Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Synthese

Is quantum mechanics an atomistic theory?

Shaughan Lavine

Published Nov 1, 1991• 24 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1007/bf00413907

Related papers

Is Quantum Mechanics a Complete Theory?

Y. Tschang

Physics Essays•Sep 1, 1992•0 citations

Does quantum mechanics tell an atomistic spacetime?

Hans-Thomas Elze

The canonical answer to the question posed is "Yes." – tacitly assuming that quantum theory and the concept of spacetime are to be unified by 'quantizing' a theory of gravitation. Yet, instead, one may ponder: Could quantum mechanics arise as a coarse-grained reflection of the atomistic nature of spacetime? – We speculate that this may indeed be the case. We recall the similarity between evolution of classical and quantum mechanical ensembles, according to Liouville and von Neumann equation, respectively. The classical and quantum mechanical equations are indistinguishable for objects which are free or subject to spatially constant but possibly time dependent, or harmonic forces, if represented appropriately. This result suggests a way to incorporate anharmonic interactions, including fluctuations which are tentatively related to the underlying discreteness of spacetime. Being linear and local at the quantum mechanical level, the model offers a decoherence and natural localization mechanism. However, the relation to primordial deterministic degrees of freedom is nonlocal.

arXiv:0906.1101•Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jun 1, 2009•31 citations

Is Quantum Mechanics a Probabilistic Theory?

Peter Mittelstaedt

Boston studies in the philosophy of science•Jan 1, 1997•4 citations

Einstein, the reality of space and the action–reaction principle

Tushar K. Sarkar

The Reality question gained prominence within the professional scientific community mainly after the advent of quantum mechanics (QM) and its alleged incompleteness', supposedly proved by the 1935 Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen (EPR) paper, followed by a powerful rejoinder by Bohr himself. The Bohr-Einstein controversy may be viewed as a disagreement about the proper interpretation of the standard formalism of QM. QM is non-atomist holism, while Einstein's view is atomistic. QM is a kind of non-atomist holism in a unique sense in the atomism of the Jainas or the logical atomism of Wittgenstein as presented in his Tractatus (TLP) are atomistic, yet a form of holism at the same time. In short, QM rejects the notion of pure objectivity as a myth, whereas for Einstein, the notion of an objective reality, free of all traces of subjectivism in it, is the prime requirement of a sound scientific methodology.

Routledge eBooks•Jun 23, 2016•22 citations

Is Quantum Mechanics a Complete Theory?

D. I. Blokhint︠s︡ev

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 1968•0 citations

Comparison of the Non-Equilibrium Predictions of Quantum Thermodynamics at the Atomistic Level With Experimental Evidence

Charles E. Smith, Michael R. von Spakovsky

Experimental evidence is presented and compared with theoretical predictions from Quantum Thermodynamics, (QT) to examine whether or not the claims of QT are consistent with the existence and generation of entropy at atomistic scales. QT makes the assertion that entropy is an intrinsic property of matter in the same way that inertial mass, energy, and momentum are and must, thus, exist even for single particles. Entropy as defined by QT is a measure of the distribution of a system’s internal energy at any given instant of time amongst the available internal degrees of freedom, i.e., the energy eigenlevels of the system. In this paper, it is shown that QT predicts the internal relaxation of a 5-level rubidium system that is consistent with the experimental data and not explained by current theory, i.e. by Quantum Mechanics. In addition, it is demonstrated that the decay of so-called “cat states” for single ions that are contained in Paul traps and that interact with a heat reservoir is also consistent with the idea of the existence of entropy and entropy generation at atomistic scales. This is accomplished by comparing experimental data with the predictions made using an extension of the equation of motion of QT that allows for heat interactions.

ASME International Mechanical Engineering Congress and Exposition (IMECE)•Jan 1, 2011•4 citations
The canonical answer to the question posed is "Yes." – tacitly assuming that quantum theory and the concept of spacetime are to be unified by 'quantizing' a theory of gravitation. Yet, instead, one may ponder: Could quantum mechanics arise as a coarse-grained reflection of the atomistic nature of spacetime? – We speculate that this may indeed be the case. We recall the similarity between evolution of classical and quantum mechanical ensembles, according to Liouville and von Neumann equation, respectively. The classical and quantum mechanical equations are indistinguishable for objects which are free or subject to spatially constant but possibly time dependent, or harmonic forces, if represented appropriately. This result suggests a way to incorporate anharmonic interactions, including fluctuations which are tentatively related to the underlying discreteness of spacetime. Being linear and local at the quantum mechanical level, the model offers a decoherence and natural localization mechanism. However, the relation to primordial deterministic degrees of freedom is nonlocal.
The Reality question gained prominence within the professional scientific community mainly after the advent of quantum mechanics (QM) and its alleged incompleteness', supposedly proved by the 1935 Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen (EPR) paper, followed by a powerful rejoinder by Bohr himself. The Bohr-Einstein controversy may be viewed as a disagreement about the proper interpretation of the standard formalism of QM. QM is non-atomist holism, while Einstein's view is atomistic. QM is a kind of non-atomist holism in a unique sense in the atomism of the Jainas or the logical atomism of Wittgenstein as presented in his Tractatus (TLP) are atomistic, yet a form of holism at the same time. In short, QM rejects the notion of pure objectivity as a myth, whereas for Einstein, the notion of an objective reality, free of all traces of subjectivism in it, is the prime requirement of a sound scientific methodology.
Experimental evidence is presented and compared with theoretical predictions from Quantum Thermodynamics, (QT) to examine whether or not the claims of QT are consistent with the existence and generation of entropy at atomistic scales. QT makes the assertion that entropy is an intrinsic property of matter in the same way that inertial mass, energy, and momentum are and must, thus, exist even for single particles. Entropy as defined by QT is a measure of the distribution of a system’s internal energy at any given instant of time amongst the available internal degrees of freedom, i.e., the energy eigenlevels of the system. In this paper, it is shown that QT predicts the internal relaxation of a 5-level rubidium system that is consistent with the experimental data and not explained by current theory, i.e. by Quantum Mechanics. In addition, it is demonstrated that the decay of so-called “cat states” for single ions that are contained in Paul traps and that interact with a heat reservoir is also consistent with the idea of the existence of entropy and entropy generation at atomistic scales. This is accomplished by comparing experimental data with the predictions made using an extension of the equation of motion of QT that allows for heat interactions.