Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Fortschritte der Physik

Outline of a Nonlinear, Relativistic Quantum Mechanics of Extended Particles

Eckehard W. Mielke

Published Jan 1, 1981• 7 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract A quantum theory of intrinsically extended particles similar to de Broglie's Theory of the Double Solution is proposed. A rational notion of the particle's extension is enthroned by realizing its internal structure via soliton‐type solutions of nonlinear, relativistic wave equations. These droplet‐type waves have a quasi‐objective character except for certain boundary conditions which may be subject to stochastic fluctuations. More precisely, this assumption amounts to a probabilistic description of the center of a soliton such that it would follow the conventional quantum‐mechanical formalism in the limit of zero particle radius. At short interaction distances, however, a promising nonlinear and nonlocal theory emerges. This model is not only capable of achieving a conceptually satisfying synthesis of the particle‐wave dualism, but may also lead to a rational resolution of epistemological problems in the quantum‐theoretical measurement process. Within experimental errors the results for, e.g., the hydrogen atom can be reproduced by appropriately specifying the nature of the nonlinear self‐interaction. It is speculated that field theoretical issues raised by such notions as identical particles, field quantization and renormalization are already incorporated or resolved by this nonlocal theory, at least in principle.

DOI
10.1002/prop.19810291103

Related papers

Relativistic Mechanics of Two Interacting Particles and Bilocal Theory

Takehiko Takabayasi

New relativistic mechanics of two-particle system is set forth, where the two constituent particles are interacting by an arbitrary (central) action-at-a-distance. The fundamental equations are presented in a form covariant under general transformation of parameters parametrizing the world lines of constituent particles. The theory represents the proper relativistic generalization of the usual Newtonian mechanics in the sense that it tends in the non-relativistic (and weak interaction) limit to the usual mechanics of two particles moving under a corresponding non-relativistic potential. For the analysis of theory it is convenient to choose a certain particular gauge (i.e., parametrization) fixed by two gauge relations. This brings the theory to a canonical formalism accompanied by two weak equations, and in this gauge quantization can be performed. The result verifies that the relativistic quantum mechanics for two particles interacting by an action-at-a-distance is just represented by a bilocal wave equation and a subsidiary condition, with the clarification of its correspondence-theoretical fundation and internal dynamics. As an example the case of Hooke-type force is illustrated, where the internal motions are elliptic oscillations in the center-of-mass frame. Its quantum theory just reproduces the original form of bilocal theory giving bound states lying on a straightly rising trajectory and on its daughter trajectories.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Aug 1, 1975•23 citations

STATISTICAL ORIGIN OF QUANTUM DESCRIPTION AND MIE-EINSTEIN FIELD PARADIGME

Yu. P. Rybakov

We discuss the statistical origin of quantum theoretical description and show that within the scope of the Mie-Einstein field approach, with particles being considered as lumps of some material field satisfying nonlinear equations, such a description appears to be natural and inevitable since it is impossible to specify initial conditions for the extended particle-soliton. Beside this, it is shown that on solitons’ basis, the special stochastic representation of quantum mechanics can be constructed, the latter one being equivalent to the theory of nonlocal hidden variables.

Metafizika•Dec 15, 2020•0 citations

Soliton Model of Extended Quantum Particles

Yu. P. Rybakov, Bijan Saha

ABSTRACT. Some flrst principles that, we believe, could serve as foundation for quantum theory of extended particles are formulated. It is also shown that in the point-like particles limit the non-relativistic quantum mechanics can be restored. Bohm problem of nonlinear res-onance has been considered and its possible solution has been given. Within the frame-work of the Einstein-de Broglie soliton model a hy-drogen atom has been simulated. R ¶ESUM ¶E. Nous formulons quelques principes fondamentaux qui pour-raient, µa notre avis, servir de base de la th¶eorie quantique des par-ticules ¶etendues. Nous montrons aussi que dans la limite des par-ticules ponctuelles la m¶ecanique quantique non relativiste se r¶etablit. Nous consid¶erons le problµeme pos¶e par D. Bohm, de la r¶esonance non lin¶eaire, dont nous proposons la solution. Dans les cadres du sch¶ema non lin¶eaire d’Einstein- de Broglie nous simulons le modµele solitonien de l’atome µa type hydrogµene. Preface \\The questions of causal interpretation of Quantum Mechanics had al-ways been among the flelds of interests of Professor Georges Lochak who actively popularized de Broglie’s views on Quantum Mechanics as a lin-ear limit of some essentially nonlinear fleld theory. Dedicating present work to Professor Georges Lochak, we express the hope that the ideas of the soliton interpretation of Quantum Mechanics lay also in the fleld of his interests." 382 Yu.P. Rybakov, Bijan Saha 1

Annales de la fondation Louis de Broglie/Annales de la Fondation Louis de Broglie•Jan 1, 2001•14 citations

Whence Nonlocality? Removing Spooky Action-at-a-Distance from the de Broglie Bohm Pilot-Wave Theory Using a Time-Symmetric Version of the de Broglie Double Solution

Aurélien Drezet

In this work, we review and extend a version of the old attempt made by Louis de Broglie for interpreting quantum mechanics in realistic terms, namely, the double solution. In this theory, quantum particles are localized waves, i.e., solitons, that are solutions of relativistic nonlinear field equations. The theory that we present here is the natural extension of this old work and relies on a strong time-symmetry requiring the presence of advanced and retarded waves converging on particles. Using this method, we are able to justify wave–particle duality and to explain the violations of Bell’s inequalities. Moreover, the theory recovers the predictions of the pilot-wave theory of de Broglie and Bohm, often known as Bohmian mechanics. As a direct consequence, we reinterpret the nonlocal action-at-a-distance in the pilot-wave theory. In the double solution developed here, there is fundamentally no action-at-a-distance but the theory requires a form of superdeterminism driven by time-symmetry.

arXiv:2312.01992•Symmetry•Dec 19, 2023•6 citations

Nonlinear wave equation with intrinsic wave particle dualism

James J. Klein

A nonlinear wave equation[Formula: see text]derived from the sine–Gordon equation is shown to possess a variety of solutions, the most interesting of which is a solution that describes a wave packet travelling with velocity uc modulating a carrier wave travelling with velocity uc. The envelop and carrier wave speeds agree precisely with the group and phase velocities found by de Broglie for matter waves. No spreading is exhibited by the soliton, so that it behaves exactly like a particle in classical mechanics. Moreover, the classically computed energy E of the disturbance turns out to be exactly equal to the frequency ω of the carrier wave, so that the Planck relation [Formula: see text] is automatically satisfied without postulating a particle–wave dualism.

Canadian Journal of Physics•Jul 1, 1976•2 citations

The Theory of Discrete Extension -- An Operator-Free Approach To Quantization

John T. Brooker

The theory of discrete extension, introduced here, demonstrates that various re-sults from elementary, non-relativistic quantum mechanics can be obtained without recourse to eigenvalue problems, operators, or state vectors in Hilbert space. Us-ing a mathematical structure similar to that of Newtonian mechanics, the theory generates correct, quasi-discrete values of action increments and energy levels for bound states of quantum-level systems. Quantization of the harmonic oscillator provides a simple illustration. Like Newtonian mechanics the theory provides intuitive conceptualizations for basic entities and kinematics. However, in place of the classical concepts of particle and field, the non-classical, unitary concept of a discretely extended ob-ject emerges from the theory as an alternative characterization of the nature of quantum-level entities. Because such an object is well-defined and unitary, the theory avoids the dilemmas of wave-particle dualism and complementarity. The theory offers insight into the nature of a number of quantum effects such as the zero-point energy of a harmonic oscillator. It also makes a number of testable predictions that distinguish it from standard quantum theory and from Bohmian mechanics.

arXiv:1308.3921•Aug 19, 2013•0 citations
Abstract A quantum theory of intrinsically extended particles similar to de Broglie's Theory of the Double Solution is proposed. A rational notion of the particle's extension is enthroned by realizing its internal structure via soliton‐type solutions of nonlinear, relativistic wave equations. These droplet‐type waves have a quasi‐objective character except for certain boundary conditions which may be subject to stochastic fluctuations. More precisely, this assumption amounts to a probabilistic description of the center of a soliton such that it would follow the conventional quantum‐mechanical formalism in the limit of zero particle radius. At short interaction distances, however, a promising nonlinear and nonlocal theory emerges. This model is not only capable of achieving a conceptually satisfying synthesis of the particle‐wave dualism, but may also lead to a rational resolution of epistemological problems in the quantum‐theoretical measurement process. Within experimental errors the results for, e.g., the hydrogen atom can be reproduced by appropriately specifying the nature of the nonlinear self‐interaction. It is speculated that field theoretical issues raised by such notions as identical particles, field quantization and renormalization are already incorporated or resolved by this nonlocal theory, at least in principle.
New relativistic mechanics of two-particle system is set forth, where the two constituent particles are interacting by an arbitrary (central) action-at-a-distance. The fundamental equations are presented in a form covariant under general transformation of parameters parametrizing the world lines of constituent particles. The theory represents the proper relativistic generalization of the usual Newtonian mechanics in the sense that it tends in the non-relativistic (and weak interaction) limit to the usual mechanics of two particles moving under a corresponding non-relativistic potential. For the analysis of theory it is convenient to choose a certain particular gauge (i.e., parametrization) fixed by two gauge relations. This brings the theory to a canonical formalism accompanied by two weak equations, and in this gauge quantization can be performed. The result verifies that the relativistic quantum mechanics for two particles interacting by an action-at-a-distance is just represented by a bilocal wave equation and a subsidiary condition, with the clarification of its correspondence-theoretical fundation and internal dynamics. As an example the case of Hooke-type force is illustrated, where the internal motions are elliptic oscillations in the center-of-mass frame. Its quantum theory just reproduces the original form of bilocal theory giving bound states lying on a straightly rising trajectory and on its daughter trajectories.
We discuss the statistical origin of quantum theoretical description and show that within the scope of the Mie-Einstein field approach, with particles being considered as lumps of some material field satisfying nonlinear equations, such a description appears to be natural and inevitable since it is impossible to specify initial conditions for the extended particle-soliton. Beside this, it is shown that on solitons’ basis, the special stochastic representation of quantum mechanics can be constructed, the latter one being equivalent to the theory of nonlocal hidden variables.
ABSTRACT. Some flrst principles that, we believe, could serve as foundation for quantum theory of extended particles are formulated. It is also shown that in the point-like particles limit the non-relativistic quantum mechanics can be restored. Bohm problem of nonlinear res-onance has been considered and its possible solution has been given. Within the frame-work of the Einstein-de Broglie soliton model a hy-drogen atom has been simulated. R ¶ESUM ¶E. Nous formulons quelques principes fondamentaux qui pour-raient, µa notre avis, servir de base de la th¶eorie quantique des par-ticules ¶etendues. Nous montrons aussi que dans la limite des par-ticules ponctuelles la m¶ecanique quantique non relativiste se r¶etablit. Nous consid¶erons le problµeme pos¶e par D. Bohm, de la r¶esonance non lin¶eaire, dont nous proposons la solution. Dans les cadres du sch¶ema non lin¶eaire d’Einstein- de Broglie nous simulons le modµele solitonien de l’atome µa type hydrogµene. Preface \\The questions of causal interpretation of Quantum Mechanics had al-ways been among the flelds of interests of Professor Georges Lochak who actively popularized de Broglie’s views on Quantum Mechanics as a lin-ear limit of some essentially nonlinear fleld theory. Dedicating present work to Professor Georges Lochak, we express the hope that the ideas of the soliton interpretation of Quantum Mechanics lay also in the fleld of his interests." 382 Yu.P. Rybakov, Bijan Saha 1
In this work, we review and extend a version of the old attempt made by Louis de Broglie for interpreting quantum mechanics in realistic terms, namely, the double solution. In this theory, quantum particles are localized waves, i.e., solitons, that are solutions of relativistic nonlinear field equations. The theory that we present here is the natural extension of this old work and relies on a strong time-symmetry requiring the presence of advanced and retarded waves converging on particles. Using this method, we are able to justify wave–particle duality and to explain the violations of Bell’s inequalities. Moreover, the theory recovers the predictions of the pilot-wave theory of de Broglie and Bohm, often known as Bohmian mechanics. As a direct consequence, we reinterpret the nonlocal action-at-a-distance in the pilot-wave theory. In the double solution developed here, there is fundamentally no action-at-a-distance but the theory requires a form of superdeterminism driven by time-symmetry.
A nonlinear wave equation[Formula: see text]derived from the sine–Gordon equation is shown to possess a variety of solutions, the most interesting of which is a solution that describes a wave packet travelling with velocity uc modulating a carrier wave travelling with velocity uc. The envelop and carrier wave speeds agree precisely with the group and phase velocities found by de Broglie for matter waves. No spreading is exhibited by the soliton, so that it behaves exactly like a particle in classical mechanics. Moreover, the classically computed energy E of the disturbance turns out to be exactly equal to the frequency ω of the carrier wave, so that the Planck relation [Formula: see text] is automatically satisfied without postulating a particle–wave dualism.
The theory of discrete extension, introduced here, demonstrates that various re-sults from elementary, non-relativistic quantum mechanics can be obtained without recourse to eigenvalue problems, operators, or state vectors in Hilbert space. Us-ing a mathematical structure similar to that of Newtonian mechanics, the theory generates correct, quasi-discrete values of action increments and energy levels for bound states of quantum-level systems. Quantization of the harmonic oscillator provides a simple illustration. Like Newtonian mechanics the theory provides intuitive conceptualizations for basic entities and kinematics. However, in place of the classical concepts of particle and field, the non-classical, unitary concept of a discretely extended ob-ject emerges from the theory as an alternative characterization of the nature of quantum-level entities. Because such an object is well-defined and unitary, the theory avoids the dilemmas of wave-particle dualism and complementarity. The theory offers insight into the nature of a number of quantum effects such as the zero-point energy of a harmonic oscillator. It also makes a number of testable predictions that distinguish it from standard quantum theory and from Bohmian mechanics.