Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Journal of Chemical Physics

Complex-valued classical trajectories for tunneling and well-defined paths

Thomas F. George

Published Jan 15, 1975• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A paper by Hirschfelder, Christoph, and Palke has suggested analogies between quantum streamlines and complex−valued classical trajectories in a semiclassical treatment of tunneling in reactive molecular collisions. This Comment points out that there are basic differences between trajectories and the streamlines and that care must be taken ataching any physical significance to complex−valued trajectories or in relating them to quantum mechanical quantities such as streamlines. (AIP)

DOI
10.1063/1.430451

Related papers

Quantum-mechanical streamlines and classical trajectories in elastic scattering

H. J. Korsch, R Möhlenkamp

The hydrodynamic formulation of quantum mechanics is considered in the semiclassical limit and the relationship between quantum streamlines and classical trajectories is discussed. The flow pattern of the quantum streamlines can be described in terms of the interference of classical trajectories. The flow inside the classically forbidden regions is related to complex-valued classical trajectories. The analytically solvable cases of Coulomb and hard-sphere scattering are investigated in detail.

Journal of Physics B Atomic and Molecular Physics•Jun 14, 1978•6 citations

Some New Classical and Semiclassical Models for Describing Tunneling Processes with Real-Valued Classical Trajectories

Jianhua Xing, Eduardo A. Coronado, William Hughes Miller

A model for describing barrier tunneling (or other classically forbidden processes) using purely real-valued classical trajectories is presented. The basic idea is to introduce an auxiliary degree of freedom that allows for fluctuations in the potential-energy surface for the original classical degrees of freedom. The model can be applied purely classically or better semiclassically (e . g ., via the initial value representation). Numerical results for 1D barrier tunneling are presented to illustrate the model.

The Journal of Physical Chemistry B•Apr 11, 2001•16 citations

Coherent Classical-Path Description of Deep Tunneling

Dong Hui Zhang, Eli Pollak

A central challenge to the semiclassical description of quantum mechanics is the quantum phenomenon of "deep" tunneling. Here we show that real time classical trajectories suffice to account correctly even for deep quantum tunneling, using a recently formulated semiclassical initial value representation series of the quantum propagator and a prefactor free semiclassical propagator. Deep quantum tunneling is effected through what we term as coherent classical paths which are composed of one or more classical trajectories that lead from reactant to product but are discontinuous along the way. The end and initial phase space points of consecutive classical trajectories contributing to the coherent path are close to each other in the sense that the distance between them is weighted by a coherent state overlap matrix element. Results are presented for thermal and energy dependent tunneling through a symmetric Eckart barrier.

Physical Review Letters•Sep 27, 2004•30 citations

Semiclassical Monte Carlo path integration for the time-domain treatment of barrier tunneling: bifurcations into real and imaginary trajectories

Tohru Kinugawa

Chemical Physics Letters•Sep 1, 1996•2 citations

Quantum mechanical streamlines. I. Square potential barrier

Joseph O. Hirschfelder, Albert C. Christoph, William E. Palke

Exact numerical calculations are made for the scattering of quantum mechanical particles from a square two-dimensional potential barrier. This treatment is an exact analog of both frustrated total reflection of perpendicularly polarized light and the longitudinal Goos-Hänchen shift. Quantum mechanical streamlines (which are analogous to either classical mechanical trajectories or optical rays) are plotted. These streamlines are smooth, continuous, and have continuous first derivatives even through the classically forbidden region. The streamlines form quantized vortices surrounding each of the nodal points (which result from interference between the incident and reflected waves). Similar vortices occur in reactive collisions of H + H2 (McCullough and Wyatt; Kuppermann, Adams, and Truhlar) and undoubtedly play an important role in molecular collision dynamics. The theory for these vortices is given in a companion paper. A comparison is given between our numerical calculations and the stationary phase approximation (SPA). Although our incident wave packet has a half-width of more than one de Broglie wavelength in contrast to the SPA which replaces the diffuse beams by rays with delta function profiles, the agreement was surprisingly good for both the Goos-Hänchen shifts and for the reflection coefficients. However, we found that the Goos-Hänchen shift for the transmitted beam is significantly smaller than for the reflected beam, although in the stationary phase approximation these two shifts are equal. Furthermore, we found that the scattering from the potential barrier has very little effect on the shape of the wave packets. The power series expansion of the incident Debye-Picht wave packet ψI has an extremely small radius of convergence, whereas the power series for ψI*ψI has a radius of convergence of more than two de Broglie wavelengths. The imaginary velocity viis introduced into the Madelung-Landau-London hydrodynamical formulation of quantum mechanics. The corresponding imaginary streamlines will be considered in a forthcoming paper. The time-independent Schrödinger equation for real wavefunctions is reduced to solving the nonlinear first order partial differential equation: ℏ▿·vi = 2(E − V) + vi2. Here, vi is irrotational. This equation may lead to interesting new methods of solving the Schrödinger equation. It does lead to a generalization of the Prager-Hirschfelder perturbation scheme which invokes an electrostatic analogy. The philosophical implications of the hydrodynamical formulation of quantum mechanics are discussed. Penetration of a one-dimensional square potential barrier is used to demonstrate exactly how tunneling occurs by particles ``riding over the barrier'' à la Bohm. Cases are cited where quantum and classical mechanical motions are identical.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Dec 15, 1974•194 citations

Complex Semiclassics: Classical Models for Tunneling Using Complex Trajectories

Max Meynig

•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations
A paper by Hirschfelder, Christoph, and Palke has suggested analogies between quantum streamlines and complex−valued classical trajectories in a semiclassical treatment of tunneling in reactive molecular collisions. This Comment points out that there are basic differences between trajectories and the streamlines and that care must be taken ataching any physical significance to complex−valued trajectories or in relating them to quantum mechanical quantities such as streamlines. (AIP)
A model for describing barrier tunneling (or other classically forbidden processes) using purely real-valued classical trajectories is presented. The basic idea is to introduce an auxiliary degree of freedom that allows for fluctuations in the potential-energy surface for the original classical degrees of freedom. The model can be applied purely classically or better semiclassically (e . g ., via the initial value representation). Numerical results for 1D barrier tunneling are presented to illustrate the model.
A central challenge to the semiclassical description of quantum mechanics is the quantum phenomenon of "deep" tunneling. Here we show that real time classical trajectories suffice to account correctly even for deep quantum tunneling, using a recently formulated semiclassical initial value representation series of the quantum propagator and a prefactor free semiclassical propagator. Deep quantum tunneling is effected through what we term as coherent classical paths which are composed of one or more classical trajectories that lead from reactant to product but are discontinuous along the way. The end and initial phase space points of consecutive classical trajectories contributing to the coherent path are close to each other in the sense that the distance between them is weighted by a coherent state overlap matrix element. Results are presented for thermal and energy dependent tunneling through a symmetric Eckart barrier.
Exact numerical calculations are made for the scattering of quantum mechanical particles from a square two-dimensional potential barrier. This treatment is an exact analog of both frustrated total reflection of perpendicularly polarized light and the longitudinal Goos-Hänchen shift. Quantum mechanical streamlines (which are analogous to either classical mechanical trajectories or optical rays) are plotted. These streamlines are smooth, continuous, and have continuous first derivatives even through the classically forbidden region. The streamlines form quantized vortices surrounding each of the nodal points (which result from interference between the incident and reflected waves). Similar vortices occur in reactive collisions of H + H2 (McCullough and Wyatt; Kuppermann, Adams, and Truhlar) and undoubtedly play an important role in molecular collision dynamics. The theory for these vortices is given in a companion paper. A comparison is given between our numerical calculations and the stationary phase approximation (SPA). Although our incident wave packet has a half-width of more than one de Broglie wavelength in contrast to the SPA which replaces the diffuse beams by rays with delta function profiles, the agreement was surprisingly good for both the Goos-Hänchen shifts and for the reflection coefficients. However, we found that the Goos-Hänchen shift for the transmitted beam is significantly smaller than for the reflected beam, although in the stationary phase approximation these two shifts are equal. Furthermore, we found that the scattering from the potential barrier has very little effect on the shape of the wave packets. The power series expansion of the incident Debye-Picht wave packet ψI has an extremely small radius of convergence, whereas the power series for ψI*ψI has a radius of convergence of more than two de Broglie wavelengths. The imaginary velocity viis introduced into the Madelung-Landau-London hydrodynamical formulation of quantum mechanics. The corresponding imaginary streamlines will be considered in a forthcoming paper. The time-independent Schrödinger equation for real wavefunctions is reduced to solving the nonlinear first order partial differential equation: ℏ▿·vi = 2(E − V) + vi2. Here, vi is irrotational. This equation may lead to interesting new methods of solving the Schrödinger equation. It does lead to a generalization of the Prager-Hirschfelder perturbation scheme which invokes an electrostatic analogy. The philosophical implications of the hydrodynamical formulation of quantum mechanics are discussed. Penetration of a one-dimensional square potential barrier is used to demonstrate exactly how tunneling occurs by particles ``riding over the barrier'' à la Bohm. Cases are cited where quantum and classical mechanical motions are identical.