called “subjectless”: There is certain choice, which originates from the transition of the future into the past. Thus that kind of choice is shared of all existing and does not need any subject: It can be considered as a low of nature. There are a few theorems in quantum mechanics directly relevant to the topic: two of them are called “free will theorems” by their authors (Conway and Kochen 2006; 2009). Any quantum system either a human or an electron or whatever else has always a choice: Its behavior is not predetermined by its past. This is a physical law. It implies that a form of information, the quantum information underlies all existing for the unit of the quantity of information is an elementary choice: either a bit or a quantum bit (qubit).

Labour and Social Relations Journal•Jan 1, 2020•0 citations

Knowledge of Past and Future in Quantum Mechanics

Guido Bacciagaluppi, Elise Crull

This is a reprinting of Einstein, Podolsky and Tolman’s 1931 letter to the editor of Physical Review . In this letter, the authors demonstrate that the principles of quantum mechanics give rise to an uncertainty in the description of past events which is analogous to the uncertainty quantum mechanics assigns to the prediction of future events.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 14, 2024•0 citations
The Heisenberg uncertainty principle is conventionally interpreted as a constraint on the precision of future measurement outcomes. We argue that this temporal asymmetry is not justified by the underlying mathematics of quantum mechanics, which is fundamentally time-symmetric. We propose that uncertainty applies equally in both temporal directions: the past has no greater ontological determinacy than the future. Between collapse events, prior states were no more determined than future states are now. Only the present moment of collapse constitutes anything approaching a definite physical state, and that moment is immediately receding into a past that was never fully determined before collapse occurred. We formalize this interpretation through a timesymmetric reading of the existing uncertainty relations and discuss its implications for the ontological status of the past, the measurement problem, and the foundations of physical determinism.
If the concept of “free will” is reduced to that of “choice” all physical world share the latter quality. Anyway the “free will” can be distinguished from the “choice”: The “free will” involves implicitly a certain goal, and the choice is only the mean, by which the aim can be achieved or not by the one who determines the target. Thus, for example, an electron has always a choice but not free will unlike a human possessing both. Consequently, and paradoxically, the determinism of classical physics is more subjective and more anthropomorphic than the indeterminism of quantum mechanics for the former presupposes certain deterministic goal implicitly following the model of human freewill behavior. Quantum mechanics introduces the choice in the fundament of physical world involving a generalized case of choice, which can be called “subjectless”: There is certain choice, which originates from the transition of the future into the past. Thus that kind of choice is shared of all existing and does not need any subject: It can be considered as a low of nature. There are a few theorems in quantum mechanics directly relevant to the topic: two of them are called “free will theorems” by their authors (Conway and Kochen 2006; 2009). Any quantum system either a human or an electron or whatever else has always a choice: Its behavior is not predetermined by its past. This is a physical law. It implies that a form of information, the quantum information underlies all existing for the unit of the quantity of information is an elementary choice: either a bit or a quantum bit (qubit).